EY Tax Alert. Delhi HC substantially dilutes ICDS by striking down to the extent of conflict with binding judicial precedents.
|
|
- Peter Little
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 9 November 2017 EY Tax Alert Delhi HC substantially dilutes ICDS by striking down to the extent of conflict with binding judicial precedents Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation that affect Indian businesses. They act as technical summaries to keep you on top of the latest tax issues. For more information, please contact your EY advisor. Executive summary This Tax Alert summarizes a Delhi High Court (HC) ruling, dated 8 November 2017, on a writ petition [1] filed by The Chamber of Tax Consultants (Chamber) where the HC was concerned with the constitutional validity of Section 145(2) (S. 145(2)) of the Indian Tax Laws (ITL) authorizing the Central Government (CG) to notify Income Computation and Disclosure Standards (ICDS), as also the validity of 10 ICDS notified by the CG, to the extent they are in conflict with the principles laid down in binding judicial precedents rendered prior to ICDS. In a landmark ruling, the HC read down S.145(2) of the ITL to hold that the CG cannot notify ICDS that seek to override binding judicial precedents or statutory provisions. It held that the force of judicial precedents can be overridden only by a validation law passed by the Parliament, which removes the defect that the Courts had found in the existing law. Such power cannot be exercised by the Executive. The HC further held that if S.145(2) is not read in such restrictive manner, it would be ultra vires the ITL, as also the Constitution of India. [1] W.P.(C) 5595/ 2017
2 The HC also struck down several contentious provisions of each individual ICDS. It held that doing away with the concept of prudence (ICDS I), valuation of inventory at market value in case of dissolution of a partnership firm even when business is continued (ICDS II), taxation of unaccrued retention money (ICDS III), prohibition of reduction of incidental interest income from borrowing cost (ICDS III read with ICDS IX), recognition of export incentive as revenue before acceptance by the Government (ICDS IV), prohibition of completed contract method for revenue recognition from rendering of services (ICDS IV), prohibition of recognition of markedto-market (MTM) losses on forward contracts held for trading or speculation (ICDS VI), recognition of government grants on the basis of receipt prior to accrual (ICDS VII) and valuation of inventory of securities at variance with GAAP [2] (Part A of ICDS VIII) are all ultra vires the ITL and, hence, struck them down to that extent. However, it held that the mandate of ICDS IV to recognize interest income on time basis, even in the absence of reasonable certainty of realization, is a valid provision since it is backed up by a statutory provision under which the taxpayer can claim bad debt deduction for such unrealizable incomes. Background S. 145 of the ITL provides that the taxable income of a taxpayer falling under the Profits and Gains from Business and Profession (PGBP) or Income from Other Sources (IFOS) heads shall be computed in accordance with either the cash or mercantile system of accounting, whichever is regularly employed by the taxpayer. S.145(2) grants power to the CG to prescribe the ICDS to be followed by any class of taxpayers or in respect of any class of income. Based on the recommendations of an Expert Committee (Committee) constituted by the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) [3] and public consultation, the CBDT notified 10 ICDS under S. 145(2) of the ITL, covering diverse items like Accounting Policies, Inventories, Revenue Recognition, Tangible Fixed Assets etc [4]. The notified ICDS are applicable from tax year to taxpayers following the mercantile system of accounting and for the computation of income chargeable under the PGBP or IFOS heads. They do not apply to taxpayers who are individuals or Hindu Undivided Families, which are not liable for tax audit under the provisions of the ITL. Having regard to concerns raised by stakeholders in the implementation of ICDS, the CG issued Circular No. 10/2017 dated 23 March 2017 (Circular) providing clarifications on 25 issues, in the form of FAQs, for the smooth implementation of ICDS [5]. However, some of the provisions of the ICDS, as well as clarifications provided in the FAQs, were directly in conflict with the settled judicial positions under the ITL. In this regard, the Chamber, a voluntary non-profit organization with tax and legal professionals as its members, filed a writ petition before the HC challenging the constitutional [6] validity of S. 145(2) to the extent it requires compliance of the ICDS and the Circular issued thereunder, in conflict with binding judicial precedents rendered prior to ICDS. The Chamber urged that while S. 145(2) of the ITL permits the CG, as a delegate of the Legislature, to notify ICDS, it cannot be read as granting unfettered powers to the CG, in the guise of delegated legislation, to notify ICDS modifying the basis of taxation which can, if at all, be done only by the Parliament by amending the ITL. The notified ICDS, to the extent they seek to unsettle binding judicial precedents and modify the basis of chargeability and computation of taxable income, are ultra vires the ITL and the Constitution of India. On the other hand, the CG sought to defend the validity of ICDS by urging that they were aimed at codifying the law and give complete guidance to the Tax Authorities and, at the same time, act as a check on Tax Authorities not to deviate from the guiding principles. The CG argued that ICDS were aimed at bringing uniformity and clarity in computation of taxable income. Issues for consideration before the HC Are ICDS an instance of excessive delegation of legislative powers to the CG and, thus, constitutionally invalid. Whether the ICDS are in direct conflict with the settled judicial positions under the ITL and, therefore, liable to be struck down. HC s ruling Constitutional validity of ICDS The HC upheld the constitutional validity of ICDS but ruled that the CG, being a delegate of the Legislature, cannot override any statutory provisions or any binding judicial decision. The Legislature alone has the power to amend the provisions of the ITL to overcome defects/loopholes in the existing law as pointed out by the judicial precedents. [2] Generally Accepted Accounting Principles [3] The apex administrative body for direct taxes in India [4] Refer EY Tax Alert dated 3 October 2016, Government of India amends Income Computation and Disclosure Standards and also defers them by one year to tax year [5] Refer EY Tax Alert dated 24 March 2017, CBDT issues clarifications for smooth implementation of Income Computation and Disclosure Standards [6] The Constitution of India guarantees certain fundamental rights to every citizen of India, such as Article 14 providing for equality before law, Article 19(1)(g) providing for freedom to practise any trade, business or profession with any reasonable restrictions that may be imposed by the CG etc.
