A Joint Credit Scoring Model for Peer-to-Peer Lending and Credit Bureau

Transcription

1 A Joint Credit Scoring Model for Peer-to-Peer Lending and Credit Bureau Credit Research Centre and University of Edinburgh joint work with Silvia Osmetti and Luca Zanin Credit Scoring and Credit Control conference 31 August 2017

2 Outline 1 The copula function The bivariate model 2 Data Empirical results 3

3 P2P lending Peer-to-peer (P2P) lending allows direct lending between lenders and borrowers using a platform. In 2014 P2P lending generated approximately $5.5 billion loans in the US. To improve the predictive accuracy accuracy of scoring models for P2P, we suggest to use the information from a credit bureau if the borrower defaults on any loan. We propose a bivariate regression model binary unbalanced data (BivGEV model).

4 The copula function The bivariate model Let Y be a binary response so defined { 1 if the borrower defaults Y = 0 otherwise Let x = (x 1,x 2,...,x p ) be a p-covariates vector. We model the probability of default P(Y = 1) = π(x β) where β = (β 0,β 1,...,β p ) are the regressor parameters. Symmetric link functions π( ), such as the logit and the probit models, are inaccurate if the binary classification is strongly unbalanced (Calabrese et al. 2015; King and Zeng, 2001; Wang and Dey, 2010).

5 GEV link function The copula function The bivariate model Link functions Pr(Y=1) Logistic GEV(tau = 0.25) GEV(tau = 0.25) GEV(tau = 1)

6 The copula function The bivariate model We suggest to model the probability of default π(x β) using the GEV distribution as follows π(x it,s i,t i ) = π(x; β,τ) = { exp = exp [ 1 + τ(β 0 + p [ (β 0 + p j=1 β jx j ) j=1 β jx j ) ] ] 1 τ + } τ = 0 τ 0 with τ denotes the shape parameter and x + = max(x,0). The GEV distribution is very flexible with the shape parameter τ controlling the tail behaviour. The R package BGEVA is available on CRAN.

7 The copula function The copula function The bivariate model A function C : I 2 I, with I 2 = [0,1] [0,1] and I = [0,1], is a bivariate copula if it is the cumulative bivariate distribution function of a rv (U,V ), with uniform marginal in [0,1] C λ (u,v) = P(U u,v v), 0 u 1 0 v 1 where the copula parameter λ Λ describes the association between the marginals. Copula functions capture the dependence structure between the marginals and allow the specification of multivariate distributions with arbitrary dependence structures.

8 The copula function The bivariate model Some characteristics of the main Copula functions Copula Dependence Tail Dependence Gaussian radially no asymptotic symmetric tail dependence Clayton asymmetric strong left (lower) (exchangeable) tail dependence Gumbel asymmetric strong right (upper) (exchangeable) tail dependence Frank radially no asymptotic symmetric tail dependence Joe asymmetric strong right (upper) (exchangeable) tail dependence

9 The copula function The bivariate model Y = (Y 1,Y 2 ) is a binary bivariate response variable with values on (0,1); the marginal probabilities are π 1 (x; β 1,τ 1 ) = P(Y 1 = 1 x; β 1,τ 1 ) π 2 (x; β 2,τ 2 ) = P(Y 2 = 1 x; β 2,τ 2 ) The marginal probabilities are modelled using the GEV distribution. The BivGEV is defined using the copula function: π 11 (x; δ,τ ) = C λ (π 1 (x; β 1,τ 1 ),π 2 (x; β 2,τ 2 )) { } { }) = C λ (exp [1 + τ 1 η 1 ] 1/τ 1,exp [1 + τ 2 η 2 ] 1/τ 2 The maximum likelihood method is used to estimate the BivGEV model.

10 Data Data Empirical results We analyse 12,579 loans of 60 months provided by Lending Club from 2010 to the first quarter of { 1 if the borrower is reported in default by the credit bureau Y 1 = 0 otherwise Y 2 = { 1 if the borrower defaults on the P2P loan 0 otherwise The percentage of defaulted P2P loans is 24% and default credit bureau is 5%.

11 Data Empirical results The determinants of the scoring models for default credit bureau and P2P lending are: Loan purpose. Housing situation: Mortgage; Rent; Own or other situation. Interest rate. Annual income. Revolving utilization. Inquiries last 6 months. DTI: Monthly debt payments to monthly income. Delinquency last 2 years. Open accounts. Credit history length. Loan amount to annual income. Spatial variables defined using the first digit of the ZIP Code.

12 Empirical results Data Empirical results Copula Copula parameter λ Kendall-Tau Gaussian Clayton Gumbel Frank Joe Copula AIC BIC Gaussian Clayton Gumbel Frank Joe

13 Data Empirical results Default Credit Bureau Default P2P lending Car financing House Major purchase Small business Rent Interest rate ln(annual income) ln(revolving utilization) Inquiries last 6 months Delinquency last 2 years Open accounts DTI Credit history length Loan amount to annual income Intercept τ

14 Out of sample Data Empirical results Model MSE + MAE + AUC H Probit Y 2 = 1 Y 1 = 1 Model MSE + MAE + AUC H BivGEV BivProbit Y 2 = 1 Y 1 = 0 Model MSE + MAE + AUC H BivGEV BivProbit

15 Out of time Data Empirical results Model MSE + MAE + AUC H Probit Y 2 = 1 Y 1 = 1 Model MSE + MAE + AUC H BivGEV BivProbit Y 2 = 1 Y 1 = 0 Model MSE + MAE + AUC H BivGEV BivProbit

16 We introduced a bivariate regression model that is accurate in classifying defaults. We implemented the model in an R package that will be publicly available. We obtain that using the information from the credit bureau improves the predictive accuracy of a scoring model for P2P lending.