Credit Union Index An Analysis of Utah Credit Unions

Transcription

1 Credit Union Index An Analysis of Utah Credit Unions

2 Credit Union Index DEFINITIONS The Credit Union Index is published by Moss Adams LLP. For more information on the data presented in this report, consult Rebecca Radell, Senior Manager, at (209) Asset Size Definition: GROUP A $0 $250 million GROUP B $251 $500 million GROUP C $501 million $1 billion GROUP D Over $1 billion

3 Utah

4 Performance Analysis

5 NM = per SNL Financial, the data was not provided as the ratios are too high/low to be meaningful. Performance Data Page 3 of 14 Performance Analysis March 31, 2017 Run Date: May 21, 2017 As of Date Quarter to Date Year to Date Region Institution Name Total Assets ($000) Net Income (Loss) ($000) Return on Avg Return on Avg Net Worth (%) Oper Exp/ Oper Rev (%) Salary&Benefits/ Employees ($000) Net Income (Loss) ($000) Return on Avg Return on Avg Net Worth (%) Oper Exp/ Oper Rev (%) Salary&Benefits/ Employees ($000) Asset Group A - $50 to $250 million in total assets Tri-County Credit Union $158 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $8 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $8 Beckstrand & Associates Credit Union $283 $0 0.00% 0.00% NA NA $0 0.00% 0.00% NA NA Presto Lewiston Employees Credit Union $337 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $24 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $24 Valley Wide Federal Credit Union $489 ($1) (0.82%) (4.55%) % $12 ($1) (0.82%) (4.55%) % $12 Granite Furniture Employees Federal Credit Union $862 $3 1.46% 3.70% 62.50% $32 $3 1.46% 3.70% 62.50% $32 North Sanpete Federal Credit Union $881 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $16 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $16 South Sanpete Credit Union $1,042 $0 0.00% 0.00% 80.00% $8 $0 0.00% 0.00% 80.00% $8 UCB Credit Union $1,213 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $20 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $20 Employees First Credit Union $1,756 ($2) (0.46%) (1.72%) % $20 ($2) (0.46%) (1.72%) % $20 Sunnyside Credit Union $2,674 ($21) (3.16%) (30.00%) % $35 ($21) (3.16%) (30.00%) % $35 Provo Police & Fire Department Credit Union $2,817 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $40 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $40 Dugway Federal Credit Union $3,163 $3 0.38% 1.56% 95.16% $26 $3 0.38% 1.56% 95.16% $26 Uintah Credit Union $3,384 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $16 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $16 Orem City Employees Federal Credit Union $3,687 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $19 $0 0.00% 0.00% % $19 Utah Prison Employees Credit Union $3,719 ($2) (0.22%) (2.60%) % $37 ($2) (0.22%) (2.60%) % $37 S E A Credit Union $4,738 $ % 4.87% 51.61% $48 $ % 4.87% 51.61% $48 Meadow Gold Employees Credit Union $4,907 $4 0.33% 1.44% 92.86% $45 $4 0.33% 1.44% 92.86% $45 Gibbons & Reed Employees Federal Credit Union $5,002 $4 0.31% 1.88% 86.36% $50 $4 0.31% 1.88% 86.36% $50 MidValley