Recent Cases of EU Banking Resolution - Liquidation One Rule Does Not Fit All
|
|
- Randell Cameron
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Recent Cases of EU Banking Resolution - Liquidation One Rule Does Not Fit All 03 July 2017 Commentary Carola Saldias Senior Director Financial Institutions Analytical Team carola.saldias@dagongeurope.com Evgeni Petkov Associate Director Financial Institutions Analytical Team evgeni.petkov@dagongeurope.com DAGONG EUROPE -
2 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. INTRODUCTION 2. COMPARISON OF THE APPLICATION OF THE SINGLE RESOLUTION MECHANISM 3. CASE OF BANCO POPULAR 4. CASE OF BANCA POPOLARE DI VICENZA AND VENETO BANCA 5. SIMILARITIES, DIFFERENCES AND CONCLUSION 2
3 1. INTRODUCTION The application of the Banking Recovery and Resolution Directive (BRRD) has been tested in practice in the last weeks with two very different cases. On one hand, the case of Banco Popular Español SA (headquartered in Spain) followed the process of resolution action and sale to avoid adverse effects on financial stability. On the other hand, the cases of Banca Popolare di Vicenza SpA and Veneto Banca SpA (both headquartered in Italy) will follow a liquidation process under Italian insolvency procedure; however they will also involve the sale of some parts of both banks and use of national funds to mitigate the impact on the real economy of the regions where the banks are most active. In this brief commentary, we introduce key financial highlights and background information on the three banks that were affected by the Single Resolution Board, we summarize the decisions for each case and we provide conclusions on the differences and similarities of the process. Ex. 1: Key financial highlights and ratios for the case study banks Key Financials YE-2016 (EUR Bn) Banco Popular Español SA Banca Popolare di Vicenza SpA Veneto Banca SpA Total Assets Total Gross Loans Total Deposits Senior Debt Subordinated Debt Common Equity Tier Key Ratios Gross Non-Performing Loans 18.8% 35.8% 38.5% Net Non-Performing Loans 9.9% 22.8% 26.3% Common Equity Tier 1 Ratio 12.1% 7.5% 6.4% Loans Market Share 7.8% 1.5% 1.0% Deposits Market Share 6.1% 1.0% 1.0% Source: Banks annual reports Important Note: Dagong Europe does not have ratings assigned to the banks mentioned in this commentary and comments on the solvency of the entities discussed below is beyond the scope of this document. 3
4 2. COMPARISON OF THE APPLICATION OF THE SINGLE RESOLUTION MECHANISM Ex. 2: Comparison of the Single Resolution Mechanism application for the banks Single Resolution Board Decision Banco Popular Español SA Banca Popolare di Vicenza SpA and Veneto Banca SpA (*) Effective date 07/06/ /06/2017 ECB declaration ECB determined that the bank was failing or likely to fail. The significant deterioration of the bank s liquidity situation in recent days led to a determination that the entity would have, in the near future, been unable to pay its debts or other liabilities as they fell due. ECB determined that the banks were failing or likely to fail as they breached supervisory capital requirements. The ECB had given the banks time to present capital plans, but it has been unable to offer credible solutions going forward. SRB declaration Buyer Process Additional conditions / measures Conditions for resolution met, resolution scheme adopted. Banco Santander S.A. for the price of EUR 1. Sale subject to normal merger and regulatory review. Existing shares and Additional Tier 1 instruments written down. Tier 2 instruments converted into new shares and transferred to Banco Santander S.A. for the price of EUR 1, or effectively written down. In accordance with the regulations, the SRB obtained a valuation from an independent expert. The valuation estimated a negative economic value of EUR 2Bn in the baseline scenario and EUR 8.2Bn in the most adverse scenario. The necessary actions must be implemented by FROB, the national resolution authority. No losses for senior debt holders and depositors. No state guarantees and no transfer of public funds to the acquiring bank. The single resolution board has decided that resolution action is not warranted. The winding up of the banks will take place under national proceedings launched by the national authorities. Intesa Sanpaolo SpA (Intesa Sanpaolo) for the price of EUR 1. Liquidation and assets-liabilities transfer supported by the Italian government. Italian authorities will wind up the banks under the Italian national insolvency procedures. Existing shares and subordinated debt written down but subordinated bonds issued before June 12th, 2014 held by retail investors will be subject to reimbursement. No losses for senior debt holders and depositors. Existing shareholders and subordinated debt holders have fully contributed to the costs, reducing the costs of the intervention for the Italian state. Both banks will be wound up in an orderly fashion and exit the market, while the transferred activities will be restructured and downsized by Intesa Sanpaolo. The subsequent deep integration by Intesa Sanpaolo will return the sold parts to viability. The European Commission confirmed that the measures do not constitute aid to Intesa Sanpaolo, because it was selected after an open, fair and transparent sale process. Cash injections of EUR 4.7Bn to Intesa Sanpaolo to maintain its CET 1 ratio unaffected by the integration (EUR 3.5Bn in cash injection and EUR 1.3Bn for integration costs); EUR 4Bn in performing loans not classified as deteriorated yet but that are of high risk and can be returned up to 3 years from the transfer. Guarantees for up to EUR 5.3Bn (EUR 6.3Bn after the due diligence) Additional guarantees of EUR 1.5Bn to cover potential fulfilment of legal obligations transferred; Both guarantees and cash injections are backed by the Italian state's senior claims in the assets of the liquidation mass. (*) The liquidation and sale process applicable for Banca Popolare di Vicenza SpA and Veneto Banca SpA does not differentiate both banks and it is presented as an aggregate transaction. 4
