AHLA. W. Responding to CMS Overpayment Demands: Legal, Statistical, and Clinical Defense Strategies
|
|
- Emma Ward
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 AHLA W. Responding to CMS Overpayment Demands: Legal, Statistical, and Clinical Defense Strategies Christine N. Bachrach Vice President and Chief Compliance Officer University of Maryland Medical System Baltimore, MD Christopher Haney Duff & Phelps Chicago, IL Mary C. Malone Hancock Daniel Johnson & Nagle PC Richmond, VA Fraud and Compliance Forum October 6-7, 2014
2 Responding to CMS Overpayment Demands: Legal, Statistical, and Clinical Defense Strategies Christine Bachrach, VP & Chief Compliance Officer, University of Maryland Medical Center Baltimore, MD Christopher Haney, CPA, CFE, Director, Dispute Consulting, Duff & Phelps, LLC Washington, DC Mary Malone, Shareholder, Hancock, Daniel, Johnson & Nagle, PC Richmond, VA Enforcement Environment, Recovery Programs, and Appeal Process 1
3 CMS Recovery Audit Program Recovery Auditors or Recovery Audit Contractors (RACs) Mission The Recovery Audit Program s mission is to identify and correct Medicare improper payments through the efficient detection and collection of overpayments made on claims of health care services provided to Medicare beneficiaries, and the identification of underpayments to providers so that the CMS can implement actions that will prevent future improper payments in all 50 states Medicare Fee For Service 3 Parameters for RACs Same Medicare policies as Medicare Administrative Contractors (MACs) National and Local Coverage Determinations and CMS Manuals Review Types Automated (no medical record needed) Semi Automated (claims review using data and potential human review of a medical record or other documentation) Complex (medical record required) 4 2
4 Parameters for RACs (cont d) Limits on number of medical records requests 3 year look back period based on date claim was paid Some demonstration projects on pre pay review IP medical necessity reviews on hold during implementation of two midnight rule CMS was awarding new contracts so all RAC activity ceased June 2014, but restarting in late August while court decides contract award dispute 5 CMS Recovery Statistics Overall Recoveries FY2013 $3.7 billion recovered Q $2.2 billion year to date Appeals FY2012 (most recent) 26% of the claims appealed Success rate of appeals 47% per CMS for FY2011 claims 67% per American Hospital Association survey 6 3
5 Appeal Process Discussion Period from the time that organization receives letter until recoupment at 40 days Opportunity for provider to give RAC additional information AHA survey report 1/3 hospitals reversed some decisions in this period Redetermination by day 120 to MAC Reconsideration within 60 days of redetermination decision to Qualified Independent Contractor (QIC) Administrative Law Judge within 60 days of reconsideration decision Further to Medicare Appeals Council, US District Court 7 Legal Strategies for Combating Appeals 4
6 Legal Strategies Authority to Audit Limitation of Liability Provider without Fault Validity of Extrapolation 9 Authority to Audit Medicare reopening regulations allow for reopening in the following timeframes: (1) Within one year from the date of the initial determination or redetermination for any reason; (2) Within four years from the date of the initial determination or redetermination for good cause as defined in Section ; or (3) At any time if there exists reliable evidence as defined in Section that the initial determination was procured by fraud or similar fault as defined in Section Generally, CMS contractors use the four year time period to reopen claims based on good cause. 10 5
7 Authority to Audit Good cause for reopening when: there is new and material evidence that (1) [w]as not available or known at the time of the determination or decision; and [m]ay result in a different conclusion; or (2) [t]he evidence that was considered in making the determination or decision clearly shows on its face that an obvious error was made at the time of the determination or decision. 42 CFR CMS contractor s decision to reopen a claim not subject to appeal, but can be discussed during rebuttal or discussion period. 11 Authority to Audit RACs must comply with CMS Statement of Work. The RAC Statement of Work forbids RACs from attempting to identify overpayments more than three years past the date of the initial determination made on the claim. The first step in responding to a RAC records request should be to confirm that all of the claims under review are within the three year window allowed by the Statement of Work. If the claims are more than three years old, the provider can challenge (in writing) the RAC s authority to select the claims. 12 6
8 Limitation of Liability Section 1879 of the Social Security Act ( SSA ) states: Where (1) a determination is made that, by reason of Section 1862(a) (1) or (9)... payment may not be made under Part A or Part B of this title for any expenses incurred for items or services furnished an individual by a provider of services or by another person pursuant to an assignment under section 1842 (b) (3) (B) (ii); and (2) both such individual and such provider of services or such other person, as the case may be, did not know, and could not reasonably have expected to know, that payment would not be made for such items or services under Part A or B, then to the extent permitted by this title, payment shall, notwithstanding such determination, be made for such items or services... as though section 1862(a) (1) and section 1862 (a) (9) did not apply U.S.C. 1395pp. 13 Limitation of Liability What does this mean? The limitation of liability provision allows a provider subject to post payment review to argue that even though the contractor may have identified an overpayment, the provider should retain its payment because the provider did not know, and could not reasonably be expected to know, that the payment would later be denied. The limitation on liability defense is best used in cases where there is little or no specific guidance on the Medicare coverage or documentation requirements for a specific service. 14 7