Federal Credit Union $5,694 ($15) (1.06%) (3.30%) % $60 ($15) (1.06%) (3.30%) % $60 Tanner Employees Credit Union $6,003 $ % 10.26% 73.91% $41 $ % 10.26% 73.91% $41 C.U.P. Federal Credit Union $6,507 $6 0.37% 2.49% 89.83% $54 $6 0.37% 2.49% 89.83% $54 HollyFrontier Employee's Credit Union $6,788 $ % 8.74% 59.74% $62 $ % 8.74% 59.74% $62 Devils Slide Federal Credit Union $11,434 $ % 4.94% 77.78% $48 $ % 4.94% 77.78% $48 City Center Credit Union $11,606 $ % 26.82% 61.34% $72 $ % 26.82% 61.34% $72 Kings Peak Credit Union $12,455 ($9) (0.31%) (3.67%) % $37 ($9) (0.31%) (3.67%) % $37 P & S Credit Union $15,795 $ % 4.42% 91.86% $55 $ % 4.42% 91.86% $55 Varex Federal Credit Union $15,914 $2 0.05% 0.31% 98.99% $51 $2 0.05% 0.31% 98.99% $51 San Juan Credit Union $18,794 $ % 25.98% 75.97% $64 $ % 25.98% 75.97% $64 Utah Federal Credit Union $18,824 $ % 2.31% 91.56% $67 $ % 2.31% 91.56% $67 Logan Medical Federal Credit Union $21,536 $ % 6.69% 65.45% $61 $ % 6.69% 65.45% $61 LU 354 IBEW Federal Credit Union $24,086 $ % 7.54% 74.90% $82 $ % 7.54% 74.90% $82 Logan Cache Rich Federal Credit Union $24,228 $ % 4.34% 73.57% $42 $ % 4.34% 73.57% $42 Grand County Credit Union $28,183 $ % 19.46% 73.67% $67 $ % 19.46% 73.67% $67 Federal Family Federal Credit Union $28,721 $ % 1.36% 93.10% $75 $ % 1.36% 93.10% $75 Education First Credit Union $30,946 $ % 5.21% 85.41% $69 $ % 5.21% 85.41% $69 National J.A.C.L. Credit Union $31,689 ($33) (0.42%) (3.88%) % $53 ($33) (0.42%) (3.88%) % $53 Nephi Western Employees Federal Credit Union $32,539 $ % 4.76% 53.15% $80 $ % 4.76% 53.15% $80 Freedom Credit Union $33,472 $ % 13.58% 68.21% $66 $ % 13.58% 68.21% $66 Desertview Federal Credit Union $33,521 $ % 3.54% 82.67% $59 $ % 3.54% 82.67% $59 Millard County Credit Union $33,928 $ % 7.68% 74.48% $48 $ % 7.68% 74.48% $48 Firefighters Credit Union $39,339 $ % 2.73% 90.94% $64 $ % 2.73% 90.94% $64 Hi-Land Credit Union $51,732 $ % 6.84% 56.02% $89 $ % 6.84% 56.02% $89 Pacific Horizon Credit Union $57,945 $ % 8.20% 79.19% $53 $ % 8.20% 79.19% $53 Utah Heritage Credit Union $63,770 $ % 9.50% 79.92% $60 $ % 9.50% 79.92% $60 Hercules Credit Union $67,391 $ % 1.23% 95.24% $70 $ % 1.23% 95.24% $70 Nebo Credit Union $83,751 $ % 6.39% 67.78% $57 $ % 6.39% 67.78% $57 Weber State Federal Credit Union $110,258 $ % 4.33% 88.41% $63 $ % 4.33% 88.41% $63 Members First Credit Union $117,409 $ % 4.91% 85.99% $72 $ % 4.91% 85.99% $72 Eastern Utah Community Federal Credit Union $119,749 $ % 6.58% 83.69% $73 $ % 6.58% 83.69% $73 Box Elder County Federal Credit Union $120,132 $ % 8.47% 57.87% $54 $ % 8.47% 57.87% $54 Transwest Credit Union $134,042 $ % 10.48% 81.17% $68 $ % 10.48% 81.17% $68 Horizon Utah Federal Credit Union $139,942 $ % 3.78% 83.68% $54 $ % 3.78% 83.68% $54 Alpine Credit Union $187,056 $ % 4.09% 85.58% $44 $ % 4.09% 85.58% $44 American United Family of Credit Unions, Federal Credit Union $195,815 $ % 12.98% 70.16% $63 $ % 12.98% 70.16% $63 Average of Asset Group A $36,706 $ % 3.98% 86.94% $50 $ % 3.98% 86.94% $50 Source: SNL Financial NA = data was not available.

