--CONSULTATION REPORT-- HARVARD PILGRIM HEALTH CARE ETHICS ADVISORY GROUP. Health Insurance/Rapid Change: Developing a Framework of Values
|
|
- Anastasia Bond
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 --CONSULTATION REPORT-- HARVARD PILGRIM HEALTH CARE ETHICS ADVISORY GROUP Health Insurance/Rapid Change: Developing a Framework of Values May 19, 2004 Customer for the Ethics Advisory Group The customer for the May 19 EAG meeting was Scott Polansky, Director of Product Management in the HPHC Department of Marketing and Sales. Background The US health insurance market is again in a period of rapid change. Here is how University of California health economist James Robinson describes the current transformation in his article on Reinvention of Health Insurance in the Consumer Era : The private health insurance industry in the United States has fundamentally changed its strategic focus, product design, and pricing policy as a result of the backlash against managed care. Rather than seek to influence the behavior of physicians through capitation and utilization review, the major health plans now seek to influence the behavior of patients through benefit designs that cover a broad range of services but with high copayments, tiered network designs that cover a broad range of physicians but with variable coinsurance, and medical management programs that provide incentives for patients to better manage their own health care. Premium prices are carefully adjusted to cover the expected costs of care for each type of product and each class of patient, with a commensurate willingness to abandon enrollment where insurance premiums cannot outrun medical costs. The contemporary product and pricing policies reflect a retreat by the insurance industry from previous efforts to transform the health care system and embody a delegation to individual consumers of responsibility for setting priorities and making financial tradeoffs. (JAMA, April 21, 2004, pages ) The May 19 meeting was focused on the future. Harvard Pilgrim Health Care has developed a new product - Primary Choice as part of the reinvention process Robinson describes. Primary Choice, which will be available to Massachusetts-based employers with 100 or more eligible employees, will create three tiers of primary care physicians (PCPs) based on risk-adjusted cost and performance measures. Premium will be lowest for Tier I, consisting of PCPs seen as providing the highest value or cost-effectiveness. Tier II adds a second group of PCPs to Tier I and incurs a higher premium. Tier III includes all PCPs in the HPHC network and has the highest premium level. Primary Choice members can receive care from any hospital or specialist in the HPHC network to which their PCP makes referrals. Primary Choice essentially overlays a tiering of primary care physicians onto existing HPHC HMO and POS ( point of service ) products. One set of questions the EAG on May 19 had intended to focus on, but which will be addressed instead at the July meeting, involves Primary Choice. Preparing for what turned out to be the focus at the May 19 th meeting required understanding another piece of background the new Health Savings Accounts (HSAs), established as part of the Medicare Prescription Drug, Improvement, and Modernization Act, which became effective January 1, 2004.
2 HSAs are tax-free accounts that allow employees to put aside money for medical expenses. HSAs can only be offered in conjunction with high deductible health insurance products. HSAs can be offered to individuals with plans that have a deductible of no less than $1,000 for individual coverage and $2,000 for family coverage. Employers and employees can contribute tax deductible funds up to $2,600 for an individual and $5,150 for a family in HSAs can be used to cover the deductible and copayments, as well as a variety of other health related expenditures. The HSA (including interest and investment earnings) is tax deductible, rolls over from one year to the next, and is portable for the employee. One writer described the HSA as a medical savings account on steroids. For a health insurance product to be eligible for an HSA, however, the deductible must apply to all benefits except preventive services. This means that office visits, for example, must be paid in full up to the deductible. Likewise, HPHC s three tier pharmacy coverage could not be offered with an HSA members would have to pay the full cost of pharmaceuticals until the deductible was met. In many ways, the high deductible health plans the new federal legislation encourages are like indemnity insurance from the pre managed care era. (An informative article about HSAs in Managed Care Magazine can be accessed via A second reading providing excellent background on HSAs can be found in Tax Notes at: %20Guide%20to%20health%20savings%20accounts.pdf. Questions for the Ethics Advisory Group a) Health Savings Accounts are on the horizon, but the horizon can move very fast in the current health care environment. On May 7, 2004 the Boston Business Journal carried an article headlined All eyes on Tufts Health as it brings HSAs to Bay State. The article reported that Tufts plans to start marketing an HSA plan to brokers this month, and that a national survey done by Mercer Human Resource Consulting found that more than half of the 991 employers they surveyed were likely to offer a high deductible plan with an HSA by As a second focus for anticipatory ethical analysis, Scott is asking the EAG to consider the following questions: Given the broad scope of the deductible under the HSA concept (Scott refers to it as a blunt deductible ), what does this mean to HPHC as a plan that has been committed to using managed care principles in pursuit of its mission? How might members perceive medical management when, under the deductible of HSA plans, they are paying the full cost for many treatments and services? What other ethical opportunities and risks does the EAG see in association with the HSA concept? b) Had the discussion of HSAs left time for considering Primary Choice as well, Scott had planned to ask the EAG to do what could be described as an ethics biopsy or ethics due diligence process for the new product. After ensuring that participants at the meeting understand how Primary Choice will work, Scott would have asked for feedback on how the EAG saw the new product through the lens of ethics. In what ways does the tiering of primary care practices interact with important values? While Primary Choice has been designed, it will not go live for 7 months, so EAG feedback can contribute to planning for its implementation. The EAG expects to return to this topic at its July meeting. Relevant precedents 2
