Military/RCMP Veterans Against CPP Annuity Benefit Reduction at Age 65 Or Sooner if Disabled. Honour, Dignity, Justice, Equality!

Transcription

1 Military/RCMP Veterans Against CPP Annuity Benefit Reduction at Age 65 Or Sooner if Disabled Honour, Dignity, Justice, Equality! 1

2 Contents Mission:... 3 Campaign Paper History:... 3 The Crux of the issue:... 3 CPP Facts:... 4 Military/RCMP Service Consideration:... 5 Endorsement of the Campaign:... 5 Solution:... 7 Conclusion:

3 Mission: The Military/RCMP Veterans mission is to have the Government of Canada terminate the unfair/unjust CPP Benefit Reduction to their Annuity at age 65 or sooner if Disable at no cost to the taxpayers. The Prime Minister must right a wrong and amend the CFSA and the RCMPSA ACT of a miscalculation of justice that affects the financial security of Veterans and their Families during their Golden Years. Campaign Paper History: Encouraged by a number of Veterans, on February 21, 2005 a letter was sent to Mr. Peter Stoffer, MP Sackville-Eastern Shore seeking his support towards a Private Member s Bill aimed at resolving the Military/RCMP Veteran s CPP Annuity benefit reduction issue. Following a meeting with him, we received a letter of support on April 28, Subsequently, a committee was formed with John Labelle as the campaign coordinator. Roger Boutin, Mel Pittman, Reina MacNeil, J. P. Martinello and many other Veterans continue to assist with the campaign today. Since 2005, Mr. Peter Stoffer, MP has introduced to the House of Commons Bill C-441, C-221, C- 502, C-201 and C-215.A number of bills had to be introduced because of the short life of minority Governments. On November 2, 2006 Peter introduced to the House the Veterans first 5 points motion. On January 30, 2014 he also introduced to the House Bill C-572. "An Act to amend the Canadian Forces Superannuation Act and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police Superannuation Act!" (Deduction of disability pensions) Mr. Bill Casey, a former Conservative MP introduced Motion M -362 in support of Veteran s annuity issue. Prior to being elected Prime Minister of Canada, in the 2005 Federal election campaign Mr. Harper, MP stated: "When a motion passes the democratic elected majority of the House of Commons, The Government shall Honor that motion!" (Hansard 2005) Once elected he quickly changed his mind! He then refused to move forward the successful vote of Bill C-201. Unfortunately for Military/RCMP Veterans, on May 5, 2010, for the fourth time, Conservatives MP s were directed to vote against our Bills. However, Bill C-201 count was successful, and the final vote recorded was 149 yeas and 134 nays. The speaker of the House of Commons declared that Bill C- 201 was carried, but he then discharged it from the agenda because Prime Minister Harper refused to request a Royal recommendation and Bill C-201 died on the order table....1 The Crux of the issue: Military/RCMP Veterans maintain that in 1965/66, the Government of Canada deliberately or otherwise imposed on them a gross unconstitutional unfairness by the so-called merging rather than stacking their Annuity contributions and benefits. The fact is that the Government of Canada has breached our enrolment contract without prior member consultation or authorization. During our enrolment contract we were promised that we would benefit of a full pension calculated at 2% of our best 6 years for a period of 25 years of service. This CPP claw back situation also affects Veterans drawing the CPP disability benefits. This Government action was taken without any 3

