Session 7b Managing the Climate Change Liability Risk Facing Greenhouse Gas Emitters. Prof. Kuan Chun Johnny Chang, SJD
|
|
- Buddy Eaton
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Session 7b Managing the Climate Change Liability Risk Facing Greenhouse Gas Emitters Prof. Kuan Chun Johnny Chang, SJD
2 Managing the Climate Change Liability Risk Facing Greenhouse Gas Emitters Kuan Chun Johnny Chang, SJD Professor, National Chengchi University College of Law President, Financial Ombudsman Institution OUTLINE INTRODUCTION U.S. DIALECTICAL ANALYSIS ON THE APPROPRIATENESS OF IMPOSING TORT LIABILITY ON MAJOR GHG EMITTERS CLIMATE CHANGE TORT CLIAM IN CHINA: A POSSIBILITY MANAGING CLIMATE CHANGE LIABILITY RISK THROUGH INSURANCE CONCLUSION 1
3 U.S. (1) Massachusetts et. al. v. E.P.A. A group of States including Massachusetts and local governments including District of Columbia, alleged in a petition for certiorari that the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has abdicated its responsibility under the Clean Air Act (CAA) to regulate the emissions of four greenhouse gases, including carbon dioxide. U.S. (2) Main Issue: Whether Petitioners have the standing to challenge the EPA's denial of their rulemaking petition. Standard of Review: 1) actual or imminent injury? 2) injury is fairly traceable to the defendant (causation)? 3) a favorable decision will redress that injury? 2
4 U.S. (3.1) 1. Injury: Erosion to substantial portion of the Massachusetts coastal property. 2. Causation: Scientific evidences reveal that the existence of a causal connection between man made greenhouse gas emissions and global warming. 3. Redressability: U.S. Motor vehicle emissions make a meaningful contribution to GHG concentrations. U.S. (3.2) the Supreme Court, by a vote of 5 to 4, held that carbon dioxide and other GHGs are within the definition of air pollutant under the Clean Air Act and that EPA does indeed have the authority to regulate them. Subsequent to the decision, the EPA under the Obama administration did indeed issue a two part endangerment finding, concluding that rising GHG levels endanger public health, safety, and welfare. Thereafter, the EPA began issuing substantive regulations to restrict GHG emissions. 3
5 U.S. (4) Connecticut et. al. v. Am. Electric Power Co. Inc. Eight states including Connecticut separately sued the same six electric power corporations, including the American Electric Power Company Inc. that owned and operated fossil fuel fired power plants in twenty states (appellees), seeking equitable relief. The States seek to: hold Defendants jointly and severally liable for creating, contributing to, or maintaining a public nuisance. permanently enjoin each Defendant to abate that nuisance first by capping carbon dioxide emissions and then by reducing emissions by a specified percentage each year for at least ten years. U.S. (5) Main Issue: whether the court is incompetent to make final resolution of the claim in issue as it constitutes non justiciable political questions. Standard of Review(Backer v. Carr): 1) textually demonstrable constitutional commitment of the issue to a coordinate political department 2) a lack of judicially discoverable and manageable standards 3) the impossibility of deciding without an initial policy determination of a kind clearly for nonjudicial discretion 4
6 U.S. (6.1) 2 nd Cir. Court Opined that there s no non justiciable political question. Because, 1) Federal courts have successfully adjudicated complex common law public nuisance cases for over a century. The fact that a case may present complex issues is not a reason for federal courts to shy away from adjudication; when a court is possessed of jurisdiction. 2) This case is governed by recognized judicial standards under the federal common law of nuisance obviates any need to make initial policy decisions of the kind normally reserved for nonjudicial discretion. U.S. (6.2) But, In a unanimous eight justice decision, with Justice Sotomayor recusing herself, the Supreme Court reversed the appellate panel. The decision was written by Justice Ginsberg and turned on Massachusetts v. EPA's holding that established the EPA's authority to regulate GHGs. Congress had decided that it was the job of EPA, and therefore not the courts, to regulate GHG emissions. The federal common law of nuisance for GHG emissions had ultimately been displaced by the Clean Air Act, and these cases should have been dismissed after all. 5
7 U.S. (7.1) Comer v. Murphy Oil USA Inc. The plaintiffs, residents and owners of lands and property along the Mississippi Gulf coast, filed a putative class action against the named defendants, corporations that have principal offices in other states but are doing business in Mississippi. Claim : defendants' operation of energy, fossil fuels, and chemical industries in the United States caused the emission of greenhouse gasses that contributed to global warming, the increase in global surface air and water temperatures, that in turn caused a rise in sea levels and exacerbate the destructiveness of Hurricane Katrina, which destroyed both the plaintiffs' private property and public property useful to them. The plaintiffs' putative class action asserts claims for compensatory and punitive damages based on Mississippi common law actions of public and private nuisance, trespass, and negligence etc. U.S. (8.1) Opinion: 1) The Plaintiffs Have Standing to Assert Their Claims. 2) Plaintiffs Claims did not Present Nonjusticiable Political Question 6