3 On July 18, 2001, the EAG discussed Ethical Issues in [Affordable Products] and Defined Contribution. At that point there had not yet been actual market demand for products that sought to make premiums more affordable by shifting financial risk to members, but the handwriting was on the wall. David Cochran, Senior Vice President for Strategic Development, asked the EAG to help HPHC anticipate and plan for the potential new developments. The key EAG perspectives included: 1. The group strongly opposed creating affordable products by stripping out major benefits. [HPHC s new products, including Best Buy HMO, do not use the stripping out approach.] 2. The group endorsed products that align financial incentives with key values, citing the generally positive reactions to the three-tier pharmacy benefit as a successful example of aligning clinical and cost considerations in the right way. 3. Given the expectation that the new products would involve increased consumer choice, the group stressed the ethical imperative for HPHC and employers to make good information available to enrollees, to enhance the potential for truly informed choice. On July 24, 2002, in the context of readying new consumer-driven products for the market, the EAG discussed HPHC s new Affordable Products Enhancing Ethical Benefits/Minimizing Ethical Risks, with Scott Polansky, Director of Product Management as customer. The EAG again emphasized the ethical importance of good information and informed stakeholders. Here is the two-paragraph summary of the July 24, 2002 discussion: This was an intellectually and emotionally complex meeting. Some members were deeply unhappy about the national market trend reflected in the [concept of consumerdriven products]. Others were deeply hopeful about the potential benefits the new developments might foster. The consensus of the discussion was that the right ethical stance for HPHC to take is to see the new developments as part of a societal experiment, not as a solution whose efficacy should be taken on faith. The central importance of education came up again and again in the EAG discussion. To make [HPHC s Affordable Products] an opportunity for true consumer-directed health care and not simply a vehicle for shifting costs to consumers, consumers need the right information at the right time. Employers are key information sources when consumers are deciding which insurance choices to make. Providers are key information sources when consumers are deciding about treatment alternatives. The EAG felt that HPHC could act as an ethical leader by working with consumers, employers and providers to enhance the potential for meaningful consumer choice, and by documenting the full range of impact the new products have on central health care values. On March 27, 2003 the EAG discussed Implementing HPHC s Affordable Products Ethical Opportunities and Risks in Consumer-Driven Health Care. Scott Polansky and Dave Segal (Senior VP for Customer Service and Operations) asked the EAG to suggest a framework of values for considering how to provide information about costs to Best Buy HMO members. The EAG recognized that providing accurate and timely information about costs is difficult but emphasized that information about costs before enrollment and at the time of making healthcare decisions as a member is crucial. The EAG suggested that one sign that Best Buy products are achieving their goal will be if providers and patients have new kinds of conversations about cost and value. The group was concerned about low income Best Buy members, especially those with less sophistication about the complexities of the health care system. For this vulnerable subgroup the deductible could act as a barrier to needed care, not just as an incentive to consider the value of marginally important care. 3
4 EAG DISCUSSION/RECOMMENDATIONS The case that was circulated prior to the meeting anticipated that the EAG would consider both HSAs and Primary Choice as two aspects of the topic of new insurance products. The discussion of HSAs, however, occupied the entire two-hour meeting. I have summarized the very active discussion in bullet form under three headings that are intended to highlight the values-related dimensions of HSAs. 1. Potential risks to important HPHC values created by HSAs: HPHC s mission is to improve the health of the people we serve Several participants at the meeting felt that the broad deductible that must be offered with HSAs could interfere with health improvement in two ways. First, financial risk is a blunt instrument. Although the intended purpose of the high deductible is to encourage individuals to seek service providers offering good quality at a lower cost and to omit services of marginal or no benefit, financial risk leads people to forgo services of significant importance to health as well. Second, the tax-free status of HSAs provide an additional inducement to treat the HSA as an investment vehicle rather than to spend it on health services. In these ways HSA products create an incentive to avoid spending that could interfere with the HPHC mission of improving health. HSAs are especially appealing to the healthy (who do not expect to make extensive use of health insurance) and wealthy (who are not deterred by the risk of the deductible). As such HSAs contribute to further fragmentation of the risk pool and to the potential for driving up the cost of insurance products that appeal to those who are less healthy and less affluent. HSAs could create confusion and administrative burdens for providers in the HPHC network who may not know whether services they render will be paid for by the patient or the patient s HPHC insurance. As insurees take on increasing financial risk, HPHC becomes more like an indemnity insurer with less opportunity to add value for members as it hopes to do. As one participant commented under HSAs HPHC is not likely to matter as much to members! 2. Potential enhancements of important HPHC values offered by HSAs: If successful, HSAs could slow the trend of premium increases. Clearly HPHC cannot improve the health of members if members cannot afford insurance! And, since income and financial security correlate with better health, reducing the cost of health insurance in itself contributes to health promotion. It is reasonable to hope that some HSA enrollees will become highly discerning purchasers of health service. Given that the public has turned against having insurers manage care, a cadre of sophisticated, value-oriented individuals intent on managing their own care could become a force for positive change. The marketplace HPHC operates in wants a range of health insurance products to choose from. While health insurance with substantial deductibles pose risks, in the current US health care system the alternative may be no insurance, not insurance with less financial risk attached. HSAs encourage people to save for health care needs. If used to pay for important health care purposes HSAs can contribute to health improvement, thereby supporting the HPHC mission. 3. Potential ways to align values to reduce risk and increase opportunity from HSAs: 4
