1 of 8 3/31/2016 1:52 PM General Docket Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals Court of Appeals Docket #: 15-3909 Docketed: 12/21/2015 Nature of Suit: 4360 Other Personal Injury Jim Sciaroni v. Target Corporation, et al Appeal From: U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota - Minneapolis Fee Status: paid - cs Case Type Information: 1) Civil 2) Private 3) null Originating Court Information: District: 0864-4 : 0:14-md-02522-PAM Court Reporter: Carla R Bebault, Court Reporter Trial Judge: Paul A. Magnuson, U.S. District Judge Date Filed: 04/02/2014 Date Order/Judgment: Date NOA Filed: Date Rec'd COA: 11/17/2015 12/09/2015 12/09/2015 Prior Cases: None Current Cases: Back-to-Back Consolidated Related Lead Member Start End 15-3909 15-3914 12/21/2015 15-3909 15-3912 12/21/2015 15-3909 16-1203 01/25/2016 15-3909 16-1245 01/29/2016 15-3909 16-1408 02/17/2016 15-8017 15-3909 12/21/2015 In re: Target Corporation Customer Data Security Breach Litigation ------------------------------ Jim Sciaroni Objector - Appellant v. Robert C. Black, III Direct: 952-831-1454 Suite 425 7400 Metro Boulevard Edina, MN 55439 Plaintiffs' Lead Counsel Terminated: Plaintiffs' Liaison Counsel Terminated: Consumer Plaintiffs Felipe J. Arroyo ROBBINS & ARROYO Firm: 619-525-3990 Suite 1900 600 B Street San Diego, CA 92101
2 of 8 3/31/2016 1:52 PM Karl L. Cambronne CHESTNUT & CAMBRONNE, P.A. Firm: 612-339-7300 Suite 300 17 Washington Avenue, N. Minneapolis, MN 55401 David Michael Cialkowski Direct: 612-341-0400 Eleanor Michelle Drake BERGER & MONTAGUE 19th Floor 100 S. Fifth Street Minneapolis, MN 55402 Vincent J. Esades Direct: 612-338-4605 HEINS & MILLS 310 Clifton Avenue Minneapolis, MN 55403 Brian C. Gudmundson Karen Riebel LOCKRIDGE & GRINDAL Firm: 612-339-6900 Suite 2200 100 Washington Avenue, S. Minneapolis, MN 55401-0000 John Gordon Rudd, Jr. Direct: 612-341-0400 David Woodward Direct: 612-338-4605 HEINS & MILLS 310 Clifton Avenue Minneapolis, MN 55403 Charles S. Zimmerman
3 of 8 3/31/2016 1:52 PM Target Corporation Defendant - Appellee Michael J. Agoglia Direct: 415-268-7000 Fred B. Burnside DAVIS & WRIGHT Suite 2200 1201 Third Avenue Seattle, WA 98101-3045 Robert G. Flanders, Jr. HINCKLEY & ALLEN Firm: 401-457-5184 Suite 1500 50 Kennedy Plaza Providence, RI 02903 Rebekah Kaufman Patrick J. Kenny Direct: 314-552-6613 ARMSTRONG & TEASDALE Firm: 314-621-5070 Suite 1800 7700 Forsyth Boulevard Saint Louis, MO 63105 Jack W. Londen Direct: 415-268-7000 David Frank McDowell Firm: 213-892-5553 Suite 3500 555 W. Fifth Street Los Angeles, CA 90013-0000 Harold J. McElhinny Douglas H. Meal
4 of 8 3/31/2016 1:52 PM ROPES & GRAY Firm: 617-951-7000 Prudential Tower 800 Boylston Street Boston, MA 02199-3600 Michael Allen Ponto Direct: 612-766-7000 FAEGRE & BAKER Firm: 612-766-7000 2200 Wells Fargo Center 90 S. Seventh Street Minneapolis, MN 55402-3901 Nancy R. Thomas Firm: 213-892-5553 Suite 3500 555 W. Fifth Street Los Angeles, CA 90013-0000 Michelle Visser ROPES & GRAY Firm: 415-315-6300 Three Embarcadero Center San Francisco, CA 94111-4006 Wendy J. Wildung Direct: 612-766-7000 FAEGRE & BAKER Firm: 612-766-7000 2200 Wells Fargo Center 90 S. Seventh Street Minneapolis, MN 55402-3901