5 3. CASE OF BANCO POPULAR ESPAÑOL SA Background: Banco Popular Español SA (BPE) is a Spanish bank ranked 6 th by total assets in the country, with significant market shares in loans and deposits. It had been listed on the stock exchange, with ownership widely spread. BPE had a very large real estate exposure for which it had to build large loan loss reserves, leading to losses of EUR 3.6Bn in 2016 and EUR 137Mn in 1Q17. Capital ratios also deteriorated further in 1Q17 (CET 1 to 10.0% and total capital ratio to 11.9%), albeit remaining within the regulatory requirements. On April 10, 2017, during the Annual General Meeting, the bank announced that it would be looking for a capital increase, triggering a sharp slump in its share price. On April 19, 2017, the Spanish Minister of Economy, affirmed that BPE had neither solvency nor liquidity issues. Between May 11 and May 16, 2017 the bank issued 3 statements denying, or clarifying, negative news coverage. News reports published on May 31, 2017 reported that the bank would be wound up if it fails to find a buyer. That information exacerbated the outflow of deposits and market funds which had started already. On June 6, 2017 the European Central Bank (ECB) informed the Single Resolution Board (SRB) that the entity was failing or likely to fail. On June 8, 2017, the ECB commented that the decision had been triggered by a liquidity run and was not a matter of assessing the solvency of the bank. Decision taken by the SRB 1 : On 7 June 2017, the SRB took resolution action in respect of BPE. The SRB assessed that the conditions for resolution, were met, namely: a) The entity is failing or likely to fail. b) There was no reasonable prospect that any alternative private sector measures or supervisory action would prevent the failure of the Institution within a reasonable timeframe. c) Resolution action would be necessary in the public interest, in two aspects: i) the significant market shares of BPE in deposits and loans, specifically SME loans and ii) to avoid adverse effects on financial stability. The SRB has assessed that the winding up of BPE under normal insolvency proceedings would not meet those resolution objectives to the same extent. As the conditions for resolution were met, the SRB adopted a resolution scheme providing for the application of the sale of BPE. Under the resolution scheme, following a marketing process, the SRB has decided to transfer BPE to Banco Santander S.A. (Santander). The SRB decided to exercise the power of write-down and conversion of capital instruments prior to the transfer, to address the shortfall in the value of BPE. In particular, all the existing shares (Common Equity Tier 1), and the Additional Tier 1 instruments were written down, while the Tier 2 instruments were converted into new shares, which were transferred to Santander for the price of EUR 1. Senior debt and deposits were not affected. The resolution action allows for the continuation of the provision of critical functions and services to individuals and SMEs by BPE, and, in particular, the deposit-taking and lending services. The necessary actions must be implemented by Fondo de Reestructuración Ordenada Bancaria (FROB), the national resolution authority. Market Reaction: After the announcement of the BPE transaction on June 7, Santander shares initially took a slight hit, but recovered almost fully during the day and gained more than 3% the next day. Santander senior unsecured issues were unaffected by the announcement. In our view that shows that market participants do not expect the acquisition of BPE to have a significant effect on the profitability and creditworthiness of Santander. Perpetual subordinated bonds of BPE, which had been trading above par until March 2017 and had gradually slumped below 60 until June 6, were wiped out. Cedulas issued by BPE were unaffected. Spanish government bonds gained slightly and the yield on 10-year bonds fell by about 9bp, indicating some relieve on the part of investors that public funds would not be used to bail out BPE creditors. European banks share prices gained slightly. 1 Source: Single Resolution Board: 5
6 4. CASE OF BANCA POPOLARE DI VICENZA SpA (BPV) AND VENETO BANCA SpA (VB) Background: BPV and VB were regional players in the Italian region of Veneto, both with market shares around 1.0% in terms of deposits and ranked 17 th and 20 th respectively, by total assets in Italy. Both banks had a traditional banking model, with loan portfolios mostly composed by local SMEs and retail clients from the north of Italy. They were created as Banche Popolare (Italian cooperative banks) and in 2016 launched capital increases that were subscribed by the Atlante Fund 2, owning 99.33% of BPV and 97.64% of VB. After the release of YE16 results, both banks presented CET 1 ratios of 7.5% for BPV and 6.4% for VB, which were above the minimum regulatory requirements but significantly below the latest SREP update requirement (10.25% and 8.75%, respectively). Following a series of recommendations and structural changes requested by the ECB, both banks presented their new strategic plans for the period in which a merger between BPV and VB was proposed. In March 2017, both banks made requests to the Italian state for a precautionary recapitalisation 3 to address their capital shortfalls, which were then subject to discussions between the European Commission and the Italian authorities. Both banks had very high amounts of non-performing loans, high operating costs and have been recording losses for the last four years. In addition, the banks were not able to adjust their balance sheets to the requirements of the BRRD, which are aimed among other things at limiting the impact of resolution or orderly liquidation. As a result of their financial distress, the precautionary recapitalisation was subject to strict conditions, including that the state support was deemed only temporary and could not be used to offset losses that the banks have incurred or were likely to incur in the future. A bank that is declared as failing or likely to fail by the ECB is not eligible for a precautionary recapitalisation. Decision taken by the SRB 4 : The SRB decided on June 23 rd 2017 not to take resolution action in respect of BPV and VB. The SRB assessed that while the conditions for a resolution action were met, given the particular characteristics of the banks and their specific financial and economic situations, resolution actions were not necessarily in the public interest. The failure of the banks was not deemed likely to result in significant adverse effects on financial stability taking into account, in particular, the low financial and operational interconnections with other financial institutions. The banks will be subject to winding up under Italian insolvency proceedings and the decision is to be implemented by Banca d Italia, in its capacity as National Resolution Authority. The SRB reached this conclusion taking into account several elements, including the banks inability to raise sufficient additional private capital, the weaknesses and lack of credibility of their business plans, and the ineffectiveness of the application of the power to write down or convert capital instruments to remedy the breach of the capital requirements. Liquidation procedure implemented by the National Resolution Authority: The Italian government, after been informed by the Banca d Italia about the decision taken by the ECB and the SRB on the request for liquidation of BPV and VB, established that the liquidation of both banks could destroy the value of the banks. This could also generate significant losses for unprotected retail investors and disrupt the access to credit for companies and families in the region, with additional consequences for the economy. With this statement, the government approved on June 25 th 2017 a law decree that will allow a liquidation procedure for BPV and VB with a transfer of the performing assets and some liabilities of both banks to Intesa Sanpaolo for the price of EUR 1. The transfer is structured in a way that will allow Intesa Sanpaolo to receive the good assets and only the liabilities related to senior unsecured debt. The banks equity and subordinated debt, in addition with 2 Atlante Fund is a closed-end alternative investment fund regulated by Italian law with a size of EUR 4.2Bn and composed by 67 Italian and foreign institutions. 3 Extraordinary and temporary financial support from the Italian government, Law Decree no. 237/ Source: Single Resolution Board: 6
