UK CORPORATE VALUATION METHODS: A SURVEY
|
|
- Alban George
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 An introduction to Corporate Finance: Transactions and Techniques By Ross Geddes Copyright 2006 John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Appendix UK CORPORATE VALUATION METHODS: A SURVEY
2 184 APPENDIX This appendix presents the results of a survey of ex perienced corporate fi nance practitioners in the UK and Ireland condu cted in May and Ju ne Qu estionnaires w ere sent to 452 corporate fi nance directors at 71 banks, stock brokers, venture capitalists and accountancy firm s listed in C rawford s Directory. A total of 113 u sable responses w ere retu rned from 41 different fi rm s by the 14 Ju ly 1998 cu t-off date. This represents a response rate of 25.0% of indiv idu als and 57.7% of firm s surveyed. Although the survey w as conducted a num ber of years ago, its resu lts continu e to be broadly v alid, w ith the possible exceptions of the current perceived equity risk prem iu m and the u sage of the Internet to research com panies. Scoring and tables Most qu estions requ ired a response regarding the frequ ency of u se of a m ethod or sou rce of inform ation. The scale used is as follow s: Alm ost Seldom Som e- Usu ally Alm ost never tim es alw ays 0 5% 6 35% 36 65% 66 95% % The tables in this report contain the m ean score, standard dev iation and the percentage of each respondent selecting 1, 2, 3, 4 or 5. Percentages m ay not add to
3 APPENDIX % because of rounding and, in som e cases, m ultiple responses. A.1 VALUATION METHODOLOGY There are tw o m ain approaches to determ ining the value of a com pany: relative valuation techniques; and determ ination of intrinsic or true value. UK corporate fi nance professionals u se relativ e v alu a- tion techniqu es m ost often. This m ay refl ect the ease w ith w hich, in m ost cases, com parable com panies can be found. How ever, num erous lim itations affect the reliability of sole reliance on com parable m ethods. These inclu de differences in accou nting policies; identifi cation of su itable com panies; hidden assets and liabilities; and non-ov erlapping ranges; bu t ignores sy nergies in the case of an acqu isition. Possibly the m ost im portant concern relating to relative v alu ation m ethods is w hen m ost or all com panies are trading at levels above their intrinsic value (a speculativ e bu bble). Certain acqu isitions or fl otations m ay be attractive on a relative basis, but cannot be justified on the basis of intrinsic value. Determ ination of intrinsic v alu e is generally accom - plished throu gh the application of Discou nted Cash Flow (DC F) techniques. This m ethod w as ranked sixth
4 186 APPENDIX in term s of frequency of use, but as one of the tw o m ost im portant m ethods as detailed in Table A.2. DCF approaches also su ffer from lim itations: identifi cation of forecast cash fl ow s can be diffi cu lt if the corporate fi nancier does not hav e access to m anagem ent forecasts and the calcu lation of an appropriate discou nt rate is su bject to debate. The ability to achiev e arithm etically precise v alu ations u sing com pu ter spreadsheets can also seduce the inexperienced into believing that DCF v alu ations are m ore accu rate. As m any financiers noted: valuation is as m uch an art as it is a science. A.1.1 Frequency of use The full results are presented in Table A.1. One lim itation of this table is that it does not recognise that certain v alu ation m ethodologies are m ore appropriate to com panies in certain sectors. For ex am ple, sev eral respondents pointed ou t that property com panies are v alu ed prim arily on the basis of appraised net asset value. The m ost frequently cited other valuation m ethod w as an enterprise v alu e/earnings Before Interest, Tax, Depreciation and Am ortisation (EBITDA) or enterprise value/ Earnings Before Interest and Tax (EBIT ) ratio. Over 10% of respondents m entioned it.
5 APPENDIX 187 Table A.1 Valu ation m ethodology. Rank Method Mean Standard score deviation (% ) (% ) (% ) (% ) (% ) 1 Trading m ultiples of com panies in the industry 2 Capitalisation of forecast earnings 3 Trading m ultiples of com panies taken over (exit m ultiples) 4 Price/EBIT Capitalisation of historic earnings 6 DCF Acquisition prem ia Industry rule of thum b 9 Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 10 Div idend y ield Other Historic book v alue Liquidation v alue Replacem ent cost asset value 15 Real options
6 188 APPENDIX A.1.2 Calculation of final valuation or value range The second set of questions dealt w ith the w ay in w hich the respondents w eighted the resu lts of different m ethods. Ov er 70% of respondents u su ally or alm ost alw ay s placed the greatest w eight on one m ethod and used others as a check. A num ber of respondents indicated that their reliance on different m ethods depended on the nature of the assignm ent. For exam ple, one suggested that relative valuation m ethods w ere m ore im portant in fl otations and other capital m ark ets transactions, w hile DCFs w ere m ore im portant in the case of acquisitions. Finally, a num ber of respondents stated that gut feel, Table A.2 Im portance of m ethods. Method First Second Third Total choice choice choice top 3 ( ) ( ) ( ) picks (% ) (% ) (% ) (% ) DCF Trading m ultiples Price/EBIT Capitalisation of forecast earnings Capitalisation of historic earnings Num ber of respondents.