9 Limitation of Liability Case Study Baptist Health Care, 2009 WL (H.H.S. June 26, 2009) Medicare Appeals Council case Hospital challenged a RAC s determination that the hospital was inappropriately paid for inpatient stays related to automatic implantable cardioverter defibrillator ( AICD ) procedures in 2003, 2005, and During these years, the AICD procedures were included on Medicare s inpatient only list. 15 Limitation of Liability Case Study (cont.) The Florida QIO, Florida Medical Quality Assurance, Inc., ( FMQAI ) issued a policy in 2006 that stated it would no longer uniformly allow AICD procedures to be billed as inpatient services, but that it would consider denying routine cases with an anticipated discharge within 24 hours. For services provided before FQMAI issued its policy, however, the Council agreed with the hospital s limitation on liability defense. The Council overturned the RAC s overpayment determination, ruling that until FMQAI issued its policy, the hospital did not know, and did not have reason to know, that Medicare would not cover automatic implantable cardioverter defibrillators services provided in an inpatient hospital setting. 16 8
10 Limitation of Liability For purposes of determining the provider s knowledge actual or constructive an ALJ or the Council look for the following evidence: A Medicare contractor s prior denial of payment for similar or reasonably comparable services; Medicare s general notices to the medical community of Medicare payment denial of services under all or certain circumstances, including manual instructions, bulletins, contractor s written guides and directives; Provision of services inconsistent with acceptable standards of practice in the local medical community; The provider s utilization review committee informed the provider in writing that the services were not covered; or A Medicare contractor previously issued a written notice to the provider that Medicare payment for a particular service or item is denied. This also includes notification of Quality Improvement Organization ( QIO ) screening criteria specific to the condition of the beneficiary for whom the furnished services are at issue and of medical procedures subject to preadmission review by the QIO. 17 Provider without Fault Section 1870(b) of the SSA states that a provider is deemed to be without fault (absent evidence to the contrary) with respect to an overpayment if the overpayment determination is made subsequent to the fifth year following the year of the initial determination. If a provider was paid for services in 2008 (or earlier) and has retained the payment until 2014, the provider is now deemed to be without fault with respect to any overpayments, unless there is evidence to the contrary. 18 9
11 Provider without Fault Medicare manual guidance states that a provider is considered to be without fault if it exercised reasonable care in billing for, and accepting, the payment, i.e.: It made full disclosure of all material facts; and On the basis of the information available to it, including, but not limited to, the Medicare instructions and regulations, it had a reasonable basis for assuming that the payment was correct, or, if it had reason to question the payment; it promptly brought the question to the Fiscal Intermediary or carrier s attention. 19 Provider without Fault Case Study Comprehensive Decubitis Therapy, Inc., 2009 WL (H.H.S. Mar. 13, 2009) Medicare Appeals Council case Facts: A supplier argued that it was without fault with respect to payments it received for supplies that should have been bundled into the beneficiary s home health benefit
12 Provider without Fault Case Study (cont.) Comprehensive Decubitis Therapy, Inc., 2009 WL (H.H.S. Mar. 13, 2009) In finding that the supplier was without fault, the Council determined that the following facts demonstrated that the supplier exercised reasonable care in billing for the services: the physician s order for the supplies indicated that the beneficiary was not receiving home health; a progress note stated that the beneficiary had discontinued home health; and, the supplier obtained pre authorization from a Medicare contractor that did not indicate that the beneficiary was receiving home health. Importantly, in this case, the presumptive without fault time period had not elapsed, but the provider was able to show it was without fault through strong documentation. 21 Challenging Use of Extrapolation Section 1893(f)(3) of the SSA states that a Medicare contractor may not use extrapolation to determine overpayment amounts to be recovered... unless the Secretary determines there is a sustained or high level of payment error or documented educational intervention has failed to correct the payment error. In order for a provider to successfully challenge an extrapolated overpayment, it must challenge the statistical analysis supporting the extrapolation, and disprove the auditor s determination on underlying sample claims
13 Challenging Use of Extrapolation Use the facts and circumstances of the audit to argue that extrapolation is unfairly punitive. For example, for documentation issues where a physician can demonstrate when a fix was made, an auditor may agree to drop the extrapolation and recover only the actual overpayment amount. 23 Statistical Defense Strategies 12
14 Statistical Defenses: Background Complex audits typically involve sampling and extrapolation, and they necessitate a high degree of statistical competency to ensure claims are properly estimated. Medicare Program Integrity Manual ( MPIM ) includes guidelines on data analysis, statistical sampling, extrapolation, and estimation of overpayments. Successful appeals often highlight a contractor s nonconformance with MPIM, including the following: Generally Accepted Standards Sample Size Precision and Confidence Representativeness and Randomness 25 Sampling Terminology Extrapolation: Projecting the results of your sample onto the entire population. Observed ratios: o Failure rate of an audit o Proportion of red M&Ms Observed descriptive statistics: o Mean overpayment per claim o Mean household income Results of extrapolation within a specified level of significance. Different sample sizes yield results with different levels of significance Confidence level (i.e. 95%, 99%, etc.) Margin of error or precision level (i.e. ±3 percentage points) e.g. Candidate X is expected to receive 47% of votes, ±2 percentage points, at a 90% confidence level 26 13