5 HPHC has devoted substantial effort most recently in its own implementation of the Best Buy HMO product to providing information and decision support tools to employers, brokers and enrollees. HPHC could again apply its skills as a knowledge organization to assist stakeholders in understanding HSAs, making informed decisions, and using the product well. This would reduce the risk that HSAs would be chosen by those for whom it is not the right product and would increase the potential for HSA enrollees to become skilled care managers on behalf of their own health. Several participants in the discussion commented that insofar as employers contribute to the HSA the risk that the deductible will impede important health care is reduced. Others responded, however, that substantial employer contribution seems unlikely. A major appeal of HSAs is the hope that they will bend the trend of premium increases and employer costs. Expecting employers to increase their costs by offsetting the deductible is unrealistic. However, HPHC could work with employers to find ways of minimizing the risk that employees will elect deductibles that are more substantial than they can handle. HSAs and other products with substantial deductibles give enrollees incentives to seek good value. Ideally provider incentives would point in the same direction, as in capitation payment or in systems that reward high value producers the way a well functioning market system would do. HPHC could seek ways to further align provider incentives with the incentives that HSAs create for members. One participant suggested that if the HSA were a medication it would be seen as experimental, needing research on its risks and benefits before wide dissemination. The fact that it is being introduced so rapidly speaks for the intense national concern about health care cost trends. This participant suggested that HPHC could take a research-like approach to new products like HSAs by carefully tracking their impact and using these findings to reduce risks and augment positive impacts. HSAs ask enrollees to make decisions about the importance of recommended health care services and the relative value of alternative approaches or providers. One participant commented that this advisory role is one that many primary care physicians want to fill. As a knowledge organization, the decision support tools that HPHC creates could be adapted for use by primary care physicians who want to assist their patients in navigating the decisions high deductible products call for. Summary The US health care system continues to seek a silver bullet that will moderate cost trends and improve value for money. The current policy candidate is having individuals put skin in the game by creating financial incentives for seeking good value. HSAs by creating the potential for portable, tax-free savings offer the strongest inducement to date for participating in high deductible health insurance. Many of the risks and benefits are similar to those the EAG identified for other new products involving deductibles. The distinctive features come from the heightened appeal of the HSA itself and the blunt deductible that applies to all services other than a limited number of preventive categories. At the end of the meeting several participants noted that as the insurance market has evolved the EAG has had a series of meetings each focused on single new products. The group suggested that a future meeting look at a range of products in light of a grid of values derived from the series of EAG product-centered meetings. This will be the agenda of the EAG s meeting on July 21. Jim Sabin 5
--CONSULTATION REPORT-- HARVARD PILGRIM HEALTH CARE ETHICS ADVISORY GROUP
--CONSULTATION REPORT-- HARVARD PILGRIM HEALTH CARE ETHICS ADVISORY GROUP Giving Incentives to Members for Health Promoting Behavior: A Values Framework for use of Carrots and Sticks March 30, 2005 Customer:
More information--CONSULTATION REPORT-- HARVARD PILGRIM HEALTH CARE ETHICS ADVISORY GROUP November 18, 2009
--CONSULTATION REPORT-- HARVARD PILGRIM HEALTH CARE ETHICS ADVISORY GROUP November 18, 2009 Developing a Framework of Values for Massachusetts Payment Reform Customer: The customer for the November 18
More information--CONSULTATION REPORT-- Ethics Advisory Group. HIPAA and the Ethics of Health Information Privacy. September 25, 2003
--CONSULTATION REPORT-- Ethics Advisory Group HIPAA and the Ethics of Health Information Privacy September 25, 2003 Customer for the Ethics Advisory Group The customer for the September 25 meeting was
More informationFive Colleges, Incorporated
Five Colleges, Incorporated Amherst College Hampshire College Mount Holyoke College Smith College University of Massachusetts Amherst Memorandum To: All Benefited s From: Barbara Lucey Date: November,
More informationList of Insurance Terms and Definitions for Uniform Translation
Term actuarial value Affordable Care Act allowed charge Definition The percentage of total average costs for covered benefits that a plan will cover. For example, if a plan has an actuarial value of 70%,
More informationRE: Comment on CMS-9937-P ( Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act; HHS Notice of Benefit and Payment Parameters for 2017: Proposed Rule )
December 21, 2015 Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Department of Health and Human Services Hubert H. Humphrey Building, Room 445-G 200 Independence Avenue, SW Washington, D.C. 20201 RE: Comment
More informationSTATE HEALTH PLAN UPDATE
STATE HEALTH PLAN UPDATE MONA M MOON CFO/INTERIM DEPUTY EXECUTIVE ADMINISTRATOR OSC Financial Conference December 12, 2012 Presentation Overview 2 State Health Plan Governance Member Feedback Benefit Design
More informationNational Grid Retiree Club Meeting Long Island. October 2, 2017
National Grid Retiree Club Meeting Long Island October 2, 2017 18 Agenda Definitions 2018 Highlights for Management Retirees & Dependents Under Age 65 2018 Highlights for Local 1049 Retirees & Dependents
More informationYOUR 2018 PROGRAMS AND PREMIUMS AT A GLANCE HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL PUBLISHING
YOUR 2018 PROGRAMS AND PREMIUMS AT A GLANCE HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL PUBLISHING WELCOME TO YOUR HARVARD UNIVERSITY BENEFITS! At Harvard, we are committed to offering an array of benefits that are part of
More informationYOUR 2018 PROGRAMS AND PREMIUMS AT A GLANCE FACULTY, ADMINISTRATIVE AND PROFESSIONAL STAFF, AND OTHER NONUNION STAFF
YOUR 2018 PROGRAMS AND PREMIUMS AT A GLANCE FACULTY, ADMINISTRATIVE AND PROFESSIONAL STAFF, AND OTHER NONUNION STAFF WELCOME TO YOUR HARVARD UNIVERSITY BENEFITS! At Harvard, we are committed to offering
More informationFrequently Asked Questions (FY 2018)
Frequently Asked Questions (FY 2018) As of January 2017 On February 17, 2017, all Massachusetts specialists were sent details of their Clinical Performance Improvement Initiative tiering designations.