7 APPENDIX 189 m arket feel or a sense of w hat w as reasonable w ere im portant influences on the final valuation or valuation range. We attem pted to determ ine w hich m ethods fi nanciers m ost relied u pon. Not all respondents prov ided an answ er to this question, nor did they all provide three responses. The DCF m ethod w as highly ranked despite its rank of sixth in the frequency of use table. The question asked w as: On w hich of the m ethodologies listed abov e in Section A do y ou ty pically place the m ost w eight? A.2 DISCOUNTED CASH FLOWS There are a num ber of DCF approaches w hich vary in their ease of calcu lation and applicability. The su rv ey ask ed respondents w hich of fou r possible approaches they used. A.2.1 DCF approaches The fi rst alternativ e discou nts the pre-interest after-tax cash fl ow s at the Weighted Av erage Cost of Capital (WAC C ) assu m ing a constant debt equ ity ratio (the WACC m ethod). This is the m ost frequ ently u sed approach in the UK w ith 63% of respondents u sing it usually or alm ost alw ays. The second approach discou nts the cash fl ow s av ailable to shareholders (i.e., after interest and principal
8 190 APPENDIX repaym ents) using the cost of equity as the discount rate the Equity C ash Flow (EC F) m ethod. This is typically used in situations w here the com pany s initial gearing is very high. The cost of equity is recalculated each year as the gearing lev el decreases. Econom ic profi t also referred to as residu al incom e, Econom ic Valu e Added (EVA) or Shareholder Valu e Added (SVA) is forecast and discounted at the WACC (Shareholder Valu e Method). There is no benefi t to be gained in using this m ethod for valuation its greatest use is in providing an annual snapshot of corporate econom ic perform ance. Finally, Adjusted Present Value (APV) separately values operating cash fl ow s and the tax shields prov ided by interest pay m ents u sing different discou nt rates. APV probably provides the m ost useful approach in com plex v alu ation situ ations as it disaggregates the sou rces of value. A.2.2 Forecast period The length of the cash fl ow forecast w as also inv estigated. A w ide range of responses w as recorded (from 2.5 to 20 years). Som e of the variance can be explained by the indu stry specialities of the respondent. Those cov ering u tilities and other relativ ely stable indu stries indicated a longer cash fl ow forecast than others. The m ost frequ ent response w as 5 y ears, althou gh the average w as 7.14 years and the m edian 7.0 years.
9 APPENDIX 191 Table A.3 DCF m ethod. Rank Method Mean Standard score deviation (% ) (% ) (% ) (% ) (% ) 1 WACC ECF Shareholder v alue Adjusted Present Value (APV ) A.2.3 Term inal value An ex trem ely im portant com ponent of any cash fl ow based valuation is the calculation of the term inal value at the end of the explicit cash flow forecast. Depending on the length of the forecast period, the term inal value estim ate can often provide m ore than half of the total value ascribed to the com pany. The m ost frequ ent response m u ltiple of earnings or EBIT in the final year is unfortunately not theoretically correct. It m ixes an accounting m easure (w ith its lim itations) w ith an econom ic m easure of cash flow. The corporate fi nancier is m ak ing assu m ptions abou t the m ultiple w hich is achievable in the future. Interestingly, the m ethod cu rrently fav ou red by m any strategy consu ltants the hold and fade m ethod w as cited very infrequently. Hold and fade is a refinem ent of the perpetuity calculation. The m ethod recognises that a com pany s cash flow s are highly unlikely to increase in perpetuity or that it w ill be able to continue
10 192 APPENDIX Table A.4 Term inal value calculation. Rank Method Mean Standard score deviation (% ) (% ) (% ) (% ) (% ) 1 Multiple of fi nal year earnings or EBIT 2 Value of perpetuity Value of a grow ing perpetuity 4 Hold and fade to earn a retu rn greater than its cost of capital indefinitely. Therefore, it suggests a period of tim e w hen the com pany continues to earn a return in excess of its cost of capital (typically up to 7 years), then gradually reducing (fading) its return on invested capital to equal its cost of capital. A.3 COST OF CAPITAL One of the m ost im portant contributors to value is the choice of the discou nt rate u sed in determ ining the present v alu e of cash fl ow s. Most debate is generated by the calculation of the cost of equity as the calculation of the cost of debt is relatively straightforw ard. A.3.1 Determ ining the cost of equity Several m ethods are available for calculating the cost of equ ity. The div idend discou nt m odel, Capital Asset
11 APPENDIX 193 Table A.5 Determ ining the cost of equity. Rank Method Mean Standard score deviation (% ) (% ) (% ) (% ) (% ) 1 CAPM Risk free rate Assum ed risk prem ium for the particular stock 3 Div idend discount m odel 4 Other Pricing Model (C APM), Arbitrage Pricing Model (APM) and option approaches are the m ost com m only taught in business schools. The CAPM continues to be the m ost used in practice. Each has lim itations either w ith respect to the ease of calculation (APM) or the inability of em - pirical testing to v alidate the theory (CAPM). A.3.2 Capital asset pricing m odel Several questions w ere asked regarding the com ponents of the form u la: the risk-free rate of interest, the com - pany s beta, and the equ ity risk prem iu m (the retu rn on the equ ity m ark et in ex cess of the risk-free retu rn that is required by equity investors) K e r f r m r f The CAPM has been su bject to ex tensiv e theoretical and em pirical exam ination. These studies indicate that
12 194 APPENDIX CAPM (and specifically the beta factor) m ay not be the best m easure of calculating the cost of equity and that other factors such as book to m arket values and firm size m ay be better indicators of ex pected equ ity retu rns. How ev er, CAPM rem ains in w idespread u se, partly because of the w ide availability of published betas (see Table A.8) and its continu ed acceptance by practitioners as noted above. In addition, none of the alternatives has proven to be w ithout lim itations. A Risk-free rate of return Responses to the question of the source of the risk-free rate of return overw helm ingly favoured m edium -/longterm governm ent bonds. Table A.6 Risk -free rate. Rank Rate used Respondents (% ) 1 Medium -/long-term gov ernm ent bonds Short-term gov ernm ent bills Other 5.5 A Beta One of the m ain reasons for the continued w idespread u se of the CAPM is the w ide range of sou rces that pu blish betas for indiv idu al com panies. This is illu s- trated by the alm ost equ al reliance on the top three beta sou rces: London Bu siness School, Datastream and Bloom berg.
