A Flight Path to Self Sufficiency
|
|
- Gregory Edwards
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 A Flight Path to Self Sufficiency Longer term planning for pension schemes Mark Humphreys and Jonathan Smith, Head of UK Strategic Solutions & Strategic Solutions Analyst Introduction In this paper we discuss how setting a Flight Path can help pension scheme trustees and sponsors plan towards achieving a self sufficiency or buy out funding level. As part of the Flight Path process, schemes can chart the progress of their funding level and use improvements as an opportunity to de-risk. From a trustee perspective, the benefits of setting a Flight Path are: A Flight Path is a plan by which trustees can reduce their scheme s reliance on the continuing support of the sponsor (the covenant ) over time. Following a Flight Path enables schemes to lock- in or at least increase the protection of gains in the funding level. A Flight Path can overcome the governance constraints associated with a more ad hoc de-risking strategy and means that schemes can be better placed to take advantage of improved market conditions when they occur. A Flight Path approach should also appeal to sponsors: It provides a managed plan to reduce funding level volatility over time, giving greater certainty over contribution levels and accounting disclosures. Ultimately, a Flight Path can help a scheme attain a level of funding that allows full buy out of the liabilities with an insurance company (or a stable long-term position similar to buy out). De-risking as the funding level improves makes sense as there is little incentive to take investment risk at higher funding levels. This is because the circumstances under which sponsors can take refunds of contributions from their pension scheme are very limited. A Flight Path gives sponsors greater certainty that action will be taken as the funding level improves. What is a Flight Path? The basic framework of such an approach is as follows: Set a long term funding target. This is usually to be fully funded on a self sufficiency or buy out basis. Chart the progress of the scheme s funding level against this target and use funding level improvements as an opportunity to manage down the overall risk profile, usually by: reducing the scheme s growth asset exposure switching in steps from growth assets into bonds extending liability coverage using Liability Driven Investment (LDI) instruments such as swaps. Crucially, working together with a consultant and asset manager it is possible to design and implement a Flight Path strategy that overcomes governance constraints to ensure action is taken if market conditions are more favourable. Issued in May 2010 by Schroder Investment Management Limited. 31 Gresham Street, London EC2V 7QA. Registered No England. Authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority.
2 Figure 1 gives an illustration of what such a Flight Path might look like. There are a number of considerations when designing such a Flight Path which we will cover in this paper. Some questions for sponsors and trustees are: How long should the Flight Path be? Should the scheme reduce unrewarded liability risks (such as interest rate and inflation risk) sooner by using LDI instruments such as interest rate and inflation swaps? When should de-risking take place should this happen using funding level triggers or market based triggers to capture good value entry points? How will the Flight Path integrate with the scheme s shorter term Recovery Plan? However, first we shall outline in more detail the benefits of a Flight Path approach. Figure 1: Flight Path illustration Funding level %- on low risk basis Interim goal full funding relative to Technical Provisions (assuming asset outperformance in discount rate) Time Funding level % Target path Risk Source: Schroders, for illustrative purposes only The case for setting a Flight Path Trustee perspective There is a strong incentive for trustees to look to reduce their reliance on the strength of their sponsor in the long term (the covenant ). The Pensions Regulator estimates that on average around 1 in 100 of all sponsors will become insolvent in the next year 1. This may not seem high in itself, but over a 20 year period this translates to broadly a 1 in 5 chance of insolvency at some time. Even allowing for the impact on insolvency rates of the current economic turmoil, many trustees will feel uncomfortable with this figure. Traditionally reducing reliance on the sponsor covenant has meant improving the scheme s funding level until it is fully funded relative to the Technical Provisions and deficit contributions are no longer required from the sponsor by law. However, even when a scheme has funded its Technical Provisions, it is likely that it will continue to depend on the ability and willingness of the sponsor to support it. For example, if investment returns are lower than expected or if life expectancy increases then the funding level may deteriorate, which could mean further contributions are required from the sponsor. Almost universally the Technical Provisions assessment of the liabilities will include some form of allowance for investing in growth assets and thus it is not possible to lock 1 The Pensions Regulator: The Purple Book
3 down a scheme around its Technical Provisions basis as these growth assets bring volatility to the funding level. Ultimately, the only way to achieve total independence from the sponsor covenant is to pay an insurance company to take on the scheme s liabilities. This usually implies holding assets in excess of the Technical Provisions (at the buy out funding level). Even if buy out is not the ultimate aim of the trustees, it is often desirable to target a low risk investment strategy, (e.g. holding only bonds or swaps), which would minimise the reliance on the sponsor covenant. Again, such a strategy will normally imply a lower discount rate and therefore the need to hold assets above the scheme s Technical Provisions. This higher level is likely to be close to the buy out funding level as insurance companies will typically use a bond or swap based discount rate to value a scheme s liabilities. A Flight Path that gradually reduces investment risk over time also has the benefit of locking in or at least increasing the protection of gains in the funding level, whilst maintaining growth asset exposure in the early years, when extra returns are needed to improve the funding position. Finally, and crucially, a Flight Path can help trustees overcome the governance constraints associated with a more ad hoc long-term de-risking plan. Once designed, it may be possible to delegate much of the day to day monitoring and implementation of a Flight Path to your asset manager. Alternatively, a trustee body could use an investment sub-committee to meet with the asset manager when a trigger to de-risk has been hit to decide upon implementation. This means that the scheme is poised to take advantage of improved market conditions quickly. Sponsor perspective A Flight Path approach should also appeal to sponsors of pension schemes for a number of reasons. The first and most obvious reason is that most sponsors would be more than happy to remove the uncertainty of their DB pension scheme from their company s balance sheet, especially given the volatility associated with the current pensions accounting regime. Of course, for most sponsors buying out their pension liabilities in full now is not