7 their non-performing loans portfolios will remain in the entities under liquidation. However, there will be a mixed solution for subordinated bonds held by retail investors and acquired before June 12 th, They will be covered by the Solidarity Fund created in The European Commission was informed about the measures taken and approved the aid for market exit proposed for BPV and VB, stating that Italy considers state aid as necessary to avoid a market disturbance in the Veneto region. The European Commission allowed the use of national funds to facilitate the liquidation process and therefore to mitigate regional economic effects, as well as considered that the guarantees and cash injections made by the Italian state are backed up by the senior claims on the assets in the liquidation mass. Market Reaction: Since the announcement of the transaction, Intesa Sanpaolo shares posted gains for three consecutive days, totalling almost 6%. In our view that shows that market participants evaluate the transaction as positive for Intesa Sanpaolo, as it would gain some additional market share and good assets without being exposed to the risks of the existing nonperforming loans of the banks in liquidation. The perceived increased likelihood of state support for Italian banks, with the favourable effects on funding costs, also has an impact on share prices of Italian banks. European banks also posted gains, contrary to the movement of the aggregate European stock market. Subordinated bonds of BPV, which had already been trading below 20 until the announcement of the liquidation, were wiped out. Italian government bonds moved largely in line with the European government bond market, indicating most likely that the bail-out was expected and the impact on public finances priced-in. 5. SIMILARITIES, DIFFERENCES AND CONCLUSION KEY SIMILARITIES In all cases depositors and senior bond holders were unaffected, which allows to make a more detailed analysis of the optimal absorption capacity of a bank s own funds in cases of resolution/liquidation. KEY DIFFERENCES Liquidity versus solvency issues; In general it would be expected that institutions with liquidity issues would receive support from the ECB (through the Emergency Liquidity Assistance programme updated in May 2017) or from national central banks, while insolvent institutions would be subject to the Single Resolution Mechanism; Subordinated debt was completely wiped out in the case of BPE, but a more differentiated solution was implemented in the case of BPV and VB due to specific enforced laws at national level; No state aid/guarantees and no transfer of public funds to the acquiring bank in Spain; significant state commitments to support the sale of BPV and VB in Italy. CONCLUSION Since the implementation of the BRRD in Europe, the cases of fully applicability of the Single Resolution Mechanisms do not allow yet to define a level playing field for banks. The cases presented above show that there is still room for interpretation of systemic importance and national authorities have still the possibility to decide on their favoured solution in the case of liquidation. In our opinion, the actions undertaken in the BPE case were completely in line with the definitions stated by the Single Resolution Mechanism. The case of the Italian banks shows that there still exists a different view between the ECB and the national authorities with regards to systemic importance, liquidation process and the use of public funds in the public interest. The cases have implications for the application of the BRRD and for state support likelihood for issuers and for senior debt issues, but they are not straightforward. The different approaches taken highlight that the cases in which a resolution/liquidation procedure needs to be implemented are still subject to country specifics and a standard model and an even playing field are still not the case. 7
8 DISCLAIMERS NO CONTENT (INCLUDING CREDIT-RELATED ANALYSES AND DATA, VALUATIONS, OR OUTPUT THEREFROM) OR ANY PART THEREOF ( CONTENT ) MAY BE MODIFIED, REVERSE ENGINEERED, REPRODUCED OR DISTRIBUTED IN ANY FORM BY ANY MEANS, OR STORED IN A DATABASE OR RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN PERMISSION OF DAGONG EUROPE. DAGONG EUROPE DOES NOT INTEND TO ASSUME, AND IS NOT ASSUMING, ANY RESPONSIBILITY OR LIABILITY TO ANY PARTY ARISING OUT OF, OR WITH RESPECT TO, THIS CONTENT. THIS CONTENT IS NOT INTENDED TO, AND DOES NOT, FORM A PART OF ANY CONTRACT WITH ANYONE, EITHER DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY. THE CONTENT SHALL NOT BE USED FOR ANY UNLAWFUL OR UNAUTHORIZED PURPOSES. RELATIONSHIP WITH ENTITIES OR INDIVIDUALS DAGONG EUROPE DOES NOT HAVE A FIDUCIARY RELATIONSHIP WITH ANY ENTITY OR OTHER INDIVIDUAL RECEIVING THIS RESEARCH. NOTHING IS INTENDED TO OR SHOULD BE CONSTRUED AS CREATING A FIDUCIARY RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DAGONG EUROPE AND ANY INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY RECEIVING THIS RESEARCH. DAGONG EUROPE DOES NOT PROVIDE TO ANY PARTY ANY CONSULTANCY SERVICE, FINANCIAL ADVICE OR LEGAL, AUDITING, ACCOUNTING, APPRAISAL, VALUATION OR ACTUARIAL SERVICES Dagong Europe Credit Rating Srl (collectively, Dagong Europe ). All rights reserved. 8
9 Via dei Bossi 2a, Milan Italy Tel (+39) , fax (+39)
Italian Banks - Accelerating the Sales of NPL to Improve Asset Quality
Italian Banks - Accelerating the Sales of NPL to Improve Asset Quality 31 July 2017 Commentary Carola Saldias Senior Director Financial Institutions Analytical Team carola.saldias@dagongeurope.com Evgeni
More informationItalian Banking Sector Outlook 2018
SECTOR OUTLOOK Italian Banking Sector Outlook 2018 Contacts: Carola Saldias Senior Director +39 02 7274 6011 carola.saldias@dagongeurope.com Evgeni Petkov, CFA Associate Director +49 69 7805 9056 evgeni.petkov@dagongeurope.com
More informationItaly: liquidation of Veneto Banca and Banca Popolare di Vicenza
ECONOMIC RESEARCH DEPARTMENT Italy: liquidation of Veneto Banca and Banca Popolare di Vicenza Given their modest size, Veneto Banca and Banca Popolare di Vicenza are set to undergo an insolvency procedure
More information1. Resolution of banks and investment firms
C. Recovery and resolution During the year under review, the Bank s work on recovery and resolution mainly concerned resolution in the banking sector. While the European institutional framework remained
