How do investors address climate risks?
|
|
- Horace Walker
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Abstract How do investors address climate risks? Niklas Kreander 1 and Ken McPhail 2 World leaders agreed to limit global temperature rise to two degrees in Paris in 2015 in an effort to avoid dangerous climate change. Climate change will create new risks (IPCC, 2014). The Governor of the Bank of England has raised concerns about the financial consequences of climate risks (Carney, 2015). Climate change issues can impact returns (Mercer, 2015; NBIM, 2015). These risks have consequences for sector allocation for portfolios (Deutsche Asset Management, 2017). Yet many pension funds gamble on climate change (Mathiesen, 2015). Managing climate risk well is important. This paper examines how this is done among some leading institutional investors. How does one invest successfully within a two degree scenario? How do investors address climate risks? Drawing on interview evidence from leading investors in Norway and the UK we outline best practice and provide recommendations for the way forward. Findings indicate some contradictions between policy and practice for some investors. 1. Corresponding author: Niklas Kreander, University College of South East Norway 2. Ken McPhail is professor at the University of Manchester Early draft, please do not quote without permission
2 Introduction There is increasing consensus that the global climate is changing (IPCC, 2014; Carney, 2015). To address the many challenges related to climate change world leaders agreed in Paris in December 2015 to try to limit the global increase in temperature to two degrees. Even if this would be successful, climate risks still have significant implications for investors and others (BlackRock, 2016; Deutsche Asset Management, 2017). However, many agree that current policy pledges are not sufficient to reach the two degree goal and thus climate risks are likely to hit investors and others even harder (BlackRock, 2016; Cicero, 2016). Traditionally asset managers have considered risk and return, but environmental risk has not been part of this (ACCA, 2009). Indeed, concerns have been raised that even in recent times many pension funds and other institutional investors have not adequately addressed climate risks and opportunities (Mathiesen, 2015; Asset Owners Climate Ranking). This raises questions for insurance companies, pension funds and other investors. How should they integrate climate change related risks into their investment approach? This paper explores the question: How can a large investor invest sensibly within a two degree framework? Environmental NGOs call for divestment of the entire fossil fuel sector and for a shift to electric and hydrogen cars and more public transport. Under the two degree scenario the share of coal in electricity generation would decline dramatically by 2040, while renewable energy would increase (UBS, 2017). Insurance companies struggle with more claims from flooding and storms. How should a prudent asset manager consider these shifts and transitions in their investment portfolios? This paper explores these themes through interviews with fund managers and examining the literature. We also consider literature from the asset managers. Climate Change Climate change is the shift in temperatures, precipitation levels and extreme weather due to the greenhouse gases prevalent in the atmosphere (Standard Life, 2016). The latest IPCC report argues that it is very likely that humans have been the main cause of climate change over the last 60 years. Greenhouse gas emissions increased by 80% from 1970 to 2010 (IPCC, 2014). Because of this greenhouse gas concentrations are higher than they have been for over years and the sea rise is faster than for over a 1000 years (Carney, 2015; IPCC 2014). This has very serious economic consequences. Insurance losses from weather related events has more than triple from the 1980s to around $50 billion in the last decade (Carney, 2015). The Economist has
3 estimated that value at risk from climate change to $4,2 trillion. Global GDP could decline significantly due to climate change (Stern, 2006; Blackrock, 2016). Even more serious is that more than 100 million people are at risk from water stress, heatwaves and sea level rise even if the two degree goal is achieved, if no action is taken twice as many people will be exposed (Deutsche Asset Management, 2017). Climate Change risks for investors We will briefly outline some risks and focus on the implications for investors. More detail about the risks can be found in IPCC (2014). A good economics based summary of climate change risk can be found in Hjorth (2015). There is a concern that climate risks are underpriced (AP4, 2014). Physical risk There has always been variations in weather and natural disasters. Yet scientist believe these risks have increased due to human activity (BlackRock, 2016). The two main aspects of this is more extreme weather events such as flooding, fires and storms. Second, rising temperatures and sea levels. Climate change may entail greater risk for flooding in the future 1. This can result in losses for insurance companies and real estate owners including companies in different sectors in addition to investors. Heat waves increase risk for fires and crop failures, which can claim many lives. These physical risks can vary substantially in different regions, but are likely to affect many hundred million people. These physical risks result in legal risk for firms. In Germany a farmer from Peru is challenging the energy giant RWE in court for compensation linked to climate change (Guardian, 2017). In the Philippines there could be a human rights motivated claim against large energy companies including Shell and Total from Europe (Vidal, 2016). The claim is that storm damage caused by climate change has breached the human rights of people. Insurance claims from extreme weather events such as storms and floods have surged in recent years (Carney, 2015). In Norway environmental NGOs have taken the state to court in an effort to stop some arctic oil exploration. It is likely that we will see more lawsuits related to climate change and energy and oil companies may be especially targeted in such legal action. 1 For example the Norwegian regulator NVE has produced regional reports which predicts greater levels of flooding which will mean that some areas become unsuitable for human habitation.