affordable; however a Flight Path puts in place a coherent plan towards achieving this objective over a period of time. A Flight Path also clearly sets out a route to the end position and is a natural extension from the sponsor s realisation that the pension scheme will not be around for ever. As a cheaper alternative to a full buy out, a Flight Path can help schemes achieve a stable long term position whereby the assets have been de-risked and the scheme is fully funded on a low risk or self sufficiency basis. Coupled with actions to manage longevity risk (e.g. longevity swaps) schemes can use this approach to replicate many of the benefits of a buy out. This is likely to be a cheaper option than full buy out as the scheme would not be paying for the higher reserving requirements of insurance companies (or contributing to their profits). Secondly, the circumstances under which sponsors can take refunds of contributions from their pension scheme are very limited, so the incentive for sponsors to take investment risk in their pension scheme reduces as the funding level improves. This is particularly true for schemes closed to future accrual where investment gains cannot be used to offset the cost of newly accrued benefits. A third reason why most sponsors should look to de-risk their pension scheme assets concerns where companies are best placed to take risk. Ultimately all company directors are paid to take some degree of risk. Shareholders usually want companies to take risks on projects they are good at, i.e. their core business. Shareholders should therefore expect directors to have a plan for reducing risk in their pension scheme over time where possible. Finally, a Flight Path that reduces the governance burden on the trustees is also likely to mean less input is required from the sponsor. Once the design of the Flight Path has been agreed between the sponsor and the trustees the sponsor can have greater comfort that appropriate action will be taken as the funding level improves. This latter point will become increasingly important to sponsors as funding levels improve. 3
4 Integrating the Flight Path with a Recovery Plan Reducing investment risk in a pension scheme is likely to have funding implications. If a scheme uses an asset based discount rate for funding purposes, reducing the allocation to growth assets can result in a reduction in the discount rate. This places a higher value on the liabilities and could potentially lead to higher company contributions. That said, with a less risky investment strategy, trustees may be willing to accept a longer Recovery Plan, which could reduce contributions. In any case, it is important to consider funding as part of the Flight Path setting process and seek the involvement of the sponsor and the Scheme Actuary at an early stage. As the Flight Path relates to a longer term funding objective it is relatively straightforward to integrate a Flight Path with a shorter term Recovery Plan. Some examples of how this may work in practice are: Set being fully funded relative to the Technical Provisions as an interim target in the Flight Path (e.g. by restating this funding level in terms of the buy out/self sufficiency basis see figure 1 for an example). State the long term funding target in terms of the Technical Provisions. For example the long term target might be stated as 120% of the Technical Provisions if, for example, a 120% Technical Provisions funding level is broadly equivalent to a 100% funding level on the buy out basis. How long should the Flight Path be? From the trustees perspective, the shorter the Flight Path the better, as this will minimise the scheme s reliance on the sponsor covenant. However, as the self sufficiency liabilities are usually greater than the Technical Provisions (sometimes significantly greater), setting a shorter term Flight Path will increase the funding requirements of the scheme. This increase in funding can either be met by higher sponsor contributions or additional investment returns. However the sponsor may be unable/unwilling to pay contributions above those required to meet the scheme s Technical Provisions. This will mean that the scheme would need to continue to invest in risky assets (such as equities) for longer to hopefully generate the required additional return. In this case, trustees may decide to select a longer Flight Path so as to keep investment risk at an acceptable level 2. Additional inputs that could be considered when deciding on the length of a Flight Path are: Probability of sponsor insolvency during the Flight Path. How quickly the scheme is expected to mature (e.g. how quickly the proportion of active members is expected to fall). Use of liability hedging instruments such as swaps Under a core Flight Path approach, as the funding level improves the scheme gradually reduces its allocation to growth assets and invests instead in bonds. This is a transfer of physical assets. A drawback of this approach is that the scheme remains exposed to unrewarded interest rate and inflation risk in the early years of the Flight Path. Schemes may wish to build into their Flight Path design the flexibility to manage liability risks through the use of derivatives, such as interest rate and inflation swaps. These instruments can help schemes manage interest rate and inflation risk, whilst retaining the potential to earn extra returns by investing in growth assets such as equities. The timing of the increase in the liability coverage can be linked to improvements in the funding level or using market triggers. We discuss these in more detail below. Many schemes will benefit from the additional risk reduction of the enhanced Flight Path, however trustees should be aware of the additional governance required to design and implement such an approach particularly if market level triggers are used. 2 We will consider how trustees and sponsors might go about deciding the length of their Flight Path further in a subsequent paper titled How long have you got? 4
5 When should a scheme de-risk? There are two basic methods to timing the switch out of growth assets and into matching assets, although in practice a combination of these may be used. 1. Switch at predetermined funding level triggers 2. Switching at predetermined market levels as market conditions move in favour of the scheme Funding level triggers Using funding level triggers ties de-risking closely to the funding level, ensuring that growth assets remain when they are needed to make up the deficit but are reduced when the funding level improves. Using the funding level has the additional benefit of helping to reduce market timing risk - the risk of selling low or buying high. This is because improvements in the funding level will usually be a consequence of a rise in growth asset prices and/or a rise in the discount rate (and so a fall in bond prices and pension scheme liabilities). Market price trigger points Market based trigger points aim to reduce market timing risk even further and might be coupled with more detailed implementation decisions such as what type of risk to hedge (interest rate, inflation or both) and which benefit cashflows to hedge (long, short or all cashflows). This approach is more likely to be associated with the enhanced Flight Path approach discussed above. Using market triggers in a Flight Path involves taking a view on whether the current price of interest rate and/or inflation protection (e.g. via the swaps market or bond market) represents