Performance Grants and TSR Upside:

Similar documents
In the Weeds with Performance Share Accounting

Implementing a Relative TSR Plan: It's New To Me - An Issuer's Story October 24, 2013

Relative Total Shareholder Return Plans: Valuation 103 How Design Decisions Impact the Cost of Relative Total Shareholder Return Awards

Relative Total Shareholder Return Plans: Valuation 102 The Impact of Volatility on Valuation

Performance Share Units

Driving Performance - Linking Equity Compensation Design with FAS 123(R) Valuation, Jeff Bacher and Terry Adamson, Aon Consulting

Relative TSR Plans: The Next Generation of Equity

FY12 Performance Share Plan. February 9, :30-9:30 a.m. (EST)

Long-Term Incentives Gone Wild?:

Relative TSR Plans: Expert Insight

Page 2 of 199 UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION. Washington, D.C FORM 10-K

UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION. Washington, D.C FORM 10-K

So Everyone is Using Market Conditions: Great! What Does that Mean?

Performance Equity Plans: The Design and Valuation Under FAS 123(R)

January 3, Company ABC, Inc Main Street. Re: 25, In 2011, Company based to the. based 200% 150% 100% 50% 0% TSR $85.54 $44.

Are You On Top of Tax Issues for Equity Plans?

Mama Mia! Cooking Up a Big Batch of ESPP

Ready, Set, Implement

Mastering RSU Releases for Your Mobile Employees October 25, 2013

Why is Everyone Grumbling? An Introduction to Understanding ISS Guidelines and Other Investor Concerns about Equity Plan Design and Governance

Calamos Phineus Long/Short Fund

The Hunger Games: Surviving Global Administration Challenges

Equity Income Sourcing and Compliance Issues for Mobile US and Non-US Employees

ASC Topic 718 Accounting Valuation Report. Company ABC, Inc.

The Value Proposition

Contents. 1. Tax Expatriates... 6

October 31, The Board of Directors Mitek Systems, Inc. 600 B Street, Suite 100 San Diego, CA Dear Members of the Board:

Radford Review: 2013 Say-on-Pay Results and Trends for the US Life Sciences Sector. One Firm. Complete Solutions.

COLD, HARD CASH: DOES CASH HAVE A ROLE IN YOUR COMPANY'S LONG-TERM INCENTIVE PROGRAM?

Radford Review: 2013 Say-on-Pay Results and Trends for the US Technology Sector. One Firm. Complete Solutions.

EQUITY REPORTING & WITHHOLDING. Updated May 2016

SAY ON PAY RESULTS RUSSELL 3000 APRIL 3

advancing the dialogue Setting 2009 Executive Compensation: A Real-Time Discussion About Long-Term Incentive Plans

Keep Calm and Carry On! How to Administer Special Events in Equity Compensation

INCENTIVE PLAN SERIES

FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA

Quarterly Market Review. First Quarter 2015

DFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Quarterly Performance Report Q2 2014

Equity Incentive Planning & Design Trends

DFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Performance Report Q3 2015

DFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Performance Report Q2 2017

DFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Performance Report Q3 2018

DFA Global Equity Portfolio (Class F) Performance Report Q4 2017

Dow Jones Dividend Indices Methodology

The value of equity-based compensation

Wells Fargo Target Date CITs E3

Incentive Plan. Performance Share Plan

Mandatory Post-Vest Holding Requirements: Maximize Your Investment in Equity Compensation and be a Good Corporate Citizen at the Same Time

PROXY ADVISORY FIRMS RELEASE 2017 POLICY UPDATES

Diversification Opportunities From Capturing China as an Asset Class An Overview of the KraneShares MSCI All China Index ETF (Ticker: KALL)

Time to Invest Some Sweat Equity in your TSR Plan #NASPP26

OPTIMISING EXITS FOR EUROPEAN TECHNOLOGY COMPANIES 30 April 2018

Salesforce Proxy Statement Supplement

Executive SERPs: Is It Time For A Performance-Based Alternative?

Investment Cost Effectiveness Analysis Norwegian Government Pension Fund Global

Over the last several years, we have witnessed

SVB Financial Group NEUTRAL ZACKS CONSENSUS ESTIMATES (SIVB-NASDAQ) SUMMARY

San Francisco Retiree Health Care Trust Fund Education Materials on Public Equity

Rebalancing International Equities: What to Know. What to Consider.