More informationItaly-Based Veneto Banca 'BB/B' Ratings Affirmed On Results Of ECB Review; Outlook Remains Negative
Research Update: Italy-Based Veneto Banca 'BB/B' Ratings Affirmed On Results Of ECB Review; Outlook Primary Credit Analyst: Francesca Sacchi, Milan (39) 02-72111-272; francesca.sacchi@standardandpoors.com
More informationAtlante Fund Offers Italian Banks Support, But There's A Sting In The Tail
Atlante Fund Offers Italian Banks Support, But There's A Sting In The Tail Primary Credit Analyst: Luigi Motti, Madrid (34) 91-788-7234; luigi.motti@standardandpoors.com Secondary Contacts: Mirko Sanna,
More informationThe Day after Tomorrow: The Future of the Financial Intermediation
The Day after Tomorrow: The Future of the Financial Intermediation Challenges of resolution planning The Joint NBR and IMF Financial Stability Seminar - 12 th edition Krzysztof Broda The Bank Guarantee
More informationThe Relevance of the Resolution Tools Within the SRM
The Relevance of the Resolution Tools Within the SRM EBI Working Paper no. 29/2018 https://ssrn.com/abstract=3274520 EBI Annual Conference, 21 and 22 February 2018 Jens-Hinrich Binder University of Tübingen
More informationHearing on Decree Law 237/2016 Urgent measures for the protection of savings in the banking sector
Joint Session of the Sixth Committees of the Senate of the Republic (Finance and Treasury) and the Chamber of Deputies (Finance) Hearing on Decree Law 237/2016 Urgent measures for the protection of savings
More informationDRAFT REPORT. EN United in diversity EN. European Parliament 2017/2072(INI) on Banking Union Annual Report 2017 (2017/2072(INI))
European Parliament 2014-2019 Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs 2017/2072(INI) 20.10.2017 DRAFT REPORT on Banking Union Annual Report 2017 (2017/2072(INI)) Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs
More informationEUROPEAN COMMISSION. State Aid SA (2017/N) Italy Additional liquidity support to Banca Popolare di Vicenza
EUROPEAN COMMISSION Brussels, 12.4.2017 C(2017) 2566 final In the published version of this decision, some information has been omitted, pursuant to articles 30 and 31 of Council Regulation (EU) 2015/1589
More informationBanking Union Scrutiny IN-DEPTH ANALYSIS. Requested by the ECON committee. Economic Governance Support Unit. External authors:
IN-DEPTH ANALYSIS Requested by the ECON committee The Provision of Critical Functions at Global, National and Regional Level Is there a need for further legal/regulatory clarification if liquidation is
More informationPublic support and the use of the Resolution Fund under BRRD
Public support and the use of the Resolution Fund under BRRD Paolo Fucile Directorate General Financial Stability, Financial Markets and Capital Markets Union 05/12/2016 Key objectives of BRRD Maintain
More informationChapter E: The US versus EU resolution regime
Chapter E: The US versus EU resolution regime 1. Introduction Resolution frameworks should always seek two objectives. First, resolving banks should be a quick process and must avoid negative spill over
More informationAsia Credit Research. The Spanish Resolution: Different Symptoms call for Different Remedies
Asia Credit Research The Spanish Resolution: Different Symptoms call for Different Remedies Summary / Key credit considerations Tuesday, 13 June 2017 The resolution of Banco Popular Espanol SA has highlighted
More informationNOTICE OF THE SINGLE RESOLUTION BOARD. of 2 August 2018
NOTICE OF THE SINGLE RESOLUTION BOARD of 2 August 2018 regarding its preliminary decision on whether compensation needs to be granted to the shareholders and creditors in respect of which the resolution
More informationSpain-Based Banco Popular Espanol Ratings Raised To 'BBB+/A-2' On Acquisition By Santander; Outlook Positive
Research Update: Spain-Based Banco Popular Espanol Ratings Raised To 'BBB+/A-2' On Acquisition By Santander; Outlook Positive Primary Credit Analyst: Lucia Gonzalez, Madrid (34) 91 788 7219; lucia.gonzalez@spglobal.com
More informationFitch Takes Rating Action on Italian Mid-Sized Banks Ratings 26 Jul :37 PM (EDT)
Pagina 1 di 6 Fitch Takes Rating Action on Italian Mid-Sized Banks Ratings 26 Jul 2013 12:37 PM (EDT) Endorsement Policy Link to Fitch Ratings' Report: Peer Review: Italian Mid-Sized Banks Fitch Ratings-London-26
More informationThe Lender of Last Resort in the Euro Area: Where Do We Stand?
The Lender of Last Resort in the Euro Area: Where Do We Stand? Karl Whelan University College Dublin Presentation at University College Cork March 9, 2018 Plan for this Talk Lender of last resort Rationale
More informationCase Study of recent Bank Resolutions in Europe and related Litigation. Workshop on the Role of the Judiciary in Bank Resolution for Judges
Case Study of recent Bank Resolutions in Europe and related Litigation Workshop on the Role of the Judiciary in Bank Resolution for Judges Kolja Stehl, Counsel, Shearman & Sterling LLP Kiev, October 2017
More informationTLAC STRATEGY UPDATE JANUARY 2017 FIXED INCOME INVESTORS PRESENTATION
TLAC STRATEGY UPDATE JANUARY 2017 FIXED INCOME INVESTORS PRESENTATION Important information Banco Santander, S.A. ("Santander") cautions that this presentation contains forward-looking statements. These
More informationUNIONE DI BANCHE ITALIANE S.P.A. and registered at the Companies' Registry of Bergamo under registration number )
SUPPLEMENT DATED 5 JULY 2017 TO THE BASE PROSPECTUS APPROVED ON 28 JULY 2016 AS SUPPLEMENTED ON 12 AUGUST 2016, ON 26 JANUARY 2017, ON 1 MARCH 2017, ON 6 MARCH 2017 AND ON 12 APRIL 2017 UNIONE DI BANCHE
More informationUneven progress in implementing cross-border bank resolution in the EU
No 2017-26/ July 2017 Uneven progress in implementing cross-border bank resolution in the EU Karel Lannoo Summary Implementing the ambitious framework for cross-border bank resolution in the EU is necessarily
More informationResolution Regimes: FSB s Key Attributes, TLAC & EU s MREL. Seminar on Crisis Management and Bank Resolution
Resolution Regimes: FSB s Key Attributes, TLAC & EU s MREL Seminar on Crisis Management and Bank Resolution Abuja, Nigeria 16-20 January 2017 Amarendra Mohan Independent Financial Sector Expert (formerly
More informationRating Action: Moody's confirms Banco Popolare's Ba3 deposit and senior debt rating; outlook stable
Rating Action: Moody's confirms Banco Popolare's Ba3 deposit and senior debt rating; outlook stable Global Credit Research - 27 May 2015 Standalone BCA upgraded to b2 from b3 London, 27 May 2015 -- Moody's
More informationPRESS RELEASE. The main figures for 2016 compared with 2015
PRESS RELEASE The first stage of the Business Plan is currently being concluded ahead of schedule and with better-than-expected results: - following the conclusion in November of the first wave of the
More informationBanca Sella Holding. Update Following Rating Action. Rating Scorecard - Key Financial Ratios. Source: Moody's Financial Metrics.