good value and if not, at which point it does. Then, when these triggers are reached, the scheme purchases protection at the more favourable price according to a predetermined formula. Thus, even if a trustee group does not wish to extend liability protection at current market levels, putting in place a Flight Path enables trustees to take advantage of opportunities to de-risk if better value arises in the future. Using market level triggers also provides a mechanism by which schemes can protect gains in the funding level that have arisen because of, for example, rising interest rates or falling inflation expectations Figure 2: Illustrative market triggers for increasing interest rate coverage Yield (%) 2.5 Over 5 year index-linked yield Feb-04 Jun-04 Oct-04 Feb-05 Jun-05 Oct-05 Feb-06 Jun-06 Oct-06 Feb-07 Jun-07 Oct-07 Feb-08 Jun-08 Oct-08 Feb-09 Jun-09 Oct-09 Trigger Level 2 Hit: Extend coverage to 75% Funding gain of c. 3.5m Current coverage: 20% Potential path of future yields Trigger Level 3 Hit: Extend coverage to 100% Funding gain of c. 2m Trigger Level 1 Hit: Extend coverage to 50% Funding gain of c. 5m Liabilities falling Liabilities rising Source: Bloomberg, Schroders, for illustrative purposes only The appropriate trigger levels will depend on the balance between the potential gain and the probability of the targets being hit. The closer the trigger level is to the current position the more likely that it will be hit (and a gain will be locked in). However a trigger level close to the current position may only result in a modest improvement in the funding level when it is hit. 5
6 A disadvantage of both funding level and market price triggers is that if market conditions/funding levels deteriorate or do not improve to the trigger levels, risk could remain in the scheme longer than desired. Governance is an important consideration both funding level and market price triggers require a mechanism to monitor funding levels/market conditions on a regular basis. Implementation under a market based approach requires the governance to be able to form a view on market conditions. That said, methods to delegate this monitoring function and the implementation of the changes in investment strategy continue to evolve, including the use of Flight Path based mandates managed by LDI investment managers. Using market based triggers in the Flight Path Before embarking on a market based approach it is important that trustees understand where the majority of their scheme s liability risk lies. As shown in figure 3, the majority of pension scheme risk is usually associated with benefit cashflows at longer durations. Whereas trustees may have a strong conviction as to what inflation or interest rates will be over the next 2 or 3 years, it is much harder to form a view over the timescales that matter the most for the majority of schemes those of longer durations. Figure 3 shows the cashflows of an example scheme, split by different pension increase types, together with the interest rate/inflation sensitivity of its liabilities over various periods of time. The majority of interest rate and inflation sensitivity (around 95%) relates to cashflows more than 10 years away, however investors/economists views on interest rates/inflation typically cover a much shorter period. Figure 3: Example scheme cashflows and where the risk is concentrated Payment per annum 14,000,000 12,000,000 Sensitivity to interest rates / inflation (% of total PV01) 5% 5% 20% 19% 28% 28% 24% 24% 23% 24% 10,000,000 8,000,000 6,000,000 4,000,000 Increases due to the effect of future inflation Index-Linked Pension Cashflows Fixed Pension Cashflow 2,000, Source: Schroders, for illustration purposes only It is therefore important to recognise that a market trigger approach involves taking a view on interest rates and inflation that are material to the scheme, and that this is likely to be harder than taking a short term view. 6
7 Monitoring At the heart of any Flight Path is a monitoring process, which is needed to determine both the correct asset allocation at a particular point in time and the continuing suitability of a Flight Path design. Successful monitoring requires the ability to see all the moving parts of your strategy, including the liabilities (including cashflows into and out of the scheme), the growth assets and the matching assets. This enables information to be collated quickly and efficiently so that actions can be taken in a timely manner. For this reason, it is desirable for a scheme s assets to be placed on a single platform that can provide this level of reporting. An example of how we can assist trustees monitor the progress of their Flight Path is shown in figure 4. Figure 4: Example of how trustees can monitor the progress of their Flight Path (1) Impact of passage of time this causes the present value of the liabilities to increase as the time to payment shortens. (2) This highlights where the hedging assets (e.g. bonds or swaps) are not exactly matched to the liabilities being hedged. (3) The effect of changes in interest rates and inflation on the liabilities which the trustees have chosen not to hedge at this stage. (4) The return on the scheme s growth assets. (5) The impact of the scheme s cashflows not occurring in line with expectations (e.g. if benefit payments were less than expected) 'm Start Passage of time Hedged Unhedged Excess return on growth assets Net inflow End Source: Schroders, for illustration only. The orange bars represent a worsening in the funding position and the grey bars represent improvements 7
8 Conclusions The aim of a Flight Path is to help schemes plan towards achieving a self sufficiency or buy out funding level. This offers the opportunity to gain independence from the fortunes of their sponsor, whilst at the same time reducing funding risk and locking in gains in the funding level as the Flight Path progresses to its final goal. A Flight Path can also help trustees overcome many of the governance constraints associated with a more ad hoc de risking strategy. This potentially allows schemes to capture more favourable market conditions using market based triggers. A Flight Path approach should also appeal to sponsors as it provides a managed plan by which schemes can reduce funding level volatility, as well as providing greater comfort that appropriate action will be taken when the funding level improves. A Flight Path will typically involve charting the progress of the scheme s funding level and using improvements as an opportunity to reduce the scheme s growth asset exposure and switch this into bonds. Schemes may also reduce interest rate and inflation risk sooner using LDI assets such as swaps. At Schroders we are able to help trustees and sponsors with the design and implementation of their Flight Path. Mark Humphreys Head of UK Strategic Solutions +44 (0) mark.humphreys@schroders.com Jonathan Smith Strategic Solutions Analyst +44 (0) jonathan.smith@schroders.com 8