15 Statistically Valid Random Sample MPIM Guidance: If a particular probability sample design is properly executed, i.e., defining the universe, the frame, and the sampling units; using proper randomization; accurately measuring the variables of interest; and using the correct formulas for estimation, then assertions that the sample and its resulting estimates are not statistically valid cannot legitimately be made. 27 Burden of Proof Relevant CMS Requirement: The burden of proof is on the appellant to prove a contractor s statistical sampling methodology invalid, not on the contractor to establish that it chose the most precise methodology. Significance Federal courts are reluctant to overturn a contractor s methodology without explicit evidence of errors. Relevant Case: Border Ambulance Service, LLC v. TrailBlazer Health Enterprises [a]ppellant s challenges to the sample are not based on demonstrable errors in the sample or reference to specific supporting evidence in the record The appellant s speculative assertions do not satisfy its burden of proving that the statistical sampling methodology at issue is invalid. Disputing a RAC s methodology is not enough for successful appeal. Appellants must prove that a contractor s statistical analysis is invalid
16 Generally Accepted Standards Relevant MPIM Requirement: Any sampling methodology must be reviewed by a statistician or a person with equivalent expertise in probability sampling and estimation methods. Significance A great deal of subjectivity exists when implementing statistical procedures. Several appeal decisions have concluded that no generally accepted standards exist for the application of sampling. Relevant Case: Michael King, M.D. and Kinston Medical Specialists v. Cigna [w]hile there may well be theories on the right way to conduct a sample, there is no formal recognition of generally accepted statistical principles and procedures. No recognized statistical principles exist. When appealing statistical methodology, show how the method impacts conclusions. 29 Sample Size Relevant Requirements: There is no CMS standard for minimum sample size. However, OIG s Provider Self Disclosure Protocol ( SDP ) requires a sample size of at least 100 claims. This does not apply to CMS contractors for recovery audits, but may serve as an indication of reasonable sample sizes. Significance Federal courts are reluctant to overturn a contractor s methodology based on insufficient sample size since no standard exists. Relevant Cases: Ratanasen v. State of California, Webb v. Shalala, and Pruchniewski v. Leavitt Courts have ruled that no minimum sample size exists. No generally accepted minimum sample size exists. Appeals should demonstrate how a larger sample size would impact conclusions
17 Precision and Confidence Relevant Requirements: No CMS standard exists for minimum precision levels of extrapolation. However, per MPIM, In most situations the lower limit of a one sided 90 percent confidence interval shall be used as the amount of overpayment to be demanded for recovery. Significance Federal courts are reluctant to overturn a contractor s methodology based on insufficient levels of precision since no standard exists. Relevant Case: Pruchniewski v. Leavitt Because there is no established standard of precision providers must go further and establish that the degree of imprecision is such that the extrapolation does not reasonably approach the actual overpayment No generally accepted minimum precision or confidence level exists. Appeals should demonstrate how a more precise analysis would impact conclusions. 31 Random and Representative Relevant Requirements: Valid samples must be selected using proper randomization to minimize selection bias, and should be representative of the total universe. Significance Analysis may improperly sample only certain subsets of a population and attempt to extrapolate conclusions across the entire universe. i.e. disproportionate samples of high dollar claims or a focus on one particular facility or provider. Software such as RAT STATS are considered a reliable means of selecting a sample, however these programs are only as effective as their operator. Relevant Case: John Sander, M.D. v. CIGNA either samples themselves were not drawn correctly or the claims were not correctly assigned to the correct stratum Sample design and selection are imperative to reliable results. RAT STATS can be effective, but users need to understand the broader strategy
18 RAT STATS Statistical Software RAT STATS is statistical software developed by the government Free and available online along with 394 page user guide and 245 page companion manual. Practically, RAT STATS is a calculator with three main functions: Calculating sample size Generating random numbers to aid sample selection Extrapolating (projecting) results of the sample to a broader population RAT STATS is used in conjunction with a broader strategy * * * Sampling Plan * These steps involve using RAT-STATS 33 Parting Tips for Statistical Appeals Evaluate a contractor s sampling plan for soundness and completeness. Ensure sufficient documentation exists. Assess sample size and levels of confidence and precision. Evaluate sample design and weigh the benefit of other designs. Consider underlying causes of bias within the sample design. Evaluate the methods of randomization and sample selection. If you identify areas of weakness in the contractor s analysis: Identify issues that may render the analysis invalid (sample too small, etc.) Conduct your own audit with improved inputs (larger sample size, etc.) Demonstrate contractor s demand does not equal actual overpayments Meet your burden of proof by demonstrating their analysis is invalid 34 17
19 Elements of a Sampling Plan Population of Interest (POI) This can help you prepare your request for data Sampling Unit Population of interest is composed of all possible sampling units Sampling Frame Population from which sample is drawn (explain if not POI) Sample Size Minimum or any other procedural requirements/thresholds Required Precision and Confidence possibly 95% confidence ±2% precision Sample Design Simple, Stratified, Clustered, etc. Specify strata or cluster criteria Source of Random Numbers often RAT STATS Method of Selecting Sampling Units Ensure randomization without bias Procedures for Missing Data Typically failures, however may use spares Estimation Methodology Also referred to as extrapolation methodology 35 QUESTIONS Christine Bachrach, VP & Chief Compliance Officer, University of Maryland Medical Center Baltimore, MD cbachrach@umm.edu Christopher Haney, CPA, CFE, Director, Dispute Consulting, Duff & Phelps, LLC Washington, DC Christopher.Haney@duffandphelps.com Mary Malone, Shareholder, Hancock, Daniel, Johnson & Nagle, PC Richmond, VA mmalone@hdjn.com 18