8 U.S. (8.2) The Supreme Court declined the plaintiffs' request and effectively ended that version of the case. The Comer case was subsequently re filed and dismissed by the District Court on many grounds including res judicata. In May 2013, the Fifth Circuit confirmed that this refiling was barred by res judicata. The time for plaintiffs to petition the Supreme Court for certiorari has now expired, so the Comer litigation appears to have ended. U.S. (9) The course of the Federal Court s position on the climate change related litigations can be discovered through comparing three cases with one another: Massachusetts affirmed the standing that a state may claim for an enjoinment as the remedy for climatechange related injuries. Connecticut et. al: (1) Upheld all plaintiffs standing, including the standing of the municipal and private plaintiffs; (2) extended the federal common law of nuisance to carbon dioxide pollution. Comer v. Murphy Oil USA Inc (1) also granted private citizens standing to engage in the discovery process based on global warming tort claims against private corporations; (2) regarded the pecuniary compensation as a suitable form of remedy in climate change tort litigations. 7
9 U.S. (10) None of these cases progressed beyond that foundational point. There was never any discovery or judicial fact finding in any of these cases. Presuming further advancement is even possible, it will likely be met with an onslaught of additional obstacles. U.S. (11) 1. Whether the particular injury suffered is really attributable to climate change, a very difficult and technical issue. 2. How the law and courts should account for the long time scales of climate change. 8
10 U.S. (12) 3. Conceptual problem with liability concerning the supply chain. The use of electricity generated from coal requires one party to mine coal, one to transport it, another to burn it for electricity, a utility to deliver that power, and finally a consumer to use the electricity. Where along that supply chain does liability attach? The same issue arises with car emissions. Somebody drills the oil, somebody else refines it and another, or perhaps the same company, transports it to gas stations, where people individually put it in their cars. In addition to this supply chain, cars are also made by various manufacturers, and still additional people drive them. Every one of these activities is lawful, and many government policies and expenditures encourage them. U.S. (13) Whether climate change is sufficiently unique to warrant a change in the judiciary's willingness to apply tort law. No. Yes. Congress passed comprehensive environmental legislation. The liability risk facing the GHG emitters is almost certain The rules of tort law are well established and courts have historically applied these rules before Congress passed comprehensive environmental legislation. The liability risk facing the GHG emitters is almost certain 9
11 DIALECTICAL ANALYSIS ON THE APPROPRIATENESS OF IMPOSING TORT LIABILITY ON MAJOR GHG EMITTERS (1) Justification Based on Theories of Private Law 1) Corrective Justice 2) Deterrence Effect Arguments in Support of Tortious Liability Legitimacy Under Common Law Nuisance 1) Interference: Yes! 2) Substantiality: Yes! 3) Unreasonableness: Yes! Efficiencies Confirmed by Economic Analysis: tort liability can contribute to the effective implementation of the polluter pays principle. Influences on the Formation of Public Policies: When the legislative process has failed to produce results, common law actions will likely to capture the legislative process. DIALECTICAL ANALYSIS ON THE APPROPRIATENESS OF IMPOSING TORT LIABILITY ON MAJOR GHG EMITTERS (2) Arguments Against Tortious Liability Challenges to the Applicability of the Corrective Justice Theory 1) environmental damage events are not losses to individuals paradigmatically protected interests. 2) causal links between a particular set of GHG emissions and those protected interests?? Obstacles in Sustaining Tortious Liability Only a very loose connection exists between the injurers and the victims because the emitters are the set of people who have engaged in activities that result in carbon emissions in the past. Tortious Liability is not the Ultimate Solution for Reducing GHG Emissions 1) compensation may be inefficient if it weakens the government s and private entities incentives to avoid harm. 2) it will weaken incentives for private and public sector investments in adaptation. 10
12 DIALECTICAL ANALYSIS ON THE APPROPRIATENESS OF IMPOSING TORT LIABILITY ON MAJOR GHG EMITTERS (3) Positions of advocating the imposition of climate change liability #1: The applicability of such theory is never required in determining whether emitters are liable. The deterrence function of tort law is wellrecognized. Theoretical justification regarding the climate change liability is still available. DIALECTICAL ANALYSIS ON THE APPROPRIATENESS OF IMPOSING TORT LIABILITY ON MAJOR GHG EMITTERS (4) Positions of advocating the imposition of climate change liability #2: The genius of the common law it can adapt to changing circumstance s. No other private way to resolve the dispute for climate change victims except for tort claims. Courts to develop standards to resolve the causation in climate change litigations according to the unique nature of climate change harms, i.e. probabilistic approach. 11