9 Appendix Jargon Buster Buy out basis This is intended to be a close match to the basis that would be used by an insurance company to take on the scheme s liabilities. It will usually use a gilts or swaps based discount rate and, as such, will usually give a higher liability than the Technical Provisions (which may make some allowance for asset outperformance in the discount rate). Enhanced Flight Path Under an enhanced Flight Path unrewarding interest rate and inflation risk is removed early on in the Flight Path (e.g. by using swaps), whist the allocation to growth assets is maintained. This ensures the scheme retains the potential for additional returns early in the Flight Path in order to make up its funding deficit. Flight Path This is a process whereby schemes set a funding and investment plan to reach self sufficiency over a preagreed number of years. Investment risk is reduced over time as the funding level improves. Funding level triggers These are predetermined funding levels at which the scheme will de-risk (e.g. by switching growth assets into matching assets such as bonds and/or purchasing additional liability coverage via swaps). Integrated funding Changing a scheme s investment strategy has implications for both the scheme s funding basis and its Recovery Plan. It is therefore important to consider funding as part of the Flight Path setting process and seek the involvement of the sponsor and the actuary at an early stage. Such an approach is sometimes referred to as integrated funding. Liability Driven Investment (LDI) Broadly speaking, LDI can be defined as a strategy whereby a scheme constructs its investment portfolio with some consideration for the nature of its liabilities. The most common tools of LDI are bonds and swaps, both of which hedge the unrewarded interest rate and inflation risk in schemes liabilities to some degree. Swaps are a more flexible tool as they can be used to build a closer match to the scheme s liabilities and can use much less capital than bonds in doing so. This frees up scheme s to invest in growth assets to potentially generate excess return. Market based triggers There are predetermined market conditions (e.g. interest rate levels) at which the scheme will de-risk. PV01 Actuaries and asset managers often use the term PV01 to describe the overall size (in terms) of the sensitivity of bonds or liabilities to changes in interest rates. PV01 = (duration x value)/10,000. Interest rate risk is minimised when the PV01 of the scheme s assets is equal to the PV01 of its liabilities. Self sufficiency This describes the position whereby a scheme is sufficiently funded to be independent of the fortunes of its sponsor. This usually implies being funded on a buy out basis as this would mean that the scheme s assets can be transferred to an insurance company. It can also mean being fully funded on a gilts or swaps basis (which is likely to be close to the buy out basis). For a scheme to be self sufficient investment risk would need to be minimised (e.g. by only investing in gilts or swaps) as otherwise the sponsor may need to be called upon again to meet deficits that emerge as a result of investment losses. Technical Provisions The Technical Provisions are the statutory measure of a scheme s liabilities used for the triennial valuation and usually for funding purposes. 9
10 Important Information For professional investors and advisors only. This document is not suitable for retail clients. This document is intended to be for information purposes only and it is not intended as promotional material in any respect. The material is not intended as an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any financial instrument. The material is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on for, accounting, legal or tax advice, or investment recommendations. Information herein is believed to be reliable but Schroder Investment Management Ltd (Schroders) does not warrant its completeness or accuracy. No responsibility can be accepted for errors of fact or opinion. This does not exclude or restrict any duty or liability that Schroders has to its customers under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (as amended from time to time) or any other regulatory system. Schroders has expressed its own views and opinions in this document and these may change. Reliance should not be placed on the views and information in the document when taking individual investment and/or strategic decisions. Issued by Schroder Investment Management Limited, 31 Gresham Street, London EC2V 7QA, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority. Company registration No England. For your security, communications may be taped or monitored. 10
Schroders. Top 10 tips for de-risking. De-risking goals for your defined benefit pension scheme. For professional investors only
Schroders Top 10 tips for de-risking De-risking goals for your defined benefit pension scheme For professional investors only What is the goal of your de-risking plan? A buy-out of the liabilities? Or
More informationLDI Solutions For professional investors only
LDI Solutions For professional investors only Liability Driven Investment Explained Chapter 1 Introduction to asset/liability management Section one What do we mean by pension scheme liabilities? 4 Section
More informationProperty: a panacea for pension funds?
Property: a panacea for pension funds? Patrick Bone, Head of UK Property Research Traditionally, pension funds have invested in UK commercial property to derive the benefits of diversification from other
More informationThe real drivers of pension scheme liabilities
September 2013 The real drivers of pension scheme liabilities Alistair Jones, UK Strategic Solutions, Schroders In this paper we analyse a significant cause in the movement of UK pension scheme liabilities
More informationAon Hewitt Retirement and Investment. Aon Investment Research and Insights. Endgame Strategies. Cashflow Driven Investment Series.
Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment Aon Investment Research and Insights Endgame Strategies Cashflow Driven Investment Series November 2017 Table of contents Executive summary....3 Introduction...4 What
More informationShould trustees buy in bulk?
Aon Retirement and Investment For professional clients only Aon Investment Research and Insights Should trustees buy in bulk? November 2018 Table of contents Executive summary....1 Suitability...1 Why
More informationFor professional investors and advisers only
February 2013 Andrew Connell, Head of LDI, Schroders Introduction The Chancellor s autumn statement announced that the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) will be consulting in the New Year: On whether
More informationPooled liability driven investment solutions.
LGIM OUR RANGE OF POOLED DE-RISKING SOLUTIONS Pooled liability driven investment solutions. For defined benefit schemes and their advisors With unrivalled scale and experience in the UK pension market,
More informationInvestment Insights. The cashflow conundrum. Plan A. Quarter three
Investment Insights The cashflow conundrum Quarter three - 2016 For many years pension schemes have been trying to balance the conflicting objectives of generating the required level of return (and hopefully
More informationAN INTRODUCTION TO LIABILITY DRIVEN INVESTMENT AN INTRODUCTION TO LIABILITY DRIVEN INVESTMENT HELPING PENSION SCHEMES ACHIEVE THEIR ULTIMATE GOAL
FOR PROFESSIONAL CLIENTS ONLY. NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT PRIOR WRITTEN APPROVAL. PLEASE REFER TO ALL RISK DISCLOSURES AT THE BACK OF THIS DOCUMENT. AN INTRODUCTION TO LIABILITY DRIVEN INVESTMENT HELPING
More informationInvestment Insights LDI PLUS
RISK PENSIONS INVESTMENT INSURANCE Newsletter Investment Insights LDI PLUS The use of liability driven investments (LDI), by which we mean the practice of using leverage to try to reduce the exposure of
More informationPooled liability driven investment solutions.