13 APPENDIX 195 Table A.7 Sou rces of beta. Rank Source Respondents using (% ) 1 London Business School Risk 26.8 Measurem ent Serv ice 2 Datastream Bloom berg Barra Internal calculation Other Use beta of 1.0 for all 2.1 A Eq uity Risk Prem ium The Equity Risk Prem ium (ERP) has been the subject of signifi cant academ ic and practitioner debate in recent y ears. Traditionally, bank ers and analy sts had relied upon historic excess returns as a proxy for future returns. It w as believed that accurate forecasts of equity m arket retu rns w ere im possible to obtain, therefore a long-ru n av erage of ex cess retu rns w as an appropriate prox y for future expected returns. Studies in both the UK and the US found that, over the long ru n ( ), equ ities prov ided a retu rn of approx im ately 8.3% abov e the risk-free rate (as calculated u sing an arithm etic m ean). When the retu rns w ere calculated on the basis of a geom etric m ean (i.e., to take account of com pounding) the historic equity risk prem ium dropped to betw een 5.0% and 5.50% leading to
14 196 APPENDIX a debate over w hether the returns should be calculated on an arithm etic or geom etric basis. Corporate fi nance tex ts line u p on both sides of the issue. Brealey & Myers Principles of C orporate Finance advocates the use of the arithm etic m ean, w hile others (including Copeland et al., 2000) recom m end the geom etric m ean. Table A.8 indicates the m ethods used by practitioners to calcu late the ERP. The fi nal colu m n indicates the UK risk prem iu m as calcu lated by each m ethod. Table A.8 Calculation of Equity Risk Prem ium. Rank Method Respondents UK Equity (% ) Risk Prem ium 1 Forw ard look ing Historic av erage (arithm etic m ean) Historic av erage (geom etric m ean) Other 14.7 NA Note: The total sum s to m ore than 100 because 12 respondents gave m ultiple answ ers. Table A.9 sum m arises the results of the current ERP in use in the UK. Many respondents entered a range rather than a single num ber. When this occurred, w e used the m idpoint of the range in calculating the m ean and standard dev iation.
15 APPENDIX 197 Table A.9 UK Equity Risk Prem ium. Country Mean Mode Standard Minim um Max im um deviation (% ) (% ) UK Num ber of responses; Mode Most frequent response. SOURCES OF INFORMATION The su rv ey also requ ested respondents to indicate the pu blicly av ailable sou rces of inform ation u sed w hile undertak ing valuations. Clearly, m anagem ent forecasts and interview s w ould be very highly ranked if they had been included in the question. Published financial statem ents and brok ers reports w ere v iew ed as the m ost valuable sources of inform ation (see Table A.10). Table A.10 Sou rces of inform ation. Rank Source Median score Standard deviation 1 Annual report and accounts Interim reports Brok ers reports (other fi rm s ) Consensus earnings estim ates Brokers reports (ow n firm ) Other Financial press Trade journals Consultants reports Gov ernm ent statistics Internet (World Wide Web)
16 198 APPENDIX Tw o categories of brok ers reports w ere inclu ded: ow n fi rm and other fi rm s. The reason that other fi rm s reports ranks higher than ow n firm is a consequence of the num ber of respondents w orking for m erchant banks, corporate finance boutiques or accounting firm s w ith no research or brok ing capacity. Within the financial statem ents, the num eric presentation of the resu lts w as deem ed to be m ore im portant than the descriptiv e, narrativ e sections. Table A.11 Content of annu al report and accou nts. Rank Source Median score Standard deviation 1 Incom e statem ent/profi t and loss 2 Balance sheet Cash fl ow statem ent Operating and fi nancial rev iew 5 Chairm an s statem ent Directors report
AQR Wholesale DELTA Fund
AQR Wholesale DELTA Fund Product Disclosure Statement 30 September 2017 Responsible Entity: Perpetual Trust Services Limited, ABN 48 000 142 049, AFSL 236648 Investment Manager: AQR Capital Management,
More informationFacts about your HSA. Your money works for you. W hat is a Healt h Savings Account (HSA)? W hat is a Qualif ied Hig h Deduct ible Healt h Plan (HDHP)?
Facts about your HSA Your money works for you. W hat is a Healt h Savings Account (HSA)? A Health Savings Account is a special account used w ith a qualif ied Hig h Deductible Health Plan. HSAs offer you
More informationA Comparison of Methods for Portfolio Optimization
87 32nd ORSNZ Conference Proceedings A Comparison of Methods for Portfolio Optimization Sonya Rennie Department of Engineering Science University of Auckland New Zealand rennie@es v 1. auckland. ac. nz
More informationUACN PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT COMPANY PLC FINANCIAL STATEMENT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2017 Financial highlights 2017 2016 % 2017 2016 % N'000 N'000 Change N'000 N'000 Change Continuing operations Revenue
More informationAn Examination on the use of Technical Trading rules versus a Buy-and-Hold Trading Strategy in the Irish Stock Market.