13 DIALECTICAL ANALYSIS ON THE APPROPRIATENESS OF IMPOSING TORT LIABILITY ON MAJOR GHG EMITTERS (5) Positions of advocating the imposition of climate change liability #3: The function of the climatechange litigation filling gaps in legislative and administrative regulation. Critics raise concern that imposing liability on GHG emitters may lead to redistribution of wealth in favor of wealthy people. Similar situation may occur where tortious liability is imposed on enterprises including product liability and pollution cases. Product liability functioned pretty well. CLIMATE CHANGE TORT CLIAM IN CHINA: A POSSIBILITY (1) China has acknowledged its role as world s biggest GHG emitter Present legislation Any new proposals vowing to limit emissions? Provide no equivocal standard distinguishing permissible volume of GHG emissions from prohibited emissions Does not grant any type of remedies to climate change victims No! 12
14 CLIMATE CHANGE TORT CLIAM IN CHINA: A POSSIBILITY (2) Tort Liabili ty Act Liability for Environmental Pollution Art. 65 with respect to any damage caused by environment pollution, the polluter shall bear tort liability. commen ts Manifests the general principle that polluters are strictly liable for any environmental damage stemming from their actions. A proof of actor s negligence or a higher degree of scienter is not required. CLIMATE CHANGE TORT CLIAM IN CHINA: A POSSIBILITY (3) Article 66 provides that In the event of any dispute arising from environmental pollution, the polluter shall bear the burden of proof with regard to the legal basis for bearing no liability or mitigation of its liability and the nonexistence of causation between its act and the harmful consequences. Such arrangement significantly increases the possibility of sustaining the tort liability in climate change litigation. 13
15 MANAGING CLIMATE CHANGE LIABILITY RISK THROUGH INSURANCE (1) Ceres, Climate Change Risk Perception and Management: A Survey of Risk Managers (2010) respondents contains electric power plants and oil and gas industries : 1) more than 57% of the respondents have perceived the likelihood of legal risk including tort liability, civil liabilities or other litigation. 2) Nearly 40% admitted that climate change is likely to pose imminent legal risk within 0 2 years. MANAGING CLIMATE CHANGE LIABILITY RISK THROUGH INSURANCE (2) GHG Emitter s Risk Identified Risk managers have to consider alternative risk management approaches.. Liability insurance, undertaking to assume the obligations imposed on the party in the event of legal liability. 14
16 MANAGING CLIMATE CHANGE LIABILITY RISK THROUGH INSURANCE (3) Scope of Coverage: Occurrence Basis or Claim made Basis? An occurrence policy :provides coverage for liability arising out of damage that occurs during the policy period, regardless of when a claim alleging liability is made. A claims made policy : covers liability arising out of claims actually made during the policy period. MANAGING CLIMATE CHANGE LIABILITY RISK THROUGH INSURANCE (4) The precise incidence of the harm is impossible to indentify, and the delay between occurrence and the resulting claims is almost certain. The occurrence policy is disadvantageous. 1) The long tail problem which refers to the lapse of time between the date of the act or neglect and the time the claim is made. 2) Insurers inability to accurately match premiums against proceeds paid due to the uncertainty in indentifying when the loss occurred and the lapse of time between the event and the loss. 15
17 CONCLUSION 1) Tort claims filed against GHG emitters is no longer an isolated case. 2) The admission of climate change tort liability can be justified from theoretical, legal as well as public policy perspectives. 3) The new PRC Tort Law of 2009 has actually created a feasible approach by shifting the burden of proving the causation from the plaintiff to the tortfeasor in articles related to environmental tort liability. 4) To manage climate change liability through purchasing liability insurance policies seems to be an appropriate choice with reasonable expense. THANKS FOR YOUR ATTENTION! 16
GLOBAL WARMING AND CLIMATE CHANGE: POTENTIAL ISSUES UNDER CGL POLICIES. Robert A. Kole Choate, Hall & Stewart LLP
GLOBAL WARMING AND CLIMATE CHANGE: POTENTIAL ISSUES UNDER CGL POLICIES Robert A. Kole Choate, Hall & Stewart LLP 1 Primary Issues Four significant issues dominate the landscape with regard to the interrelationship
More informationJanuary 5, To Our Clients and Friends:
DISCLOSING CLIMATE CHANGE RISKS IN SEC FILINGS January 5, 2010 To Our Clients and Friends: As companies begin to prepare their annual reports on Forms 10-K or 20-F, they should consider whether it may
More informationLegal Liability for Failing to Adapt
Legal Liability for Failing to Adapt Elena Mihaly, Staff Attorney Deanna Moran, Director of Environmental Planning Conservation Law Foundation April 30, 2018 2 Kivalina v. ExxonMobil (2008) CLAIM: Public
More informationAEP Generating Company
AEP Generating Company 2012 Third Quarter Report Financial Statements TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Number Glossary of Terms 1 Condensed Statements of Income Unaudited 2 Condensed Statements of Changes in Common
More informationInsurance Coverage Alert
November 18, 2009 Author: James S. Malloy james.malloy@klgates.com +1.412.355.8965 Additional Contact: Michael J. Lynch michael.lynch@klgates.com +1.412.355.8644 K&L Gates is a global law firm with lawyers
More informationClimate Change and Insurance: An Overview
CHAPTER 1 Climate Change and Insurance: An Overview Climate change has become a leading issue in scientific, political, and legal circles, and this may have profound implications for the insurance industry.