LGIM OUR RANGE OF POOLED DE-RISKING SOLUTIONS Pooled liability driven investment solutions. For defined benefit schemes and their advisors With unrivalled scale and experience in the UK pension market,
More informationDB Dynamics. Setting the liability hedge level. For investment professionals only. Not for distribution to individual investors.
DB Dynamics Setting the liability hedge level For investment professionals only. Not for distribution to individual investors. In this edition of DB Dynamics we present our hedging philosophy, explaining
More informationPension scheme de-risking a practical guide
Pension scheme de-risking a practical guide Pension scheme de-risking a practical guide Introduction The Aon Hewitt Mid-Market Pension Survey 2012 found that over 80% of UK pension schemes with assets
More informationSchroders Insurance-Linked Securities
October 2015 For professional investors or advisers only. Not suitable for retail clients. Schroders Insurance-Linked Securities Advised by Secquaero Advisors AG Schroders Insurance-Linked Securities
More informationUnderstanding the route to retirement
March 2012 Understanding the route to retirement Lauren Juliff, UK Institutional Business Development, Schroders Jonathan Smith, UK Strategic Solutions, Schroders In the UK, Defined Contribution (DC) pensions
More informationMeeting the capital challenge of investing in equities
Schroders Insurance Asset Management Insurance Strategy Meeting the capital challenge of investing in equities For professional investors only In a low-yield world the potential long-term returns from
More informationLiability aware investing
August 2017 Liability aware investing The benefits of integrating your liability hedging and growth portfolios This document is for investment professionals only and should not be distributed to or relied
More informationFees Survey. March 2014
Fiduciary Man nagement Insights Fees Survey March 2014 Contents Executive summary 1 Introduction 4 Components of fees in a fiduciary management mandate 5 Context for survey 6 Base fiduciary 7 Investment
More informationHow to contingency plan. What does TPR mean by contingency planning and what should trustees be doing? RISK MANAGEMENT INSIGHTS
RISK PENSIONS INVESTMENT INSURANCE RISK MANAGEMENT INSIGHTS How to contingency plan What does TPR mean by contingency planning and what should trustees be doing? As part of its focus on Integrated Risk
More informationNovember Pension Investment and Governance Survey 2018
November 2018 Pension Investment and Governance Survey 2018 Contents Introduction 01 Headlines from the survey 02 Investment governance 04 Investment strategy 07 Investment risk 11 Appendix Survey participation
More informationCashflow Driven Investment
Cashflow Driven Investment Presentation to the PIA Jon Exley January 2018 Marketing material for professional investors only. Not suitable for retail clients. Agenda Principles of CDI Return profiling
More informationTelefónica UK Pension Plan. Statement of Investment Principles
Telefónica UK Pension Plan Statement of Investment Principles Introduction Under the Pensions Act 1995 (as updated by the Pensions Act 2004), the Telefónica UK Pension Trustee ( the Trustee ) is required
More informationCashflow Management Strategy
Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment Aon Investment Research and Insights Cashflow Management Strategy Cashflow Driven Investment Series November 2017 Table of contents Executive summary....3 Introduction...4
More informationThe Co-operative Pension Scheme ( Pace )
The Co-operative Pension Scheme ( Pace ) Statement of Investment Principles August 2013 1. Introduction Pace Trustees Limited ( the Trustee ) has drawn up this Statement of Investment Principles ( the
More informationActuarial valuation as at 31 December 2015
Actuarial valuation as at 31 December 2015 Rentokil Initial 2015 Pension Scheme ('the Scheme') Prepared for Rentokil Initial Pension Trustee Limited ('the Trustee') Prepared by David Lindsay FIA, Scheme
More informationAon Hewitt Retirement and Investment. Trigger Strategies. Staying on track. Risk. Reinsurance. Human Resources.
Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment Trigger Strategies Staying on track Risk. Reinsurance. Human Resources. Trigger Strategies What is a trigger strategy and why is it important? Recent political and
More informationControlling volatility for better investment outcomes
14 Controlling volatility for better investment outcomes Swings in asset prices are a concern for most investors. Some, however, suffer more than others. Many want the returns that equities can give, but
More informationStatement of Investment Principles
Statement of Investment Principles This is the Statement of Investment Principles (the Statement ) made by Hermes Pension Trustees Limited, as Trustee (the Trustee ) of the Hermes Group Pension Scheme
More informationEscrow White Paper. - reconciling stability and surplus. Alternative Finance. Think Pensions Stability Think Aon Hewitt
Escrow White Paper - reconciling stability and surplus Contributors of Stability Alternative Finance Think Pensions Stability Think Aon Hewitt September 2014 Contents Page 01 - Synopsis Page 02 - Introduction
More informationMerchant Navy Officers Pension Fund (MNOPF) Statement of Investment Principles
Merchant Navy Officers Pension Fund (MNOPF) Statement of Investment Principles Introduction The main purpose of the MNOPF is to provide pensions on retirement at normal pension age for Officers in the
More informationThe Metal Box Pension Scheme and AVC Plan Investment Guide
The Metal Box Pension Scheme and AVC Plan Investment Guide June 2007 A Glossary of special pension terms used in this booklet can be found on the fold-out flap at the back Contents Introduction 2 What
More informationInvestment Guide December 2015
Investment Guide December 2015 For members of the Hewlett Packard Enterprise Investment Scheme Your investment guide This guide is for members of the Hewlett Packard Enterprise Investment Scheme (the Scheme)
More informationFunding DB pension schemes: Getting the numbers right
Aon Hewitt Consulting Retirement & Investment Funding DB pension schemes: Risk. Reinsurance. Human Resources. Funding DB pension schemes: Executive summary There is considerable debate in the UK pensions
More informationJones Lang LaSalle Retirement Benefits Scheme. Statement of Investment Principles August Background
Jones Lang LaSalle Retirement Benefits Scheme Statement of Investment Principles August 2006 1. Background This Statement of Investment Principles (the Statement ) has been prepared by Jones Lang LaSalle
More informationPension funds and index-linked gilts A supply/demand mismatch made in hell
Marketing material for professional investors or advisers only Pension funds and index-linked gilts A supply/demand mismatch made in hell June 16 UK private sector defined benefit schemes already own an
More informationSchroders Global Equity Solutions for Defined Contribution
August 2011 For professional investors and advisors only. Not suitable for retail clients. Schroders Global Equity Solutions for Defined Contribution Global Equity Solutions Active vs passive Why active
More informationPension scheme consolidation
Briefing Pension scheme consolidation An alternative to traditional exit strategies? RISK PENSIONS INVESTMENT INSURANCE Traditionally, there have been two main pension scheme exit strategies: 1. Prudent
More informationBy way of background, Carillion (DB) Pension Trustee limited became trustee of the 6 schemes on 1 April I have been chairman since that date.