CREDIT OPINION 1 December 16 Banca Sella Holding Update Following Rating Action Update Summary Rating Rationale Banca Sella Holding's Baa deposit rating is underpinned by the bank's ba standalone baseline
More informationExecutive summary. 11 July 2012
11 July 2012 Update on the implementation of Capital Plans following the EBA s 2011 Recommendation on the creation of temporary capital buffers to restore market confidence Executive summary 1. In December
More informationThe provision of critical functions at global, national or regional level
IN-DEPTH ANALYSIS Requested by the ECON Committee The provision of critical functions at global, national or regional level Is there a need for further legal/regulatory clarification if liquidation is
More informationDevelopments in regulatory frameworks: implications for risk management. Colin Ellis, Chief Credit Officer EMEA
Developments in regulatory frameworks: implications for risk management Colin Ellis, Chief Credit Officer EMEA 26 September 2017 Key messages 1 Banking Union is a useful step; but even if credible and
More informationAfter the global financial crisis: challenges for the EU Banking System
After the global financial crisis: challenges for the EU Banking System Conference on «The Changing Environment and Deposit Insurers» Session 1 Tokyo, 16 February 2017 Giuseppe Boccuzzi Agenda 1 2 3 4
More informationThe below new definitions are inserted into the TOB at Annex 1, Part 1, definitions:
NOTICE SUPPLEMENTING CITI'S TERMS OF BUSINESS FOR PROFESSIONAL CLIENTS AND ELIGIBLE COUNTERPARTIES IN RELATION TO THE BANK RECOVERY AND RESOLUTION DIRECTIVE Dear Client, We refer to Citi s Terms of Business
More informationCreditreform Bank Rating
Rating object Intesa Sanpaolo S.p.A. (Group) as parent of Rating information Long Term Issuer Rating / Outlook: Short Term: BBB / stable L3 Rating of Bank Capital and Unsecured Debt Instruments: Senior
More informationGermany-Based UniCredit Bank AG Upgraded To 'BBB+/A-2' On Improving Conditions At The Italian Parent; Outlook Developing
Research Update: Germany-Based UniCredit Bank AG Upgraded To 'BBB+/A-2' On Improving Conditions At The Italian Parent; Outlook Developing Primary Credit Analyst: Benjamin Heinrich, CFA, FRM, Frankfurt
More informationTHE SPANISH BANKING RESOLUTION FRAMEWORK
THE SPANISH BANKING RESOLUTION FRAMEWORK Francisco-Javier Priego / Secretary General Roberto Ugena / Head of the Legal Department XI MEETING OF CENTRAL BANK LEGAL ADVISORS Santiago, Chile 23-25 October
More informationCredit Opinion: Banco Popolare Società Cooperativa
Credit Opinion: Banco Popolare Società Cooperativa Global Credit Research - 15 Apr 2016 Verona, Italy Ratings Category Outlook Bank Deposits Baseline Credit Assessment Adjusted Baseline Credit Assessment
More informationPlacement of financial instruments with depositors, retail investors and policy holders ('Self placement')
JC 2014 62 31 July 2014 Placement of financial instruments with depositors, retail investors and policy holders ('Self placement') Reminder to credit institutions and insurance undertakings about applicable
More informationAPPLICATION OF THE MINIMUM REQUIREMENT FOR OWN FUNDS AND ELIGIBLE LIABILITIES (MREL) Bank Resolution and Recovery Directive 2014/59/EU
MEMORANDUM 14.2.2018 This memorandum was last updated on 14 February 2018, and it reflects the outlines set in the memorandum on MREL called "SRB Policy for 2017 and Next Steps" issued by the SRB on 20
More informationRussia-Based B&N Bank Affirmed At 'B/B'; Outlook Stable
Research Update: Russia-Based B&N Bank Affirmed At 'B/B'; Outlook Stable Primary Credit Analyst: Anastasia Turdyeva, Moscow (7) 495-783-40-91; anastasia.turdyeva@spglobal.com Secondary Contact: Roman Rybalkin,
More informationCredit Opinion: Banca Sella Holding
Credit Opinion: Banca Sella Holding Global Credit Research - 2 Nov 215 Biella, Italy Ratings Category Outlook Bank Deposits Baseline Credit Assessment Adjusted Baseline Credit Assessment Counterparty Risk
More informationBURSA MALAYSIA SECURITIES BERHAD
BURSA MALAYSIA SECURITIES BERHAD PRACTICE NOTE 17 CRITERIA AND OBLIGATIONS OF PN17 ISSUERS Details Cross References Effective date: 3 January 2005 Paragraphs 8.03A, 8.04, 16.02 and 16.11 Revision date:
More informationBanking Sector Dynamics
April 2015 Banking Sector Dynamics Issue 2 In this issue At a glance 1 Capital adequacy 2 Key banking sector indicators 3 Total assets 4 Total deposits and liabilities 6 Recent developments 8 Key events
More informationBasel 3 Pillar 3 Disclosure as at 30 June 2017
Basel 3 Pillar 3 Disclosure as at 30 June 2017 This is an English translation from the original Terzo pilastro di Basilea 3 Informativa al pubblico al 30 giugno 2017 and was prepared solely for the convenience
More informationTransaction Update: Bankia S.A. (Mortgage Covered Bonds)
Transaction Update: Bankia S.A. (Mortgage Covered Bonds) Primary Credit Analyst: Ana Galdo, Madrid (34) 91-389-6947; ana.galdo@spglobal.com Secondary Contact: Maria Luisa Gomez Grande, Madrid (34) 91-788-7208;
More informationCyprus Financial Assistance Programme Memoranda signed with the EU and the International Monetary Fund: Q&A regarding the financial sector
Cyprus Financial Assistance Programme Memoranda signed with the EU and the International Monetary Fund: Q&A regarding the financial sector Part A: Key policy questions Q1: What were the reasons that Cyprus
More informationThe orderly liquidation of Veneto Banca and Banca Popolare di Vicenza
IPOL EGOV DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR INTERNAL POLICIES ECONOMIC GOVERNANCE SUPPORT UNIT B R IE F IN G The orderly liquidation of Veneto Banca and Banca Popolare di Vicenza This briefing focusses on the failure
More informationAnnual Report of the National Resolution Fund. Rome, 28 April st financial year. 1 st. Financial Year
Annual Report of the National Resolution Fund Rome, 28 April 2016 1 st financial year Financial Year 1 st Annual Report of the National Resolution Fund Financial Year Rome, 28 April 2016 Banca d Italia,
More informationLISTING PROSPECTUS DATED FEBRUARY 7, U.S.$10,000,000,000 U.S. COMMERCIAL PAPER PROGRAM of BANCO BILBAO VIZCAYA ARGENTARIA, S.A.