4 Political risk Taxes on carbon and restriction in use of carbon can affect especially fossil fuel and energy firms. Some countries may place heavier regulation on coal power plants. However, many other high impact sectors can also be affected by more stringent regulation, for example the cement and steel industries. Many cities in Europe imposed restrictions on the use of diesel cars in This has implications for the automobile industry as demand for diesel cars plummet. Transition risk Climate change implies many types of transitions. People will have to move to other areas and change occupation. We have seen how challenging managing the migration from the middle east and Africa to Europe has been in recent years, climate change can amplify migration by rendering areas unhabitable. Industries will need to change and adapt to climate change. In addition to obvious sectors such as automobile and real estate, transition risk is also material for banks, chemical, iron & steel, pharmaceuticals and the semiconductor industries (Deutsche Asset Management, 2017). This also involves technological risks as the demise of diesel cars and the race to develop electric and hydrogen cars show. Implications for investors Many investment portfolios may be overvalued because climate risk is not sufficiently factored in (AP4, 2014). If IPCC (2014) are right when they state that only 20% to 25% 2 of the known fossil fuel reserves can be utilized if global warming is to be limited to two degrees this has serious implications. The carbon budget suggested by IPCC (2014) mean that most coal and some of the existing oil reserves cannot be used, see also Carney (2015). This means that not only many firms with business linked to thermal coal may be overvalued but also many oil companies and many firms supplying the oil industry. For example Mercer (2015) and Deutsche Asset management (2017) estimates that the oil and coal industry will suffer at least 1% reduced returns annually, while returns could be down to 4% for oil and 5% for coal companies over a 35 year period. For example, the largest fund in Europe the 2 IPCC 2014 states that existing fossil fuel reserves exceed what can be burned by 4 to 7 times. Thus in the worst case only 15% of known fossil fuel reserves could be used (and maximum 25%) consistent with a two degree scenario (IPCC, 2014, section 2.2).
5 Government Pension Fund Global from Norway states that: The scientific basis for climate change is widely accepted climate outcomes may affect company and portfolio return over time.» NBIM (2015). Even in the short term (under five years) portfolios of different types can suffer losses of 10% under a two degree scenario according to modelling done by the University of Cambridge (Deutsche Asset management, 2017). Climate related opportunities for investors There is a need for a significant energy transition away from fossil fuels towards renewables. For example, Mercer (2015) estimate that annual additional positive returns for the renewable energy sector could be up to 3% annually over a 35 year horizon. Some investors think that natural gas could be the winner in the short to medium term. There is also a need to improve energy efficiency across sectors. This presents opportunities (Kapital Article Soros manager). Some financial institutions such as KLP and Pansjon Danmark invest directly in renewable energy projects. Warren Buffet have also made large investments in solar projects. Dimson et al., (2015) show that investor engagement on climate change can lead to positive change but it takes time and collaboration. Here is also an opportunity as Dimson et al., (2015) and Becht et al., (2009) have shown that engagement can both change practice and create value. Method We interview leading financial institutions on climate change in Norway and the UK. Interviews were done in Bristol and Oslo in 2016 and A first write up of the interview was done shortly after each interview. Interviews were semi structured and lasted about one hour. All interviewees had long experience of Socially responsible investment including climate change. We also specifically interviewed individuals and organisations known for expertise in the area such as the Environment Agency Pension Fund in the UK and KLP in Norway. Both have been rated as best financial institutions in their countries for addressing climate change. We have also interviewed the Council on Ethics for the Norwegian Government Pension Fund Global. We pursued purposeful sampling (Patton, 2002). We study the literature on climate change and investment. We specifically wish to include literature from Asset managers as this is important for addressing our research question. Insert Table of interviews
6 Findings We first discuss why some investors integrate climate considerations into their investments, then we outline some Strategies for dealing with climate change based on our interviews and the literature. For example our interviewee in the Environment Agency Pension Fund said that Climate Change was the most significant ESG risk. A challenge for investors here is lack of high quality data on carbon emissions. Our second KLP interviewee said the data quality has been terrible. Why consider climate change in investments The Norwegian financial institution KLP mentioned three key reasons for responsible investment of which addressing climate change is an important part. First, customers expect a responsible investment approach. KLPs customer base includes municipalities and health sector clients. Second, KLP believes that companies that address sustainability issues well are more likely to create value in the long term. Third, given the challenges linked to the Paris Agreement and climate change everyone needs to do their part (KLP 2017, interview). The Environment Agency Pension Fund (EAPF) mentioned that their beneficiaries work for the Environment Agency which is involved in flood defence. Their employees who wade to their hips in water in English towns because of floods expect climate factors to be considered by their pension fund also. Our EAPF interviewee also argued that considering climate change leads to risk reduction. He also noted that companies poorly prepared for climate change may be squeezed out of the market. The Norwegian Government Pension Fund (GPFG) has for a number of years had climate as a focus area, meaning that climate issues have been brought up in engagement with some firms. It is only from 2016 that the GPFG have had formal coal exclusion criteria. This was an initiative by the labour party in Norway, although environmental NGOs had suggested it earlier. 3 The initiative got strong backing in the Norwegian Parliament and the coal related criteria came into force in January For the GPFG it was a political process combined with NGO campaigning that resulted in stronger criteria for coal. Divestment/Exclusions The global carbon divestment movement has grown to over $5 trillion (Deutsche Asset Management, 2017). There is a large divestment movement of coal stocks especially. For example, KLP and GPFG 3 The original proposal had more stringent criteria including a 25% cutoff for coal, after negotiations parties agreed on a 30% cutoff. Companies with a higher turnover from coal were to be excluded.
7 from Norway have divested more than 60 coal companies (either coal mining companies or energy utilities for which coal power is over 30% of the power source or income). KLP stated that you get a lot of bang for the bucks by excluding coal companies. «By excluding coal we exclude 1% of the portfolio and get a 25% reduction in carbon footprint» KLP Interview 2016 However KLP also argued that excluding oil firms would be a step too big to take. KLP mainly follows a passive index based strategy so this would be impossible for their Norwegian and Europe based funds if the oil industry was completely excluded. The Council on Ethics for the GPFG is also looking into operationalizing another carbon criterion linked to an unacceptable level of emissions. We asked them in 2016 what is an «unacceptable level of carbon emissions»? Our Interviewee answered: «Nobody knows», yet the Council was working on operationalising the criterion. Other large investors part of this divestment movement include ABP, Aegon, Axa, Alliantz, Aviva, the Swedish AP4 Pension fund and the Dutch pension fund PFZW (Deutsche Asset Management, 2017). Some French institutional investors and London borough pension funds have also joined the divestment movement (PRI conference 2017). Engagement with companies and sectors This engagement also includes voting of company shares. These campaigns have really gained momentum. For example 62% of Exxon shareholders voted for a resolution calling for a shareholder resolution calling for Exxon to report on portfolio impact and scenarios consistent with limiting global warming to 2 C in A similar motion at the Occidental Petroleum AGM got 67% of the votes ( For example, GPFG, KLP, Aviva and the Environment Agency Pension fund actively vote their shares on climate change issues. AXA a French insurer meets with coal companies about climate change, if there are no improvement the coal firms risk divestment. There is a new campaign which will target 100 of the top CO2 emitting corporations in the world. Investors who have pledged to target these firms include the large US pension fund Calpers and the financial institution Schroeders (PRI Conference, 2017). KLP is a Norwegian Financial institution which has in recent years engaged with over 20 companies specifically on climate issues.