Rt Hon Frank Field MP Chair Work and Pensions Committee House of Commons London SW1A 0AA workpencom@parliament.uk By email 26 January 2018 Dear Mr Field Carillion (DB) Pension Trustee Many thanks for your
More informationLDI Swap Funds and Gilt Funds
LDI Solutions For professional investors only PAGE 1 LDI Swap Funds and Gilt Funds BMO Global Asset Management is a leading provider of Liability Driven Investment (LDI) solutions in the UK marketplace
More informationClick & Invest. Managing your investments
Managing your investments Building trust from the start When you entrust us with managing your money, you want to know exactly what we will do with the investments we buy and look after on your behalf.
More informationBBC Pension Scheme. Actuarial valuation as at 1 April June willistowerswatson.com
BBC Pension Scheme Actuarial valuation as at 1 April 2016 30 June 2017 willistowerswatson.com 1 Summary The main results of the Scheme s actuarial valuation are as follows: Technical provisions funding
More informationPension Solutions Insights
Pension Solutions Insights Swaptions: A better way to express a short duration view Aaron Meder, FSA, CFA, EA Head of Pension Solutions Andrew Carter Pension Solutions Strategist Legal & General Investment
More informationUK Risk Settlement. Pricing Opportunity Continues
Aon Hewitt Retirement & Investment UK Risk Settlement Pricing Opportunity Continues As the graph below shows, annuities are continuing to deliver notably better yields than comparable low-risk assets for
More informationContinental European real estate
October 216 For professional investors only. This material is not suitable for retail clients 1 Schroders Insurance Asset Management Insurance Strategy Continental European real estate The right time to
More informationDevon Pension Fund Funding Strategy Statement
Devon Pension Fund Funding Strategy Statement 1 Introduction 1.1 This is the Funding Strategy Statement for the Devon County Council Pension Fund. It has been prepared in accordance with Regulation 58
More informationEuropean companies with UK defined benefit schemes. Analysing levels of deficit, contributions paid and risk
European companies with UK defined benefit schemes Analysing levels of deficit, contributions paid and risk This survey relates to constituent companies of the Dutch AEX, French CAC40, German DAX, Spanish
More informationThe illiquidity conundrum: does the illiquidity premium really exist?
Marketing material for professional investors or advisers only The illiquidity conundrum: does the illiquidity premium really exist? August 2015 Locking your money up for a longer period of time can be
More informationSummary Funding Statement as at 31 March 2012
SUMMARY FUNDING STATEMENT AS AT 31 MARCH 2012 Summary Funding Statement as at 31 March 2012 The USS Summary Funding Statement is issued to all scheme members and beneficiaries with information on the financial
More informationChoosing investment funds Lifestyle Investment Programmes
Choosing investment funds Lifestyle Investment Programmes Contents 1 Introduction Lifestyle investment programmes How do these programmes work? 5 Why the Retirement Protection Fund and the Halifax Fund?
More informationDefined contribution: an alternative route to investing
Defined contribution: an alternative route to investing Stephen Bowles, Head of Defined Contribution, and David Heathcock, Head of Life Company Operations, Schroders DC investing looking beyond the why
More informationInvestment Implications of RPI to CPI
Robert Gardner, Redington Jay Shah, Pension Corporation Investment Implications of RPI to CPI 21 September 2011 The Inflation basket RPI: + Financial Services 1 1 Percentage 21/09/2011 What has happened
More informationLONDON BOROUGH OF HARINGEY PENSION FUND INVESTMENT STRATEGY STATEMENT. 1. Introduction
LONDON BOROUGH OF HARINGEY PENSION FUND INVESTMENT STRATEGY STATEMENT 1. Introduction Haringey Council is the Administering Authority for the Local Government Pension Scheme in the London Borough of Haringey
More informationCurrent Issues in Pensions
30 September Current Issues in Pensions Financial Reporting The key financial assumptions required for determining pension liabilities under the Accounting Standards FRS102 (UK non-listed), IAS19 (EU listed)
More informationThe objective of an occupational DB pension scheme is simple pay members their
October 2016. For professional investors only. Please read the important disclosure at the end of this article. spotlight Supporting the liability-hedging and return-seeking demands of a modern LDI strategy
More informationMethodology and Inputs for the 2017 Valuation: Initial assessment. Technical discussion document for sponsoring employers
NOTE: This document was first circulated to stakeholders in February 2017 as part of the Trustee's preparations for the 2017 valuation. In December 2017, a formal actuarial report was submitted to the
More informationPowering ahead The current UK LDI Market
1 Powering ahead The current UK LDI Market June 216 www.kpmg.com/investment/advisory 216 KPMG LDI SURVEY 2 Executive summary The UK Liability Driven Investment (LDI) industry powered ahead during 21 with
More informationBank of America Merrill Lynch UK Pension Plan Statement of Investment Principles
Bank of America Merrill Lynch UK Pension Plan Statement of Investment Principles This Statement of Investment Principles ( SIP ) covers both the defined benefit (also known as final salary ) and the defined
More informationGW Contracted-out Money Purchase Scheme ( the Scheme ) Statement of Investment Principles
GW Contracted-out Money Purchase Scheme ( the Scheme ) Statement of Principles This Statement of Principles (SIP) covers the defined contribution section of the Scheme. It is set out in three parts: 1)
More informationGSK Pension Fund ( the Fund ) Statement of Investment Principles
GSK Pension ( the ) Statement of Principles This Statement of Principles (SIP) covers the defined benefit and the defined contribution sections of the. It is set out in four parts: 1) Governance arrangements
More informationICI Specialty Chemicals Pension Fund
ICI Specialty Chemicals Pension Fund 15 May 2015 Summary The main results of the Fund s actuarial valuation are as follows: Technical provisions funding level as at 31 March 2014 has decreased to 91.1%
More informationFor professional investors or advisers only. Schroders. Defined Contribution Services. Advanced. pension products
For professional investors or advisers only Schroders Defined Contribution Services Advanced pension products Experience and advanced thinking Schroders has significant experience of managing DC assets
More informationCARILLION (DB) PENSION TRUSTEE LIMITED
MERCER CARILLION (DB) PENSION TRUSTEE LIMITED ACTUARIAL VALUATIONS AS AT 31 DECEMBER 2011 - CARILLION STAFF PENSION SCHEME - MOWLEM STAFF PENSION AND LIFE ASSURANCE SCHEME - ALFRED MCALPINE PENSION PLAN
More informationPension De-Risking. De-risking your future: A structured plan.