3 The provisions of ICDS, being a delegated legislation, have to be so read down such that they do not modify the basis for computation of taxable income as recognized by the provisions of the ITL or the binding judicial precedents laid down by the Supreme Court (SC) or HCs. It is, thus, clear that ICDS are not meant to overrule the provisions of the ITL, the Rules thereunder and the settled judicial positions. Accordingly, the HC dealt with each ICDS that was challenged by the Chamber and struck down some of the contentious provisions, which are discussed below. A snapshot of ICDS provisions struck down by the HC is provided at Annexure A. ICDS I on Accounting Policies Absence of prudence concept is in conflict with the ITL provisions and, hence, unsustainable ICDS I provides that expected or MTM losses are not to be allowed as deduction, unless specifically permitted by any other ICDS and, thus, does away with the concept of prudence. The Chamber contended that this provision of ICDS I is contrary to the settled judicial position since the Delhi and Gujarat HC rulings [7] have recognized the principle of prudence by allowing deduction for provision for expected losses on contracts recognized in the books of account by the taxpayer in compliance with GAAP. The ITL also grants deduction for revenue expenses laid out or expended for the purpose of business in which the concept of prudence is inherent. Accepting the above contentions, the HC held that nonacceptance of the prudence concept is contrary to the ITL provisions and, hence, ICDS I is unsustainable to that extent. ICDS II on Valuation of Inventory - ICDS II is contrary to the settled judicial positon As per the settled judicial position [8], if the business of a partnership firm continues after dissolution of the firm, then the inventory has to be valued at lower of the cost and the market price. On the other hand, if the business is discontinued on dissolution of the firm, then the inventory has to be valued at market price [9]. II requires that inventory, as on the date of dissolution of the firm, is to be valued at market price, irrespective of continuance or discontinuance of the business. This leads to notional taxation of income contrary to the judicial position. [7] CIT v. Triveni Engineering & Industries Ltd. [(2011) (49 DTR 253) (Del.HC)] and CIT v. Advance Construction Co. Pvt. Ltd. [(2005) (275 ITR 30) (Guj. HC)] [8] Shakti Trading Co. v. CIT [(2001) 250 ITR 871 (SC)] [9] ALA Firm v. CIT [(1989)(189 ITR 285)(SC)] Furthermore, there is a specific provision of the ITL [10], which overrides S. 145 and provides that the inventory shall be valued as per the method of accounting regularly employed by the taxpayer. The HC held that: (a.) It is not permissible for ICDS II to override the settled judicial position. (b.) Where the taxpayer follows a certain method of accounting for valuation of inventory, the same shall override ICDS II by virtue of the specific provision. Thus, the HC held that ICDS II is ultra vires the ITL and, as such, it is struck down. ICDS III on Construction Contracts - Taxability of retention money depends on contractual terms, conditions attached to such amount and settled principles of accrual of income ICDS III provides that retention money should form part of the contract revenue and taxed on the basis of percentage of completion method (POCM). The Circular reiterates this position. However, as per the settled judicial position [11], retention money accrues to the taxpayer only when the related performance conditions are fulfilled. Retention money cannot form part of the revenue unless the same has accrued as income as per the charging provisions of the ITL. The HC held that taxation of retention money would need to be seen on a case-to-case basis depending upon the contractual terms, conditions attached to such amount and keeping in mind the settled tax principles of accrual of income. ICDS III, to the extent it seeks to bring retention money to tax at the earliest stage even when the receipt is uncertain or conditional, is contrary to the settled position and, therefore, ultra vires the ITL. ICDS III on Construction Contracts - Incidental income not allowed as reduction from borrowing cost is contrary to the settled judicial position and is unsustainable to that extent [12], held that receipts which are inextricably linked to the setting up of plant or machinery can be reduced from the cost of asset. However, ICDS III, read with the provisions of ICDS IX on Borrowing Cost, provides that incidental income earned cannot be reduced from the borrowing cost forming part of the cost of the asset. The HC held that, to the extent the provisions of ICDS III are contrary to the settled judicial position, they are not sustainable. [10] S.145A [11] CIT v. Simplex Concrete Piles India (P) Ltd. [(1988) (179 ITR 8) (Cal)], CIT v. P & C Constructions (P) Ltd. [(2009) (318 ITR 113) (Mad)], Amarshiv Construction (P) Ltd v. DCIT [(2014) (367 ITR 659) (Guj)], DIT v. Ballast Nedam International [(2013) (355 ITR 300) (Guj)] [12] [(1999) (236 ITR 315)]
4 ICDS IV on Revenue Recognition Export incentives are taxable only in the year of acceptance of claim by the Government As per the SC ruling in the case of CIT v. Excel Industries Ltd. [13], export incentives are taxable only in the year in which the claim is accepted by the Government, as the right to receive the payment accrues in favor of the taxpayer when the corresponding obligation to pay arises for the Government. the year of making claim if there is a reasonable certainty of ultimate collection. ICDS IV, being contrary to the SC ruling, is ultra vires the ITL provisions and, hence, struck down to that extent. ICDS IV on Revenue Recognition Both POCM and completed contract methods are permissible for revenue recognition from service contract Accounting principles permit the taxpayer to follow either completed service contract method or POCM for revenue recognition. Judicial precedents [14] have recognized both methods as valid for tax purposes under the mercantile system of accounting. ICDS IV, which only permits POCM, is contrary to the above judicial position and, hence, liable to be struck down to that extent. ICDS IV on Revenue Recognition Recognition of interest income, in the absence of reasonable certainty of ultimate collection, is not ultra vires since corresponding bad debt deduction can be claimed ICDS IV provides that interest income is to be taxed on time basis, irrespective of reasonable certainty of ultimate collection. The Chamber contended that under ICDS IV, interest income on non-performing assets (NPAs) of Non-banking Financial Companies (NBFCs) would become taxable on time basis even though such interest is not recoverable. The HC noted that the Circular clarifies that while interest income is to be taxed on time basis alone, bad debt deduction, if any, can be claimed under the provisions of the