8 Direct investment in progressive sectors and projects KLP has invested in new solar and wind projects in Africa and South America in partnership with Norfund. These are infrastructure projects resulting in new renewable capacity. KLP decided that just excluding some coal firms would not make such a big difference and therefore committed to use the money instead to fund renewable projects in developing countries where the alternative often is coal (KLP interview, November 2017). KLP also invests in renewable energy projects in Norway and the rest of Europe. Thus KLP has invested over 20 billion NOK in renewable energy and further investments are being made (KLP Interview 2017). Pensjon Danmark and Warren Buffet also invest directly in renewable energy projects. The EAPF also do this and try to be very careful with what projects they invest in as our interviewee mentioned that there is a risk of being tied up in these investments for many years. Infrastructure investments of course have much more liquidity risk than equity or bonds. Other strategies Environment Agency Pension fund factors in shadow prices for carbon into investment models (EAPF interview, 2016). This means that even if companies are not formally excluded, for example the most coal intensive firms do not enter the portfolio. It also leads to the oil sector being underweighted. The Environment Agency Pension Fund has as a goal to reduce its coal exposure by 90% by 2020 and the oil exposure by 50% (EAPF, 2016 interview). The carbon footprint of the EAPF went down 44% from 2008 to Data quality is also a challenge (Council on Ethics and KLP interviews). Because of this KLP has worked 10 years with Carbon Disclosure Project to improve company reporting on Greenhouse Gas emissions (KLP Interview 2017). The Council on Ethics interviewee said that everyone is talking about climate change but no one has data. Another possibility is to increasingly switch to low carbon benchmarks. For example, FTSE provide such indexes for investors. The Bank of Norway has recently argued that the oil fund should exclude oil companies from a purely economic perspective (Given the large oil exposure Norway has through Statoil and its own oil reserves, Norway is more exposed to the oil sector than most countries even without any other oil investments). Engagement with standard setters and industry initiatives were also mentioned as effective tools (KLP Interview). Interviewees from NBIM have also mentioned this.
9 Another important aspect of the responsibility of EAPF, GPFG and KLP is transparency. They all publish their holdings and details about their voting in addition to a lot of information about climate and other sustainability issues relating to investments. Conclusions Our research indicates that institutional investors deal with the issue of climate change in different ways. The main strategies were: 1. Divest/Exclude some coal firms. 2. Engage with high impact firms and sectors about climate change. 3. Direct investment in renewable energy projects. 4. Other strategies, including using a shadow price for carbon in investment models, focusing on low carbon benchmarks and working with others to improve data quality. These strategies are not mutually exclusive and all the institutions we interviewed used more than one of the strategies. We think divestment of coal shares can reduce the carbon footprint substantially with little or no effect on the portfolio. While no one is excluding major oil companies 4, the EAPF is an example of a pension fund which has produced excellent returns while underweighting the oil sector. Engagement has the potential of changing company practice, this can be very helpful for energy companies which can move towards a less carbon intensive way of producing energy and electricity. Engagement may be more limited with firms where a large majority of revenues come from coal. Academic studies have also confirmed that engagement can change practices and have positive financial consequences (Becht et al., 2009; Dimson et al., 2015; New LSE study presented at PRI, 2017). Direct investment in renewable projects can help a shift to more low carbon economy as well as providing good returns as KLP and Norfund have shown. In addition they can provide electricity to new areas and much needed employment, especially in developing countries. The problem here can be low liquidity and a long tie in. The mandates of some investors may not allow such investments, this is so for the GPFG for example. There is great potential we believe in ensuring that more fund managers incorporate a shadow price for carbon into their investment models. This price may need to be higher than the current market 4 A Norwegian insurance company Storebrand has said it may exclude some companies involved with oilsands and the fund of the Church of Sweden has indicated it may avoid some oil firms.
10 price. Such an approach will lead to high impact sectors being underweighted, especially coal. This approach might be especially interesting for pension funds which do not think that screening fits well with their investment approach/philosophy. Lastly, there is still a need to improve low carbon benchmarks (although for example FTSE has such benchmarks) and work to improve the data quality so that investors actually can assess the carbon risks of companies. Bibliography ACCA, (2009), Report on trustees and climate change. Author J.Solomon. London. Becht, M, Franks, J., Mayer, Rossi, S. (2009), Returns to shareholder activism: Evidence from a clinical study of the UK Hermes UK Focus Fund, Review of Financial Studies, 22, Carney, M. (2015), Breaking the tragedy of the horizon climate change and financial stability Speech by Mark Carney, Governor of the Bank of England in London, Deutsche Asset Management, (2017), Sustainable Finance Report, Issue 2. Dimson, E., Karakas, O. and Li, X. (2015), Active ownership, Review of Financial Studies, Vol. 28 No. 12, pp Guardian (2017), Peruvian farmer sues German energy giant for contributing to climate change, the Guardian Hjort, I. (2016), Potential Climate Risks in Financial Markets: A literature Review, 2016, University of Oslo memo 01/2016. IPCC, (2014) Climate Change 2014 Synthesis Report, Fifth Assessment Report, accessed syr.ipcc.ch/index.php KLP, (2016), Engagement list Mangset L. and Jensen, N. (2016), Et nytt klima for Oljefondets investeringer, Internasjonal Politikk, Nr 1, pp.1 8. Mathiesen, K. (2015), Nearly half of top pension funds gambling on climate change, The Guardian, Read from funds climate changefossil fuels.