5 of 8 3/31/2016 1:52 PM In re: Target Corporation Customer Data Security Breach Litigation ------------------------------ Jim Sciaroni Objector - Appellant v. Consumer Plaintiffs Target Corporation Defendant - Appellee
6 of 8 3/31/2016 1:52 PM 12/21/2015 12/21/2015 12/21/2015 12/23/2015 12/23/2015 12/29/2015 12/29/2015 01/25/2016 01/29/2016 02/03/2016 02/12/2016 02/12/2016 02/15/2016 02/17/2016 02/17/2016 7 pg, 26.98 KB 75 pg, 563.81 KB 2 pg, 17.15 KB 1 pg, 32.68 KB 6 pg, 112.09 KB 3 pg, 55.96 KB 3 pg, 56.19 KB 2 pg, 16.95 KB 2 pg, 17.24 KB 1 pg, 15.46 KB 11 pg, 429.81 KB 26 pg, 322.96 KB 3 pg, 40.23 KB 4 pg, 163.26 KB 2 pg, 17.25 KB Civil case docketed. [4348648] [15-3909] (CYZ) Originating court document filed consisting of notice of appeal, docket entries, order of 11/17/2015 [4348683] [15-3909] (CYZ) Transcript due on or before 02/01/2016. Appendix due 02/09/2016. BRIEF APPELLANT, Jim Sciaroni and Leif A. Olson due 02/09/2016 appellee brief. [4348690] [15-3909, 15-3912] (CYZ) APPEARANCE filed by Robert C. Black, III for Appellant Mr. Jim Sciaroni w/service 12/23/2015 [4349655] [15-3909] (RCB) CORPORATE disclosure statement filed by Appellant Mr. Leif A. Olson in 15-3912. - FOR CAL [4349755] [15-3912, 15-3909] (MAH) METHOD of appendix preparation filed by Appellant Mr. Leif A. Olson in 15-3912 - Separate Appendix - w/service 12/29/2015 [4350664] [15-3912, 15-3909] (MAH) Certificate of transcript filed by Appellant Mr. Leif A. Olson in 15-3912. Transcript ordered [4350665] [15-3912, 15-3909] (MAH) Transcript due on or before 03/07/2016. Appendix due 03/15/2016. BRIEF APPELLANT, Jim Sciaroni and Leif A. Olson due 03/15/2016 appellee brief. [4359499] [15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203] (CYZ) Transcript due on or before 03/09/2016. Appendix due 03/21/2016. BRIEF APPELLANT, Jim Sciaroni and Leif A. Olson due 03/21/2016 appellee brief. [4361532] [15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203, 16-1245] (CYZ) APPEARANCE filed by Robert C. Black, III for Appellant Mr. Jim Sciaroni w/service 02/03/2016 [4363187] [15-3909] (RCB) MOTION for stay pending appeal, filed by Attorney Mr. Robert C Black, III for Appellant Mr. Jim Sciaroni in 16-1245 w/service 02/12/2016. [4366813] [16-1245, 15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203] (RCB) MOTION to Vacate $46,872 of Appeal Bond, or in the Alternative, Motion for Order Vacating Joint and Several Liability and Requiring Appellant Sciaroni to Contribute His One-Half Share of Appeal Bond, or, in the Alternative, to Dismiss Appellant Sciaroni's Appeal, filed by Attorney Ms. Melissa Ann Holyoak for Appellant Mr. Leif A. Olson in 15-3912, 16-1203 w/service 02/12/2016. [4366962] [15-3912, 15-3909, 16-1203, 16-1245] (MAH) Certificate of transcript filed by Appellant Mr. Jim Sciaroni in 16-1245. Transcript ordered 02/22/2016 [4366995] [16-1245, 15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203] (RCB) Originating court document filed consisting court order dated 01/29/2016 regarding appeal bond. [4368165] [15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203, 16-1245] (CYZ) Transcript due on or before 03/28/2016. Appendix due 04/07/2016. BRIEF APPELLANT, Jim Sciaroni and Leif A. Olson due 04/07/2016 appellee brief. [4368222] [15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203, 16-1245, 16-1408] (CYZ) 02/17/2016 RECORD FILED - MOTION TRANSCRIPT, Location STP, Comments: Dist. Ct. Doc. #649, Source Location: DC, Dt. of Proceeding/Hearing: 11/10/2015, No. of Pgs.: 49, Court Reporter: Bebault, Carla R [4368227] [15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203, 16-1245, 16-1408] (CYZ)