How To Appeal and Win a Medicare Audit
How To Appeal and Win a Medicare Audit Presented by: Howard E. Bogard Burr & Forman LLP Attorney at Law 420 North Twentieth Street Suite 3400 Birmingham, Alabama 35203 hbogard@burr.com www.burr.com 205-458-5416
More informationAgenda. Fraud, Waste, and Abuse. Extrapolation: Understanding the Statistics What to do When it Happens to your Audit Results 3/17/2015
Extrapolation: Understanding the Statistics What to do When it Happens to your Audit Results Frank Castronova, PhD, Pstat Health Management Bio-Statistician Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Andrea Merritt,
More informationSampling & Statistical Methods for Compliance Professionals. Frank Castronova, PhD, Pstat Wayne State University
Sampling & Statistical Methods for Compliance Professionals Frank Castronova, PhD, Pstat Wayne State University Andrea Merritt, ABD, CHC, CIA Partner Athena Compliance Partners Agenda Review the various
More informationDefending Against Statistical Sampling and Extrapolation. April Anna M. Grizzle Bass, Berry & Sims PLC
Defending Against Statistical Sampling and Extrapolation April 2012 Anna M. Grizzle Bass, Berry & Sims PLC agrizzle@bassberry.com 8855692 Overview When is statistical sampling and extrapolation used? What
More informationREGULATORY UPDATE 60 Day Repayment, Compliance, Appeals and CMS/OMHA Appeal- Reduction Strategies
REGULATORY UPDATE 60 Day Repayment, Compliance, Appeals and CMS/OMHA Appeal- Reduction Strategies Jessica L. Gustafson, Esq. and Abby Pendleton, Esq. The Health Law Partners, P.C. www.thehlp.com jgustafson@thehlp.com
More informationRecovery Audit Contractors The Beginning to Now and Overview RACs Challenged by Providers? A Recent OIG Report May Be Indicating Just That 1 CEU
Recovery Audit Contractors The Beginning to Now and Overview RACs Challenged by Providers? A Recent OIG Report May Be Indicating Just That 1 CEU Article submitted by Carl James Byron, III ATC-L, CHA CPC,
More informationThe Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)
DATA ANALYSIS CORNELIA M. DORFSCHMID Why RAT-STATS and Sampling Are Hot The Best Strategy for Health Care Entities Is One of Proactive Preparedness Cornelia M. Dorfschmid, PhD, is executive vice president
More informationRAC Audits, Extrapolation and Defensive Strategies
RAC Audits, Extrapolation and Defensive Strategies RAC University, powered by edutrax February 18, 2010 Cornelia M. Dorfschmid, PH.D. Executive Vice President Strategic Management 5911 Kingstowne Village
More informationMedicare Claims Appeals Developments and Proposals for Expansion
Medicare Claims Appeals Developments and Proposals for Expansion Donna Thiel Tracy Weir Shareholder Shareholder Washington, D.C. Washington, D.C. 202.508.3404 202.508.3481 dthiel@bakerdonelson.com tweir@bakerdonelson.com
More informationMedicare Claims Appeals: From Audit to OMHA
+ Medicare Claims Appeals: From Audit to OMHA Donna K. Thiel Partner King & Spalding, LLC Washington, DC American Health Lawyers Association March 2013 + The Appeals Process Original Medicare Appeals Process
More informationMedicare Audit and Appeals: Practical Advice on Preparing for and Responding to RAC, ZPIC, and MAC Audits. February Overview
Medicare Audit and Appeals: Practical Advice on Preparing for and Responding to RAC, ZPIC, and MAC Audits February 2012 B. Scott McBride Baker & Hostetler LLP smcbride@bakerlaw.com Anna M. Grizzle Bass,
More informationAll the President s Men : Medicare Denials and Appeals
All the President s Men : Medicare Denials and Appeals Joe Crea, DO, MHA, FACOEP Senior Medical Director Audit, Compliance and Education (ACE) NJ HFMA June 10, 2014 AHA Solutions, Inc., a subsidiary of
More informationSETTLEMENT CONFERENCE FACILITATION
SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE FACILITATION Cherise Neville Senior Attorney Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals Program Evaluation and Policy Division What is Settlement Conference Facilitation? Settlement
More informationFREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS Last Updated: January 25, 2008 What is CMS plan and timeline for rolling out the new RAC program? The law requires that CMS implement Medicare recovery auditing in all states
More informationRACs and Beyond. Kristen Smith, MHA, PT. Peter Thomas, JD Ron Connelly, JD Christina Hughes, JD, MPH. Senior Consultant, Fleming-AOD.
RACs and Beyond Kristen Smith, MHA, PT Senior Consultant, Fleming-AOD Peter Thomas, JD Ron Connelly, JD Christina Hughes, JD, MPH The Powers Firm RACs and Beyond Objectives Describe the various types of
More informationRecovery Audit Contractors (RACs) Reference Document Created by Elin Baklid-Kunz
RAC Demonstration Program The RAC Demonstration: Evaluation Report July 2008 RAC Permanent Program Legislation What is the Purpose? How RACs Are Paid? Review Selection Physicians Medical Record Request
More informationHow to Prepare for and Respond to RAC Audits. Kathleen H. Drummy, Esq.
How to Prepare for and Respond to RAC Audits by Kathleen H. Drummy, Esq. What is a RAC? 2 IMPROPER PAYMENT INFORMATION ACT Requires federal agencies to measure improper payment rates Focus is on where
More informationDMEPOS Audit Trends. Understanding the DME Audit Landscape. They re All Watching Licensing You YOU
DMEPOS Audit Trends Wayne H. van Halem Ross Burris President, The van Halem Group Shareholder, Polsinelli PC State They re All Watching Licensing You Agencies Plaintiff Lawyers RACs/ ZPICs DOJ FDA Commercial
More informationMedicare Audit and Appeals: Practical Advice on Preparing for and Responding to RAC, ZPIC, and MAC Audits. February 2012
Medicare Audit and Appeals: Practical Advice on Preparing for and Responding to RAC, ZPIC, and MAC Audits February 2012 Presented by: B. Scott McBride, Esq. Baker & Hostetler LLP smcbride@bakerlaw.com
More informationAHLA. M. Surviving an Overpayment Demand Resulting from an Extrapolation of a High Error Rate in an Extremely Small Probe Sample
AHLA M. Surviving an Overpayment Demand Resulting from an Extrapolation of a High Error Rate in an Extremely Small Probe Sample Catherine Gill LW Consulting, Inc. Harrisburg, PA Donna J. Senft Baker Donelson
More informationAnatomy of an Appeal. Fourth Medicare RAC Summit September 13-14, 14, 2010
Anatomy of an Appeal Fourth Medicare RAC Summit September 13-14, 14, 2010 Andrew B. Wachler,, Esq. Wachler & Associates, P.C. 210 E. Third St., Ste. 204 Royal Oak, MI 48067 (248) 544-0888 awachler@wachler.com