11 Mercer, (2015), Investing in a time of climate change NBIM, (2015), Responsible Investment 2015, Oslo. Standard Life, (2016), Climate Change Statement, Edinburgh. UBS, (2017), Up in the air on carbon Vidal, J. (2016), World s largest carbon producers face landmark human rights case, The Guardian Key climate vote survey 2017
Carbon Report: Investments in Fossil Fuel. November 2014
Carbon Report: Investments in Fossil Fuel November 2014 English Summary of the Norwegian Report About the report The consequences of climate change are serious, and there is broad scientific consensus
More informationCLIMATE RISK NORWEGIAN CLIMATE RISK COMMISSION PATRICK DU PLESSIS
CLIMATE RISK NORWEGIAN CLIMATE RISK COMMISSION PATRICK DU PLESSIS Agenda 1. Responsible investment at Norges Bank Investment Management Overview Role and contributions of Risk Monitoring Department 2.
More informationRESPONSIBLE INVESTMENT GOVERNMENT PENSION FUND GLOBAL DEPUTY GOVERNOR EGIL MATSEN
RESPONSIBLE INVESTMENT GOVERNMENT PENSION FUND GLOBAL DEPUTY GOVERNOR EGIL MATSEN 7 MARCH 2017 The GPFG A financial investor with a unique set of characteristics Size Intergenerational investment horizon
More informationFuture World Fund Q&A
For Professional Investors and their Financial Advisers Only. Not to be distributed to or intended for use by Retail Clients. Index Fund launch Future World Fund Q&A Investing for the world you want to
More informationWorkers Capital and Responsible investment. SFL Pension Conference May 4, 2016
Workers Capital and Responsible investment SFL Pension Conference May 4, 2016 Agenda About SHARE Responsible investment Capital stewardship What to do? About SHARE About SHARE Responsible Investment Services
More informationInvestment Insight Engage or divest? The carbon debate
November 2015 Kirsten Temple Senior Consultant JANA Kirsten is the Head of JANA s Environmental Social and Governance (ESG) & Socially Responsible Investment (SRI) team. In this role, she is responsible
More informationHeed the New Climate-Change Calculus
Heed the New Climate-Change Calculus July 18, 2016 by Rajeev Eyunni, Akhil Kapoor, David Wheeler of AllianceBernstein The United Nations climate accord signed in Paris last December committed 195 countries
More informationGENERAL SYNOD. Debate on a Motion from the National Investing Bodies
GENERAL SYNOD GS 2093 Debate on a Motion from the National Investing Bodies Summary In 2015, General Synod affirmed its support for the newly adopted climate change policy of the Church of England National
More informationThe Taskforce on Climate related Financial Disclosures August 2018
The Taskforce on Climate related Financial Disclosures August 2018 1 Climate change is an issue of global significance. We subscribe to the scientific consensus that man-made emissions of carbon dioxide
More informationSTRANDED ASSETS: FOSSIL FUELS. CARBON STORES in ENVIRONMENT AGENCY PENSION FUND
CARBON STORES in ENVIRONMENT AGENCY PENSION FUND public report 2014 ABOUT TRUCOST Trucost has been helping companies, investors, governments, academics and thought leaders to understand the economic consequences
More informationThe Costs of Climate Change
BACKGROUNDER The Costs of Climate Change Prepared by Clare Demerse, federal policy advisor, Clean Energy Canada November 17, 2016 CLIMATE COSTS IN CONTEXT Canada s governments are developing a climate
More informationRecent policy developments and the rise of climate-related securities disclosure
Recent policy developments and the rise of climate-related securities disclosure ACC Conference May 8, 2017 Laura Zizzo Founder and CEO Topics We Will Cover Overview of Climate Impacts International and
More informationClimate change and fiduciary duties: What should pension trustees know? SHARE Webinar September 15, 2015
Climate change and fiduciary duties: What should pension trustees know? SHARE Webinar September 15, 2015 Agenda Introduction Peter Chapman, Executive Director, SHARE Climate Change and the Fiduciary Duties
More information2.5 Briefing Note to Inform Or Update on an Event
This material was prepared by Andrew Graham, School of Policy Studies, Queen s University, Kingston, Canada. Use it freely and share it with my full permission. If you have any comments or questions, contact
More informationAllianz Global Investors. Climate Risk Investment Positioning
Allianz Global Investors Climate Risk Investment Positioning Climate Risk Investment Positioning Pre-word This investment positioning document aims to summarize Allianz Global Investors (AllianzGI) view
More informationFinancial Regulators and Climate Risk
Financial Regulators and Climate Risk How financial regulators can assess the impacts of climate change under the Adaptation Reporting Power 1 Executive summary 1. The next round of reporting under the
More informationAllianz: Frontrunner on Climate Change in Danger of Losing Ground
Introduction Allianz: Frontrunner on Climate Change in Danger of Losing Ground Briefing Paper by Urgewald and the Unfriend Coal Coalition August 2, 2017 Since 2015, Allianz has been rightfully praised
More informationClimate Change Challenges. Condensed Overview. Climate change scenarios and their impact on funding risk and asset allocation
Climate Change Challenges Condensed Overview Climate change scenarios and their impact on funding risk and asset allocation November 2018 Table of contents Executive introduction....3 Background....4 Where
More informationTHE STATE OF CLIMATE CHANGE RISK MANAGEMENT BY INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS
FROM MSCI ESG RESEARCH LLC THE STATE OF CLIMATE CHANGE RISK MANAGEMENT BY INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS Current Status and Future Trends Short Version* July 2017 Manish Shakdwipee *The full version of this report