More informationAEP Generating Company
AEP Generating Company 2009 Third Quarter Report Financial Statements TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Glossary of Terms Condensed Statements of Income and Condensed Statements of Retained Earnings Unaudited Condensed
More informationThe Evolution of Fraud on the Market Suits and Halliburton II
The Evolution of Fraud on the Market Suits and Halliburton II Law and Economics of Capital Markets Fellows Workshop Columbia Law School Professor Merritt B. Fox September 11, 2014 Overview Nature of Fraud-on-the-market
More informationBeyond the Usual Suspects: Coverage for Natural and Not-So-Natural Disasters
ABA Section of Litigation Insurance Coverage Litigation Committee CLE Seminar, March 3-5, 2011: Beyond the Usual Suspects: Coverage for Natural and Not-So-Natural Disasters Beyond the Usual Suspects: Coverage
More informationCLIMATE CHANGE LIABILITY
CLIMATE CHANGE LIABILITY Ffion Griffiths Reed Smith Type: Published: Last Updated: Keywords: Legal guide July 2011 July 2011 Climate change; environmental law; state liability. This document provides general
More informationNON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT I.O.P
NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT I.O.P. 65.37 BOCHETTO & LENTZ, P.C. Appellant IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA v. A. HAROLD DATZ, ESQUIRE, AND A. HAROLD DATZ, P.C. Appellee No. 3165
More informationVapor Intrusion Bases for Legal Liability and Defenses
Vapor Intrusion Bases for Legal Liability and Defenses Jay A. Tufano Attorney Ring Bender LLLP What is Vapor Intrusion? Vapor intrusion is the general term given to migration of hazardous vapors from any
More informationSummary of the defendant's submission of 30 October 2017
Summary of the defendant's submission of 30 October 2017 Supplementary opinion on the plaintiff's written submission of 5 September 2017 in preparation for oral proceedings by Francesca Mascha Klein (IKEM)
More informationPREEMPTION QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
PREEMPTION QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ERISA PREEMPTION QUESTIONS 1. What is an ERISA plan? An ERISA plan is any benefit plan that is established and maintained by an employer, an employee organization (union),
More informationAPPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF HARRISON COUNTY, MISSISSIPPI, FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT, CAUSE NO.: A
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF MISSISSIPPI COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF MISSISSIPPI NO. 2009-CA-Ol723 BERTHA MADISON APPELLANT VERSUS GEICO GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY APPELLEE APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT
More informationRecovering losses from product recalls - December 2001
Recovering losses from product recalls - December 2001 In brief: What considerations will a Court take into account in assessing the costs of recovering damages for a product recall? AAR lawyer Joe Tan
More informationCarbon Report: Investments in Fossil Fuel. November 2014
Carbon Report: Investments in Fossil Fuel November 2014 English Summary of the Norwegian Report About the report The consequences of climate change are serious, and there is broad scientific consensus
More informationFRACKING UNIVERSAL KEY ISSUES IN POLLUTION DAMAGE INSURANCE COVERAGE
FRACKING UNIVERSAL KEY ISSUES IN POLLUTION DAMAGE INSURANCE COVERAGE Fracking is due to start in South Africa within the next two to three years despite adamant opposition Shale gas provides cheaper cleaner
More informationClimate change litigation in the Anthropocene: new pathways or deadend
Climate change litigation in the Anthropocene: new pathways or deadend streets? Hendrik Schoukens Belgisch Klimaat-Governance 28 mei 2018 Brussel (Université Saint-Louis) 1) ACTING ON BEHALF OF FUTURE
More informationSENATE DOCKET, NO FILED ON: 1/18/2019. SENATE... No. The Commonwealth of Massachusetts PRESENTED BY: Michael J. Barrett
SENATE DOCKET, NO. 1817 FILED ON: 1/18/2019 SENATE.............. No. The Commonwealth of Massachusetts PRESENTED BY: Michael J. Barrett To the Honorable Senate and House of Representatives of the Commonwealth
More informationTask Force on Civil Justice Spring Task Force Summit Pittsburgh, PA May 6, 2016
Task Force on Civil Justice Spring Task Force Summit Pittsburgh, PA May 6, 2016 12:30 PM Civil Justice Task Force Luncheon 1:30 PM Break Task Force on Civil Justice Tentative Meeting Agenda 2016 Spring
More informationClimate Justice and the China Fallacy
Berkeley Law Berkeley Law Scholarship Repository Faculty Scholarship 1-1-2009 Climate Justice and the China Fallacy Daniel A. Farber Berkeley Law Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.law.berkeley.edu/facpubs
More informationEnvironmental Liabilities for the Power Industry
Environmental Liabilities for the Power Industry Presented by: Beverley Parrish bparrish@exponent.com Presented to: Willis December 8, 2015 London Agenda Liability for Environmental Damage Tort and Statutory
More informationRecent Housing Allowance Opinion - Its Contents and Reasoning
Recent Housing Allowance Opinion - Its Contents and Reasoning On October 6, 2017, U.S. District Judge Barbara B. Crabb of the Western District of Wisconsin found that 26 U.S.C. 107(2) violates the establishment
More informationPublic Claims and Damages Arising from Environmental Harms to Our Rivers, Bays and Estuaries Bill Jackson