ITL. Furthermore, the Parliament has inserted a specific provision in the ITL to grant bad debt deduction for incomes recognized under ICDS (without recognition in the books) in the year in which they become irrecoverable. [13] [(2015) (358 ITR 295) (SC)] [14] CIT v. Bilhari Investment Pvt. Ltd. [(2008) 299 ITR 1 (SC)], CIT v. Manish Buildwell Pvt. Ltd. [(2011) 245 CTR 397 (Del)], Paras Buildtech India Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT [(2016) 382 ITR 630 (Del)]. The HC held that this provision of ICDS IV cannot be held to be ultra vires since a corresponding bad debt deduction can be claimed by the taxpayer if the amount of interest is irrecoverable. Also, the Chamber has not demonstrated that ICDS IV is contrary to any ruling of the SC or any other Court [15]. offered to tax on time basis by claiming corresponding bad debt deduction, if the amount is not recoverable, ICDS creates a mechanism to track unrecognized interest amounts for future taxability, if so accrued. ICDS VI on Foreign Exchange Fluctuations ICDS VI not allowing MTM loss/gain in case of foreign currency derivatives held for trading or speculation purpose and taxation of opening balance of Foreign Currency Translation Reserve (FCTR) pertaining to monetary items is contrary to the settled judicial decision The SC, in the case of Godhra Electric Supply Company Ltd v. CIT [16], held that hypothetical income cannot be taxed. Furthermore, it held, in the case of Sutlej Cotton Mills Ltd v. CIT [17], that exchange fluctuation gain/loss in relation to loan utilized for acquiring a capital item would be capital in nature. case of foreign currency derivatives held for trading or speculation purposes shall be allowed on actual settlement, and not on MTM basis. The HC held that this is not consonant with the ratio laid down by the SC in the Sutlej Cotton Mills ruling and, therefore, ultra vires the ITL and, as such, struck it down. The Circular clarifies that the opening balance of FCTR Account as on 1 April 2016 (i.e., on the date ICDS first became applicable), which comprises of accumulated balance of exchange fluctuation gains/losses in relation to non-integral foreign operations, is taxable to the extent it relates to monetary items. However, the HC held that valuation of monetary assets and liabilities of the foreign operations as at the end of the year cannot be treated as real income as it is only in the nature of notional or hypothetical income which cannot be subjected to tax. [15] It seems several rulings like CIT v. Vasisth Chay Vyapar Ltd. [(2011)(330 ITR 440)(Del)] laying down the principle that there can be no taxation of interest on NPAs not permitted to be recognized by prudential guidelines of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), were not noticed by the HC. [16] [(1997)(225 ITR 746)(SC)] [17] [(1979)(116 ITR 1)(SC)]
5 ICDS VII on Government Grants Taxation of unaccrued subsidy on the date of actual receipt is ultra vires the ITL ICDS VII provides that recognition of government grants cannot be postponed beyond the date of actual receipt. This is in conflict with the accrual system of accounting since, many times, conditions are attached to the receipt of government grant which need to be fulfilled in the future and, hence, the amount may not have accrued to the taxpayer. Therefore, the HC held that ICDS VII is ultra vires the ITL to that extent. ICDS VIII on Securities held as Inventory Part A of ICDS VIII which prescribes bucket approach applicable to taxpayers other than banks and public financial institutions is ultra vires the ITL ICDS VIII provides for valuation of securities held as inventory and is divided into two parts. Part A applies to taxpayers other than banks and public financial institutions. It requires valuation of inventory on bucket approach i.e., category-wise valuation of securities instead of individual valuation of each security. However, this is different from the normal accounting principles and, thus, taxpayers will need to maintain separate records for tax purposes every year. Part B of ICDS VIII, which applies to banks and public financial institutions, provides that recognition of securities should be in accordance with the RBI [18] guidelines. The HC held that Part A of ICDS VIII, which prescribes bucket approach, differs from ICDS II on valuation of inventory which, under similar circumstances, does not prescribe the bucket approach. This shows that ICDS has adopted separate approaches at different places for valuation of inventory. This change is not possible without a corresponding amendment in the ITL. Hence, to that extent, Part A of ICDS VIII is ultra vires the ITL. Comments This HC ruling is a landmark ruling which addresses several controversies which had arisen on interpretation of ICDS. It provides clarity on the interplay between ICDS and binding judicial precedents. It also provides a welcome relief to taxpayers by striking down several contentious provisions of ICDS, which had raised apprehensions of taxation of unrealized/notional incomes. Taxpayers which are yet to file returns for tax year can consider the impact of the present ruling in their tax computations. Taxpayers which have already filed returns for tax year can explore revising their returns on the basis of the law laid down by the present ruling. While the ruling has addressed majority of the concerns of taxpayers, to the extent that the ruling has upheld the validity of taxation of unrealizable interest, it may have a significant impact on certain sectors like NBFCs, in relation to interest on NPAs. Those taxpayers will need to take care to offer such incomes in their tax computation (even if not recognized in the books) and claim bad debt deduction as per the specific provision in the ITL. However, even on this issue, there is a silver lining for taxpayers in the form of the Tax Authority s admission before the HC that ICDS does not, in any way, seek to alter the well-laid principles of real income by the SC, but merely ensures that there is a trace available of the income which is not taxed. Therefore, if there is an unrealizable interest income, it can be written off by the taxpayer for tax purposes and claimed as bad debt deduction in the same year under the specific provision inserted in the ITL for this purpose. The Tax Authority s clarification that the process is intended to obtain information, rather than tax unrealizable income, should offer a sigh of relief to taxpayers. [18] The central bank of India