More informationCLIMATE CHANGE INVESTMENT STRATEGY
"HOW WE INVEST" WHITE PAPER CLIMATE CHANGE INVESTMENT STRATEGY By Matt Whineray and Anne-Maree O'Connor MARCH 2019 www.nzsuperfund.nz enquiries@nzsuperfund.co.nz PREFACE The New Zealand Superannuation
More informationSpeech by Jacqueline Aloisi de Larderel Director, UNEP Division of Technology, Industry and Economics
Speech by Jacqueline Aloisi de Larderel Director, UNEP Division of Technology, Industry and Economics at the UNEP/Swedish EPA Insurance meeting Stockholm, Sweden 5 th May 2000 1 Good morning Ladies and
More informationPolicy for responsible investment
v Policy for responsible investment Adopted by the Board of Xact Kapitalförvaltning AB (hereinafter referred to as the fund management company or Xact Kapitalförvaltning) 31 May 2017. Value base It is
More informationGlobal Companies Joining Climate Change Efforts
Global Companies Joining Climate Change Efforts NAME: By JUSTIN GILLIS and NICHOLAS ST. FLEUR SEPT. 23, 2015 Some of the world s most prominent companies are expected to set a long-term target on Wednesday
More informationHedging Climate Risk with Decarbonized Indices
Hedging Climate Risk with Decarbonized Indices Mats Andersson AP4 Patrick Bolton Columbia University and Frédéric Samama Amundi PARIS 2015 AND BEYOND, COOLING THE CLIMATE DEBATE -- PARIS 29-30 October
More informationPosition statement Danske Bank March 2018
Climate change Position statement Danske Bank March 2018 1 Introduction About Danske Bank Group Danske Bank is a Nordic universal bank with strong regional roots and close ties to the rest of the world.
More informationClimate Change Action by the National Investing Bodies. Delivering on our commitments
Climate Change Action by the National Investing Bodies Delivering on our commitments NIBs Commitment Action Results The 2015 General Synod Resolution stated: The NIBs to engage robustly with companies
More informationBest practice in fixed income and environmental issues. Hilkka Komulainen, Project Manager, Fixed Income and Infrastructure
Best practice in fixed income and environmental issues Hilkka Komulainen, Project Manager, Fixed Income and Infrastructure ESG strategies in fixed income Both globally and in the Nordics, screening is
More informationRathbones. Divestment debate: should your university or college divest from fossil fuels?
Rathbones Divestment debate: should your university or college divest from fossil fuels? 8 September 2017 Page 2 " The clear and present danger of climate change means we cannot burn our way to prosperity.
More informationTCFD Final Report A summary for business leaders
www.pwc.co.uk TCFD Final Report A summary for business leaders June 2017 Context The G20 Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors are concerned that the financial implications of climate change are
More informationFOSSIL FUEL DIVESTMENT: CONSIDERATIONS FOR PRIVATE WEALTH PORTFOLIOS
FOSSIL FUEL DIVESTMENT: CONSIDERATIONS FOR PRIVATE WEALTH PORTFOLIOS NEPC Impact Investing Committee September 2017 INTRODUCTION An increasing number of private clients are contemplating scaling back or
More informationAP2 s climate report based on TCFD s recommendations
AP2 s climate report based on TCFD s recommendations 1 180226 In Paris in December 2015, 195 states reached a global agreement on climate in order to reduce emissions that that have an impact on climate.
More informationThe FSB Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures What do its recommendations mean for the energy sector?
www.pwc.co.uk The FSB Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures What do its recommendations mean for the energy sector? June 2017 An introduction to the Task Force TCFD established The G20 Finance
More information[Urging the Retirement Board to Divest from Fossil Fuel Companies] Resolution urging the Retirement Board of the Employees' Retirement System
FILE NO. -0-COE [Urging the Retirement Board to Divest from Fossil Fuel Companies] Resolution urging the Retirement Board of the Employees' Retirement System to divest from publicly-traded fossil fuel
More informationThe shared response to climate change: turning momentum into action
1 The shared response to climate change: turning momentum into action Speech given by Sarah Breeden, Executive Director, International Banks Supervision, Bank of England Based on remarks made on 19 March
More informationEconomic Risk and Potential of Climate Change
Economic Risk and Potential of Climate Change Prof. Dr. Peter Hoeppe; Dr. Ernst Rauch This document appeared in Detlef Stolten, Bernd Emonts (Eds.): 18th World Hydrogen Energy Conference 2010 - WHEC 2010
More informationSustainable Investing
FOR INSTITUTIONAL/WHOLESALE/PROFESSIONAL CLIENTS AND QUALIFIED INVESTORS ONLY NOT FOR RETAIL USE OR DISTRIBUTION Sustainable Investing Investment Perspective on Climate Risk February 2017 Clients entrust
More informationI. EQUITY MARKETS AND INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS
Equity markets, benchmark indices, and the transition to a low- carbon economy Authors: Jakob Thomä, Stan Dupré, Fabien Hasan, Nick Robins Key Messages Equity markets have a significant share in financial
More informationClimate change investment risks, opportunities and impacts
Climate change investment risks, opportunities and impacts Justine Sefton Justine Sefton This presentation has been prepared for the Actuaries Institute 2018 Financial Services Forum. The Institute Council
More informationGovernance and Management
Governance and Management Climate change briefing paper Climate change briefing papers for ACCA members Increasingly, ACCA members need to understand how the climate change crisis will affect businesses.