LISTING PROSPECTUS DATED FEBRUARY 7, 2018 U.S.$10,000,000,000 U.S. COMMERCIAL PAPER PROGRAM of BANCO BILBAO VIZCAYA ARGENTARIA, S.A. THIS LISTING PROSPECTUS IS NOT AN OFFERING DOCUMENT. IT HAS BEEN PREPARED
More informationCOMP Operations EUROPEAN COMMISSION. Brussels, C(2011) 5461 final. SA (2011/N) Spain Recapitalisation of the CAM Group.
EUROPEAN COMMISSION Brussels, 24.7.2011 C(2011) 5461 final COMP Operations Subject: SA.33402 (2011/N) Spain Recapitalisation of the CAM Group Sir, 1 PROCEDURE (1) On 29 June 2010, Spain informed the Commission
More informationII-Annex 2: Resolution of Insurers
II-Annex 2: Resolution of Insurers II-Annex 2 Resolution of Insurers Excerpt from Key Attributes of Effective Resolution Regimes for Financial Institutions The Key Attributes of Effective Resolution Regimes
More informationMediobanca SpA. Primary Credit Analyst: Regina Argenio, Milan (39) ;
Summary: Mediobanca SpA Primary Credit Analyst: Regina Argenio, Milan (39) 02-72111-208; regina.argenio@spglobal.com Secondary Contact: Mirko Sanna, Milan (39) 02-72111-275; mirko.sanna@spglobal.com Table
More informationState aid rules in the context of BRRD
State aid rules in the context of BRRD Presentation Europolis Seminar January 2017 Bernhard Windisch, DG Competition, European Commission Agenda 1. State aid rules 2. in the context of BRRD and SRMR 3.
More informationOverview of the post-consultation revisions to the TLAC Principles and Term Sheet
9 November 2015 Overview of the post-consultation revisions to the TLAC Principles and Term Sheet On 10 November 2014, the FSB published a consultative document with policy proposals developed at the request
More informationBANCO BILBAO VIZCAYA ARGENTARIA, S.A., ( BBVA ) EMIR Article 39(7) CLEARING MEMBER DISCLOSURE DOCUMENT
Version: February 2015 BANCO BILBAO VIZCAYA ARGENTARIA, S.A., ( BBVA ) EMIR Article 39(7) CLEARING MEMBER DISCLOSURE DOCUMENT Introduction Throughout this document references to we, our and us are references
More informationLong-Term Credit Rating BBB+ Short-Term Credit Rating A-2. Low, National Systemic. Development Strategy: Sustainability and Competition:
Financial Institutions Credit View OTP Bank Plc. 28 November 2017 Primary Analyst Evgeni Petkov, CFA Associate Director Financial Institutions Schillerstraße 2, 60313 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Tel. +49
More informationIntroduction Post crisis Bank resolution principles with a focus on the BRRD in the EU
Introduction Post crisis Bank resolution principles with a focus on the BRRD in the EU Pamela Lintner Sr. Financial Sector Specialist Workshop on the role of the Judiciary in Bank resolution for Judges
More informationQuarterly results presentation
Quarterly results presentation 1Q 2017 28 April 2017 1 Disclaimer This document was originally prepared in Spanish. The English version published here is for information purposes only. In the event of
More informationJune 2018 The Bank of England s approach to setting a minimum requirement for own funds and eligible liabilities (MREL)
June 2018 The Bank of England s approach to setting a minimum requirement for own funds and eligible liabilities (MREL) Statement of Policy (updating November 2016) June 2018 The Bank of England s approach
More informationBanking Resolution Spanish experience. Future implications of BRRD.
Banking Resolution Spanish experience. Future implications of BRRD. FinSAC workshop on Recovery and Resolution Planning 24 April Mario Delgado EY; Partner, Risk & Regulation Banking resolution Spanish
More informationNote on the Strategic Development of an Enhanced Bank Resolution Framework for Ukraine in Alignment with the EU Acquis March 2019
Note on the Strategic Development of an Enhanced Bank Resolution Framework for Ukraine in Alignment with the EU Acquis March 2019 Disclaimer: This summary is based on discussions held in a Working Group
More informationResearch Update: Italy-Based Banca Carige SpA Ratings Lowered To 'BBB-/A-3' On Italy BICRA Change; Outlook Negative.