More information5/7/2013. CMS Part B Inpatient Rebilling Rules
CMS Part B Inpatient Rebilling Rules Appeal Academy s Special Report on CMS-1455-R, posted 03/13/2013 1 Background Hospitals currently allowed to "rebill" denied Part A claim for IP admission But only
More informationZone Program Integrity Contractors (ZPICs), 2013 TEXAS HEALTH CARE ASSOCIATION SUMMER MEETING
Zone Program Integrity Contractors (ZPICs), 2013 TEXAS HEALTH CARE ASSOCIATION SUMMER MEETING Carla J. Cox Jackson Walker L.L.P. cjcox@jw.com 512-236-2040 1 Zone Program Integrity Contractors (ZPICs) ZPICs
More informationPAYMENTS MADE BY NOVITAS SOLUTIONS, INC., TO HOSPITALS FOR CERTAIN ADVANCED RADIATION THERAPY SERVICES DID NOT FULLY COMPLY WITH MEDICARE REQUIREMENTS
Department of Health and Human Services OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL PAYMENTS MADE BY NOVITAS SOLUTIONS, INC., TO HOSPITALS FOR CERTAIN ADVANCED RADIATION THERAPY SERVICES DID NOT FULLY COMPLY WITH MEDICARE
More informationNavigating ZPIC Audits: Challenges and Solutions for Health Care Providers
Navigating ZPIC Audits: Challenges and Solutions for Health Care Providers American Health Care Association (AHCA) Scot T. Hasselman and Rahul Narula April 24, 2012 Navigating ZPIC Audits Today s Topics
More informationReedSmith. Part B Inpatient Billing in Hospitals. Client Alert. Life Sciences Health Industry Group
The business of relationships. SM Client Alert Life Sciences Health Industry Group Part B Inpatient Billing in Hospitals Written by Daniel A. Cody, Rachel M. Golick and Susan A. Edwards April 2013 Table
More informationFundamentals and Practicalities of Identifying and Returning Overpayments
Fundamentals and Practicalities of Identifying and Returning Overpayments American Health Lawyers Association Physicians and Physician Organizations Law Institute Hospitals and Health Systems Law Institute
More informationAuditing RACphobia. Lamon Willis, CPCO, CPC-I, CPC-H, CPC AHIMA-Approved ICD-10-CM/PCS Trainer Xerox Healthcare Consultant
Auditing RACphobia Lamon Willis, CPCO, CPC-I, CPC-H, CPC AHIMA-Approved ICD-10-CM/PCS Trainer Xerox Healthcare Consultant 1 Agenda Overview of present industry landscape in relation to auditing Audit Entities
More informationABN Requirements, Updates and Challenges from the ALJ Ruling
ABN Requirements, Updates and Challenges from the ALJ Ruling April 30, 2014 Catherine (Kate) H. Clark, CPC, CRCE-I Charlotte Kohler, CPA, CVA, CRCE-I, CPC, CHBC And Robert E. Mazer, Esquire Financial Liability
More informationPalmetto GBA Demands to RHCs re Improper Payment of Medicare Advantage Plan Claims
Stephen D. Bittinger Member Admitted in OH Bill Finerfrock, Executive Director National Association of Rural Health Clinics 1009 Duke Street Alexandria, VA 22312 Via email only: bf@capitolassociates.com
More informationMedicaid Performance Audit. My Brief Resume 2/5/2014. Molina Healthcare of Washington: Blue Cross and Blue Shield: An Emerging Challenge for MCOs
Medicaid Performance Audit An Emerging Challenge for MCOs Harry Carstens Director, Compliance Molina Healthcare of Washington My Brief Resume Molina Healthcare of Washington: Compliance Director 2 years
More informationDRAFT Statement of Work for the Recovery Audit Contractor Program
DRAFT Statement of Work for the Recovery Audit Contractor Program I. Purpose The RAC Program s mission is to reduce Medicare improper payments through the efficient detection and collection of overpayments,
More informationAHLA. RR. Part B Claims Substantive and Sampling. Lester J. Perling Broad and Cassel Fort Lauderdale, FL
AHLA RR. Part B Claims Substantive and Sampling Lester J. Perling Broad and Cassel Fort Lauderdale, FL Andrew Wachler Wachler & Associates PC Royal Oak, MI Institute on Medicare and Medicaid Payment Issues
More informationRefunds and Reporting Overpayments. David M. Glaser Fredrikson & Byron, P.A. (612)
Refunds and Reporting Overpayments David M. Glaser Fredrikson & Byron, P.A. dglaser@fredlaw.com (612) 492-7143 1 Core Principles Treat the government fairly and require them to treat you fairly. It is
More informationPrepared for state, metropolitan and regional hospital associations. Recovery Audit Contractor Program Update. May 28, 2009
RAC REPORT Prepared for state, metropolitan and regional hospital associations. (This report is one page.) Recovery Audit Contractor Program Update May 28, 2009 In a meeting this week with AHA, the Centers
More informationStark Self-Disclosure. Thomas S. Crane 1/ Mintz Levin Cohn Ferris Glovsky and Popeo, PC
Stark Self-Disclosure Thomas S. Crane 1/ Mintz Levin Cohn Ferris Glovsky and Popeo, PC A. Background 1. Stark Law The Physician Self-Referral Statute (or the Stark Law ) prohibits a physician from referring
More informationLessons Learned from the ALJ Experience
Lessons Learned from the ALJ Experience Ralph Wuebker, MD, MBA Chief Executive Officer AHA Solutions, Inc., a subsidiary of the American Hospital Association, is compensated for the use of the AHA marks
More informationMedicare Program Integrity Manual
Medicare Program Integrity Manual Chapter 8 Administrative Actions and Statistical Sampling for Overpayment Estimates Table of Contents (Rev. 377, 05-27-11) Transmittals for Chapter 8 8.1 Appeal of Denials
More informationAgenda. RAC Mission MAC s Medical Review MAC s Role in the RAC process Demand Letters and Collection Process Appeals Process Resources
Deanna Cruser, CGS Agenda RAC Mission MAC s Medical Review MAC s Role in the RAC process Demand Letters and Collection Process Appeals Process Resources 2 Objective To provide an understanding of the roles
More informationMedicare. Claim Review Programs: MR, NCCI Edits, MUEs, CERT, and RAC. Official CMS Information for Medicare Fee-For-Service Providers
Medicare Claim Review Programs: MR, NCCI Edits, MUEs, CERT, and RAC R Official CMS Information for Medicare Fee-For-Service Providers Background Since 1996, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
More informationMedicaid Overpayments: Challenging State Audit Allegations of Overpayment and the Use of Statistical Sampling and Extrapolation
Presenting a live 90-minute webinar with interactive Q&A Medicaid Overpayments: Challenging State Audit Allegations of Overpayment and the Use of Statistical Sampling and Extrapolation TUESDAY, OCTOBER
More informationFinal IPPS 2015 AKA CMS 1607-F (Published in Federal Register on August 22, 2014)