Pension De-Risking De-risking your future: A structured plan. Planning for an uncertain future is a key aspect of pension scheme management. Over the past decade, a seemingly never-ending flow of developments
More informationSTATEMENT OF INVESTMENT PRINCIPLES (SIP) IN RESPECT OF EDS RETIREMENT PLAN and EDS 1994 PENSION SCHEME (Plans)
INTRODUCTION STATEMENT OF INVESTMENT PRINCIPLES (SIP) IN RESPECT OF EDS RETIREMENT PLAN and EDS 1994 PENSION SCHEME (Plans) 1.1 EDS Trustee Limited and EDS 1994 Trustee Limited (Trustees) have each prepared
More informationSmithKline Beecham Senior Executive Pension Plan ( the Plan ) Statement of Investment Principles
SmithKline Beecham Senior Executive Pension Plan ( the Plan ) Statement of Principles This Statement of Principles (SIP) is set out in three parts: 1) Governance arrangements 2) Objectives and implementation
More informationStatement of Investment Principles University of Oxford Staff Pension Scheme (Defined Benefit)
Statement of Investment Principles University of Oxford Staff Pension Scheme (Defined Benefit) Introduction This Statement of Investment Principles (SIP) has been prepared by the Trustee of the University
More informationUK Risk Settlement. Understanding and Managing Pension Risks. Risk Settlement Group Quarterly Update, January 2012
UK Risk Settlement Understanding and Managing Pension Risks Risk Settlement Group Quarterly Update, uary 2012 ket news Despite another rollercoaster year and difficult conditions in many investment markets,
More informationKen MacDonald & Co Lawyers and Estate Agents Mortgages: A Guide
Ken MacDonald & Co Lawyers and Estate Agents Mortgages: A Guide Introduction A mortgage is a sum of money borrowed from a bank or building society in order to purchase property. The money is then paid
More informationCurrent Issues in Pensions Financial Reporting
Briefing 31 December 2018 Current Issues in Pensions Financial Reporting RISK PENSIONS INVESTMENT INSURANCE The key financial assumptions required for determining pension liabilities under the Accounting
More informationLondon Borough of Barnet Pension Fund
Appendix D - JLT Investment Strategy Positioning Report London Borough of Barnet Pension Fund Investment strategy Contents 1 Introduction... 1 2 Executive summary... 2 3 Current investment strategy...
More informationPrice Risk Management
Using The Steel Index Price Risk Management Prevent runaway margin erosion on fixed price contracts Gain access to spot prices, without exposure to spot market volatility......with the safety-net of contracts
More informationINSIGHT S POOLED LDI PLATFORM LDI SOLUTIONS PLUS
FOR PROFESSIONAL CLIENTS ONLY. NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT PRIOR WRITTEN APPROVAL. PLEASE REFER TO ALL RISK DISCLOSURES AT THE BACK OF THIS DOCUMENT. INSIGHT S POOLED LDI PLATFORM LDI SOLUTIONS PLUS OPPORTUNITY
More informationPENSIONS Lafarge UK Pension Plan PensionBuilder plus CONTENTS 1
PENSIONS Lafarge UK Pension Plan PensionBuilderplus PensionsINVESTMENTS A guide to investing your personal investment account and AVCs January 2017 CONTENTS 1 Contents INTRODUCTION JARGON-BUSTER INVESTMENTS
More informationSchroders Investing in Property During and After a Recession
August 29 For professional investors and advisors only. Not suitable for retail clients. Schroders Investing in Property During and After a Recession Mark Callender Head of Property Research, Schroders
More informationUSING FIXED INCOME TO HELP DELIVER THE PENSIONS PROMISE: POOLED CASH-FLOW DRIVEN INVESTMENT
INFORMATION FOR INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS USING FIXED INCOME TO HELP DELIVER THE PENSIONS PROMISE: POOLED CASH-FLOW DRIVEN INVESTMENT COLUMBIATHREADNEEDLE.COM USING FIXED INCOME TO HELP DELIVER THE PENSIONS
More informationCashflow Driven Investment Assets
Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment Aon Investment Research and Insights Cashflow Driven Investment Assets Cashflow Driven Investment Series November 2017 Table of contents Executive summary....3 Introduction...4
More informationConnections matter. Jonathan Smith & Simon Bentley. Designing your end game. For professional investors only CM17913 UK
CM17913 UK Connections matter For professional investors only Jonathan Smith & Simon Bentley Designing your end game Investment risks The value of investments and any income derived from them can go down
More informationWhile this group have made preparations for retirement, they have not thought through their financial position or their spending needs in any
Executive Summary This report, Supporting DC members with defaults and choices up to, into, and through retirement: Qualitative research with those approaching retirement, is the first stage in a two stage
More informationInfrastructure debt: Ready to ride on the road to rising rates
Primer: building a case for infrastructure finance Infrastructure debt: Ready to ride on the road to rising rates November 17 Marketing material for professional investors or advisers only In an environment
More information1. Background Introduction
1. Background Introduction April 2017 This guide gives you an overview of the points you should consider before you decide how you should invest your DC contributions. There is a range of funds in which