An Examination on the use of Technical Trading rules versus a Buy-and-Hold Trading Strategy in the Irish Stock Market. J o n a t h a n C r o s b i e A d is s e r ta tio n s u b m itte d in p a rtia l f
More informationCONSUMER LENDING PLAN
3900 Crow n Road Atlanta GA 30380-0001 CONSUMER LENDING PLAN BORROWER'S NAME AND ADDRESS MEMBER NUMBER DATE OF BIRTH CO-BORROWER'S NAME AND ADDRESS MEMBER NUMBER DATE OF BIRTH "You", "Your" and Borrower,
More informationCom pensation philosophy
Disclosure statement Com pensation philosophy May 29, 2017 The following disclosure statem ent presents the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority s executive com pensation program. The statem ent includes information
More information(ii) Period 2 closing balance Period 1 Probability Period 2 Probability Period 2 Joint Expected closing cash flow closing Probability value
Answers Fundamentals Level Skills Module, Paper F9 Financial Management June 2010 Answers 1 (a) (i) Period 1 closing balance Opening balance Cash flow Closing balance Probability Expected value $000 $000
More informationOFFICIAL BULLETIN OF STATISTICS
OFFICIAL BULLETIN OF STATISTICS CENTRAL STATISTICS AGENCY No. 2/05/TH.X/15 May 200 ECONOMIC GROWTH IN I NDONESIA, I ndonesia s econom ic growth in Q1/ 200, m easured by GDP expansion over Q4/ 200, reached
More informationNew Accounting Standards and Interpretations for Public Benefit Entities. 31 March 2013
New Accounting Standards and Interpretations for Public Benefit Entities 31 March 2013 Introduction his docu ent is applicable for Public Benefit Entities PBEs appl ing New ealand E ui alents to International
More informationValuation Methods and Discount Rate Issues: A Comprehensive Example
9-205-116 REV: NOVEMBER 1, 2006 MARC BERTONECHE FAUSTO FEDERICI Valuation Methods and Discount Rate Issues: A Comprehensive Example The objective of this note is to present a comprehensive review of valuation
More informationGENERAL REGULATIONS. - intrastate messages jointly ov er facilities of this Company and Bell Telephone Company.
Telephone-Pa. P.U.C. No. 4 General Telephone Com pany Section 2 of Pennsy lv ania Second Rev ised Sheet 1 Canceling Original Sheet 1 and First Rev ised Sheet 1 A. APPLICATION OF TARIFF 1. This Tariff gov
More informationRepair and Assem bly Conditions
Repair and Assem bly Conditions These General Conditions shall apply in full on inspection, m odification, repair, refurbishm ent and m ounting work provided by SKF ( the Works ) unless otherwise expressly
More informationRE : Fair and open procurem ent rules for Services of General I nterest
SUEZ ENVI RONNEMENT 1 RUE D ASTORG 75008 PARI S, FRANCE TEL + 33 (0)1 58 18 43 05 FAX + 33 (0)1 58 18 51 68 WWW.SUEZ-ENVI RONNEMENT.COM Mrs Joanna SZYCHOW SKA COMMI SSI ON EUROPEENNE Direction Générale
More informationCherry Tree Mortgages Limited In Administration
www.pwc.co.uk 9 May 2014 Cherry Tree Mortgages Limited In Administration Joint Administrators progress report for the period 13 October 2013 to 12 April 2014 Contents Section 1 Purpose of the Joint Administrators
More informationEstimating Price Trends of Industrial Countries Exports to OPEC
Estimating Price Trends of Industrial Countries Exports to OPEC U. S. Department of Labor Bureau of Labor Statistics 1977 Bulletin 1969 Estimating Price Trends of Industrial Countries Exports to OPEC U.
More informationAbu Dhabi Marina Real Estate Investment PJSC
Abu Dhabi Marina Real Estate Investment PJSC CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND BOARD OF DIRECTORS REPORT 31 DECEMBER 2013 Abu Dhabi Marina Real Estate Investment PJSC BOARD OF DIRECTORS REPORT 31 DECEMBER
More informationDeloitte. audit matter INDEPENDENT AUDITORS REPORT. O pinion. Basis fo r O pinion. Em phasis o f Matter. Key A udit Matters
Deloitte. Deloitte & Touche" Audit organization LLC Business Center "Inkonel 75, Mustakillik Avenue Tashkent, 100000, Republic of Uzbekistan Tel: +998(71) 120 44 45 Fax: +998 (71)120 44 47 deloitte.uz
More informationRelated Person Transaction Policy. For purposes of this Policy, the following terms have the following meanings:
Related Person Transaction Policy The Company recognizes that transactions with Related Per son s can present potential or actu al conflicts of interest and therefore has adopted this policy which shall
More informationAn EDISON INTERNATIONAL Company (U 338-E) 2015 General Rate Case APPLICATION. Workpapers. Transmission & Distribution T&D Policy SCE-03 Volume 01
An EDISON INTERNATIONAL Company (U 338-E) 2015 General Rate Case APPLICATION Workpapers Transmission & Distribution T&D Policy SCE-03 Volume 01 N ovem ber 2013 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 I. INTRODUCTION
More informationEAA AIR VENTURE OSHKOSH JOSEPH S. LAWDER, ESQ. STEVEN KLUZ, JR., ESQ. Rid er, Ben n ett, Egan & Aru n d el, LLP
Aircraft Accident/ Incident Liability and Ins urance Is s ues With an Em phas is On Hom e- Built Aircraft EAA AIR VENTURE OSHKOSH 2 001 JOSEPH S. LAWDER, ESQ. STEVEN KLUZ, JR., ESQ. Rid er, Ben n ett,
More informationLess Bang For The Buck Part I
Less Bang For The Buck Part I J ames G ulick Location Engineer Division of Location and Environm ent, ID O H [E ditor s Note Gulick and V an Cleave, Engineer of Road Plans, Division of Design, ID O H both
More informationDestination - A Case of Jam m u & Kashm ir 'Fourislé'.
%'lsltors' I1l3tlrta I n('(,. F.a Llsfokxtlort A na 1'szs ) of 'i'eu rlst l'jtrstlltoxion 1 V isitors' im poriance - Satisfaction A nalysis of T ourik;t Destination - A Case of Jam m u & Kashm ir 'Fourislé'.