2015 Inpatient Prospective Payment Services (IPPS) and Insights on Best Practices Marc Tucker,DO,FACOS,MBA Senior Medical Director Executive Health Resources Agenda 2014/2015 IPPS Final Rule 2015 proposed
More informationThe Updated OIG Self-Disclosure Protocol and Statistical Sampling for Non-Statisticians
The Updated OIG Self-Disclosure Protocol and Statistical Sampling for Non-Statisticians October 13, 2015 Health Care Compliance Association Clinical Practice Compliance Conference Agenda Enforcement Climate
More informationRAC Preparation Checklist
RAC Preparation Checklist A. Select an internal RAC Team using individuals from key departments and identify individual roles (if any) in the RAC process. Communicate each individual s roles to others
More informationMedicare Program Integrity Primer: What the Government Can Do And How to Respond. AHLA Fraud & Compliance Forum October 2014
Medicare Program Integrity Primer: What the Government Can Do And How to Respond AHLA Fraud & Compliance Forum October 2014 By Troy A. Barsky, Esq. Meredith N. Larson, Esq. Crowell & Moring I. Introduction
More informationFrom Legislative Authorization To National Implementation: The Key RAC Milestones, Results and Lessons to Date
From Legislative Authorization To National Implementation: The Key RAC Milestones, Results and Lessons to Date John Valenta, Director Health Sciences Regulatory Practice Deloitte & Touche LLP September
More information9/17/2018. Non-covered services. Description: Billing for services not covered under the Medicare program
Top billing and coding errors: Duplicate claims submitted The claim was previously processed (no payment made, allowed amount applied to deductible on the initial claim). The provider re-files the claim
More informationMMA Mandate: Medicare Contract Reform
MMA Mandate: Medicare Contract Reform Julie E. Chicoine, JD, RN, CPC The Ohio State University Medical Center julie.chicoine@osumc.edu Medicare Program Created in 1965 Part A: Facilities, including hospitals
More informationCompliance Issues: Self-Disclosure, RAC Audits and Red Flags
Compliance Issues: Self-Disclosure, RAC Audits and Red Flags Kimberly A. Licata Presented to GE Centricity Group Management Southeast User Group Winter Conference February 11-12, 2010 These materials have
More informationCurrent Payor Audit Mechanics and How to Defend Against Them. Role of Office of Inspector General in Federal Audits
Current Payor Audit Mechanics and How to Defend Against Them Stephen Bittinger Healthcare Reimbursement Attorney NEXSEN PRUET, LLC Role of Office of Inspector General in Federal Audits Most Recent OIG
More informationRAC Jurisdictions D B. March 1, March 1, August 1, 2009
Medicare Recovery Audit Contractors (RACs): An Overview 1 1 What is a RAC? RAC Program Mission The RACs will detect and correct past improper payments so that CMS and the Carriers/FIs/MACs can implement
More informationProposed Prior Authorization for Certain DMEPOS Items
July 28, 2014 Ms. Marilyn B. Tavenner Administrator Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Department of Health and Human Services Attention: CMS-1600-P Room 445-G, Hubert H. Humphrey Building 200 Independence
More information4 years after services are furnished.
RECORD TYPE RETENTION PERIOD AUTHORITY MEDICARE 1 42 U.S.C. 1395x (v)(1)(i) Contracts with Subcontractors Any contract between a provider and a subcontractor and between an organization related to the
More informationHandling Potential Overpayment and "Voluntary" Refund Situations
Handling Potential Overpayment and "Voluntary" Refund Situations Timothy P. Blanchard, MHA, JD American Academy of Professional Coders 2011 National Conference April 4, 2011 2011 Blanchard Manning LLP.
More informationFrequently Asked Questions
1. What is the look-back period for the RAC? The look-back period is 3 years, based on the date of service. 2. What provider types should be prepared for a RAC review? The scope of the Medicaid RAC includes
More informationCenter for Medicaid and State Operations/Survey and Certification Group
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services 7500 Security Boulevard, Mail Stop S2-12-25 Baltimore, Maryland 21244-1850 Center for Medicaid and State Operations/Survey
More informationCOMPLIANCE; It s Not an Option
COMPLIANCE; It s Not an Option AAPC April 17, 2013 Rose B. Moore, CPC, CPC-I, CPC-H, CPMA, CEMC, CMCO, CCP, CEC, PCS, CMC, CMOM, CMIS, CERT, CMA-ophth President/CEO Medical Consultant Concepts, LLC Copyright
More informationMedicare Program; Extension of Prior Authorization for Repetitive Scheduled
This document is scheduled to be published in the Federal Register on 12/04/2018 and available online at https://federalregister.gov/d/2018-26334, and on govinfo.gov BILLING CODE 4120-01-P DEPARTMENT OF
More informationTHE MEDICARE RECOVERY AUDIT CONTRACTOR (RAC) PROGRAM: An Evaluation of the 3-Year Demonstration
THE MEDICARE RECOVERY AUDIT CONTRACTOR (RAC) PROGRAM: An Evaluation of the 3-Year Demonstration June 2008 THE MEDICARE RECOVERY AUDIT CONTRACTOR (RAC) PROGRAM: An Evaluation of the 3-Year Demonstration
More informationAnticipating Medicare's Alphabet Soup of Audit Contractors, Ranging from ZPICs and RACs to CERTs and MACs
Anticipating Medicare's Alphabet Soup of Audit Contractors, Ranging from ZPICs and RACs to CERTs and MACs 18th Annual Executive War College April 30-May 1, 2013 New Orleans, LA Presented by: Christopher
More informationCopyright 2009, National Academy of Ambulance Coding Unauthorized copying/distribution is strictly prohibited
Your instructor Denials & Appeals National Academy of Ambulance Coding Steve Wirth Founding Partner, Page, Wolfberg & Wirth LLC Over 30 years experience as an EMT, Paramedic, Flight Medic, EMS Instructor,
More informationImplementation of Provider Enrollment Provisions in CMS-6028-FC
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services News Flash The revised brochure titled The Medicare Appeals Process: Five Levels to Protect Providers, Physicians, and Other
More informationAgenda. Key Terms. How to Effectively Manage A Medicare Audit. Welcome. The Basics. ADR Process Appeals. Record Submission Process Questions & Closing
How to Effectively Manage A Medicare Audit ASCEND 2017 September 29, 2017 Washington DC Mary R. Daulong, PT, CHC, CHP 1 Agenda Welcome Tag us during this presentation @bcmscomp.com #ascendevent The Basics
More informationMedicare Program Integrity Manual
Medicare Program Integrity Manual Chapter 12 The Comprehensive Error Rate Testing Program Transmittals for Chapter 12 Table of Contents (Rev. 240, 02-08-08) 12.3 The Comprehensive Error Rate Testing (CERT)