6 Annexure A List of ICDS provisions struck down by the HC The application of the principle laid down by the HC on the overriding impact of binding judicial precedents over ICDS may throw up some interesting issues. For example, while there may be no difficulty in case of the SC ruling which is binding on all lower Courts in India, there could be difficulties in the case of conflicting rulings of different HCs or where an issue is covered by a decision of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (which is lower in status than the HC). Taxpayers may also need to note that the present ruling does not impact adjustments required by ICDS which have not been specifically struck down by the HC. For example, ICDS IX requires capitalization of general borrowing costs as per the normative formula, which is at variance with GAAP. Furthermore, the impact of the present ruling on companies which have adopted or are in the process of adopting Indian Accounting Standards (Ind-AS ) [19] will need to be specifically evaluated. ICDS Particulars ICDS I Non-acceptance of the concept of prudence ICDS II Valuation of inventory at market price in case of dissolution of firm if firm s business is continuing ICDS III Taxation of retention money at the earliest possible stage even when the receipt of such money is conditional/uncertain Incidental income not allowed to be reduced from the borrowing cost even if it is inextricably linked to the setting up of project ICDS IV Taxation of export incentives on reasonable certainty of ultimate collection even if not admitted by the Government Completed contract method not permissible for recognition of service revenue ICDS VI MTM gain/loss in case of foreign currency derivatives entered into for trading or speculation purposes not allowed for tax purposes Upfront taxation of opening balance of FCTR as on 1 April 2016 pertaining to monetary items in tax year ICDS VII Taxation of government grants on the date of actual receipt even though not accrued ICDS VIII Bucket approach applicable for valuation of securities held as inventory in case of taxpayers other than banks and public financial institutions [19] Converged form of International Financial Reporting Standards
7 Our offices Ahmedabad 2nd floor, Shivalik Ishaan Near C.N. Vidhyalaya Ambawadi Ahmedabad Tel: Fax: Bengaluru 6th, 12th & 13th floor UB City, Canberra Block No.24 Vittal Mallya Road Bengaluru Tel: Fax: Ground Floor, A wing Divyasree Chambers # 11, O Shaughnessy Road Langford Gardens Bengaluru Tel: Fax: Chandigarh 1st Floor, SCO: Sector 9-C, Madhya Marg Chandigarh Tel: Fax: Chennai Tidel Park, 6th & 7th Floor A Block (Module 601, ) No.4, Rajiv Gandhi Salai Taramani, Chennai Tel: Fax: Delhi NCR Golf View Corporate Tower B Sector 42, Sector Road Gurgaon Tel: Fax: rd & 6th Floor, Worldmark-1 IGI Airport Hospitality District Aerocity, New Delhi Tel: Fax th & 5th Floor, Plot No 2B Tower 2, Sector 126 NOIDA Gautam Budh Nagar, U.P. Tel: Fax: Hyderabad Oval Office, 18, ilabs Centre Hitech City, Madhapur Hyderabad Tel: Fax: Jamshedpur 1st Floor, Shantiniketan Building Holding No. 1, SB Shop Area Bistupur, Jamshedpur Tel: BSNL: Kochi 9th Floor, ABAD Nucleus NH-49, Maradu PO Kochi Tel: Fax: Kolkata 22 Camac Street 3rd Floor, Block C Kolkata Tel: Fax: Mumbai 14th Floor, The Ruby 29 Senapati Bapat Marg Dadar (W), Mumbai Tel: Fax: th Floor, Block B-2 Nirlon Knowledge Park Off. Western Express Highway Goregaon (E) Mumbai Tel: Fax: Pune C-401, 4th floor Panchshil Tech Park Yerwada (Near Don Bosco School) Pune Tel: Fax: Ernst & Young LLP EY Assurance Tax Transactions Advisory About EY EY is a global leader in assurance, tax, transaction and advisory services. The insights and quality services we deliver help build trust and confidence in the capital markets and in economies the world over. We develop outstanding leaders who team to deliver on our promises to all of our stakeholders. In so doing, we play a critical role in building a better working world for our people, for our clients and for our communities. EY refers to the global organization, and may refer to one or more, of the member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a separate legal entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, does not provide services to clients. For more information about our organization, please visit ey.com. Ernst & Young LLP is one of the Indian client serving member firms of EYGM Limited. For more information about our organization, please visit Ernst & Young LLP is a Limited Liability Partnership, registered under the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008 in India, having its registered office at 22 Camac Street, 3rd Floor, Block C, Kolkata Ernst & Young LLP. Published in India. All Rights Reserved. This publication contains information in summary form and is therefore intended for general guidance only. It is not intended to be a substitute for detailed research or the exercise of professional judgment. Neither Ernst & Young LLP nor any other member of the global Ernst & Young organization can accept any responsibility for loss occasioned to any person acting or refraining from action as a result of any material in this publication. On any specific matter, reference should be made to the appropriate advisor. Join India Tax Insights from EY on Download the EY India Tax Insights App Logo
Supreme Court rules accumulated losses of amalgamating company to be set off after reducing interest waiver benefit
19 April 2017 EY Tax Alert Supreme Court rules accumulated losses of amalgamating company to be set off after reducing interest waiver benefit Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
5 January 2018 EY Tax Alert Mumbai Tribunal rules stamp duty value cannot be deemed as consideration while computing capital gains arising on contribution of land by a partner to the partnership firm which
More informationEY Tax Alert. J&K HC rules that contract receipts of a JV result in diversion of income to JV members; receipt not an income of the JV
21 September 2017 EY Tax Alert J&K HC rules that contract receipts of a JV result in diversion of income to JV members; receipt not an income of the JV Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments
More informationEY Alert. Kerala High Court quashes 2014 notification amending the Employees Pension Scheme, 1995
31 December 2018 EY Alert Kerala High Court quashes 2014 notification amending the Employees Pension Scheme, 1995 Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation that affect
More informationEY Tax Alert. Supreme Court reaffirms constitutional validity of Aadhaar PAN linking requirement. Executive summary
27 September 2018 EY Tax Alert Supreme Court reaffirms constitutional validity of Aadhaar PAN linking requirement Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation that affect
More informationEY PAS Alert. Finance bill proposes tax on long-term gains arising on sale of listed equity shares Impact on employee stock option plans
27 February 2018 EY PAS Alert Finance bill proposes tax on long-term gains arising on sale of listed equity shares Impact on employee stock option plans Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments
More informationEY Tax Alert. Supreme Court upholds lease equalization adjustment in finance lease as per the ICAI Guidance Note for tax purposes.