Public Claims and Damages Arising from Environmental Harms to Our Rivers, Bays and Estuaries Bill Jackson bjackson@jgdpc.com Complexity of Rivers, Bays and Sediment Sites Risk Based Cleanup: Human
More informationCLAIM SUMMARY / DETERMINATION FORM
CLAIM SUMMARY / DETERMINATION FORM Date : 10/12/2010 Claim Number : N08057-080 Claimant : Mabanaft, Inc. Type of Claimant : Corporate (US) Type of Claim : Loss of Profits and Earning Capacity Claim Manager
More informationMONTEREY BAY UNIFIED AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT. < Protocol >
MONTEREY BAY UNIFIED AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT < Protocol > Subject: Mutual Settlement Program Final: Adoption Date: June 20, 2012 Pages: 11 Electronic File: Mutual_Settlement_Protocol_6.20.12.doc
More informationHosted by the Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment A Proposal for Climate Justice
Hosted by the Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment A Proposal for Climate Justice Professor Jeffrey D. Sachs LOGOS Professor of Economics at Columbia University, a leader in
More informationTORTS / REMEDIES Copyright July, State Bar of California
Copyright July, 2000 - State Bar of California Dan operates a plant where he makes pottery. To provide a special high-capacity power source to his pottery kilns, Dan recently installed on the electric
More informationProcedural Considerations For Insurance Coverage Declaratory Judgment Actions
Procedural Considerations For Insurance Coverage Declaratory Judgment Actions New York City Bar Association October 24, 2016 Eric A. Portuguese Lester Schwab Katz & Dwyer, LLP 1 Introduction Purpose of
More informationLegal Issues in Carbon Sequestration
Legal Issues in Carbon Sequestration Douglas A. Henderson & Peter S. Glaser Troutman Sanders LLP Preliminary Issue #1 Climate President-Elect Obama supports carbon sequestration 1 Preliminary Issue #2
More informationTHE STATE OF NEW HAMPSHIRE SUPREME COURT. Docket No Terry Ann Bartlett
THE STATE OF NEW HAMPSHIRE SUPREME COURT Docket No. 2014-0285 Terry Ann Bartlett v. The Commerce Insurance Company, Progressive Northern Insurance Company and Foremost Insurance Company APPEAL FROM FINAL
More informationPresent: Carrico, C.J., Lacy, Hassell, Keenan, Koontz, and Kinser, JJ., and Compton, Senior Justice
Present: Carrico, C.J., Lacy, Hassell, Keenan, Koontz, and Kinser, JJ., and Compton, Senior Justice JOHN A. BERCZEK OPINION BY v. Record No. 991117 SENIOR JUSTICE A. CHRISTIAN COMPTON April 21, 2000 ERIE
More informationCLIMATE CHANGE LITIGATION AND EU ENVIRONMENTAL LIABILITY DIRECTIVE
Vanesa Vujanić Centre for Energy, Petroleum and Mineral Law and Policy, University of Dundee, LLM Candidate CLIMATE CHANGE LITIGATION AND EU ENVIRONMENTAL LIABILITY DIRECTIVE UDK: 349.6 (4) Pregledni znanstveni
More informationCHAPTER House Bill No. 813
CHAPTER 2002-261 House Bill No. 813 An act relating to environmental protection; amending s. 201.15, F.S.; providing for distribution of proceeds from excise taxes on documents to pay debt service on Everglades
More informationAPA Challenges to Treasury Regulations: Partly Cloudy with a Chance of Success
DID YOU GET YOUR BADGE SCANNED? APA Challenges to Treasury Regulations: Partly Cloudy with a Chance of Success Panelists Starling Marshall, Covington & Burling LLP Gil Rothenberg, Department of Justice,
More informationImplementation of Article 19 of the WHO FCTC: Liability
66 66 Conference of the Parties to the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Seventh session Delhi, India, 7 12 November 2016 Provisional agenda item 5.7 FCTC/COP/7/13 14 June 2016 Implementation
More informationIN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE H. DAVID MANLEY, ) ) No. 390, 2008 Defendant Below, ) Appellant, ) Court Below: Superior Court ) of the State of Delaware in v. ) and for Sussex County ) MAS
More informationGENERAL ASSEMBLY OF NORTH CAROLINA SESSION 2009 SESSION LAW SENATE BILL 836
GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF NORTH CAROLINA SESSION 2009 SESSION LAW 2010-179 SENATE BILL 836 AN ACT TO: (1) CLARIFY LIABILITY FOR DAMAGES CAUSED BY THE DISCHARGE OF NATURAL GAS, OIL, OR DRILLING WASTE INTO STATE
More informationBet the Port Litigation: Claims and Damages Considerations for Ports in the Wake of an Environmental Catastrophe
Bet the Port Litigation: Claims and Damages Considerations for Ports in the Wake of an Environmental Catastrophe Bill Jackson Jackson Gilmour & Dobbs, PC (713) 355-5050 bjackson@jgdpc.com Surface Water
More informationSURVEY OF RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN MICHIGAN CONSTRUCTION LAW
SURVEY OF RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN MICHIGAN CONSTRUCTION LAW Construction Law, Construction Site Accidents, Contractors Legal Issues, OSHA/MIOSHA Issues Practice Groups August 1, 2009 With the November 2008
More informationSTATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS
STATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS CYNTHIA ADAM, Plaintiff-Appellant, FOR PUBLICATION August 11, 2015 9:00 a.m. v No. 319778 Oakland Circuit Court SUSAN LETRICE BELL and MINERVA LC No. 2013-131683-NI DANIELLE
More informationAn Economic Critique of SB Under consideration this session is Senate Bill , which aims to restrict the
Morse 1 Alan Morse Prof. Jeffrey Zax Applied Economic Analysis April 6, 2016 An Economic Critique of SB17-181 Under consideration this session is Senate Bill 17-181, which aims to restrict the collateral
More informationTHE STATE OF FLORIDA...