More informationThe 1995 Report on the IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change)
The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance, 22 (No. 85, October 1997) 496-500 The 1995 Report on the IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) Working Group Chapter 17 - Financial Services by Andrew
More informationResponsible investment in green bonds
Responsible investment in green bonds march 2016 Contents 1 Green bonds 3 2 Investing in themes 4 2.1 Climate 4 2.2 Land 4 2.3 Water 4 3 Definition of green bonds 5 4 Conclusion 7 Appendix 1: CBI Standards
More informationClimate changes your business. Wim Bartels 28 February, 2018
Climate changes your business. Wim Bartels 28 February, 2018 2018 KPMG N.V., registered with the trade register in the Netherlands under number 34153857, is a member firm of the KPMG network of independent
More informationClimate change policy. Fulfilling our fiduciary duties on climate
Climate change policy Fulfilling our fiduciary duties on climate As a global investor, we are aware of the risks climate change presents to our investments and as such we are committed to playing our full
More informationClimate Risk and Financial Institutions
Climate Risk and Financial Institutions Sharanjit Paddam & Kate Mackenzie Deloitte Actuaries & Consultants, The Climate Institute This presentation has been prepared for the 2016 Financial Services Forum.
More informationWHY WE BELIEVE RESPONSIBLE INVESTING PAYS OFF Anne-Maree O Connor, David Rae and Rishab Sethi NOVEMBER 2015
HOW WE INVEST WHITE PAPER WHY WE BELIEVE RESPONSIBLE INVESTING PAYS OFF Anne-Maree O Connor, David Rae and Rishab Sethi NOVEMBER 2015 www.nzsuperfund.co.nz email:enquiries@nzsuperfund.co.nz PREFACE The
More informationRemarks at the Accounting for Sustainability Summit 2018
1 Remarks at the Accounting for Sustainability Summit 2018 Remarks given by Mark Carney, Governor of the Bank of England Accounting for Sustainability Forum, St. James s Palace London 21 November 2018
More informationEconomics of Climate Adaptation
Shaping Climate-resilient Development Economics of Climate Adaptation A Framework for Decision-makers Dr. David N. Bresch, Head Sustainability & Political Risk Management, Swiss Re david_bresch@swissre.com
More informationFossil Fuel Promotion in the SU
Fossil Fuel Promotion in the SU Approved By Zone, including comments and details of any vote DAN SCHOFIELD Approved by Scrutiny Committee, including comments Overview (100 words) Facts Statements that
More informationbcimc Responsible Investing Newsletter
Vol. 4 No. 1 MAY 2017 ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIAL GOVERNANCE bcimc Responsible Investing Newsletter TOPIC: WATER bcimc is a global investor that provides investment management services to British Columbia s public
More informationUniversity of Maine System
Fossil Fuel Discussion April 2014 Jay E. Roney, Partner Kelly Regan, Consultant Summary The University of Maine System s investment policy statements include the following: Maximum total return, consistent
More informationOxford Energy Comment March 2007
Oxford Energy Comment March 2007 The New Green Agenda Politics running ahead of Policies Malcolm Keay Politicians seem to be outdoing themselves in the bid to appear greener than thou. The Labour Government
More informationDivestment and Stranded Assets in the Low-carbon Transition. Chair s Summary
Divestment and Stranded Assets in the Low-carbon Transition 32 nd Round Table on Sustainable Development held on 28 October 2015 OECD Headquarters, Paris Chair s Summary Connie Hedegaard Chair, Round Table
More informationLow carbon: a unique global equities solution
Low carbon: a unique global equities solution George Thomson, Consultant, Not-for-Profit EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In this document, we explain how we can help investors manage the potential investment implications
More informationAXA AND CLIMATE RISKS Why does climate change warrant our attention?
AXA AND CLIMATE RISKS Why does climate change warrant our attention? Climate change is increasingly impacting the world s populations and economies The latest scientific findings have reinforced the message
More informationClimate Change. An Unfunded Mandate. By Fran Sussman, Cathleen Kelly, and Kate Gordon October 2013
AP PHOTO/CHARLIE RIEDEL, FILE Climate Change An Unfunded Mandate By Fran Sussman, Cathleen Kelly, and Kate Gordon October 2013 WWW.AMERICANPROGRESS.ORG Introduction and summary There are many reasons why
More informationWe define the Fund s carbon footprint as including both carbon emissions intensity and carbon reserves:
NZ SUPER FUND CARBON REDUCTION - Q&A 15 August 2017 What is the Fund s carbon footprint? We define the Fund s carbon footprint as including both carbon emissions intensity and carbon reserves: For the
More informationPolicy for Responsible Investments Adopted by the Board of Directors of the Management Company on 13 September 2018
Policy for Responsible Investments Adopted by the Board of Directors of the Management Company on 13 September 2018 The purpose of this policy is to set the direction of Handelsbanken Fonder s work on
More informationWEATHER EXTREMES, CLIMATE CHANGE,
WEATHER EXTREMES, CLIMATE CHANGE, DURBAN 2011 ELECTRONIC PRESS FOLDER Status: 25.11.2011 Contents 1. Current meteorological knowledge 2. Extreme weather events 3. Political action required 4. Insurance
More informationLegal & General Investment Management takes action on climate change risks
Press release 11 June 2018 takes action on climate change risks Praises companies taking positive action and removes laggards from the Future World Funds* (LGIM) has today revealed the corporate leaders
More informationResponsible Investment
June 2015 Schroders Responsible Investment Global and International Equities At Schroders, Responsible principles drive our investment decisions and the way we manage funds. From choosing the right assets
More informationSector Compliance Report
NBIM INVESTOR EXPECTATIONS CLIMATE CHANGE RISK MANAGEMENT Sector Compliance Report 2010 1 Sector Compliance Report 2010 ISSN 1891-7720 Sector Compliance Report 2010 Print: 07 Gruppen a/s Design and illustration:
More informationHow can Rathbones help universities and colleges navigate the fossil fuel divestment debate?