February 10, 2012 Research Update: Italy-Based Banca Carige SpA Ratings Lowered To 'BBB-/A-3' On Italy BICRA Change; Outlook Negative Table Of Contents Overview Rating Action Rationale Outlook Ratings
More information5FINANCIAL MARKETS: GAPS IN REGULATION, GROWING RISKS
5FINANCIAL MARKETS: GAPS IN REGULATION, GROWING RISKS I. Gaps in regulation should be closed II. Room for improvement in the bank resolution regime 1. Gaps in the resolution regime 2. How to reform the
More informationFinal Guidelines. on the treatment of shareholders in bail-in or the write-down and conversion of capital instruments EBA/GL/2017/04 11/07/2017
GUIDELINES ON THE TREATMENT OF SHAREHOLDERS EBA/GL/2017/04 11/07/2017 Final Guidelines on the treatment of shareholders in bail-in or the write-down and conversion of capital instruments 1. Compliance
More information4 Bank failing or likely to fail
23 Restoring confidence. The changing European banking landscape 4 Bank failing or likely to fail If it becomes clear that a bank is unable to restore its financial position and any early intervention
More informationBANCA POPOLARE DELL'ALTO ADIGE VOLKSBANK
Base Prospectus BANCA POPOLARE DELL'ALTO ADIGE VOLKSBANK S.p.A. (incorporated with limited liability as a società per azioni under the laws of the Republic of Italy) EUR 1,000,000,000 Euro Medium Term
More informationBanca Popolare dell'alto Adige Outlook Revised To Positive From Stable; 'BB/B' Ratings Affirmed
Research Update: Banca Popolare dell'alto Adige Outlook Revised To Positive From Stable; 'BB/B' Ratings Affirmed Primary Credit Analyst: Letizia Conversano, Milan (39) 02-72111-283; letizia.conversano@spglobal.com
More informationThe EU Framework for Deposit Guarantee Schemes
The EU Framework for Deposit Guarantee Schemes Raluca Painter European Commission Senior Policy Officer, Financial Stability Unit 21/09/2014 Background: key steps Directive 94/19/EC of 30 May 1994 on DGS
More informationMain principles for resolution of small and mediumsized banks and determination of minimum requirements for own funds and eligible liabilities (MREL)
Discussion paper Main principles for resolution of small and mediumsized banks and determination of minimum requirements for own funds and eligible liabilities (MREL) Introduction According to the Danish
More informationWHY COCOS ARE LESS PROBLEMATIC THAN BAILING-IN OF LIABILITIES
WHY COCOS ARE LESS PROBLEMATIC THAN BAILING-IN OF LIABILITIES THE FOURTH SYMPOSIUM ON ENDING TOO BIG TO FAIL, FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF MINNEAPOLIS SEPTEMBER 26 PROFESSOR EMILIOS AVGOULEAS CHAIR IN INTERNATIONAL
More informationComunicato Stampa DIFFUSO A CURA DEL SERVIZIO SEGRETERIA PARTICOLARE DEL DIRETTORIO E COMUNICAZIONE
Comunicato Stampa DIFFUSO A CURA DEL SERVIZIO SEGRETERIA PARTICOLARE DEL DIRETTORIO E COMUNICAZIONE Results of the Comprehensive Assessment 26 October 2014 The results have been published today of the
More informationSingle Resolution Mechanism
Single Resolution Mechanism A pro-active approach to resolution planning November 2015 Executive summary Over the coming year, the Single Resolution Mechanism (SRM) will undertake two exercises that will
More informationBANCO POPULAR ESPAÑOL, S.A.
BANCO POPULAR ESPAÑOL, S.A. Audit report, Condensed Interim Financial Statements and Interim Management Report at 30 June 2017 PricewaterhouseCoopers Auditores, S.L., Torre PwC, Pº de la Castellana 259
More informationSetting of MREL for subsidiaries of foreign banks
Setting of MREL for subsidiaries of foreign banks Emil Vonvea, Director, Bank Resolution Department National Bank of Romania FINSAC WORKSHOP ON BAIL-IN AND MREL, Vienna 13 th December, 2016 The opinions
More informationQuarterly results presentation
Quarterly results presentation 3Q 2017 30 October 2017 1 Disclaimer This document was originally prepared in Spanish. The English version published here is for information purposes only. In the event of
More informationAnnual results presentation. 29 January 2018
Annual results presentation 2017 29 January 2018 1 Disclaimer This document was originally prepared in Spanish. The English version published here is for information purposes only. In the event of any
More informationAddendum to Hippocrates Provisional Valuation Report. [Sale of Business scenario]
Addendum to Hippocrates Provisional Valuation Report [Sale of Business scenario] Index 1. Executive Summary 3 1.1. Outcome of the alternative insolvency scenario... 3 2. Liquidation scenario simulation
More informationPRESS RELEASE. Results as at 31 March 2017 of the UBI Group
PRESS RELEASE Results as at 31 March 2017 of the UBI Group The first quarter saw the completion of important strategic initiatives to evolve the Group s business and operating model in accordance with
More informationBANCA CARIGE: CONSOLIDATED RESULTS AS AT 31 MARCH 2016
PRESS RELEASE BANCA CARIGE: CONSOLIDATED RESULTS AS AT 31 MARCH 2016 ROBUST CAPITAL POSITION WITH COMMON EQUITY TIER 1 (CET1) AT 12.3% LEVERAGE RATIO AMONG THE HIGHEST IN THE SYSTEM AT 8.1% AND LIQUIDITY
More informationFITCH REVISES DEUTSCHE BANK'S OUTLOOK TO NEGATIVE; AFFIRMS AT 'BBB+'
FITCH REVISES DEUTSCHE BANK'S OUTLOOK TO NEGATIVE; AFFIRMS AT 'BBB+' Fitch Ratings-London-21 June 2018: Fitch Ratings has revised Deutsche Bank AG's (Deutsche Bank) Outlook to Negative from Stable while
More informationHearing with Mrs Elke König, Chair of the Single Resolution Board
IPOL EGOV DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR INTERNAL POLICIES ECONOMIC GOVERNANCE SUPPORT UNIT B R IE F IN G Hearing with Mrs Elke König, Chair of the Single Resolution Board ECON, 28 January 2016 The Single Resolution
More informationFinancial Institutions
Sector Specific Criteria India This sector-specific criteria report outlines India Ratings and Research s (Ind-Ra) methodology to assign ratings to bank and bank holding company s subordinated and hybrid