4 Veterans consultation. Senior Officers have no authority to negotiate their benefits. Legal representation was not made available. Today the maximum contributions to both plans continue to be listed separately on our pay guide, given them a false sense of Financial Security. Furthermore, the vast majority of serving personnel were not informed of the CPP claw back plan until they arrived at age 65. Take notice that in 1966 the CPP contributions were 1.8% of basic rate of pay. Today s contributions are 4.95% of basic rate of pay. The difference is an additional 3.15% is taken from our basic rate of pay. Why is it that we lose all of our CPP benefits on our Canadian Forces Superannuation? CPP Facts: The Government of Canada enacted the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) in 1965 and the plan came into force on January 1, Its intention was to provide another source for an "Income Security" program to supplement the Old Age Security Pension Plan. As of June 30, 2015, the CPP funds delivered a strong investment performance with an all time high surplus of $268.6 billions. We are aware that the CPP funds are going to grow by 2050 by something like 1 Trillion dollars. (CEO,CPPIB) The CPP plan will continue to grow and reached assets above $15 Trillion dollars by Veterans are aware that the Government of Canada has depleted over $16.5 billion dollars and a further $ 630 million dollars in 2003/04 to pay down the National debt. These surplus funds are considered to be a Sacred Trust Obligation to the Financial welfare of Canada s Forces personnel and their Families during their retirement Golden years. During the 6 and 5 price and wage control years, the Government of Canada took a contributions holiday to our Service pension accounts and never paid it back. The Canadian Forces annual Annuity report, ending 31 March 2013, indicated that there were 86,305 retired Military Annuitants in receipt of an Annuity. Only $2.673 billion was required to pay all annuities` under the Canadian Forces Superannuation Act for the year Military/RCMP Veterans are not seeking any additional funds from the Public purse. They are seeking a fair and equitable treatment in receiving their unreduced CFSA/RCMP Annuity at age 65, or sooner if disabled. Our Pension surpluses continue to grow. As of 31 March 2013, the net assets held on behalf of the Canadian Forces pension plan indicated that the Veterans Annuity plan total $ billion dollars. It clearly indicates that Veterans have over contributed and are not receiving the benefits they paid for. The phrase "Bridge Benefits" is a misrepresentation of facts! It is not listed in the Pension Act and/or the Base Financial Counselor s manual. (A-Fn /ID-001) Furthermore, the manual was not made available to service personnel. The bridge benefit term is a myth that was never used prior to the establishment of our Annuity Campaign. 4

5 Military/RCMP Service Consideration: Compare the following different issues Military/RCMP personnel face on a regular basis: What price tag can we place on the Voluntary service we ask our Spouse to perform while we serve our Country Canada? Loss of Veterans Financial disability protection in the application of the New Veterans Charter; Loss of Spouse income/employment opportunities as a result of member numerous operational moves, leading to the loss of Spouse CPP benefits; Spouses often face extended Family separation with elevated level of stress while maintaining a family on their own. The unavailability to celebrate Anniversaries, Birthdays and Family gathering; Numerous moves affecting the ability and opportunity to purchase a home and be mortgage free during a career; Veterans have served far abroad on numerous 24/7, 16 hour days without overtime compensation; Veterans faced dangerous conditions, health hazards and they were committed to an unlimited liability; The Supplementary Death Benefit (SDB) for Public service employees is set at $10,000 while Forces personnel is set at $5,000; Senators, Members of Parliament and Judges Advocate were exempted the CPP claw back to their pension at age 65 until 2005; and Senators and MP s Spouse survivors benefit is 66% of the members Annuity while Forces Spouse only receive 50%. Endorsement of the Campaign: This worthwhile initiative continues to grow! Over 112,500 Military/RCMP Veterans have pronounced their support of the issue. To date 121 former Colonel and Generals have signed our Veterans petition. It included the signatures of 54 former officers of the rank of Generals and/or former RCMP Superintendents. The Dominion Command of the Royal Canadian Legion, the Army, Navy and Air Forces Veterans (ANAVETS) of Canada and the Air Forces Association in Canada have adopted resolutions at their Annual General meetings in 2006 in full support of our campaign. Support has also been received from Mrs Lilian Morgenthau, Founder and President of CARP (Canada s Association for the 50 plus). 5