How can Rathbones help universities and colleges navigate the fossil fuel divestment debate? 1 The clear and present danger of climate change means we cannot burn our way to prosperity. We already rely
More informationIAP Stern Review Discussion Talking About Risk John E. Parsons
IAP Stern Review Discussion Talking About Risk John E. Parsons Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research A Problem of Risk Management it it was was clear clear that that the the modelling framework
More informationCool Brands versus Hot Brands?
Cool Brands versus Hot Brands? To what extent are big companies and leading brands tackling climate change and what should investors do about it? Executive summary This is the third of EIRIS annual Climate
More informationThe work of the Council on Ethics
The work of the Council on Ethics The Council on Ethics for the Government Pension Fund Global (GPFG) is an independent body that makes recommendations to Norway s central bank, Norges Bank, to exclude
More informationThe impact of present and future climate changes on the international insurance & reinsurance industry
Copyright 2007 Willis Limited all rights reserved. The impact of present and future climate changes on the international insurance & reinsurance industry Fiona Shaw MSc. ACII Executive Director Willis
More informationSocially Responsible Investing Panel
FINANCIAL FORUM 2017 Socially Responsible Investing Panel March 29, 2017 SOCIALLY RESPONSIBLE INVESTING PANEL Introduction SFU Perspective UVic Perspective PH&N Perspective Key Considerations Outcomes
More informationResponse to EIOPA call for evidence for an opinion on sustainability within Solvency II. Ecofin department
Position Paper Response to EIOPA call for evidence for an opinion on sustainability within Solvency II Our reference: Referring to: ECO-LTI-19-050 Call for evidence for an opinion on sustainability within
More informationStranded Assets: A Climate Risk Challenge
Stranded Assets: A Climate Risk Challenge Authors: Ben Caldecott, Elizabeth Harnett, Theodor Cojoianu, Irem Kok, and Alexander Pfeiffer Editor: Ana R. Rios Executive Summary Over the last few years, the
More informationInvesting in a sustainable future
Investing in a sustainable future A framework for charity investors to translate intention into implementation December 2017 Capital at risk. All financial investments involve an element of risk. Therefore,
More information1. Do the trustees accept the TCFD conclusion that pension funds are potentially exposed to financial risks through climate change?
Strathclyde Pension Fund Response to Environmental Audit Committee Green Finance Enquiry Request for Information 1. Do the trustees accept the TCFD conclusion that pension funds are potentially exposed
More information3D Star Rating - Summary
3D Star Rating - Summary 4 January 2019 Overview The 3D Star Rating is a short-hand for identifying the best investment funds with a positive social impact registered for sale in the UK. It is derived
More informationSustainable Finance. Andrew Park Sustainability Group Bloomberg LP New York City, USA
Sustainable Finance Andrew Park Sustainability Group Bloomberg LP New York City, USA CONTEXT Growing awareness of global sustainability challenges Rank 2014 Global Risks of Highest Concern 1 Fiscal crisis
More informationThe impact of recent changes in fiduciary law and obligations to allow trustees to invest Alice Garton, ClientEarth
The impact of recent changes in fiduciary law and obligations to allow trustees to invest Alice Garton, ClientEarth Thank you for having me. It s a great honour to be here speaking to such an esteemed
More informationFossil fuels: Divestment or dialogue? Belinda Gan Sustainable Investment team
Fossil fuels: Divestment or dialogue? Belinda Gan Sustainable Investment team Agenda Fossil fuels: Divestment or dialogue? 1 Divestment: what are the catalysts, challenges and considerations? 2 3 Dialogue:
More informationOct 26 th, Redwood Grove Capital, LP 855 El Camino Real Building 3, Suite 405 Palo Alto, CA 94301
Oct 26 th, 2018 Redwood Grove Capital, LP 855 El Camino Real Building 3, Suite 405 Palo Alto, CA 94301 As fundamental investors, we analyze a company s business prospects, management team and valuation.
More informationClimate Change and Mortality
International Actuarial Association Climate Change and Mortality November 29, 2017 Webcast Climate Change and Mortality Sam Gutterman FSA, FCAS, MAAA, CERA, HonFIA Co-Vice Chair, IAA Resources & Environment
More informationÖKOWORLD ÖKOVISION CLASSIC THE TRADITIONAL SUSTAINABILITY FUND
ÖKOWORLD ÖKOVISION CLASSIC THE TRADITIONAL SUSTAINABILITY FUND S P R I N G 2 0 1 7 THE SIGNIFICANCE OF CLIMATE PROTECTION FOR THE ÖKOWORLD OR ÖKOWORLD S POSITION ON CLIMATE PROTECTION INVESTMENT STRATEGIES
More informationCOMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA RESOLUTION UNDER SECTION 249N OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT FOR CONSIDERATION AT AGM
COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA RESOLUTION UNDER SECTION 249N OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT FOR CONSIDERATION AT AGM SYDNEY, 10 SEPTEMBER 2014: In accordance with ASX Listing Rule 3.17A, Attachment A is a copy
More informationThe Church Commissioners for England. Responsible Investment and Engagement Review 2016
The Church Commissioners for England Responsible Investment and Engagement Review 2016 Responsible Investment Our ambition is to be at the forefront of responsible investment practice. In 2016 we took
More informationCorporate Governance Policy for Xact Kapitalförvaltning Adopted by the Board of Directors of Xact Kapitalförvaltning AB on September 26, 2018.