More information2015 Retiree Benefits Open Enrollment Highlights NOVEMBER 5-19, 2014
2015 Retiree Benefits Open Enrollment Highlights NOVEMBER 5-19, 2014 Table of Contents About Open Enrollment 2015... 3 Summary of Changes for 2015... 3 New Prescription Drug Provider Beginning January
More informationYOUR 2017 PROGRAMS AND PREMIUMS AT A GLANCE HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL PUBLISHING
YOUR 2017 PROGRAMS AND PREMIUMS AT A GLANCE HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL PUBLISHING WELCOME TO YOUR HARVARD UNIVERSITY BENEFITS! At Harvard, we are committed to offering an array of benefits that are part of
More informationYOUR 2019 PROGRAMS AND PREMIUMS AT A GLANCE HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL PUBLISHING
YOUR 2019 PROGRAMS AND PREMIUMS AT A GLANCE HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL PUBLISHING BENEFITS CONTACTS Have questions or need more information about your benefits? Here s where you can find more information
More informationHealth Care in California: The Chronically Ill
Health Care in California: The Chronically Ill A report for the California HealthCare Foundation prepared by Prepared for the California HealthCare Foundation by Harris Interactive Contents About this
More informationYOUR 2019 PROGRAMS AND PREMIUMS AT A GLANCE FACULTY, ADMINISTRATIVE AND PROFESSIONAL STAFF, AND OTHER NONUNION STAFF
YOUR 2019 PROGRAMS AND PREMIUMS AT A GLANCE FACULTY, ADMINISTRATIVE AND PROFESSIONAL STAFF, AND OTHER NONUNION STAFF BENEFITS CONTACTS Have questions or need more information about your benefits? Here
More informationBuilding a New Payment System: Stakeholder Perspectives on Principles and Elements
Building a New Payment System: Stakeholder Perspectives on Principles and Elements Robert L. Broadway, FHFMA VP of Corporate Strategy, Bethesda Healthcare System, Boynton Beach, FL Chairman, HFMA Presentation
More informationCLARIFYING INSURANCE CLAIMS What is an Insurance Claim?
CLARIFYING INSURANCE CLAIMS What is an Insurance Claim? Often those in the scleroderma community find themselves frequenting health care providers and being left with mounds of invoices and bills. Medical
More informationOregon 2 50 Employees Effective 7/01/10. UnitedHealthcare Multi-Choice SM Health care plans that fit your business
Oregon 2 50 Employees Effective 7/01/10 UnitedHealthcare Multi-Choice SM Health care plans that fit your business California 5 50 Employees Effective 2/1/2011 Just as your business is unique, your health
More informationValue Based Contracting
Value Based Contracting CONCEPTS FOR THE MEDICAL PRACTICE dhgllp.com/healthcare 225 Peachtree Street NE, Suite 600 Atlanta, GA 30303 Bill Hannah PRINCIPAL Bill.Hannah@dhgllp.com 404.575.8921 Doral Davis-Jacobsen
More information2018 Maine Small Group (1-50) Health Plan Portfolio.
2018 Maine Small Group (1-50) Health Plan Portfolio. What do you value in a health plan? Businesses today are faced with a lot of difficult decisions. Finding the right health care benefits plan should
More information2017 Rhode Island Small Group (1-50) Health Plan Portfolio.
2017 Rhode Island Small Group (1-50) Health Plan Portfolio. What do you value in a health plan? Businesses today are faced with a lot of difficult decisions. Finding the right health care benefits plan
More informationTable 1: Examples of Benefit Packages Offered to California Small (2-50 employees) Businesses as of Summer 2001
Insurance Markets Small Businesses and Individuals Face Greater Cost-sharing and Increasing Complexity April 2002 Introduction In recent months, there have been marked shifts in the types of benefits offered
More informationFLEXIBLE, INNOVATIVE OPTIONS THAT WORK FOR YOU
FLEXIBLE, INNOVATIVE OPTIONS THAT WORK FOR YOU JULY 2011 JUNE 2012 GROUP COVERAGE OPTIONS FOR PEOPLE EMPLOYED BY A GROUP WITH 50 EMPLOYEES OR LESS Health benefit programs are issued or administered by
More informationEmployee Presentation Cindy McGrath, Marketing and Communications Consultant
Town of Marblehead Annual Enrollment April 4-May 2, 2018 Employee Presentation Cindy McGrath, Marketing and Communications Consultant 0 1 Rising Health Care Costs Crowing Out Other Important Services Billions
More informationOPEN ENROLLMENT GUIDE
2018 BENEFITS OPEN ENROLLMENT GUIDE GUIDE October 25 November 8, 2017 For members of HUCTW who retired on or after 7/5/11 and members of ATC, Local 26, HUPA, HUSPMGU, or SEIU who retired on or after 9/4/14
More informationHealth Benefit Trends for Small Employers
Health Benefit Trends for Small Employers Jon Gabel National Opinion Research Center Presentation Objectives To document the state of employer-based health benefits for small employers, 2009 To examine
More informationRate Component Overview
Oxford Health Plans (NY), Inc. Oxford Health Insurance, Inc. New York Small Group POS Plans Narrative Summary of Requested Rate Changes Effective 4th quarter 2013 We have prepared this Narrative Summary
More information2018 Rhode Island Small Group (1 50) Health Plan Portfolio.