More informationJanuary TD Bank Mortgage Service Index 2015
January 2015 TD Bank Mortgage Service Index 2015 Overview To guide press and marketing strategies TD Bank conducted its third annual Mortgage Service Index. This survey focuses on understanding consumers
More informationMutual Funds June 2004
Mutual Funds June 2004 1 Disclaimer This docum ent is only provided for information purposes and does not constitute, nor must it be interpreted as, an offer to sell or exchange or acquire, or an invitation
More informationDiploma in International Financial Reporting
Answers Diploma in International Financial Reporting June 200 Answers (a) Consolidated statement of financial position of Alpha at 3 March 200 (all numbers in $ 000 unless otherwise stated) ASSETS Non-current
More informationINSURANCE REGULATORY AND DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY NOTIFICATION. H y d e r a b a d, t h e 1 6 t h F e b r u a r y,
[ TFT III * 3 ^ 4 ] W ^ T W T 3 : 3T?nmT0T 2 7 INSURANCE REGULATORY AND DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY NOTIFICATION H y d e r a b a d, t h e 1 6 t h F e b r u a r y, 2 0 1 3 Insurance Regulatory and Development
More informationS a f e H a r b o r N o tic e We have made forward-l ook i n g s t at emen t s i n t he p res en t at i on. O u r forward-l ook i n g s t at emen t s
Qisda Corporation 2 0 1 1 Q4 R e su l ts March 6, 2012 Outline Q4 and 2011 Financial Results 2011 Q4 B usiness S um m ar y 2 1 S a f e H a r b o r N o tic e We have made forward-l ook i n g s t at emen
More informationThird Quarter Earnings Presentation. November 2, 2018
Third Quarter Earnings Presentation November 2, 2018 Safe Harbor Statement and Other Matters This presentation contains forward-looking statements, within the meaning of the safe harbor provisions of the
More informationIFRIC 7 Applying the Restatement Approach under IAS 29 Financial Reporting in Hyperinflationary Economies
NIIF-IFRS International Financial Report... Part B Interpretations IFRS 2014-IFRIC 7 APPLYING THE RESTATEMENT APPROACH UNDER IAS 29 FINANCIAL IFRIC 7 Applying the Restatement Approach under IAS 29 Financial
More informationCONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN EQUITY
UNAUDITED INTERIM FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE PERIOD ENDED 30TH SEPTEMBER, 2016 OUTLINE PAGE CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME 1 CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION 2 CONSOLIDATED
More informationThird Quarter Earnings Conference Call September 1, 2010
Third Quarter Earnings Conference Call September 1, 2010 Agenda 1 Introduction of Call Participants 2 Third Quarter 2010 Highlights 3 Financial Review 4 Operating Results 5 Fiscal 2010 Annual Guidance
More informationJacob Holm & Sønner Holding A/S. Interim Report Q CVR-nr
Jacob Holm & Sønner Holding A/S Interim Report Q3 2017 CVR-nr. 28 15 69 60 Table of content Page Management s Review 2 Interim Report for Q3 2017 (Jul 1 - Sep 30, 2017) 3 Financial Review 4 General information
More informationA G E N D A. 2. M inutes o f th e l a s t m eetin g ( p r e v io u s ly c i r c u l a t e d ).
Dawson House, Great Sankey Warrington WA5 3LW Telephone Penketh 4321 F1/B1 8 th December 1981 To: Members o f th e R e g io n a l F i s h e r i e s A d v iso ry C om m ittee: (M essrs. T.. A. F. B arn
More informationBNP Paribas: Global Netw ork BN P Paribas is one of the largest, m ost stable financial institutions in the w orld, w ith a global netw ork com prisin
BNP Paribas Global Transaction Banking Integrated Solutions, International Scale April 3 rd, 2013 BNP Paribas: Global Netw ork BN P Paribas is one of the largest, m ost stable financial institutions in
More informationF E D E R A L R E SE R V E BANK O F N E W Y O R K. Results of Bidding for 172-Day Treasury Bills, Dated April 3, 1961 Tax Anticipation Series
F E D E R A L R E SE R V E BANK O F N E W Y O R K Fiscal A gent o f the United States r Circular N o. 5 0 1 1 I March 29, 1961 Results of Bidding for 172-Day Treasury Bills, Dated April 3, 1961 Tax Anticipation
More informationEY Fast Growth Tracker 2018
EY Fast Growth Tracker 2018 A survey of UK entrepreneurs December 2 Executive summary EY is pleased to share the second annual Fast Growth Tracker, a survey of the UK s leading entrepreneurs and startup
More informationSuzano Pulp and Paper discloses consolidated results for the 2 nd quarter of 2008
Suzano Pulp and Paper discloses consolidated results for the 2 nd quarter of 2008 Learning curve of the Mucuri Line 2 concluded in June. Production of 221 thousand tons for the quarter São Paulo, July
More informationRep u tation - Based Tru st Man agem en t
Rep u tation - Based Tru st Man agem en t by V. Sh m atikov an d C. Talcott Presen ted by Mika Silan d er November 29 th, 2006 Ou tlin e Objectives of the paper Concepts Reputation & reputation m anagem
More informationFirst Quarter Earnings Presentation. May 4, 2018
First Quarter Earnings Presentation May 4, 2018 Safe Harbor Statement and Other Matters This presentation contains forward-looking statements, within the meaning of the safe harbor provisions of the U.S.
More informationHare the Economic Contradictions of Capitalism been Solved?