6 RCMP Deputy Commissioner Larry R. Proke, Mr. Bill Gildley, Executive Director, RCMP Veteran s and Mr. Alex Geddes National Secretary, RCMP Veteran s Association have unanimously supported our issue. Numerous other Military Associations have also declared their support. On May 6, 2008 Mr. Jack Frost, Dominion Command President of the Royal Canadian Legion, sent a letter to the Minister of the National Defense with copies to The Prime Minister of Canada and The Minister of Veterans Affairs expressing his grave concerns regarding the issue of fairness pertaining to the CPP reduction to the CFSA. The highest decorated Officer of the Canadian Forces, Colonel (Ret d) Donald S. Ethel, the former Lieutenant Governor of Alberta has signed our petition. Quote: Major General Lewis MacKenzie It does my heart good to see the Lower Sackville Vets leading this charge with the much appreciated support from MP Peter Stoffer. I for one doubt that the majority of retirees realised the scale of the claw back until a month before it happens when you get the dreaded notification in the mail. The scale of the deduction certainly came as a surprise to me after 36 years in the Queen s service. Your campaign has brought this somewhat underhanded measure into light of the day and I congratulate and fully support your efforts. Best regards, Lew MacKenzie, OstJ, Oont, MSC, CD end of quote. In 2011, the Yukon and the Nova Scotia Provincial standing committees on Veterans Affairs unanimously passed motions in support of the Military/RCMP veterans Annuity issue. The Right Honourable Justin Trudeau: The Royal Canadian Naval Association (RCNA) Peregrine Branch wish to inform you that our Association is in full support of terminating the Canada Pension Plan clawback affecting our Military and RCMP Veterans and their Families. It is a fact that the Government of Canada has breached our enrolment contract. In that contract, all Military personnel were promised that we would benefit from a full pension calculated at 2% of our best six years after a period of 25 years of service. The CPP clawback not only affects Veterans who have completed 25 years or more service to our Country, but also veterans drawing CPP disability benefits. We are not seeking any additional funds from the Public. We are only seeking fair and equitable treatment in receiving unreduced CFSA/RCMP benefits after serving our Country faithfully for more than 25 years. We are asking for your prompt attention to this unfair and unjust treatment of our Country's long serving Veterans. Sincerely, Ernest Marcoux President, RCNA Peregrine 6

7 Solution: Quote: As the former Commissioner with the Canadian Pension and Appeal Board, I know that such initiative could be remedied by the Commissioner s Executive with a simple White Paper, followed by a request to the Minister of Veterans Affairs Canada (VAC) for the needed action and amendment to the Pension Act and its policies. End of Quote Conclusion: Prime Minister Harper did not honour his 2005 election campaign promise to respect the successful vote of Parliament Bills. His Government did not acknowledge the democratic successful vote of 149 yeas for Bill C-201, it must be acted on. Since no additional funds are required from the taxpayers, A royal Recommendation should not be required. This undemocratic CPP Annuity benefit reduction imposed upon Military/RCMP Veterans without fair and open consultation now affects the welfare of Veterans and their Families during their well earned Golden years of retirement. Surely, the Government has a solemn obligation to treat its Veterans with fairness and dignity. Sufficient funds are available in our Annuity account to resolve this outstanding issue. We live in a free Country today because over 100,000 Canadians service members died on the field of battles since Some Veterans shed some blood, some did not return, all were prepared to give the ultimate sacrifice and some Families gave it their all. The sacred trust obligation to Veterans and their Families must be restored in their Golden Years. Military/RCMP Veterans and their Families have paid for it in so many different ways. Sincerely, " Kindness is a language the deaf can hear & the blind can see! " John Labelle Veterans Annuity Campaign Coordinator florencejohn@ns.sympatico.ca Dresden Court Lower Sackville Nova Scotia B4C 3X1 CC: Peter Stoffer Patron Mel Pittman Reina MacNeil J.P. Martinello 7

8 Honour, Dignity, Justice, Equality! Revised: July 23, 2018 " In memory of Roger Boutin, Public Relations Coordinator! " 8