More informationRAC Appeals Settlement
RAC Appeals Settlement A webinar for Missouri Hospital Association Stacy Harper (913) 451-5125 sharper@lathropgage.com September 25, 2014 Presented by Donn Herring (314) 613-2808 dherring@lathropgage.com
More informationCenter for Medicaid and State Operations/Survey and Certification Group
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services 7500 Security Boulevard, Mail Stop S2-12-25 Baltimore, Maryland 21244-1850 Center for Medicaid and State Operations/Survey
More informationThere is nothing wrong with change, if it is in the right direction Winston Churchil
Changes Changes 2012 2012 There is nothing wrong with change, if it is in the right direction Winston Churchill New tools provided by the Affordable Care Act are strengthening the Obama administration
More informationHow to Submit an Appeal: The Redetermination Level
How to Submit an Appeal: The Redetermination Level FEBRUARY 17, 2016 Presented by: Part B Provider Outreach and Education John Florence Jurisdiction J A/B Medicare Administrative Contractor 1 Disclaimer
More informationMGMA Medicare Audits Fact Sheet
MGMA Medicare Audits Fact Sheet Several types of Medicare contractors may audit physicians. This fact sheet describes audits under fee-for-service Medicare (traditional Medicare), Medicare managed care
More informationMedicare Program Integrity: Overview and Issues
Medicare Program Integrity: Overview and Issues Marjorie Kanof, M.D. Managing Director, Health Care U.S. Government Accountability Office February 22, 2007 1 Overview Introduction to Medicare What is Program
More informationSANCTION SCREENING: OIG HIGH RISK PRIORITY
SANCTION SCREENING: OIG HIGH RISK PRIORITY Overview Healthcare organizations and entities have as a Condition of Participation the affirmative duty to screen all those with whom they have a business relationship
More informationTHE MEDICARE R x DRUG LAW
THE MEDICARE R x DRUG LAW The Exceptions and Appeals Process: Issues and Concerns in Obtaining Coverage Under the Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Benefit Prepared by Vicki Gottlich, Esq. Center for Medicare
More informationOctober 10, th Annual Ambulatory Surgery Center Conference Improving Profitability and Business / Legal Issues
October 10, 2009 16 th Annual Ambulatory Surgery Center Conference Improving Profitability and Business / Legal Issues How It All Started. What Should I Do Next? 2 Defense Plan Audit Management Recoupment
More informationVoluntary Refunds and Internal Investigations: Tips, Tricks and Tripwires
Voluntary Refunds and Internal Investigations: Tips, Tricks and Tripwires By David Glaser and Katie Ilten June 2015 Preparation: What can you do to A trick question. prevent a audit? Get an Anomalies happen
More informationGoals for Today s Presentation
AMERICAN HEALTH LAWYERS ASSOCIATION Institute on Medicare and Medicaid Payment Issues March 20-22, 2013 Baltimore, Maryland Medicare and Medicaid Overpayments and Refunds Presented by: Robert L. Roth,
More informationAHLA. T. Legal and Practical Considerations for Internal Payment Audits. Timothy P. Blanchard Blanchard Manning LLP Orcas, WA
AHLA T. Legal and Practical Considerations for Internal Payment Audits Timothy P. Blanchard Blanchard Manning LLP Orcas, WA Beth DeLair President DeLair Consulting SC Middleton, WI Fraud and Compliance
More informationImproving Integrity in Nursing Centers
Improving Integrity in Nursing Centers Susan Edwards Reed Smith LLP AHCA/NCAL s General Counsel Goals of this webinar Introduce you to AHCA/NCAL s Fraud and Abuse Toolkit Provide you with a basic understanding
More information5. Recovery Auditors shall perform the necessary provider outreach to notify provider communities of the Recovery Auditor s purpose and direction.
Statement of Work for the Medicare Fee-for-Service Recovery Audit Program I. Purpose The Recovery Audit Program s mission is to reduce Medicare improper payments through the efficient detection and correction
More informationAMERICAN BAR ASSOCIATION ADOPTED BY THE HOUSE OF DELEGATES August 11-12, 2003
AMERICAN BAR ASSOCIATION ADOPTED BY THE HOUSE OF DELEGATES August 11-12, 2003 RESOLVED, That the American Bar Association recommends the following reforms in the Medicare claims adjudication process to
More informationMedicaid Audit Overpayments: Challenging Statistical Sampling and Extrapolation
Presenting a live 90-minute webinar with interactive Q&A Medicaid Audit Overpayments: Challenging Statistical Sampling and Extrapolation WEDNESDAY, MARCH 15, 2017 2pm Eastern 1pm Central 12pm Mountain
More informationPart B Rebilling When Part A Denied
RAC Summit Washington, D.C. Dec 5, 2013 Part B Rebilling When Part A Denied Steven J. Meyerson, M.D SVP, Regulations and Education Group Accretive Physician Advisory Services 231 S La Salle St, Ste 1600
More informationThird National Medicare RAC Summit
Third National Medicare RAC Summit Zone Program Integrity Contractors (ZPICs) Cristine M. Miller, CMPE, CCP, CHC Thursday, March 4, 2010 RAC Audit Preparation Cristine Miller Certified Medical Practice
More information3/17/2015. HCCA Compliance Institute April 19, Legal Obligations to Disclose and Refund. Background on Government Approach to Overpayments
HCCA Compliance Institute April 19, 2015 Exploring CMS s Proposed Rule on Reporting and Refunding Overpayments Gary W. Eiland, Partner King & Spalding LLP Houston, Texas Background on Government Approach
More informationMedicare Accounts Receivable Management Strategies. Your Speakers
Medicare Accounts Receivable Management Strategies Leading Age Michigan 2014 Annual Leadership Institute Friday, August 15, 2014 8:30 am 9:30 am 1 Your Speakers Janet Potter, CPA, MAS Manager, Healthcare
More informationRegion [Region #] Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) Date: [Request Date]
Region [Region #] Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) Date: [Request Date] [RA Point of Contact] [Physician Practice Name] [Street Address Line 1] [Street Address Line 2] [City, State ZIP] Re: [Provider Name]
More informationMedicare Program Integrity Manual
Medicare Program Integrity Manual Chapter 3 - Verifying Potential Errors and Taking Corrective Actions Transmittals for Chapter 3 Table of Contents (Rev. 422, 05-25-12) 3.1 - Introduction 3.2 - Overview
More informationIS YOUR PRACTICE A GOVERNMENT TARGET? A BRIEF REVIEW OF THE AUDIT PROCESS WHAT IS AN AUDIT?