2018 Rhode Island Small Group (1 50) Health Plan Portfolio. What do you value in a health plan? Businesses today are faced with a lot of difficult decisions. Finding the right health care benefits plan
More informationfor Employer Groups LIVE LIFE ASSURED
for Employer Groups LIVE LIFE ASSURED 1 Live life assured Together, creating better health and better health care consumers Successfully providing excellent health benefits costeffectively requires a partner
More informationControlling Health Care Spending Growth. Michael Chernew Oct 11, 2012
Controlling Health Care Spending Growth Are new payment strategies the solution Michael Chernew Oct 11, 2012 Definitional issues matter Definition of spending Cost per service [i.e. Price] Spending per
More informationInnovation Health Plan Guide
Innovation Health Plan Guide For businesses with 51 100 eligible employees Plans effective January 1, 2014 innovation-health.com 71.02.302.1-IH (11/13) Team up with us for the health of your business.
More informationMarch 1, Chairman Lamar Alexander United States Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Washington, DC 20510
March 1, 2019 Chairman Lamar Alexander United States Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Washington, DC 20510 Dear Chairman Alexander: On behalf of AMGA and our members, I appreciate
More informationLife & Health. Health Insurance Marketplace Individual & Family Plans. Underwritten by QualChoice Life and Health Insurance Company, Inc.
Life & Health Health Insurance Marketplace 2017 Individual & Family Plans Underwritten by QualChoice Life and Health Insurance Company, Inc. 1608 MK 014 09/2016 Why QualChoice is the Quality Choice We
More informationOctober 19, Re: MassHealth Section 1115 Demonstration Amendment Request. Dear Administrator Verma:
Administrator Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Hubert H. Humphrey Building, Room 445-G 200 Independence Avenue, SW Washington, DC 20201 Re: MassHealth
More informationRESPIRONICS, INC. CONTRACTING WITH HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS OR PROVIDERS AND REFERRAL SOURCES POLICY
Page 1 of 6 RESPIRONICS, INC. CONTRACTING WITH HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS OR PROVIDERS AND REFERRAL SOURCES POLICY I. Purpose This document sets forth Respironics, Inc. s ( Company ) policy for engaging
More informationIntroduction to U.S. Health Care
Introduction to U.S. Health Care Daniel Prinz September 2, 2015 Hartman et al., National Health Spending In 2013 Micah Hartman, Anne B. Martin, David Lassman, Aaron Catlin, and the National Health Expenditure
More informationSan Francisco Health Service System Health Service Board
San Francisco Health Service System Health Service Board Medicare Advantage Marketplace Overview December 13, 2018 Prepared by: Health & Benefits Medicare Advantage Marketplace Overview Agenda Medicare
More informationLegal Implications of Concierge Medical Practice for Health Plan Providers and Enrollees
Legal Implications of Concierge Medical Practice for Health Plan Providers and Enrollees James F. Doherty, Jr. Pecore & Doherty, LLC Columbia, Maryland Samantha E. Freed Law Student University of Maryland
More informationStuart H. Altman. The Changing Health Care System: Economic Forces Pushing States To Become More Involved
The Changing Health Care System: Economic Forces Pushing States To Become More Involved Stuart H. Altman Sol Chaikin Professor of Health Policy The Heller School for Social Policy and Management Brandeis
More informationConsider Value Vs. Budget Impact In Mass. Drug Prices
Consider Value Vs. Budget Impact In Mass. Drug Prices By Noam Kirson; Analysis Group, Inc. Law360, Boston (September 29, 2017, 2:18 PM EDT) Noam Kirson Prescription drug spending in the U.S. has received
More informationfor Employer Groups 2016
for Employer Groups 2016 1 Together. Health Tradition and Mayo Clinic create exceptional group health benefit solutions A partner who understands your priorities With access to the resources of one of
More informationConsumer Driven Health Plan (CDHP) with Health Savings Account (HSA)
Consumer Driven Health Plan (CDHP) with Health Savings Account (HSA) Interact with this ebrochure. Here s how. This ebrochure is designed for onscreen viewing, allowing you to navigate through the document
More information2016 Virginia Small Group (1-50) Health Plan Portfolio
2016 Virginia Small Group (1-50) Health Plan Portfolio What do you value in a health plan? You want to offer benefits that attract employees and keep them healthy. UnitedHealthcare provides a variety of
More informationCommon Managed Care Terms & Definitions
Contact Us: Email: info@emedbiz.com Phone: 561-430-2090 Fax: 561-430-2091 Website: www.emedbiz.com Common Managed Care Terms & Definitions Balance billing: The practice of billing a patient for the amount
More information-CONSULTATION REPORT- HARVARD PILGRIM HEALTH CARE ETHICS ADVISORY GROUP MARCH 4, 2015 A FRAMEWORK OF VALUES FOR MANAGING THE VALUE FORMULARY
-CONSULTATION REPORT- HARVARD PILGRIM HEALTH CARE ETHICS ADVISORY GROUP MARCH 4, 2015 A FRAMEWORK OF VALUES FOR MANAGING THE VALUE FORMULARY Attendees Connie Barr (HPHC Board of Directors); Gerald Belastock
More informationJanuary 31, Dear Mr. Larsen:
January 31, 2012 Steve Larsen Director, Center for Consumer Information and Insurance Oversight Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services U.S. Department of Health and Human Services 7500 Security Boulevard
More informationSubcommittee on Health and Human Services Government Efficiency Task Force 401 Senate Office Building April 3, :00 a.m. 11:00 a.m.