TABLE OF CONTENTS I. THE STATE OF FLORIDA... 1 A. FREQUENTLY CITED FLORIDA STATUTES... 1 1. General Considerations in Insurance Claim Management... 1 2. Insurance Fraud... 4 3. Automobile Insurance...
More informationSTATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS
STATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS LAKELAND NEUROCARE CENTERS, Plaintiff-Appellant, FOR PUBLICATION February 15, 2002 9:15 a.m. v No. 224245 Oakland Circuit Court STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE LC No. 98-010817-NF
More informationUnited Nations Environment Programme
Guidelines for the Development of Domestic Legislation on Liability, Response Action and Compensation for Damage Caused by Activities Dangerous to the Environment Adopted by the Governing Council of the
More informationAEP Generating Company
AEP Generating Company 2008 Second Quarter Report Financial Statements TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Glossary of Terms Condensed Statements of Income and Condensed Statements of Retained Earnings Unaudited Condensed
More informationEleventh Court of Appeals
Opinion filed July 19, 2018 In The Eleventh Court of Appeals No. 11-16-00183-CV RANDY DURHAM, Appellant V. HALLMARK COUNTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellee On Appeal from the 358th District Court Ector
More informationCOURT OF APPEALS GUERNSEY COUNTY, OHIO FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
[Cite as State v. Glenn, 2009-Ohio-375.] COURT OF APPEALS GUERNSEY COUNTY, OHIO FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT STATE OF OHIO JUDGES Hon. W. Scott Gwin, P.J. Plaintiff-Appellee Hon. John W. Wise, J. Hon. Patricia
More informationClaim Procedure Manual
Claim Procedure Manual Liability Program December 2010 INTRODUCTION This manual was prepared for PARSAC members as a guide for processing claims and lawsuits presented to your entity where there is potential
More informationProcedures for Protest to New York State and City Tribunals
September 25, 1997 Procedures for Protest to New York State and City Tribunals By: Glenn Newman This new feature of the New York Law Journal will highlight cases involving New York State and City tax controversies
More informationManagement liability corporate legal liability Policy wording
The General terms and conditions and the following terms and conditions all apply to this section. Cover under this section is given on an aggregate basis unless otherwise specified. Special definitions
More informationPRODUCT LIABILITY INDEMNITY UNDER TEXAS LAW. 1. Claim for Indemnity by a Seller Against an Upstream Supplier
PRODUCT LIABILITY INDEMNITY UNDER TEXAS LAW 1. Claim for Indemnity by a Seller Against an Upstream Supplier One Court has held that there is no claim for common law indemnity by an innocent retailer from
More informationVermont Bar Association 134 th Annual Meeting
Vermont Bar Association 134 th Annual Meeting Year in Review Insurance Law Seminar Materials Faculty Samuel Hoar, Jr., Esq. Paul J. Perkins, Esq. September 21, 2012 Lake Morey Resort, Fairlee, VT 2012
More informationClimate change and fiduciary duties: What should pension trustees know? SHARE Webinar September 15, 2015
Climate change and fiduciary duties: What should pension trustees know? SHARE Webinar September 15, 2015 Agenda Introduction Peter Chapman, Executive Director, SHARE Climate Change and the Fiduciary Duties
More informationPCI Northeast General Counsel Seminar
PCI Northeast General Counsel Seminar September 18-19, 2017 Insurance Law Developments Laura A. Foggan Crowell & Moring LLP lfoggan@crowell.com 202-624-2774 Crowell & Moring 1 Zhaoyun Xia v. ProBuilders
More informationDamages Pt. 3 Diminished Value of Vehicle Due to Traffic Accident
www.pavlacklawfirm.com April 26 2012 by: Colin E. Flora Associate Civil Litigation Attorney Damages Pt. 3 Diminished Value of Vehicle Due to Traffic Accident In this week s installment in the series on
More informationVolume Six, Issue Nine October 2003
Volume Six, Issue Nine October 2003 In This Issue Benefit Recoveries & Subrogation In this ninth issue of the McGraw Wentworth Benefit Advisor for 2003, we will discuss benefit recoveries. Benefit recoveries
More informationFEDERAL REPORTER, 3d SERIES
470 705 FEDERAL REPORTER, 3d SERIES HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL, INC. and E.I. DuPont de Nemours and Company, Petitioners v. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, Respondent Arkema Inc., et al., Intervenors. Nos.
More informationERISA Causes of Action *
1 ERISA Causes of Action * ERISA authorizes a variety of causes of action to remedy violations of the statute, to enforce the terms of a benefit plan, or to provide other relief to a plan, its participants
More informationAEP Generating Company
AEP Generating Company 2008 First Quarter Report Financial Statements TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Glossary of Terms Condensed Statements of Income and Condensed Statements of Retained Earnings Unaudited Condensed
More informationH 7250 S T A T E O F R H O D E I S L A N D
LC00 01 -- H 0 S T A T E O F R H O D E I S L A N D IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 01 A N A C T RELATING TO WATERS AND NAVIGATION -- THE OFFSHORE OIL AND GAS DRILLING AND EXPLORATION ACTIVITIES
More informationAttacks on Health Reform and Developing Litigation Issues in Managed Care. Chris Flynn Jeff Poston
Attacks on Health Reform and Developing Litigation Issues in Managed Care Chris Flynn Jeff Poston Overview Current Constitutional Challenges to PPACA The Florida Action The Virginia Action 2 Overview (cont
More informationAEP Generating Company
AEP Generating Company 2012 Annual Report Audited Financial Statements TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Number Glossary of Terms 1 Independent Auditors Report 2 Statements of Income 3 Statements of Changes in Common
More informationIN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CARBON COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CARBON COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION CARBON COUNTY TAX CLAIM BUREAU, : Plaintiff : : vs. : No. 11-0850 : RIDGEWOOD COUNTRY ESTATES : HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC.,
More informationIntroduction. It depends, but in general, the answer is No. Sound strange? What about McDonald's coffee?