Charlie Silver Hare the Economic Contradictions of Capitalism been Solved? M A R X SHOW ED that there was a basic contradiction between social production and the private (capitalist) ownership of the means
More informationFacilitation Fundamental PDE Conference 2014: Making a Diference
istock_000019362235s Facilitation Fundamental PDE Conference 2014: Making a Diference Rhonda Beach Tyree * The Compact: Educational Design Consultants e ion ur o e uilding funda ental facilitation skills
More informationReview. Vol. 68, No. 6 June/July Forward Exchange Hates in Efficient Markets: The Effects of News and Changes in M onetary Policy Regimes
Review Vol. 68, No. 6 June/July 1986 5 Forward Exchange Hates in Efficient Markets: The Effects of News and Changes in M onetary Policy Regimes 16 How Federal Farm Spending Distorts Measures of Economic
More information1. Differential Premium Score Determination
DICO Differential Premium Score Determination Published, The Ontario Gazette, Date April 12, 2014 This document is issued by the Deposit Insurance Corporation of Ontario ( Corporation ) under subsection
More informationS a f e H a r b o r N o tic e We have made forward-l ook i n g s t at emen t s i n t he p res en t at i on. O u r forward-l ook i n g s t at emen t s
Qisda Corporation 2 0 1 1 Q3 R e su l ts October 26, 2011 Outline 2011 Q 3 F i n a n c i a l R e s u l t s 2011 Q 3 B u s i n e s s S u m m a r y 2 1 S a f e H a r b o r N o tic e We have made forward-l
More informationFederal Reserve Independence
a c h a n g i n g s tr u c tu r e O n f o r c h a n g i n g tim e s Federal Reserve Independence F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B a n k o f M in n e a p o lis A n n u a l R e p o rt 1 9 7 6 Perspectives on
More informationAccelerated Return Notes Linked to the S&P 500 Index
Preliminary Pricing Supplement AR N -117 (To Prospectus dated April 27, 2016, Prospectus Supplement dated July 31, 2015 and Product Supplement EQUITY INDICES AR N -1 dated August 4, 2015) Subject to Completion
More informationMAIN LINE HEALTH, INC. RETIREMENT INCOME PLAN SUMMARY PLAN DESCRIPTION
MAIN LINE HEALTH, INC. RETIREMENT INCOME PLAN SUMMARY PLAN DESCRIPTION Effective January 1, 2011 Topic MAIN LINE HEALTH, INC. RETIREMENT INCOME PLAN SUMMARY PLAN DESCRIPTION TABLE OF CONTENTS Page INTRODUCTION...1
More informationRoad Revenue Sources for State and Local Government
Road Revenue Sources for State and Local Government A rt Graham In d iana Highways for Survival, Inc. Indianapolis, In d iana In d ia n a s gasoline tax is up 3.1 cents a gallon. T ruck fees are 25% higher.
More informationVerint Systems Inc. (VRNT) - Financial and Strategic SWOT Analysis Review. Reference Code: GDTC34016FSA Publication Date: OCT 2014.
Analysis Review Publication Date: OCT 2014 Company Overview Phone Fax Website Exchange Revenue Net Profit Employees Industry Verint Systems, Inc. (Verint) provides Actionable Intelligence solutions. It
More informationImpact of Economic Incentives on Costs and Benefits of Occupational Health and Safety
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND ERGONOMICS 2000, SPECIAL ISSUE, 71-83 Impact of Economic Incentives on Costs and Benefits of Occupational Health and Safety Zofia Pawtowska Jan Rzepecki
More informationFinancial Statements 2017
Financial Statements 2017 Gram Car AS Org.no.: 919 422 793 Prepared by: NRP Procurator NRP P rofit and loss account All figures in USD OPERATING INCOME AND EXPENSES Note 2017 Start-up expenses 2 256377
More informationFinancial Statements 2017
Financial Statements 2017 Mediterranean Sea AS Org.no.: 919 778 296 Prepared by: NRP Procurator NRP Profit and loss account All figures in USD OPERATING INCOME AND EXPENSES Note 31.12.17 Operating income
More informationNEW ZEALAND LIBRARIES
NEW ZEALAND LIBRARIES BULLETIN O F TH E N.Z. LIBRARY ASSOCIATION, INC. VOLUME 29 NUM BER 9 OCTOBER 1966 CONTENTS THE FU TURE OF LIBRARY EDUCATION IN NEW ZEALAND 161 NINETEENTH CEN TU RY FRENCH HYDROGRAPHIC
More informationFMIA Agreement of. between
FMIA Agreement of between And ("") ("") LEI: LEI: Email: Email: 1. Scope 1.1 and (the "Parties" and each a "Party") enter into transactions (the "Transactions") f or which they may become subject to risk
More informationTHE NEW ZEALAND NATIONAL BIBLIOGRAPHY
A. G. B A C N A L L THE NEW ZEALAND NATIONAL BIBLIOGRAPHY Despite the publication som e six years ago of a progress report on the National B ibliography (N e w Z ealand Libraries 22:101-5 Jul 1959) there
More informationS af e H arb or N otic e We have made forward-l ook i n g s t at emen t s i n t he p res en t at i on. O u r forwardl ook i n g s t at emen t s c on t
O Qisda Corporation 2 0 1 2 Q3 R e su l ts October 26, 2012 u tl ine 2012 Q3 Financial Results 2012 Q3 B usiness S um m ar y 2 1 S af e H arb or N otic e We have made forward-l ook i n g s t at emen t
More informationHitMe Cash App. Sed t Card, Inc s Patent Pending Blockchain-Based Financial Application and Network to Replace Credit Cards
HitMe Cash App Sed t Card, Inc s Patent Pending Blockchain-Based Financial Application and Network to Replace Credit Cards Managem ent Presentation - Con fid e n tia l We re not a cryptocurrency, but we
More informationReinsurance Management - What creates value? Piers Maunder November 2007
Reinsurance Management - What creates value? Piers Maunder November 2007 Finity Consulting Pty Limited 2007 Reinsurance Management Companies will be targeting reinsurance savings and alternatives to traditional
More informationOpen Banking. Reshaping the financial services landscape
Open Banking Reshaping the financial services landscape re read What is open banking? Following similar moves across the globe, Australia is in the process of developing policy to support an open banking
More informationABB Group Results - First Six Months 1999
1 Press Release 99/31 (12 pages) For your Business Editor Group Results - First Six Months 1999 Continued Earnings Growth Net income up 32 percent including power generation gain Revenues up 10 percent,
More informationIndependent Super Markets and Retail Store Employees Union, Local 655
Cornell University ILR School DigitalCommons@ILR Retail and Education Collective Bargaining Agreements - U.S. Department of Labor Collective Bargaining Agreements 5-1-1961 Independent Super Markets and
More informationSuzano Papel e Celulose: consolidated 1Q08 results
Suzano Papel e Celulose: consolidated 1Q08 results Ebitda of R$ 341 million with Ebitda margin 35.2% São Paulo, April 23, 2007: Suzano Papel e Celulose (Bovespa: SUZB5), one of Latin America s largest
More informationAPPENDIX 4E PRELIMINARY FINAL REPORT
FAIRFAX MEDIA LIMITED ACN 008 663 161 APPENDIX 4E PRELIMINARY FINAL REPORT Results for Announcement to the Market 2 Underlying Trading Performance 3 Compliance Statement 4 Consolidated Income Statement
More informationR epresented by P artners 1. Mr. S uresh N Patel 2. Mrs. H asm itha S Patel. No. 1/4 - V am adam Road, T ennur, Trichy, T am ilnadu
o \ o A P r e m i e r P u b l i c S e c t o r B a n k D I N D I G U L B R A N C H 1 S T F L O O R, J E E V A J O T H I B U I L D I N G S A L A I R O A D, P O S T B O X N O. 3 5 D I N D I G U L - 6 2 4
More informationQ1 What is your role in your occupation?