27 April 2018 EY Tax Alert Supreme Court upholds lease equalization adjustment in finance lease as per the ICAI Guidance Note for tax purposes Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationEY Tax Alert. Delhi Tribunal rules guarantee fee income received by foreign parent from Indian subsidiary is taxable in India.
12 December 2017 EY Tax Alert Delhi Tribunal rules guarantee fee income received by foreign parent from Indian subsidiary is taxable in India Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationGovernment of India amends Income Computation and Disclosure Standards and also defers them by one year to tax year
3 October 2016 EY Tax Alert Government of India amends Income Computation and Disclosure Standards and also defers them by one year to tax year 2016-17 Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. Delhi Tribunal rules on advertisement and promotion expenses involving use of trademarks as not royalty.
4 April 2017 EY Tax Alert Delhi Tribunal rules on advertisement and promotion expenses involving use of trademarks as not royalty Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and
More informationEY Tax Alert Delhi High Court upholds weighted R&D deduction for recognized inhouse R&D facility from the date prior to recognition and approval
8 August 2017 EY Tax Alert Delhi High Court upholds weighted R&D deduction for recognized inhouse R&D facility from the date prior to recognition and approval Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments
More informationEY Tax Alert. Mumbai Tribunal rules conversion of compulsory convertible preference shares into equity shares is not transfer.
19 November 2018 EY Tax Alert Mumbai Tribunal rules conversion of compulsory convertible preference shares into equity shares is not transfer Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. SC settles certain controversies on profit-linked deduction for export units. 21 December 2016
21 December 2016 EY Tax Alert SC settles certain controversies on profit-linked deduction for export units Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation
More informationPune Tribunal upholds tax deductibility of MTM exchange fluctuation loss on forex loan borrowed to reduce interest cost and hedge export receivables
19 May 2016 EY Tax Alert Pune Tribunal upholds tax deductibility of MTM exchange fluctuation loss on forex loan borrowed to reduce interest cost and hedge export receivables Executive summary Tax Alerts
More informationEY Tax Alert. Full Bench of Karnataka HC rules incidental interest income earned by Taxpayer is eligible for export incentive scheme deduction
2 November 2017 EY Tax Alert Full Bench of Karnataka HC rules incidental interest income earned by Taxpayer is eligible for export incentive scheme deduction Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments
More informationMoF issues Notifications and Circular for services relating to transportation of goods by vessel
19 April EY Tax Alert MoF issues Notifications and Circular for services relating to transportation of goods by vessel Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationEY Tax Alert. Central Government modifies conditions for availing exemption from angel tax provision. Executive summary
29 May 2018 EY Tax Alert Central Government modifies conditions for availing exemption from angel tax provision Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation that affect
More informationEY Tax Alert. Supreme Court negates claim for 100% deduction for fresh five years of new units undertaking substantial expansion.
23 August 2018 EY Tax Alert Supreme Court negates claim for 100% deduction for fresh five years of new units undertaking substantial expansion Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationAmendments at enactment stage of Finance Bill, 2017
22 March 2017 Amendments at enactment stage of Finance Bill, 2017 The Finance Bill, 2017 (FB 2017 or Bill) was presented by the Finance Minister (FM) on 1 February 2017 [1]. In the wake of representations
More informationClarifications on Indirect transfer provisions under the Incometax Act, 1961
22 December 2016 2013mber 2012 EY Tax Alert Clarifications on Indirect transfer provisions under the Incometax Act, 1961 Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationBombay HC upholds non-taxability of deferred consideration on transfer of shares in the absence of accrual
18 April 2016 EY Tax Alert Bombay HC upholds non-taxability of deferred consideration on transfer of shares in the absence of accrual Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments
More informationEY Tax Alert Central Board of Direct Taxes issues final rules prescribing methodology for determining fair market value of unquoted shares
13 July 2017 EY Tax Alert Central Board of Direct Taxes issues final rules prescribing methodology for determining fair market value of unquoted shares Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments
More informationEY PAS Alert. Executive summary. Press release dated 27 February
17 April 2018 EY PAS Alert Recent Provident Fund updates PAS Alerts cover significant tax and regulatory changes that affect Indian businesses. Our PAS alert is a summary of technical developments intended
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
8 June 2016 EY Tax Alert Delhi HC rules that Service tax shall not be leviable on under construction flats if contract price includes value of land Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news,
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
16 March 2018 EY Tax Alert Supreme Court rules on disallowance of expenditure in relation to exempt dividend income from shares held as strategic investment and stock-intrade Tax Alerts cover significant
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. Chennai Tribunal upholds salary taxation of SARs benefits received from foreign parent of employer.