More informationBanco Popolare Societa Cooperativa
CREDIT OPINION 16 September 16 Banco Popolare Societa Cooperativa Semiannual Update Update Summary Rating Rationale On 1 April 16 we placed the Banco Popolare Societa Cooperativa's (Banco Popolare) b standalone
More informationEUROSTAT SUPPLEMENTARY TABLE FOR REPORTING GOVERNMENT INTERVENTIONS TO SUPPORT FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
EUROPEAN COMMISSION EUROSTAT Directorate D: Government Finance Statistics (GFS) and Quality Unit D1: Excessive deficit procedure and methodology Unit D2: Excessive deficit procedure (EDP) 1 Unit D3: Excessive
More informationNon-preferred senior debt in Spain
Non-preferred senior debt in Spain Ferran Foix Miralles Senior Associate, Banking, Capital Markets and Insurance Practice Area, GA_P On 23 June 2017, Spain introduced a new debt asset class, known as non-preferred
More informationDBRS Assigns Critical Obligations Ratings to 33 European Banking Groups
Date of Release: February 4, 2016 DBRS Assigns Critical s to 33 European Banking Groups Industry: Fin.Svc.--Banks & Trusts, Fin.Svc.--Credit Unions & Building Societies DBRS has today assigned Critical
More informationEU Financial System Perspectives
EU Financial System Perspectives BNP Paribas Securities (Japan) Limited Head of Investment Research Department Chief Credit Analyst Mana Nakazora 03-6377-1707 mana.nakazora@japan.bnpparibas.com How strong
More informationGUIDELINES ON FAILING OR LIKELY TO FAIL EBA/GL/2015/ Guidelines
EBA/GL/2015/07 06.08.2015 Guidelines on the interpretation of the different circumstances when an institution shall be considered as failing or likely to fail under Article 32(6) of Directive 2014/59/EU
More informationFITCH AFFIRMS ABN AMRO BANK AT 'A+'; OUTLOOK STABLE
FITCH AFFIRMS ABN AMRO BANK AT 'A+'; OUTLOOK STABLE Fitch Ratings-London-24 February 2017: Fitch Ratings has affirmed ABN AMRO Bank N.V.'s Long-Term Issue Default Rating (IDR) at 'A+' with a Stable Outlook,
More informationTechnical advice on delegated acts on the deferral of extraordinary ex-post contributions to financial arrangements
EBA/Op/2015/06 6 March 2015 Technical advice on delegated acts on the deferral of extraordinary ex-post contributions to financial arrangements 1. Legal references - Article 104(3) of Directive 2014/59/EU
More informationInformation on bank resolution and bail-in
Information on bank resolution and bail-in As of: December 2016 Information on bank resolution and bail-in As a reaction to experience made during the financial crisis in 2008, many countries adopted rules
More informationFITCH DOWNGRADES DEUTSCHE BANK TO 'BBB+'; OUTLOOK STABLE
FITCH DOWNGRADES DEUTSCHE BANK TO 'BBB+'; OUTLOOK STABLE Fitch Ratings-London-28 September 2017: Fitch Ratings has downgraded Deutsche Bank AG's (Deutsche Bank) Long-Term Issuer Default Rating (IDR) to
More informationAcquisition of GE Capital Interbanca Group. 28 July 2016
Acquisition of GE Capital Interbanca Group 28 July 2016 Disclaimer This presentation does not represent a prospectus or other offering documentation, and does not constitute or form part of, and should
More informationConsultation Paper. Draft Guidelines On the treatment of shareholders in bail-in or the write-down and conversion of capital instruments
11 November 2014 EBA/CP/2014/40 Consultation Paper Draft Guidelines On the treatment of shareholders in bail-in or the write-down and conversion of capital instruments Contents 1. Responding to this Consultation
More informationGovernment Development Bank for Puerto Rico Downgraded To 'CC' From 'CCC-' On Imminent Default; Outlook Negative
Research Update: Government Development Bank for Puerto Rico Downgraded To 'CC' From 'CCC-' On Imminent Default; Outlook Negative Primary Credit Analyst: Brendan Browne, CFA, New York (1) 212-438-7399;
More informationTesting the EU Framework for the Recovery and Resolution of Banks: the Italian Experience
Policy Brief February 15, 2019 Testing the EU Framework for the Recovery and Resolution of Banks: the Italian Experience Stefano Micossi Abstract The financial crisis of 2008-09 and the ensuing sovereign
More informationBanking union: restoring financial stability in the Eurozone
EUROPEAN COMMISSION MEMO Brussels, 15 April 2014 Banking union: restoring financial stability in the Eurozone 1. Banking union in a nutshell Since the crisis started in 2008, the European Commission has
More informationIccrea Banca SpA. Table Of Contents. Major Rating Factors Rationale Outlook. May 20,
May 20, 2010 Iccrea Banca SpA Primary Credit Analyst: Monica Spairani, Milan (39) 02-72111-208; monica_spairani@standardandpoors.com Secondary Credit Analyst: Francesca Sacchi, Milan (39) 02 72111-272;
More informationBail-in or bailout? State aid to banks under the Single Resolution Mechanism
Agenda Advancing economics in business Bail-in or bailout? State aid to banks under the Single Resolution Mechanism Various European banks and other credit institutions are facing a challenging economic
More informationPRESS RELEASE. UBI Group (UBI Banca+ 3 Acquired Banks) results for the period ended 30 th June 2017
PRESS RELEASE UBI (+ 3 Acquired Banks) results for the period ended 30 th June 2017 Significant strategic actions were successfully undertaken in the second quarter which, together with initiatives concluded
More informationTHIS IS AN UNOFFICIAL TRANSLATION OF THE ACT ON RESTRUCTURING AND RESOLUTION OF CERTAIN FINANCIAL ENTERPRISES PREPARED BY FINANSIEL STABILITET.
THIS IS AN UNOFFICIAL TRANSLATION OF THE ACT ON RESTRUCTURING AND RESOLUTION OF CERTAIN FINANCIAL ENTERPRISES PREPARED BY FINANSIEL STABILITET. ONLY THE OFFICIAL VERSION IN DANISH PUBLISHED IN THE DANISH
More information