Subcommittee on Health and Human Services Government Efficiency Task Force 401 Senate Office Building April 3, 2012 9:00 a.m. 11:00 a.m. 1) Call to Order 2) Roll Call 3) Presentation on State Employee
More informationHealth Care Industry Advisory Committee
Health Care Industry Advisory Committee Synthesis of Discussion of November 19, 2013 The Committee found it difficult to move to a discussion about possible future changes to MNsure when so much is not
More informationEmployer Health Benefits
57% $5,884 2013 Employer Health Benefits 2 0 1 3 S u m m a r y o f F i n d i n g s Employer-sponsored insurance covers about 149 million nonelderly people. 1 To provide current information about employer-sponsored
More informationUnivera Community Health Participating Provider Manual
Univera Community Health Participating Provider Manual 1.0 Introduction 1.1 About the Manual The Univera Community Health Participating Provider Manual is a reference and source document for physicians
More informationCARECOUNSEL TIPS SELECTING A HEALTH PLAN. Step 1: Gather Basic Information. Step 2: Assess Your Needs
SELECTING A HEALTH PLAN Choosing between health plans is no longer a simple matter. As a healthcare consumer, it s important that you educate yourself about the various health plans available to you. You
More informationRe: Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit Manual Draft Chapter 6
September 26, 2006 BY ELECTRONIC DELIVERY Cynthia Tudor, Ph.D. Director, Medicare Drug Benefit Group Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Mail Stop C4-13-01 7500 Security Boulevard Baltimore, MD 21244
More informationHealth Insurance Terms You Need To Know
From [C_Officialname] Health Insurance Terms You Need To Know The health care system in the United States can be confusing. In order to get the most out of your health care benefits, you need to understand
More informationHistory and Status of Health Insurance
Health Insurance DEFINITION Insurance is a contract between two or more parties whereby, in exchange for a payment (premium), the insurer protects (indemnifies) the insured against a defined peril or loss
More informationCENTER FOR HEALTH INFORMATION AND ANALYSIS PERFORMANCE OF THE MASSACHUSETTS HEALTH CARE SYSTEM PRIVATE COMMERCIAL CONTRACT ENROLLMENT COVERAGE COSTS
CENTER FOR HEALTH INFORMATION AND ANALYSIS PERFORMANCE OF THE MASSACHUSETTS HEALTH CARE SYSTEM PRIVATE COMMERCIAL CONTRACT ENROLLMENT COVERAGE COSTS COST-SHARING PAYER USE OF FUNDS TECHNICAL APPENDIX 2018
More informationValue Three-Tier EFFECTIVE DATE: 01/01/2016 FORM #1779_03
Value Three-Tier This brochure is a legal document that explains the prescription drug benefits provided by Harvard Pilgrim Health Care, Inc. (HPHC) to Members with plans that include outpatient pharmacy
More informationSubmitted via Federal e-rule making Portal: April 5, 2019
1 Submitted via Federal e-rule making Portal: http://www.regulations.gov April 5, 2019 Aaron Zajic Office of Inspector General Department of Health and Human Services Cohen Building, Rm 5527 330 Independence
More informationCOVERED CALIFORNIA: THE GOOD, THE BAD & THE UNDEFINED FOR CHILDREN WITH SPECIAL HEALTH CARE NEEDS
1 COVERED CALIFORNIA: THE GOOD, THE BAD & THE UNDEFINED FOR CHILDREN WITH SPECIAL HEALTH CARE NEEDS Ann-Louise Kuhns President & CEO California Children s Hospital Association Health Care Reform: The Basics
More informationConsumer Cost Sharing: The Ranges of Alternatives
Consumer Cost Sharing: The Ranges of Alternatives Pay for Performance Summit 02.20.12 James C. Robinson Leonard D. Schaeffer Professor of Health Economics Director, Berkeley Center for Health Technology
More informationECONOMIC PRINCIPLES IMPACTING MANAGED CARE PHARMACY. Adrian Washington PharmD., MBA Vice President of Client Management United Healthcare OptumRx
ECONOMIC PRINCIPLES IMPACTING MANAGED CARE PHARMACY Adrian Washington PharmD., MBA Vice President of Client Management United Healthcare OptumRx As vice president, Adrian is responsible for strategic planning
More informationImportance of Essential Benefits
IN THIS ISSUE Importance of Essential Benefits... 1 About the ViewsLetter... 1 Did You Know... 2 Your Questions... 3 Debt Deal Impact on Health Care Reform... 4 Trend Tidbits... 4 Technical Corner... 5
More informationRedesigning Insurance Benefits and Consumer Cost-Sharing for High-Cost Surgical Services
Issue Brief No. 1 September 2011 Redesigning Insurance Benefits and Consumer Cost-Sharing for High-Cost Surgical Services James C. Robinson, PhD Leonard D. Schaeffer Professor of Health Economics Director,
More informationDRAFT Premium Adjustment Percentage
Washington Health Benefit Exchange Comments: Proposed Federal Rule Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act; HHS Notice of Benefit and Payment Parameters for 2020 The Washington State Health Benefit
More informationRE: CMS-9926-P; Medicaid Program; Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act; HHS Notice of Benefit and Payment Parameters for 2020
February 19, 2019 Seema Verma, Administrator Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Department of Health and Human Services Room 445-G, Hubert H. Humphrey Building Attn: CMS-9926-P 200 Independence Avenue,
More informationCVS HEALTH/AETNA INVESTOR CALL SCRIPT
MIKE McGUIRE, CVS HEALTH IRO Good morning, everyone. Thanks so much for joining us this morning to hear about the definitive merger agreement we announced yesterday to acquire Aetna, one of the nation
More informationHarvard Pilgrim s. Maine s Choice HMO. Quality. Savings. Choice.