6 NM = per SNL Financial, the data was not provided as the ratios are too high/low to be meaningful. Performance Data Page 4 of 14 Performance Analysis March 31, 2017 Run Date: May 21, 2017 As of Date Quarter to Date Year to Date Region Institution Name Total Assets ($000) Net Income (Loss) ($000) Return on Avg Return on Avg Net Worth (%) Oper Exp/ Oper Rev (%) Salary&Benefits/ Employees ($000) Net Income (Loss) ($000) Return on Avg Return on Avg Net Worth (%) Oper Exp/ Oper Rev (%) Salary&Benefits/ Employees ($000) Asset Group B - $251 to $500 million in total assets Jordan Federal Credit Union $264,511 $ % 2.84% 90.03% $63 $ % 2.84% 90.03% $63 Wasatch Peaks Federal Credit Union $299,779 $ % 3.53% 87.55% $63 $ % 3.53% 87.55% $63 Utah First Federal Credit Union $326,341 $1, % 13.63% 69.27% $68 $1, % 13.63% 69.27% $68 Granite Federal Credit Union $418,539 $ % 9.19% 71.52% $65 $ % 9.19% 71.52% $65 Average of Asset Group B $327,293 $ % 7.30% 79.59% $65 $ % 7.30% 79.59% $65 Asset Group C - $501 million to $1 billion in total assets Deseret First Federal Credit Union $591,534 $ % 7.51% 77.13% $67 $ % 7.51% 77.13% $67 Utah Power Credit Union $625,690 $1, % 6.12% 61.19% $90 $1, % 6.12% 61.19% $90 Cyprus Federal Credit Union $828,248 $1, % 9.22% 74.09% $55 $1, % 9.22% 74.09% $55 University First Federal Credit Union $912,008 $1, % 8.23% 70.48% $51 $1, % 8.23% 70.48% $51 Average of Asset Group C $739,370 $1, % 7.77% 70.72% $66 $1, % 7.77% 70.72% $66 Asset Group D - $1 billion and over in total assets Utah Community Federal Credit Union $1,238,335 $1, % 4.97% 79.55% $68 $1, % 4.97% 79.55% $68 Goldenwest Federal Credit Union $1,372,546 $4, % 9.05% 74.77% $57 $4, % 9.05% 74.77% $57 Mountain America Federal Credit Union $6,456,586 $19, % 14.05% 68.94% $79 $19, % 14.05% 68.94% $79 America First Federal Credit Union $8,761,088 $25, % 11.69% 67.04% $53 $25, % 11.69% 67.04% $53 Average of Asset Group D $4,457,139 $12, % 9.94% 72.58% $64 $12, % 9.94% 72.58% $64 Source: SNL Financial NA = data was not available.