Corporate Governance Policy for Xact Kapitalförvaltning Adopted by the Board of Directors of Xact Kapitalförvaltning AB on September 26, 2018. The Corporate Governance Policy and its purpose Xact Kapitalförvaltning
More informationSEPTEMBER 2016 EXPERT VIEW ESG IN CREDIT: APPLYING EXCLUSION CRITERIA TO INVESTMENT PORTFOLIOS
FOR PROFESSIONAL CLIENTS ONLY. NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT PRIOR WRITTEN APPROVAL. PLEASE REFER TO ALL RISK DISCLOSURES AT THE BACK OF THIS DOCUMENT. SEPTEMBER 2016 EXPERT VIEW ESG IN CREDIT: APPLYING
More informationGUIDANCE ON PRI PILOT CLIMATE REPORTING
GUIDANCE ON PRI PILOT CLIMATE REPORTING BASED ON THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE FSB TASK FORCE ON CLIMATE-RELATED FINANCIAL DISCLOSURES An investor initiative in partnership with UNEP Finance Initiative and
More informationGREEN BOND FRAMEWORK. 22 August /12
GREEN BOND FRAMEWORK http://www.hypovbg.at 22 August 2017 1/12 CONTENTS Green Bond Framework... 1 1. Introduction... 3 2. HypoV Green Bond... 4 3. HypoV Green Bond Framework... 5 3.1 Use of proceeds...
More informationPFM Asset Management LLC. 300 S. Orange Avenue Suite 1170 Orlando, FL
PFM Asset Management LLC 300 S. Orange Avenue Suite 1170 Orlando, FL 32801 407.648.2208 www.pfm.com Gender, race and other forms of equality? Poverty, access to food or education? Environment, clean water
More informationSustainable Investment Strategies 2016 Highlights
Sustainable Investment Strategies 2016 Highlights a general agency of The United Methodist Church Sustainable Investment Strategies 2016 Highlights Wespath invests in a sustainable and responsible manner,
More informationClimate Finance. São Paulo 28 th June 2016 Senior Adviser Harald Francke Lund
Climate Finance São Paulo 28 th June 2016 Senior Adviser Harald Francke Lund 6000 billion USD needed a year Climate finance flows in last five years have been significant despite economic crisis 2011
More informationFINANSINSPEKTIONEN How can the financial sector contribute to sustainable development?
How can the financial sector contribute to sustainable development? 7 NOVEMBER 2016 7 november 2016 Ref. 16-7623 TABLE OF CONTENTS FOREWORD 3 SUMMARY 4 SUSTAINABILITY AND CLIMATE RISKS 6 An economic perspective
More informationAnalysis of AXA s 12th December commitment on divestment and underwriting
Analysis of AXA s 12th December commitment on divestment and underwriting On the 12th of December, AXA s CEO, Thomas Buberl, adopted new measures to scale-up climate action, covering four courses of action:
More informationFrom why to why not : Sustainable investing as the new normal
From why to why not : Sustainable investing as the new normal Private Equity & Principal Investors Practice October 2017 Authored by: Sara Bernow Bryce Klempner Clarisse Magnin From why to why not : Sustainable
More information+ 50% by In the short term: 50% increase in low carbon investments. + investment
Responsible investment Our investment strategy to address climate change Table of contents Investing in light of a changing climate Summary Four principles A rigorous process A risk and opportunity analysis
More informationSwiss Re: Progress and Contradictions on Climate Change and Fossil Fuels
Swiss Re: Progress and Contradictions on Climate Change and Fossil Fuels Introduction Briefing Paper by Greenpeace Switzerland and the Unfriend Coal coalition August 2, 2017 Along with Munich Re, Swiss
More informationNSHE Fossil Fuel Divestment Discussion
NSHE Fossil Fuel Divestment Discussion Presentation to Investment Committee of the Board of Regents September 6, 2018 Stephanie Shepherd - NSHE Staff, Wendy Walker - Cambridge Associates and Matt Beardsley
More informationNew financing approaches, instruments and opportunities that address the risks of loss and damage
A global sustainability framework and the largest collaborative initiative between the UN and the insurance industry New financing approaches, instruments and opportunities that address the risks of loss
More informationInvestment Strategies for Reducing Carbon Exposure
Investment Strategies for Reducing Carbon Exposure Chris Gauthier, CFA Stonehearth Capital Management Chief Investment Officer 2018 WHY DIVEST OR REDUCE FOSSIL FUELS IN YOUR PORTFOLIO? Align your investments
More information#MICEU Fiona Reynolds. Managing Director, Principles for Responsible Investment
#MICEU #ESG #UNPRI @Fireynolds @PRI_news Fiona Reynolds Managing Director, Principles for Responsible Investment Europe - the ESG Landscape, and why it matters Morningstar European Conference The challenges
More informationOCTOBER 2011 STOXX GLOBAL ESG LEADERS INDICES TRANSPARENCY AND FLEXIBILITY STAND OUT IN THE FLOOD OF SUSTAINABLE PRODUCTS
OCTOBER 2011 STOXX GLOBAL ESG LEADERS INDICES TRANSPARENCY AND FLEXIBILITY STAND OUT IN THE FLOOD OF SUSTAINABLE PRODUCTS 2/5 Does the market really need another sustainability index? Numerous approaches
More informationOF CLIMATE CHANGE. Kim Knowlton, DrPH. Assistant Clinical Professor, Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University
Images: NOAA VALUING THE HEALTH COSTS OF OF CLIMATE CHANGE Kim Knowlton, DrPH Senior Si Scientist, i Natural Resources Defense Council il(nrdc); Assistant Clinical Professor, Mailman School of Public Health,
More informationLONDON BOROUGH OF HARINGEY PENSION FUND INVESTMENT STRATEGY STATEMENT. 1. Introduction
LONDON BOROUGH OF HARINGEY PENSION FUND INVESTMENT STRATEGY STATEMENT 1. Introduction Haringey Council is the Administering Authority for the Local Government Pension Scheme in the London Borough of Haringey
More informationCONFERENCE FORUM. Sustainable Investment Strategies
CONFERENCE FORUM Sustainable Investment Strategies Sustainable Investment Directives 1504.14 717 discharge its fiduciary duties solely in the interest of the participants and beneficiaries with care, skill,
More information