Harvard Pilgrim s Maine s Choice HMO SM Quality. Savings. Choice. Get more out of your health plan with Maine s Choice SM HMO* Harvard Pilgrim Health Care is partnering with leading doctors and health
More informationWellCare Benefit Plan
WellCare Benefit Plan Presented to: WellCare Advisory Committee 9/21/2006 Presented by: Tom Boyd, Executive Vice President Blue Cross & Blue Shield of RI Agenda Review Recommendations from WellCare Advisory
More informationWhite Paper: Formulary Development at Express Scripts
White Paper: Formulary Development at Express Scripts Express Scripts works with health-benefit plan sponsors and individual members of health plans to provide affordable access to clinically sound, high-quality
More informationCommonwealth Choice 2013 Seal of Approval
Commonwealth Choice 2013 Seal of Approval Sarah Stephany Plan Management Coordinator Jean Yang Chief Financial Officer Board of Directors Meeting September 13, 2012 Agenda Current Commonwealth Choice Product
More informationTALKING POINTS ISSUES RELATING TO STATUS, FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE AND OTHER CORPORATE ISSUES
TALKING POINTS ISSUES RELATING TO STATUS, FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE AND OTHER CORPORATE ISSUES BCBSF's Status BCBSF's Status Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Florida (BCBSF) is a tax-paying mutual insurance company,
More informationHEALTH INSURANCE 101. Finding the Right Plan
HEALTH INSURANCE 101 Finding the Right Plan HEALTH CARE 101: FINDING THE RIGHT PLAN Introduction... 2 Common Health Insurance Terms and Definitions... 3 Health Care Reform: What You Need to Know... 7 Important
More information10 Statistics to Analyze a Hospital s Performance
10 Statistics to Analyze a Hospital s Performance Chicago, Illinois / May 20, 2011 Presented by: Zachary Hafner, Vice President zhafner@kaufmanhall.com DEBT-RELATED FINANCIAL ADVISORY Since 1985, Kaufman
More informationHealth Care Coverage You Need. A Company You Know.
Health Care Coverage You Need. A Company You Know. 2018 Call 800-531-4456, visit bcbstx.com or contact an independent, authorized agent to get a quote today. When It s Time to Get Health Care Coverage,
More informationGEORGIA. CIGNA health savings plans. Health and Pharmacy Benefits c GA 07/ CIGNA
GEORGIA Individual & Family Plans CIGNA health savings plans Health and Pharmacy Benefits PLAN comparison 822163c GA 07/10 2010 CIGNA CIGNA HealthCare plans, offered through Connecticut General Life Insurance
More informationPRESCRIPTION DRUG SPENDING IN THE U.S. HEALTH CARE SYSTEM: AN ACTUARIAL PERSPECTIVE
PRESCRIPTION DRUG SPENDING IN THE U.S. HEALTH CARE SYSTEM: AN ACTUARIAL PERSPECTIVE Moderator Audrey Halvorson, Vice Chairperson, Health Practice Council Presenters Karen Bender, Member, Prescription Drug
More information10 Statistics to Analyze a Hospital s Performance
10 Statistics to Analyze a Hospital s Performance Becker s Hospital Review Annual Meeting Chicago, Illinois / May 20, 2011 Presented by: Zachary Hafner, Vice President zhafner@kaufmanhall.com DEBT-RELATED
More information--CONSULTATION REPORT-- HARVARD PILGRIM HEALTH CARE ETHICS ADVISORY GROUP March 9, 2011
--CONSULTATION REPORT-- HARVARD PILGRIM HEALTH CARE ETHICS ADVISORY GROUP March 9, 2011 A FRAMEWORK OF ETHICS FOR DISCONTINUING PRODUCTS OR EXITING MARKETS USING MEDICARE ADVANTAGE AS THE EXAMPLE Attendees:
More informationTENNESSEE. CIGNA health savings plans. Health and Pharmacy Benefits TN 09/ b TN 07/ CIGNA
TENNESSEE Individual & Family Plans CIGNA health savings plans Health and Pharmacy Benefits PLAN comparison 820920 TN 09/08 820920b TN 07/10 2010 CIGNA CIGNA HealthCare plans, offered through Connecticut
More informationCenters for Medicare & Medicaid Services: Innovation Center New Direction Request For Information: Medicare Advantage (MA) Innovation Models
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: Innovation Center New Direction Request For Information: Medicare Advantage (MA) Innovation Models 1. Do you have any comments on the guiding principles or focus
More informationImportant: There is no need for you to take any action now. This is for your information only.