Q1 What is your role in your occupation? Answ ered: 327 Skipped: 0 Employer/ Surv ey Firm Employer/ Multiple... Employee/ Mulit... Employee/ Priv ate... Employee/ Gov ernment Employee/ Local Authority
More informationSale of Protomaster has been concluded. TP slightly reduced, Neutral maintained
G E S C O A G Next Cap 1621 1811 x 6515 2 Page 1/5 Equity flash Target price lowered Holding companies Germany Neutral Target 30.40 EUR vs 31.00 EUR Price (12/12/2017) : 34.23 EUR Upside : -11 % Est.chg
More informationFEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF RICHMOND SEPTEMBER Digitized for FRASER Federal Reserve Bank of St.
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF RICHMOND SEPTEMBER 1962 2 Collection and Fiscal Agency Functions of... GENTRAL BANKS This is the third in a series o f articles on central banks ivith special reference to the Federal
More informationAcquisition of Granahorrar:
Acquisition of Granahorrar: Pursuing profitable growth 1st November 2005 Disclaimer This docum ent is only provided for inform ation purposes and does not constitute, nor m ust it be interpreted as, an
More informationAGREEMENT NO. 2 OF 2003
AGREEMENT NO. 2 OF 2003 COLLECTIVE AGREEMENT ON DISPUTE RESOLUTION LEVY AND REGISTRATION OF EMPLOYERS IN THE CHEMICAL INDUSTRY 1. SCOPE OF APPLICATION OF THIS AGREEMENT The terms of this Agreement shall
More informationThe balance of all cash accounts as at 30 June 2011 is w ithout any discount and including accrued unpaid interest up to 30 June 2011.
The valuation methodology for each asset class is abbreviated below. Cash in hand Loans to and claims against credit institutions Loans to customers Bonds and debt instruments Shares and instruments w
More informationOrientation on Retirem ent Benefits for State Em ployees
Orientation on Retirem ent Benefits for State Em ployees Agenda Facts for Part-Tim e/ Tem porary Em ployees Georgia State Employees Pension and Savings (GSEPS) Plan Inform ation Peach State Reserves 40
More informationThe Monthly Business Review
The Monthly Business Review Covering business and industrial conditions in the Fourth Federal Reserve D istrict FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF CLEVELAND D. C. Wills, Chairman of the Board VOL. I CLEVELAND, OHIO,
More informationA PPLICA TIO NS A RE NOT ACCEPTED IF THEY A RE NOT CO M PLETE. THE FO LLOW ING ITEM S M U ST BE RETURNED W ITH THE APPLICA TION
1 Bryan Housing Authority is a Non -Sm oking Cam pus Instructions To Applicants Applications Accepted 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. M onday Friday All docum ent copies m ust be received when turning in application
More informationIndian Accounting Standards (Ind AS)
Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS) Applicability to Companies Phase I Phase II Voluntary adoption Year of adoption FY 2016-17 FY 2017-18 FY 2015-16 or thereafter Comparative year FY 2015-16 FY 2016-17
More informationRESI DENT SELECTI ON PLAN LYNCHBURG COVENANT FELLOW SHI P, I NC. HOUSI NG PROGRAMS
RESI DENT SELECTI ON PLAN LYNCHBURG COVENANT FELLOW SHI P, I NC. HOUSI NG PROGRAMS Revised May 1, 2015 Effective July 1, 2015 This docum ent is available for review by applicants and interested individuals
More informationFixed Income Opportunities in Emerging Markets
Fixed Income Opportunities in Emerging Markets Hemant Baijal Portfolio Manager September 7, 2017 2017 OppenheimerFunds, Inc. All rights reserved., 225 Liberty Street, New York, NY 10281-10081 Local vs.
More informationChina Connect Supplement Custody
China Connect Supplement Custody Goldman Sachs International Peterborough Court 133 Fleet Street, London EC4A 2BB Tel: 44 (0) 20 7774 1000 Authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated
More informationF3 CIMA Q & A! CIMA F3 Workbook Questions & Solutions
CIMA F3 Workbook Questions & s Lecture 1 Financial Strategy Shareholder Wealth - Illustration 1 Year Share Price Dividend Paid 2007 3.30 40c 2008 3.56 42c 2009 3.47 44c 2010 3.75 46c 2011 3.99 48c There
More informationPOPULAR METHOD Less Time and Resource Intensive as Compared to DCF. Easy to Understand and Communicate to Clients.