11 May 2016 EY Tax Alert Chennai Tribunal upholds salary taxation of SARs benefits received from foreign parent of employer Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
10 October 2014 EY Tax Alert CBDT Circular on threshold limit for transfer of technical manpower to new SEZ unit for availing profit-linked deduction Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax
More informationand Master File implementation
4 November 2017 India Tax Alert News from Transfer Pricing Indian Tax Administration releases final rules on Countryby-Country reporting and Master File implementation Tax Alerts cover significant tax
More informationHC denies refund of SAD paid on import of coil sheets sold after corrugation as proflex roof
24 March 2017 EY Tax Alert HC denies refund of SAD paid on import of coil sheets sold after corrugation as proflex roof Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
7 October 2015 EY Tax Alert Karnataka HC rules on availability of foreign tax credit relief where the income is exempt from Indian taxes under incomelinked incentive scheme Executive summary Tax Alerts
More informationEY Tax Alert. Conversion of company into LLP under LLP Act results in transfer subject to capital gains tax. Executive summary
1 December 2018 EY Tax Alert Conversion of company into LLP under LLP Act results in transfer subject to capital gains tax Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation
More informationCBDT introduces form for employee investment declarations and extends due date for quarterly withholding statements
4 May 2016 EY Tax Alert CBDT introduces form for employee investment declarations and extends due date for quarterly withholding statements Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. Supreme Court rules on characterization of property rental income as income from house property.
16 May 2017 EY Tax Alert Supreme Court rules on characterization of property rental income as income from house property Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationCBDT releases fifth round of FAQs on Income Declaration Scheme, 2016
19 August 2016 EY Tax Alert CBDT releases fifth round of FAQs on Income Declaration Scheme, 2016 Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation that affect
More informationEY Tax Alert Central Government notifies the transactions of listed equity shares not eligible for Long Term capital gains exemption
6 June 2017 EY Tax Alert Central Government notifies the transactions of listed equity shares not eligible for Long Term capital gains exemption Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and
More informationIndian Equalization Levy on digital services to be effective from 1 June 2016, administrative rules notified
31 May 2016 EY Tax Alert Indian Equalization Levy on digital services to be effective from 1 June 2016, administrative rules notified Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
3 July 2015 EY Tax Alert SC rules on presumptive taxation; activities inextricably linked with prospecting, extraction or production of mineral oil eligible for presumptive taxation Executive summary Tax
More informationEY Tax Alert Bangalore Tribunal rules on constitution of service PE for services rendered virtually as well as physically
12 July 2017 EY Tax Alert Bangalore Tribunal rules on constitution of service PE for services rendered virtually as well as physically Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
21 April 2015 EY Tax Alert Delhi High Court declines to interfere with order of lower authorities rejecting Taxpayer s tax holiday claim that units approved under a single license are distinct Executive
More informationDelhi High Court strikes down several ICDS provisions
Direct Tax Alert 09 November 2017 Delhi High Court strikes down several provisions Background: Section 145 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 ( the Act ) gives the power to the Central Government to notify Income
More informationDelhi Tribunal rules income of non-resident that is not attributable to PE in India shall still be taxable in India as FTS
12 October 2016 EY Tax Alert Delhi Tribunal rules income of non-resident that is not attributable to PE in India shall still be taxable in India as FTS Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax
More informationTax Alert Key amendments at enactment stage of Finance Bill, 2018
14 March 2018 Tax Alert Key amendments at enactment stage of Finance Bill, 2018 Executive Summary The Finance Bill, 2018 (FB 2018 or Bill) was presented by the Finance Minister (FM) on 1 February 2018
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. CBDT provides clarifications on Direct Tax Dispute Resolution Scheme, September 2016
13 September 2016 EY Tax Alert CBDT provides clarifications on Direct Tax Dispute Resolution Scheme, 2016 Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation
More informationThis Tax Alert provides highlights of the Taxation Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2017 ( Bill ) introduced in the Lok Sabha on 31 March 2017.