Introduction Can or should the law provide incentives for vendors to build better software? Are vendors currently liable for software defects of any sort? It depends, but in general, the answer is No.
More informationClimate Change Litigation a global phenomenon. Presentation by Gillian Lobo Law & Environment Conference Lawyer, ClientEarth 26 April 2018
Climate Change Litigation a global phenomenon Presentation by Gillian Lobo Law & Environment Conference Lawyer, ClientEarth 26 April 2018 1. Introduction to ClientEarth Contents 2. Climate change as a
More informationAEP Generating Company
AEP Generating Company 2007 Third Quarter Report Financial Statements TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Glossary of Terms Condensed Statements of Income and Condensed Statements of Retained Earnings Unaudited Condensed
More informationThe Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill and its Economic Impact on the Seafood. Industry. Introduction
Tiajuana Robinson Admiralty Law Professor Hooks November 16, 2012 The Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill and its Economic Impact on the Seafood Industry Introduction The United States has faced many grave tragedies
More informationThe Future Directive on Environmental Liability A tool to implement the precautionary principle?
IDDRI "European Precautionary practice" The Future Directive on Environmental Liability A tool to implement the precautionary principle? Dr. Peter Beyer Strict liability as foreseen by the future European
More informationState v. Continental Insurance Company
Public Land and Resources Law Review Volume 0 Case Summaries 2012-2013 State v. Continental Insurance Company John M. Newman john.newman@umontana.edu Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.umt.edu/plrlr
More informationSTATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS
STATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS MICHIGAN EDUCATIONAL EMPLOYEES MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, UNPUBLISHED January 27, 2004 Plaintiff-Appellant, v No. 242967 Oakland Circuit Court EXECUTIVE RISK INDEMNITY,
More informationCalifornia Offset Program Upheld By Erika K. Anderson February 11, 2013
California Offset Program Upheld By Erika K. Anderson February 11, 2013 Introduction California s carbon offset program was upheld on January 25, 2013 when Superior Court Judge Ernest Goldsmith rejected
More informationMONTEREY BAY UNIFIED AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT. <Protocol >
MONTEREY BAY UNIFIED AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT Subject: Mutual Settlement Program Final: X Adoption Date: 9-16-98; revised 6-21-00; 6-20-01; 6-19-02; Pages: 9 6-18-03; 6-16-04; 6-15-05;
More informationMlekush v. Farmers Insurance Exchange: Defining the Standard for the Insurance Exception to the American Rule
Montana Law Review Online Volume 78 Article 10 7-20-2017 Mlekush v. Farmers Insurance Exchange: Defining the Standard for the Insurance Exception to the American Rule Molly Ricketts Alexander Blewett III
More informationRULE 2301 EMISSION REDUCTION CREDIT BANKING (Adopted September 19, 1991; Amended March 11, 1992; Amended December 17, 1992; Amended January 19, 2012)
RULE 2301 EMISSION REDUCTION CREDIT BANKING (Adopted September 19, 1991; Amended March 11, 1992; Amended December 17, 1992; Amended January 19, 2012) 1.0 Purpose The purposes of this rule are to: 1.1 For
More information[Urging the Retirement Board to Divest from Fossil Fuel Companies] Resolution urging the Retirement Board of the Employees' Retirement System
FILE NO. -0-COE [Urging the Retirement Board to Divest from Fossil Fuel Companies] Resolution urging the Retirement Board of the Employees' Retirement System to divest from publicly-traded fossil fuel
More informationRisks & opportunities of climate change for the insurance sector
Risks & opportunities of climate change for the insurance sector Mark Way Head Sustainability Issue Management & Reporting Sustainability & Emerging Risk Management Agenda Science update Impact on insurance
More informationD. Brian Hufford. Partner
D. Brian Hufford Partner D. Brian Hufford leads a national practice representing patients and health care providers in disputes with health insurance companies. Brian developed innovative and successful
More informationNo. 07SA50, In re Stephen Compton v. Safeway, Inc. - Motion to compel discovery - Insurance claim investigation - Self-insured corporation
Opinions of the Colorado Supreme Court are available to the public and can be accessed through the Court s homepage at http://www.courts.state.co.us/supct/ supctindex.htm. Opinions are also posted on the
More informationSTATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS
STATE OF MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS ANDERSON MILES, Plaintiff-Appellant, UNPUBLISHED May 6, 2014 v No. 311699 Wayne Circuit Court STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE LC No. 10-007305-NF INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant-Appellee.
More information2018 CO 42. No. 15SC934, Am. Family Mut. Ins. Co. v. Barriga Unreasonable Delay and Denial of Insurance Benefits Damages.