More informationThe five biggest DB pensions challenges today
Aon Hewitt Retirement and Investment The five biggest DB pensions challenges today and how to solve them Enter What are the biggest challenges facing UK Defined Benefit (DB) schemes today? The DB pensions
More informationThe Pathway Funds. To and through retirement. The Pathway Funds
The Pathway Funds To and through retirement The Pathway Funds are target date funds which allow you to match your investment strategy to a target date range. This will normally include the date at which
More informationWest Midlands Pension Fund. Investment Strategy Statement 2017
West Midlands Pension Fund Investment Strategy Statement 2017 March 2017 Investment Strategy Statement 2017 1) Introduction This is the Investment Strategy Statement (the ISS ) of the West Midlands Pension
More informationCashflow Driven Investing for defined benefit pension schemes. Secure income investing in a low-yield environment
Cashflow Driven Investing for defined benefit pension schemes Secure income investing in a low-yield environment Alpha Real Capital 2 Cashflow Driven Investing overview The path to self-suffi ciency for
More informationReport on actuarial valuation as at 31 December Church Workers Pension Fund
Report on actuarial valuation as at 31 December 2016 Church Workers Pension Fund 3377205 Page 1 of 32 Church Workers Pension Fund Report on actuarial valuation as at 31 December 2016 As instructed, we
More informationBuck Global Investment Advisors at Xerox Directed Consulting
Buck Global Investment Advisors at Xerox Directed Consulting Directed Consulting takes a streamlined approach, providing direct and proactive recommendations on asset allocation and investment manager
More informationManaging longevity risk
Managing longevity risk Working with Towers Watson AWARDS 2014 Deal of the year Managing longevity risk is becoming increasingly important and the market is evolving rapidly. Towers Watson has driven innovation
More informationYour AVC Plan, Your Choice Investment Choice Guide for Public Sector Employees
Your AVC Plan, Your Choice Investment Choice Guide for Public Sector Employees taking care of you... 2 Contents Investing Your Additional Voluntary Contributions 4 Why Investment Choice Is Important 6
More informationCORE CAPABILITIES LIABILITY DRIVEN INVESTMENT
FOR PROFESSIONAL CLIENTS ONLY. NOT TO BE REPRODUCED WITHOUT PRIOR WRITTEN APPROVAL. PLEASE REFER TO ALL RISK DISCLOSURES AT THE BACK OF THIS DOCUMENT. CORE CAPABILITIES LIABILITY DRIVEN INVESTMENT LIABILITY
More informationStandard Life Stanplan A. Statement of Investment Principles
Standard Life Stanplan A Statement of Investment Principles Date signed: July 2017 Contents 1. Introduction 4 2. Choosing investments 4 3. Investment objectives 5 4. Kinds of investments to be held 5 5.
More informationInvestment Strategy Statement: September 2018
Investment Strategy Statement: September 2018 Introduction and background This is the Investment Strategy Statement ( ISS ) of the London Borough of Lewisham Pension Fund ( the Fund ), which is administered
More informationAkzo Nobel (CPS) Pension Scheme
Akzo Nobel (CPS) Pension Scheme Actuarial valuation as at 31 March 2015 23 March 2016 willistowerswatson.com Summary The main results of the Scheme s actuarial valuation are as follows: Technical provisions
More informationInfrastructure debt in Europe
For Investment Professionals only Infrastructure debt in Europe An M&G Institutional perspective January 2017 The value of investments will fluctuate, which will cause prices to fall as well as rise and
More informationStatement of Investment Principles
Statement of Investment Principles Cheshire Pension Fund November 2014 Page 1 of 15 Introduction The Cheshire Pension Fund ( The Fund ) is required to publish a Statement of Investment Principles (SIP)
More informationGuide to Risk and Investment - Novia
www.canaccord.com/uk Guide to Risk and Investment - Novia This document is important. Its purpose is to help with understanding investment in financial markets, the associated risks and the potential returns.
More informationSchroders Emerging markets - time for trustees to look again?
Schroders Emerging markets - time for trustees to look again? June 2014 Introduction Jonathan Smith, UK Strategic Solutions Most UK pension schemes already have some exposure to emerging markets (EM),
More informationGOVERNANCE REVIEW 2017 FULL REPORT
GOVERNED INVESTMENT STRATEGIES (GIS) GOVERNANCE REVIEW 2017 FULL REPORT This information is for UK financial adviser use only and should not be distributed to or relied upon by any other person. As part
More informationUnderstanding investments. A quick and simple guide to investing.
Understanding investments A quick and simple guide to investing. Irish Life Multi-Asset Portfolio funds are available on investment and pension plans provided by Irish Life Assurance plc. INTRODUCTION
More informationSuccessful investment strategy for pension schemes
RISK PENSIONS INVESTMENT INSURANCE Successful investment strategy for pension schemes A three-step approach 1 Successful investment strategy for pension schemes Pension fund investment is undoubtedly one
More information