7 Balance Sheet & Net Interest Margin

8 NM = per SNL Financial, the data was not provided as the ratios are too high/low to be meaningful. BS & NIM Data Page 6 of 14 Balance Sheet & Net Interest Margin March 31, 2017 Run Date: May 21, 2017 As of Date Year to Date Region Institution Name Total Assets ($000) Total Lns & Leases ($000) Total Shares & Deposits ($000) Total Loans/ Total Shares (%) Assets/ FTE Employees ($000) Yield on Avg Interest Expense/ Avg Net Interest Income/ Avg Asset Growth Rate (%) Market Growth Rate (%) Asset Group A - $50 to $250 million in total assets Tri-County Credit Union $158 $75 $ % $ % 0.00% 2.56% 10.39% 15.38% Beckstrand & Associates Credit Union $283 $26 $ % NA 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% (20.13%) 4.40% Presto Lewiston Employees Credit Union $337 $276 $ % $ % 0.00% 5.83% (12.64%) 31.44% Valley Wide Federal Credit Union $489 $352 $ % $ % 0.00% 2.45% (0.82%) 1.00% Granite Furniture Employees Federal Credit Union $862 $851 $ % $1, % 0.49% 3.89% 40.36% 65.94% North Sanpete Federal Credit Union $881 $782 $ % $1, % 0.45% 2.67% (14.86%) (19.62%) South Sanpete Credit Union $1,042 $544 $ % $1, % 0.40% 1.59% 29.69% 32.31% UCB Credit Union $1,213 $373 $ % $1, % 0.33% 2.94% (6.49%) (6.81%) Employees First Credit Union $1,756 $294 $1, % $ % 0.23% 3.19% 0.91% 1.87% Sunnyside Credit Union $2,674 $1,446 $2, % $1, % 0.30% 3.16% 4.39% 8.18% Provo Police & Fire Department Credit Union $2,817 $1,772 $2, % $2, % 0.42% 2.68% (5.60%) (6.49%) Dugway Federal Credit Union $3,163 $2,148 $2, % $ % 0.25% 4.69% 1.52% 2.21% Uintah Credit Union $3,384 $1,338 $2, % $2, % 0.12% 2.11% (6.63%) (7.72%) Orem City Employees Federal Credit Union $3,687 $1,303 $3, % $1, % 0.11% 1.97% 7.74% 8.55% Utah Prison Employees Credit Union $3,719 $2,447 $3, % $1, % 0.32% 3.89% 4.02% 4.40% S E A Credit Union $4,738 $2,634 $3, % $4, % 0.60% 2.56% 7.57% 8.48% Meadow Gold Employees Credit Union $4,907 $3,105 $3, % $1, % 0.33% 4.02% 5.62% 8.86% Gibbons & Reed Employees Federal Credit Union $5,002 $2,365 $4, % $2, % 0.16% 3.14% (14.71%) (18.07%) MidValley Federal Credit Union $5,694 $2,376 $3, % $2, % 0.14% 2.41% 7.30% 12.32% Tanner Employees Credit Union $6,003 $4,390 $5, % $2, % 0.14% 4.00% 15.22% 16.04% C.U.P. Federal Credit Union $6,507 $4,845 $5, % $2, % 0.00% 3.46% 3.41% 4.46% HollyFrontier Employee's Credit Union $6,788 $6,308 $5, % $3, % 0.48% 4.58% 18.69% 26.87% Devils Slide Federal Credit Union $11,434 $7,747 $9, % $4, % 0.48% 2.73% (10.19%) (12.24%) City Center Credit Union $11,606 $10,399 $10, % $2, % 1.56% 6.55% 47.03% 51.61% Kings Peak Credit Union $12,455 $7,741 $11, % $1, % 0.24% 3.81% 60.06% 77.44% P & S Credit Union $15,795 $9,194 $14, % $3, % 0.10% 3.19% 27.18% 29.34% Varex Federal Credit Union $15,914 $6,404 $13, % $3, % 0.18% 2.23% 5.43% 6.41% San Juan Credit Union $18,794 $11,474 $17, % $1, % 0.55% 5.84% 33.37% 33.62% Utah Federal Credit Union $18,824 $11,578 $16, % $4, % 0.38% 2.86% 4.75% 5.07% Logan Medical Federal Credit Union $21,536 $13,108 $18, % $5, % 0.47% 2.79% 16.36% 20.46% LU 354 IBEW Federal Credit Union $24,086 $18,096 $20, % $4, % 0.47% 3.08% 5.62% 5.19% Logan Cache Rich Federal Credit Union $24,228 $10,137 $21, % $5, % 0.25% 2.19% 10.28% 10.87% Grand County Credit Union $28,183 $22,818 $25, % $2, % 0.35% 4.73% 27.00% 42.93% Federal Family Federal Credit Union $28,721 $13,545 $24, % $4, % 0.29% 2.58% 5.53% 7.64% Education First Credit Union $30,946 $21,322 $28, % $3, % 0.63% 3.10% 14.10% 14.76% National J.A.C.L. Credit Union $31,689 $13,243 $28, % $4, % 0.22% 2.41% 13.88% 16.05% Nephi Western Employees Federal Credit Union $32,539 $24,904 $22, % $8, % 0.68% 2.91% 14.35% 18.57% Freedom Credit Union $33,472 $24,855 $29, % $5, % 0.41% 3.29% 22.81% 25.00% Desertview Federal Credit Union $33,521 $18,338 $29, % $3, % 0.22% 3.35% 13.52% 14.90% Millard County Credit Union $33,928 $19,563 $30, % $2, % 0.10% 3.00% 22.84% 24.43% Firefighters Credit Union $39,339 $24,672 $34, % $4, % 0.53% 2.62% 18.49% 20.59% Hi-Land Credit Union $51,732 $25,758 $43, % $12, % 0.60% 2.27% 4.09% 3.45% Pacific Horizon Credit Union $57,945 $46,360 $52, % $4, % 0.80% 3.17% 8.65% 8.38% Utah Heritage Credit Union $63,770 $46,091 $57, % $2, % 0.60% 3.69% 16.70% 17.03% Hercules Credit Union $67,391 $27,548 $61, % $5, % 0.47% 2.41% 9.11% 10.10% Nebo Credit Union $83,751 $63,739 $69, % $2, % 0.49% 4.17% 16.24% 19.16% Weber State Federal Credit Union $110,258 $91,414 $99, % $2, % 0.29% 3.30% 23.89% 26.02% Members First Credit Union $117,409 $72,062 $103, % $4, % 0.33% 2.81% 13.13% 11.01% Eastern Utah Community Federal Credit Union $119,749 $69,672 $108, % $3, % 0.44% 2.96% 11.53% 12.73% Box Elder County Federal Credit Union $120,132 $66,087 $94, % $3, % 0.34% 3.00% 19.99% 22.60% Transwest Credit Union $134,042 $101,287 $122, % $3, % 0.56% 3.20% 13.24% 13.62% Horizon Utah Federal Credit Union $139,942 $74,581 $124, % $2, % 0.22% 3.10% 17.48% 15.81% Alpine Credit Union $187,056 $119,216 $165, % $3, % 0.27% 2.81% 16.60% 16.96% American United Family of Credit Unions, Federal Credit Union $195,815 $157,779 $169, % $2, % 0.76% 4.54% 7.43% 6.11% Average of Asset Group A $36,706 $23,903 $32, % $3, % 0.36% 3.19% 11.21% 14.62% Source: SNL Financial NA = data was not available.