5 April 2017 EY Tax Alert Highlights of Taxation Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2017 introduced in Lok Sabha Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation that
More informationCBDT releases second round of FAQs on Income Declaration Scheme, 2016
28 June 2016 EY Tax Alert CBDT releases second round of FAQs on Income Declaration Scheme, 2016 Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation that affect
More informationKerala HC upholds the constitutional validity of levy of Service tax on admission and access to entertainment event & amusement facilities
3 May 2016 EY Tax Alert Kerala HC upholds the constitutional validity of levy of Service tax on admission and access to entertainment event & amusement facilities Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant
More informationDelhi Tribunal rules on indirect transfer of shares on transaction undertaken in 2006
15 March 2017 EY Tax Alert Delhi Tribunal rules on indirect transfer of shares on transaction undertaken in 2006 Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
16 March 2016 EY Tax Alert CESTAT allows credit of Service tax on transportation, treating the place where property in goods is transferred in terms of Sale of Goods Act - as Place of removal Executive
More informationEY Tax Alert Indian tax administration issues final rules on certain aspects for determining buy-back tax in India Executive summary
18 October 2016 EY Tax Alert Indian tax administration issues final rules on certain aspects for determining buy-back tax in India Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
01 September 2016 EY Tax Alert AAR affirms availability of India-Mauritius treaty benefit on sale of shares of Indian company, distinguishes Bombay High Court ruling of Aditya Birla Nuvo Executive summary
More informationEY Tax Alert. Mumbai Tribunal rules intercompany
17 December 2018 EY Tax Alert Mumbai Tribunal rules intercompany deposits between sister-subsidiaries not deemed dividend under domestic law; rules on application of tax treaty provisions in hands of Mauritius
More informationEY India Defence EY s point of view on amended Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) Policy on Defence Sector
24 June 2016 EY India Defence EY s point of view on amended Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) Policy on Defence Sector Further to the FDI policy reforms in a number of sectors (including defence) as introduced
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
20 April 2017 EY Tax Alert HC quashes levy of Service tax on services in relation to promotion or marketing of lottery in absence of machinery provisions Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. Supreme Court rules on year of deductibility of debenture interest paid upfront. 26 March 2015
26 March 2015 EY Tax Alert Supreme Court rules on year of deductibility of debenture interest paid upfront Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation
More informationAAR rules that provision of business support services to US affiliate are naturally bundled and are not intermediary services
17 March 2016 EY Tax Alert AAR rules that provision of business support services to US affiliate are naturally bundled and are not intermediary services Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax
More informationCBDT amends rules relating to furnishing information in respect of payments to nonresidents
18 December 2015 EY Tax Alert CBDT amends rules relating to furnishing information in respect of payments to nonresidents Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. CBDT sets up a Committee to deal with retroactive indirect transfer taxation. 1 September 2014
1 September 2014 EY Tax Alert CBDT sets up a Committee to deal with retroactive indirect transfer taxation Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation
More informationEY Regulatory Alert. Executive summary. SEBI releases Discussion Paper on review of framework for Institutional Trading
5 August 2016 EY Regulatory Alert SEBI releases Discussion Paper on review of framework for Institutional Trading Platform for inviting comments from public on the changes proposed Executive summary Regulatory
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. Protocol signed on 10 May 2016 to amend the 1982 India- Mauritius tax treaty. 12 May 2016
12 May 2016 EY Tax Alert Protocol signed on 10 May 2016 to amend the 1982 India- Mauritius tax treaty Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation that
More informationEY Tax Alert. CBEC issues clarifications on exports-related refund issues. Executive summary
19 March 2018 EY Tax Alert CBEC issues clarifications on exports-related refund issues Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation that affect Indian businesses. They
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
23 July EY Tax Alert Government issues Notifications to restrict benefit in respect of CVD exemption for certain goods under exemption notifications, to domestic manufacturers Executive summary Tax Alerts
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
5 April 2016 EY Tax Alert CESTAT rules that Service tax is not leviable under reverse charge mechanism on salary and other costs reimbursed by the Indian head office to its foreign branch Executive summary
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
27 July 2015 EY Tax Alert Chennai Tribunal rules on tax withholding obligation on provision for site restoration, year-end expense provisions and roaming charges Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant
More informationKarnataka High Court rules that implementation of customized software is a service and cannot be subject to VAT
14 September 2015 EY Tax Alert Karnataka High Court rules that implementation of customized software is a service and cannot be subject to VAT Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments
More informationEY Tax Alert. CBEC releases four Rules approved by GST Council and issues Notifications under Central and Integrated GST.
21 June 17 EY Tax Alert CBEC releases four Rules approved by GST Council and issues Notifications under Central and Integrated GST Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation
More informationAmendments to the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Alternative Investment Funds) Regulations, Executive summary
23 September 2013 August 2013 EY Regulatory Alert Amendments to the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Alternative Investment Funds) Regulations, 2012 Executive summary Regulatory Alerts cover significant
More informationHigh Court rules that in-transit sale in turnkey contracts not eligible for exemption under Section 6(2) of the Central Sales Tax Act
23 September 2015 EY Tax Alert High Court rules that in-transit sale in turnkey contracts not eligible for exemption under Section 6(2) of the Central Sales Tax Act Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant
More informationOperational, prudential and reporting norms for Alternative Investment Funds. Executive summary
1 August 2013 EY Regulatory Alert Operational, prudential and reporting norms for Alternative Investment Funds Executive summary This Regulatory Alert summarizes the operational, prudential and reporting
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
19 August 2015 EY Tax Alert Delhi Tribunal (Larger Bench) rules that interchange fees and merchant establishment discounts earned in respect of credit card transactions not subject to Service tax prior
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
18 February 2019 EY Tax Alert Calcutta HC upholds initiation of prosecution under Black Money Act for non-disclosure of foreign bank account pertaining to years prior to enactment of Black Money Act Tax
More informationMumbai Tribunal rules on DAPE in case of marketing and distribution activities carried out by an Indian branch for group companies
4 July 2013 2013mber 2012 EY Tax Alert Mumbai Tribunal rules on DAPE in case of marketing and distribution activities carried out by an Indian branch for group companies Executive summary Tax Alerts cover
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
25 January 2016 EY Tax Alert AAR rules that transfer of shares of Indian subsidiary by a Mauritius company to a Singapore group entity is not a tax avoidant transaction Executive summary Tax Alerts cover
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. Mumbai Tribunal rules on legality and taxability of certain gift transactions by corporates.
24 March 2015 EY Tax Alert Mumbai Tribunal rules on legality and taxability of certain gift transactions by corporates Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
9 January 2015 EY Tax Alert Jabalpur Tribunal rules on interplay between provisions of PE and FTS for taxing installation/commissioning activities in composite contracts Executive summary Tax Alerts cover
More informationIndian Administration issues draft Exit Tax Rules for charitable organisations; invites comments from stakeholders
26 October 2016 EY Tax Alert Indian Administration issues draft Exit Tax Rules for charitable organisations; invites comments from stakeholders Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news,
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. CBDT notifies ITR Forms for Company/ Firms/ LLP/ Trusts and others. 05 August 2015 October 2014
05 August 2015 October 2014 EY Tax Alert CBDT notifies ITR Forms for Company/ Firms/ LLP/ Trusts and others Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation
More informationBombay HC rules that appropriate State for levy and collection of CST is the State from where movement of goods commences
20 January 2017 EY Tax Alert Bombay HC rules that appropriate State for levy and collection of CST is the State from where movement of goods commences Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. CBDT notifies guidelines for onshore management of offshore funds. 17 March 2016
17 March 2016 EY Tax Alert CBDT notifies guidelines for onshore management of offshore funds Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation that affect
More informationGuidance Note on FATCA and CRS dated 30 November Key clarifications
7 December 2016 EY Tax Alert Guidance Note on FATCA and CRS dated 30 November 2016 - Key clarifications Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. Supreme Court upholds disallowance of expenditure incurred in relation to exempt dividend income.