Your Harvard Pilgrim Health Care Benefits and Rates are changing on April 1, 2018 January 2018 Dear SBSB Member: Important: There is no need for you to take any action now. This is for your information
More informationFrequently Asked & Answered Questions NY Health and Medicare
Frequently Asked & Answered Questions NY Health and Medicare Pending state legislation known as NY Health would ensure that ALL New Yorkers have comprehensive insurance coverage through a single payer
More information2016 Massachusetts Small Group (1-50) Health Plan Portfolio
2016 Massachusetts Small Group (1-50) Health Plan Portfolio What do you value in a health plan? Businesses today are faced with a lot of difficult decisions. Finding the right health care benefits plan
More informationStatement of Kirsten Sloan National Coordinator Health and Long-Term Care Issues AARP on the Regulation of Medicare Private Plans
Statement of Kirsten Sloan National Coordinator Health and Long-Term Care Issues AARP on the Regulation of Medicare Private Plans Before the Medicare Private Plans SubGroup Senior Issues Task Force National
More informationMolinaMarketplace.com. Quality health care you deserve
! W tes NE r ra we lo Quality health care you deserve Health care made simple Get a plan that s good for you and your budget From preventive to emergency care, with Molina, you have more choices. And a
More informationIntroduction to the US Health Care System. What the Business Development Professional Should Know
Introduction to the US Health Care System What the Business Development Professional Should Know November 2006 1 Understanding of the US Health Care System Evolution of the US health care system to its
More informationElevate by Denver Health Medical Plan
Quality Overview by Denver Health Medical Plan Accreditation Exchange Product Accrediting Organization: Accreditation Status: NCQA Health Plan Accreditation (Marketplace HMO) Accredited* Excellent: Organization
More informationPre-Open Enrollment Benefit Information Sessions. October 2015
Pre-Open Enrollment Benefit Information Sessions October 2015 Meeting Purpose Provide education to our employees about their benefits Gain feedback about a possible shift in our healthcare insurance provider
More informationUnitedHealthcare of California
California Large Group Annual Aggregate Rate Data Report Form Version 3, September 7, 2017 (File through SERFF as a PDF or excel. If you enter data on a Word version of this document, convert to PDF before
More informationCalifornia Health Benefit Exchange
Board Members Diana S. Dooley, Chair Kimberly Belshé Paul Fearer Susan Kennedy Robert Ross, MD Executive Director Peter V. Lee Small Employer Health Options Program Final Board Recommendations August 20,
More informationIdaho insurers: Next year, stay in network or pay big
Page 1 of 6 Idaho insurers: Next year, stay in network or pay big Most of the plans that go up for sale Nov. 1 on the Your Health Idaho insurance exchange will have much higher out of network costs than
More informationInnovative Plan Designs as a Response to Rising Health Care Costs
Innovative Plan Designs as a Response to Rising Health Care Costs Christopher F. Koller Health Insurance Commissioner Health Insurance Advisory Council Meeting October 23, 2012 Overview Understanding the
More informationComments of Aetna Inc. before the Joint Public Hearing of the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation And the Florida health Insurance Advisory Board
Comments of Aetna Inc. before the Joint Public Hearing of the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation And the Florida health Insurance Advisory Board May 4, 2010 Mark LaBorde President, Jacksonville/Tampa
More informationGoing for the Gold (level plan)!
Going for the Gold (level plan)! Chris Bartnik Practice Leader April 2014 Wells Fargo Insurance 2014 Wells Fargo Insurance, Inc. All rights reserved. Discussion Outline Paradigm Shift Market Trends Survey
More informationFinal Award of 2018 Seal of Approval (VOTE)
Final Award of 2018 Seal of Approval (VOTE) AUDREY GASTEIER Chief of Policy & Strategy EMILY BRICE Deputy Chief of Policy & Strategy BRIAN SCHUETZ Director of Program and Product Strategy Board of Directors
More informationHOW TO CHOOSE A MEDICAL PLAN MOTT COMMUNITY COLLEGE
HOW TO CHOOSE A MEDICAL PLAN MOTT COMMUNITY COLLEGE Chadd Hodkinson SET SEG Employee Benefit Services Account Executive The content in this presentation is informational. Each employee should review the
More informationJanuary 16, Seema Verma Administrator Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services 7500 Security Boulevard Baltimore, MD 21244
Seema Verma Administrator Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services 7500 Security Boulevard Baltimore, MD 21244 RE: CMS-4182-P: Medicare Program; Contract Year 2019 Policy and Technical Changes to the Medicare
More informationFEDERAL AND STATE HEALTH REFORM HIGHLIGHTS 2014
FEDERAL AND STATE HEALTH REFORM HIGHLIGHTS 2014 MMA Annual Meeting January 25, 2014 MARGE HOUY, SENIOR CONSULTANT ATTORNEY PAUL V. MULKERN, JR. BAILIT HEALTH PURCHASING, NEEDHAM, MA MILTON, MA 2 Topics
More informationHealth Plan Shopping Guide
Health Plan Shopping Guide Use this guide to help you choose a health insurance plan through the Massachusetts Health Connector. Step 1: Know which plans you qualify for First, you ll need to know which
More information2019 Quick Guide. Individual and Family Plans. We believe health care should be personal.
2019 Quick Guide Individual and Family Plans We believe health care should be personal. Highest member-rated health plan 1 among reporting California health plans Highest member-rated health care 1 among
More information