An Overview of Current Trends in Emerging Markets

Quick Facts about the 2009 Equity Grant and Performance Shares

2013 Annual Report of the Investment Committee

2017 Fourth Quarter Data Book

The China / India Syndrome

Share Ownership Guidelines - How to Handle this Governance Golden Child March 24, 2014 Seattle NASPP Chapter

2017 Fourth Quarter Data Book

Salesforce. Supplemental Proxy Materials. May NYSE: CRM San Francisco, CA

DIVERSIFICATION. Diversification

In the third quarter, total revenue of $5.3 billion was flat from the prior year or down 1 percent in constant currency.

Equity Compensation All Stars Game: Silicon Valley vs. The Rest of the World

Live life without boundaries. Live life without boundaries

Q Global Equity. (888)

Paying For Performance Around the World

For institutional use only 1

Designing Outcome-Focused Defined Contribution Plans: Building Sustainable Income for Retirees

Selecting Effective Performance Metrics: Why Shareholders Are Wild About Return on Invested Capital John Borneman,

P R E S S R E L E A S E

ShoreTel Reports Financial Results for Fourth Quarter and Fiscal Year 2017

VMware Reports Fiscal 2019 First Quarter Results. Total revenue growth of 14% year-over-year Broad-based strength across all three geographies

athenahealth Inc. NEUTRAL ZACKS CONSENSUS ESTIMATES (ATHN-NASDAQ) SUMMARY

POTBELLY CORPORATION REPORTS RESULTS FOR FOURTH FISCAL QUARTER AND FULL FISCAL YEAR 2017

Q Global Equity. (888)

MSCI China A-Share Inclusion: A Long Term Catalyst For The Mainland Chinese Equity Market

Q2 13 FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS

CAP 100 Company Research

Q1 14 FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS. April 15, 2014

Retirement Board Presentation to the City Council. Proposal for Use of Water Sale Proceeds April 7, 2014

February 3, Intel Stockholders,

Stock & Option Solutions September 7, Title Handling the Perks and Pitfalls of

Allscripts Healthcare Solutions, Inc.

The Real Deal? Are Performance Awards Really Paying for Performance? October 24, 2013

ANGI HOMESERVICES REPORTS Q4 2017

An Introduction to Dynamic Overlay

Q Global Equity. (888)

Nuance Mid Cap Value Fund (NMVLX)

Best Practices in Fiduciary Liability

Historical Price Returns

Global Report: Global Survey of Retirement Plan Accounting Assumptions

A Push for More Diverse Metrics

Q2 Quarterly Market Review Second Quarter 2015

Transcription:

Performance Grants and TSR Upside: An Approach to Plan Design, Expensing, Plan Administration and Communication Jon Burg, FSA, Vice President, Radford, an Aon Hewitt Company Barry Sullivan, Principal, Semler Brossy Consulting Group Jule Torre, Global Stock Programs Manager, Applied Materials James Clark, Senior Director Executive and Equity Compensation, Applied Materials

Applied Materials: At A Glance Applied Materials solar energy system at its campus in Sunnyvale, CA, is one of the largest corporate solar power installations in the U.S. Stock Ticker: Market Cap * : Fiscal 2011 Revenue: Fiscal 2011 R&D: Nasdaq: AMAT $14.35 billion $10.52 billion $1.2 billion Founded: November 10, 1967 Headquarters: Global Presence: RD&E and/or Manufacturing Centers: Employees: Patents: Santa Clara, California 83 locations in 19 countries Canada, China, Germany, India, Israel, Italy, Singapore, Switzerland, Taiwan, United States ~15,000 worldwide ~9,300 issued 2

The Challenge: How to bring total shareholder return into focus? 3

Performance Metrics for PRSU Grants Financial Performance and Market Condition Relative Operating Profit Margin (OPM) is the primary measure of performance Requires Applied to be ranked at the 40 th percentile to begin earning grants Compared to Applied Peer Group Non-GAAP OPM adjusted for nonrecurring items Relative Total Shareholder Return (TSR) upside measure of performance Applies to shares vested from a given grant Must be at 60 th percentile or higher Measured at end of the second year of a given grant 4

Current Performance RSU Plan Design 4-year performance window; 1-year performance periods Each grant has a re-earn provision; unearned shares are eligible through the fourth performance window Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4 Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4 Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4 Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4 1-year Operating Margin relative to peers Earn-out % at 65 th %ile and above results in 100% earn-out additional 15% vests for each 5 percentile performance improvement 40 th %ile to 45 th %ile 25% Below 40 th %ile No earn-out 5