IS YOUR PRACTICE A GOVERNMENT TARGET? A BRIEF REVIEW OF THE AUDIT PROCESS 3/16/2016 1 WHAT IS AN AUDIT? An audit is a review of medical claims submitted to a government or private payer. Audits can be
More informationSHARP HEALTH PLAN POLICY AND PROCEDURE Product Line (check all that apply):
SHARP HEALTH PLAN POLICY AND PROCEDURE Product Line (check all that apply): Title: Organization Determination Reopenings - Claims Division(s): Finance Health Services and Operations Group HMO Individual
More informationZPIC, RAC, HIPAA AUDITS IN LTC: ARE YOU READY?
HCCA s 17 th Annual Compliance Institute April 21-24, 2013 ZPIC, RAC, HIPAA AUDITS IN LTC: ARE YOU READY? Mark E. Reagan Hooper, Lundy & Bookman, P.C. 575 Market Street, Suite 2300 San Francisco, CA 94105
More informationMedicare and Medicaid Audits Using Statistical Sampling and Extrapolation: Challenging Methods and Results
Presenting a live 90-minute webinar with interactive Q&A Medicare and Medicaid Audits Using Statistical Sampling and Extrapolation: Challenging Methods and Results THURSDAY, JUNE 14, 2018 1pm Eastern 12pm
More informationRACs to ZPICs. Program Integrity Audits and the Ever Increasing Burden on Healthcare Providers. April 22, 2015 Claire Owens, JD
RACs to ZPICs Program Integrity Audits and the Ever Increasing Burden on Healthcare Providers April 22, 2015 Claire Owens, JD How did we get here? The High Cost of Healthcare Where did it come from? What
More informationMedicare Overpayment 60 Day Rule
Medicare Overpayment 60 Day Rule What Your Compliance and Auditing Departments Need to Know Objectives Review the key legal, operational and technical takeaways from the ACA 60 Day Report and Repay Statute.
More informationPredictive Modeling and Analytics for Health Care Provider Audits. Sixth National Medicare RAC Summit November 7, 2011
Predictive Modeling and Analytics for Health Care Provider Audits Sixth National Medicare RAC Summit November 7, 2011 Predictive Modeling and Analytics for Health Care Provider Audits Agenda Objectives
More informationPROVIDER REIMBURSEMENT REVIEW BOARD DECISION ON THE RECORD 20ll-D31
PROVIDER REIMBURSEMENT REVIEW BOARD DECISION ON THE RECORD 20ll-D31 PROVIDER- George Washington University Hospital Washington, D.C. DATE OF HEARING - May 25, 2010 Provider No.: 09-0001 Cost Reporting
More informationWHAT YOUR BOARD NEEDS TO KNOW ABOUT COMPLIANCE NATIONAL MEDICARE RAC SUMMIT 9/13/10
WHAT YOUR BOARD NEEDS TO KNOW ABOUT COMPLIANCE NATIONAL MEDICARE RAC SUMMIT 9/13/10 JAMES G. SHEEHAN NEW YORK MEDICAID INSPECTOR GENERAL James.Sheehan@OMIG.NY.GOV 518 473-3782 3782 1 RAC, MIC, DATA MINING
More informationCMS Audit Contractors
Andrew B. Wachler, Esq. Wachler & Associates, P.C. 210 E. Third St., Ste. 204 Royal Oak, MI 48067 (248) 544 0888 awachler@wachler.com www.wachler.com HCCA 20 th Annual Compliance Institute April 17 20,
More information20. CLAIMS PROCESSING. A. Claims Processing APPLIES TO:
20. CLAIMS PROCESSING A. Claims Processing APPLIES TO: A. This policy applies to all Capitated Providers (Payers) delegated for claims payment for IEHP DualChoice Cal MediConnect Plan (Medicare Medicaid
More informationReopening and Redetermination Submissions
A CMS Medicare Administrative Contractor http://www.ngsmedicare.com Reopening and Redetermination Submissions Understanding your next steps are very important for quick reimbursement and providers are
More informationRisk Analysis and Communication. Improving Coding/Audit Result Accuracy and Communicating Coding Concerns and Audit Results Effectively DISCLAIMER
Improving Coding/Audit Result Accuracy and Communicating Coding Concerns and Audit Results Effectively Presenter: Michael D. Miscoe Esq, CPC, CASCC, CUC, CCPC, CPCO CPMA DISCLAIMER This course was current
More informationPresenters. Sara Kay Wheeler. Kirk Dobbins Peachtree St., NE Atlanta, GA Phone: (404)
Medicare Prescription Drug Part D Compliance Conference Medicare Part D: How to Ensure Your Appeals, Grievances, Determinations and Reconsiderations Meet CMS Requirements December 7, 2008 Presenters Sara
More information