9 May 2017 EY Tax Alert Supreme Court upholds disallowance of expenditure incurred in relation to exempt dividend income Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationEY Tax Alert Indian tax administration issues clarifications to compute book profit for Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) levy for Ind-AS companies
26 July 2017 EY Tax Alert Indian tax administration issues clarifications to compute book profit for Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) levy for Ind-AS companies Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments
More informationCBDT releases revised draft of Income Computation and Disclosure Standards for public comments
16 January 2015 EY Tax Alert CBDT releases revised draft of Income Computation and Disclosure Standards for public comments Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes
More informationMumbai Tribunal rules charterer includes slot charter arrangement for availing treaty benefit under Article 8 of India Malaysia DTAA
22 July 2014 EY Tax Alert Mumbai Tribunal rules charterer includes slot charter arrangement for availing treaty benefit under Article 8 of India Malaysia DTAA Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant
More informationControl premium in India. Ernst & Young LLP July 2017
Control premium in India Ernst & Young LLP July 2017 Executive summary Control premium: Concept Control premium is the difference between the pro-rata controlling interest and the pro-rata non-controlling
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary. Bangalore Tribunal rules on deductibility of employee share reward discount cross-charged by foreign parent company
22 October 2013 2013mber 2012 EY Tax Alert Bangalore Tribunal rules on deductibility of employee share reward discount cross-charged by foreign parent company Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
19 September 2014 EY Tax Alert Bombay HC decides - CENVAT credit refund ineligible in respect of onsite services provided by foreign subsidiaries to overseas clients prior to 27 February 2010, as the same
More informationGST: How it will impact advertising budgets? June 2017
GST: How it will impact advertising budgets? June 2017 Background The levy of GST will have diverse impacts across sectors, and this could impact their ability to spend on advertising The objective of
More informationMumbai Tribunal rules reimbursement of expenses on secondment of employees not FTS
20 September 2013 2013mber 2012 EY Tax Alert Mumbai Tribunal rules reimbursement of expenses on secondment of employees not FTS Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and
More informationEY Tax Alert. Executive summary
07 June 2016 EY Tax Alert Mumbai Tribunal rules contractually agreed fixed return on equity investment is akin to interest on fixed deposit taxable on year-on-year basis Executive summary Tax Alerts cover
More informationCBDT Committee recommends MAT framework for Ind-AS companies
2 May 2016 EY Tax Alert CBDT Committee recommends MAT framework for Ind-AS companies Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation that affect Indian
More informationSpecial Bench rules ESOP discount is deductible on vesting of options
19 July 2013 2013mber 2012 EY Tax Alert Special Bench rules ESOP discount is deductible on vesting of options Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news, developments and changes in legislation
More informationReserve Bank of India releases final guidelines for on tap licensing of Universal Banks in the private sector
5 August 2016 EY Regulatory Alert Reserve Bank of India releases final guidelines for on tap licensing of Universal Banks in the private sector Executive summary In 2013, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
More informationCBEC releases draft rules on Assessment and Audit under GST and E-Way Bill. The key highlights of the rules are as under:
18 April 2017 EY GST News Alert CBEC releases draft rules on Assessment and Audit under GST and E-Way Bill Executive summary This Alert provides an insightful coverage of news related to GST and recent
More informationEY India Real Estate EY s point of view on Amended Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) Policy on Construction Development Sector
16 vember 2015 EY India Real Estate EY s point of view on Amended Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) Policy on Construction Development Sector Q.1 When will be the proposed changes to the FDI Policy in construction
More information10 April EY Tax Alert. AAR treats buyback of shares as tax avoidance scheme taxable as dividend under Mauritius DTAA
10 April 2012 EY Tax Alert AAR treats buyback of shares as tax avoidance scheme taxable as dividend under Mauritius DTAA Executive summary This Tax Alert summarizes a recent ruling of the Authority for
More informationMadras High Court rules Indian tax provision notifying Cyprus as non-cooperative jurisdiction is not unconstitutional
14 April 2016 EY Tax Alert Madras High Court rules Indian tax provision notifying Cyprus as non-cooperative jurisdiction is not unconstitutional Executive summary Tax Alerts cover significant tax news,
More informationSecurities and Exchange Board of India notifies regulations for Share Based Employee Benefits
31 October 2014 EY Regulatory Alert Securities and Exchange Board of India notifies regulations for Share Based Employee Benefits Executive Summary Regulatory Alerts cover significant regulatory news,
More informationReserve Bank of India releases draft guidelines for on tap licensing of Universal Banks in the private sector
11 May 2016 EY Regulatory Alert Reserve Bank of India releases draft guidelines for on tap licensing of Universal Banks in the private sector Executive summary In 2013, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
More informationEY Regulatory Alert. Executive summary
21 April 2015 2013mber 2012 EY Regulatory Alert The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India issues draft regulations for registration and operations of branch offices of foreign reinsurers
More informationApplying Ind AS 115 Automotive: The new revenue recognition standard
Applying Ind AS 115 Automotive: The new revenue recognition standard 2 Applying Ind AS 115 Automotive: The new revenue recognition standard Contents Overview...1 Key considerations...3 Incentives...3 Long-term
More information