POPULAR METHOD Less Time and Resource Intensive as Compared to DCF. Easy to Understand and Communicate to Clients. Can be Defended Easily Reflects the Current Market Mood. PITFALLS Inconsistent estimates
More informationFunding DB pension schemes: Getting the numbers right
Aon Hewitt Consulting Retirement & Investment Funding DB pension schemes: Risk. Reinsurance. Human Resources. Funding DB pension schemes: Executive summary There is considerable debate in the UK pensions
More informationFor personal use only
AVZ Minerals Limited Quarterly Report for the Period Ending 30 June 2016 27 July 2016 Companies Announcements Office Australian Securities Exchange Level 6, 20 Bridge Street Sydney NSW 2000 The Board is
More informationThe Interpretation of National Income Estimates. B. D. Haig and S. S. McBurney
The Interpretation of National Income Estimates B. D. Haig and S. S. McBurney The Interpretation of National Income Estimates Summaries of the flows of total expenditure and income in the economy and in
More informationCapital Asia. Product Disclosure Statement. The easy way to invest in Asia. Capital Asia. Everything for the DIY investor
Capital Asia Capital Asia Product Disclosure Statement The easy way to invest in Asia Issued by Commonwealth Bank of Australia ABN 48 123 123 124, AFSL 234945 Issue date 22 May 2006 Everything for the
More informationCHAPTER 19. Valuation and Financial Modeling: A Case Study. Chapter Synopsis
CHAPTER 19 Valuation and Financial Modeling: A Case Study Chapter Synopsis 19.1 Valuation Using Comparables A valuation using comparable publicly traded firm valuation multiples may be used as a preliminary
More informationPremier Partner Awards 2018
Premier Partner Awards 2018 Search Innovation Award Case Study Taking Google Ads performance to the next level and achieving over 2,014% average ROAS for Evolution Organics via innovative Search campaigns.
More informationCOLORADO RIVER RECOVERY PROGRAM PROGRAM
COLORADO RIVER RECOVERY PROGRAM PROGRAM FY-99 ANNUAL PROJECT REPORT RECOVERY PROJECT # 19H I. Pro jec t T itle: General Hydrology Support for W ater Acquisition Activities. II. Principa l Investiga tor:
More informationRegulatory Impact Statement
Regulatory Impact Statement Requiring non-resident IRD number applicant to have a New Zealand bank account Agency Disclosure Statement This Regulatory Impact Statement has been prepared by Inland Revenue.
More informationSupplementary Information. (unaudited)
Supplementary Information (unaudited) 3 rd quarter 2013 Important notice: This document may contain forward-looking statements. By their nature, forward-looking statements involve risk and uncertainty
More informationHistorical background
Historical background 3. Company legislation in India started w ith the Joint Stock Companies A ct, 1850 (Act X L I I I o f 1850). A n historical account o f the course o f subsequent legislation w ill
More informationTHEOLOGICAL COLLEGE OF THE CANADIAN REFORMED CHURCHES FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED MAY 31,1986 INDEX
THEOLOGICAL COLLEGE OF THE CANADIAN REFORMED CHURCHES FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED MAY 31,1986 AUDITORS' REPORT BALANCE SHEET EQUITY REVENUE AND EXPENDITURE EXPENDITURE DETAIL NOTES TO THE FINANCIAL
More informationNotes to the consolidated financial statements
Notes to the consolidated financial statements Overview Strategy Performance Sustainable Business Model Corporate governance Financial statements 1. Group organisation Givaudan SA and its subsidiaries
More informationThank you for helping us raise $16,8 8 1 on Colorado Gives Day! O n Colorado G ives Day, our s upporters were able to rais e $16,881, alm os t $2,000
Issue #17.12 December 20 17 From all of us at DCAC, we want to wish you a happy holiday season and a wonderful new year. We are so thankful for all of you and your support in 2017. Without you, DCAC would
More informationCase 1:18-cr DPG Document 19 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/14/2018 Page 1 of 5 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
Case 1:18-cr-20596-DPG Document 19 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/14/2018 Page 1 of 5 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA C ase No. 18-CR-20596-D PG UNITED STATES OF AM ERICA VS. JUAN
More informationIf you would like more information, please call our Investor Services Team on or visit us online at
This guide has been created to make investment literature easier to understand and to clarify some of the more common terms. Emphasis has been placed on clarity and brevity rather than attempting to cover
More informationCyber Risk. October 2017
Cyber Risk October 2017 The Cyber Landscape Dimensions to cyber risk Who is likely to target your clients Which jurisdictions do they operate in? Threat Types What is their line of business? Geography
More informationFull file at CHAPTER 3
CHAPTER 3 Adjusting the Accounts ASSIGNMENT CLASSIFICATION TABLE Study Objectives Questions Brief Exercises Exercises A Problems B Problems *1. Explain the time period assumption. 1, 2 *2. Explain the
More informationDip IFR. Diploma in International Financial Reporting. Thursday 10 June The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants.
Diploma in International Financial Reporting Thursday 10 June 2010 Time allowed Reading and planning: Writing: 15 minutes 3 hours This paper is divided into two sections: Section A This ONE question is
More informationThe Characteristics Approach to Consumer Theory
112 PART TWO Theory of Consumer Behavior and Demand (the dimensions of the box). Individual A is on indifference curve U\ and individual B is on indifference curve U\. Since at point C (where U\ and U\
More informationAUDITORS REPORT & AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF FIRST SECURITY ISLAMI BANK LIMITED
AUDITORS REPORT & AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF FIRST SECURITY ISLAMI BANK LIMITED FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2010 Auditors Report to the shareholders' of First Securit y I slam i Bank Lim ited We
More information