Opinions of the Colorado Supreme Court are available to the public and can be accessed through the Judicial Branch s homepage at http://www.courts.state.co.us. Opinions are also posted on the Colorado
More informationEnvironmental, Safety & Toxic Torts. Practice Overview
Environmental, Safety & Toxic Torts Practice Overview Environmental, Safety & Toxic Torts Businesses today are confronted with a complex web of environmental and safety concerns, ranging from contaminated
More informationCase 2:16-cv JEO Document 1 Filed 05/19/16 Page 1 of 12
Case 2:16-cv-00837-JEO Document 1 Filed 05/19/16 Page 1 of 12 FILED 2016 May-20 PM 02:43 U.S. DISTRICT COURT N.D. OF ALABAMA IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ALABAMA (SOUTHERN
More informationChapter 7 Topics in the Economics of Tort Liability
Chapter 7 Topics in the Economics of Tort Liability I. Extending the Economic Model A. Relaxing the core assumptions of the model developed in the previous chapter 1. Decision makers are rational In order
More informationAllianz Global Investors. Climate Risk Investment Positioning
Allianz Global Investors Climate Risk Investment Positioning Climate Risk Investment Positioning Pre-word This investment positioning document aims to summarize Allianz Global Investors (AllianzGI) view
More informationObjectives: Pharmacist Liability
Objectives: Pharmacist Liability Martha Dye-Whealan R.Ph., J.D. Define negligence and tort law. Review elements of and defenses to a negligence claim and relate to pharmacy practice. Understand relevance
More informationIN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI WESTERN DIVISION
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI WESTERN DIVISION RICHARD BARNES, ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) v. ) No. 4:13-cv-0068-DGK ) HUMANA, INC., ) ) Defendant. ) ORDER GRANTING DISMISSAL
More informationManufacturing Strategies Guide
Manufacturing Strategies Guide A Manufacturing Strategy for Jobs and a Competitive America Goal 1: To Be the Best Country in the World to Headquarter a Business Manufacturing today is global and mobile.
More informationOUR WORK. SUPERFUND, COST RECOVERY AND CONTRIBUTION - Overview
SUPERFUND, COST RECOVERY AND CONTRIBUTION - Overview We have represented clients in all types of Superfund matters, including as PRPs at multi-party disposal sites, as both plaintiffs and defendants in
More informationJune 19, I hope this information is helpful to you. The CBO staff contacts are Frank Sammartino and Terry Dinan. Sincerely,
CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE U.S. Congress Washington, DC 20515 Douglas W. Elmendorf, Director June 19, 2009 Honorable Dave Camp Ranking Member Committee on Ways and Means U.S. House of Representatives
More informationQ UPDATE EXECUTIVE RISK SOLUTIONS CASES OF INTEREST D&O FILINGS, SETTLEMENTS AND OTHER DEVELOPMENTS
EXECUTIVE RISK SOLUTIONS Q1 2018 UPDATE CASES OF INTEREST U.S. SUPREME COURT FINDS STATE COURTS RETAIN JURISDICTION OVER 1933 ACT CLAIMS STATUTORY DAMAGES FOR VIOLATION OF TCPA FOUND TO BE PENALTIES AND
More informationSUPREME COURT OF ALABAMA
REL: 09/01/2017 Notice: This opinion is subject to formal revision before publication in the advance sheets of Southern Reporter. Readers are requested to notify the Reporter of Decisions, Alabama Appellate
More informationThe Commuter: Residents v. Non-Residents
June 16, 1999 The Commuter: Residents v. Non-Residents By: Glenn Newman The hottest New York tax issue in the last few years has nothing to do with the New York State and City Tax Tribunals or does it?
More informationIn the Missouri Court of Appeals Eastern District
In the Missouri Court of Appeals Eastern District DIVISION FIVE CLIFFORD HINDMAN REAL ESTATE, ) INC., ) No. ED91472 ) Appellant, ) Appeal from the Circuit Court of ) St. Louis County v. ) Cause No. 06CC-002248
More informationCase No. LACV Plaintiffs, GRAIN PROCESSING CORPORATION, Defendant.
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE STATE OF IOWA IN AND FOR MUSCATINE COUNTY LAURIE FREEMAN, SHARON MOCKMORE, BECCY BOYSEL, GARY D. BOYSEL, LINDA L. GOREHAM, GARY R. GOREHAM, KELCEY BRACKETT and BOBBIE LYNN
More informationCGL Coverage for Climate Change Related Civil Litigation
CGL Coverage for Climate Change Related Civil Litigation By Seth D. Lamden PHOTO BY: ISTOCK.COM/PIJAMA61 It is far too early to tell whether companies currently or formerly engaged in operations that emit
More informationSUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA JOHN D. DUDLEY, Petitioner, CASE NO.: SC 07-1747 vs. DCA CASE NO.: 5D06-3821 ELLEN F. SCHMIDT, Respondent. / PETITIONER S AMENDED JURISDICTIONAL BRIEF Richard J. D
More informationSupreme Court of the United States
No. 07-219 din THE Supreme Court of the United States EXXON SHIPPING COMPANY, et al., v. GRANT BAKER, et al., Petitioners, Respondents. ON PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF
More information