The Starting Point: Performance RSU s 4-year performance window; 1-year performance periods New grants each year that tie to a new 4-year window Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4 Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4 Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4 Performance in any year could apply to 4 active cycles Y1 Y2 Y3 Y4 1-year Operating Margin relative to peers Earn-out % at 65 th %ile and above results in 100% earn-out additional 15% vests for each 5 percentile performance improvement 40 th %ile to 45 th %ile 25% Below 40 th %ile No earn-out 6

The Path Forward: Upside Opportunity Tied to Relative TSR Maintain the structure of the current program Operating Margin for efficiency at any point of the cycle Relative measure for outperformance and to help with goal-setting Four one-year performance periods to address differences across peers Bring fresh attention to share price with relative TSR External optics are clear Maintain Operating Margin as superordinate? TSR relative to whom? 7

Determining the relative basis: Back-testing TSR Back-tested a handful of potential groups SELECTION: S&P500 Information Technology Sector competitors for capital objective third-party definition meaningful sample size 8

The Plan: 4 year period 2 year TSR Performance 4-year window; 1-year relative Operating Margin as principal basis New 2-year relative TSR key market reference at midpoint of each 4-year window 2yr TSR relative to S&P Tech at 75th %ile and above Upside on shares already earned results in + 50% 70 th to 75 th + 40% 65 th to 70 th + 30% 60 th to 65 th + 20% Below 60 th %ile No additional shares 9

Lessons Learned: the Good, the Bad, the Compromise Tool Keep the Good Don t do away with the current practice for the sake of change Avoid the Bad: Look ahead to where design may go wrong and work backwards Stand Ready to Compromise Know the boundaries for each major decision point and work within those boundaries 10

How to Value the TSR Upside All PRSU target shares are subject to the market condition TSR Upside performance can earn an additional 50% based on the underlying OPM target shares that vest The market condition is a modifier of the OPM shares from 1.0x to 1.5x. The Monte Carlo simulation captures the possible outcomes of 1.0x to 1.5x. Value is then used as the underlying fair value used for the OPM shares 11

Ten Tips in a Nutshell.. 1. Get Started as Soon as Possible 2. Engage in Conversations and Dialogs Early 3. Create a Checklist 4. Make an Effort to Understand and Address Differences 5. Be Aware of Differences in Expectations 6. Don t Be In the Dark Regarding Compliance Activities 7. Work with Advisors to Review Regulations and Applications 8. Extensive Communications are Critical to Success 9. Special Issues: Expect the Unexpected 10. Keep your sense of Humor! 12

Special Issues: Expect the Unexpected Design Implementation Execution Handling special agreements and restrictions Systems limitations for equity programs Customizing procedures Advice regarding conflict resolution, e.g. varying interpretations of agreements Compensation and its advisors Finance - External Reporting, Tax, Treasury, Payroll Legal and Securities Vendor applications 13

Miscellaneous Items Determine responsible party for the communications and documentation Coordinator of internal process Global issues including expats, multiple payroll systems, withholding tax rates, etc. Audit and risk tolerance No one does it perfectly Work in Progress 14

Communicating New Plan Design Feature: TSR Performance Shares Summary Document Explains both the OPM and TSR performance metrics for PRSU s Provides examples of potential earn-outs Performance share agreement PeerTracker Web site Plan Summary TSR Performance OPM Performance More Information 15

Performance Shares Summary Document Relative Operating Profit Margin and Relative Total Shareholder Return Thresholds Peer Group (OPM and TSR) Earn-out tables Provides examples of potential earn-outs OPM and TSR Performance Share Agreement 16

PeerTracker Custom Web site for Applied Materials 17

PeerTracker Custom Web site for Applied Materials 18

PeerTracker Custom Web site for Applied Materials 19

PeerTracker Custom Web site for Applied Materials 20

Contact Information: Jon W. Burg, FSA Barry Sullivan Radford Semler Brossy Vice President Principal E-mail: jburg@radford.com E-mail: BSullivan@semlerbrossy.com Phone: +1 (415) 486-7137 Phone: +1 (310) 943-8385 Jule Torre James Clark Applied Materials, Inc. Applied Materials, Inc. Global Stock Programs Manager Senior Director, Executive and Equity Compensation Email: Jule_Torre@amat.com Email: James_Clark@amat.com Phone: +1 (408) 235-6074 Phone: +1 (408) 563-5557 21