7 of 8 3/31/2016 1:52 PM 02/17/2016 RECORD FILED - TRANSCRIPT, Location STP, Comments: PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT HEARING - Dist. Ct. Doc. #662, Source Location: DC, Dt. of Proceeding/Hearing: 12/02/2015, No. of Pgs.: 20, Court Reporter: Anderson, Jeanne Marie [4368228] [15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203, 16-1245, 16-1408] (CYZ) 02/19/2016 02/22/2016 02/22/2016 02/29/2016 03/18/2016 03/22/2016 35 pg, 274.08 KB 7 pg, 99.88 KB 12 pg, 209.33 KB 15 pg, 174.52 KB 1 pg, 44.91 KB 7 pg, 26.84 KB 1 pg, 82.08 KB 1 pg, 82.39 KB 5 pg, 84.04 KB 16 pg, 249.83 KB RESPONSE in opposition to motion for stay [4366813-2] filed by Attorney Mr. Vincent J. Esades for Appellee Plaintiffs' Lead Counsel in 16-1245, w/service 02/19/2016. [4369165] [16-1245, 15-3909] (VJE) RESPONSE in opposition to motion for stay [4366813-2] filed by Attorney Ms. Melissa Ann Holyoak for Appellant Mr. Leif A. Olson in 15-3912, w/service 02/22/2016. [4369442] [15-3912, 15-3909, 16-1203, 16-1245, 16-1408] (MAH) MOTION to spread Appellant Sciaroni's Motion to Stay, or in the alternative, for leave to file Response to Appellant Sciaroni's Motion to Stay, filed by Attorney Ms. Melissa Ann Holyoak for Appellant Mr. Leif A. Olson in 15-3912 w/service 02/22/2016. [4369577] [15-3912, 15-3909, 16-1203, 16-1245, 16-1408] (MAH) REPLY to response [4370326-2], motion for miscellaneous relief [4366962-2] filed by Appellant Mr. Leif A. Olson in 15-3912, 16-1203, 16-1408 w/service 02/29/2016. [4372412] [15-3912, 15-3909, 16-1203, 16-1245, 16-1408] (MAH) Originating court document filed consisting of originating court order dated 03/03/2016 regarding modifying the case captions by deleting Plaintiffs' Lead Counsel; Plaintiffs' Liaison Counsel" and substituting "Consumer Plaintiffs" as appellees in 15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203, 16-1245 & 16-1408. [4375102] [15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203, 16-1245, 16-1408] (CYZ) CLERK LETTER sent regarding new caption in case. [4375178] [15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203, 16-1245, 16-1408] (CYZ) APPEARANCE filed by Vincent J. Esades for Appellee Consumer Plaintiffs w/service [4375426] [15-3909] (VJE) APPEARANCE filed by David Woodward for Appellee Consumer Plaintiffs w/service [4375452] [15-3909] (DW) MOTION to hold the briefing schedule in abeyance filed by Attorney Ms. Melissa Ann Holyoak for Appellant Mr. Leif A. Olson in 15-3912, 16-1203, 16-1408 w/service 03/18/2016. [4379583] [15-3912, 15-3909, 16-1203, 16-1245, 16-1408]--[Edited 03/21/2016 by YML] ***TO CORRECT THE CM/ECF RELIEF USED*** (MAH) RESPONSE in opposition to motion hold briefing schedule in abeyance [4379583-2] filed by Attorney Mr. Vincent J. Esades for Appellee Consumer Plaintiffs in15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203, 16-1245, 16-1408, w/service 03/22/2016. [4380547] [15-3909, 15-3912, 16-1203, 16-1245, 16-1408]--[Edited 03/22/2016 by YML] (VJE)