9 NM = per SNL Financial, the data was not provided as the ratios are too high/low to be meaningful. BS & NIM Data Page 7 of 14 Balance Sheet & Net Interest Margin March 31, 2017 Run Date: May 21, 2017 As of Date Year to Date Region Institution Name Total Assets ($000) Total Lns & Leases ($000) Total Shares & Deposits ($000) Total Loans/ Total Shares (%) Assets/ FTE Employees ($000) Yield on Avg Interest Expense/ Avg Net Interest Income/ Avg Asset Growth Rate (%) Market Growth Rate (%) Asset Group B - $251 to $500 million in total assets Jordan Federal Credit Union $264,511 $153,195 $243, % $3, % 0.30% 2.91% 15.79% 17.09% Wasatch Peaks Federal Credit Union $299,779 $222,260 $270, % $3, % 0.43% 2.91% 17.47% 19.11% Utah First Federal Credit Union $326,341 $257,809 $287, % $3, % 0.44% 4.02% 22.74% 23.59% Granite Federal Credit Union $418,539 $314,396 $373, % $4, % 0.29% 3.09% 14.40% 15.45% Average of Asset Group B $327,293 $236,915 $293, % $3, % 0.37% 3.23% 17.60% 18.81% Asset Group C - $501 million to $1 billion in total assets Deseret First Federal Credit Union $591,534 $426,190 $547, % $3, % 0.45% 3.21% 15.51% 16.80% Utah Power Credit Union $625,690 $271,316 $542, % $12, % 0.89% 1.71% 12.90% 13.87% Cyprus Federal Credit Union $828,248 $672,330 $734, % $2, % 0.48% 3.05% 19.26% 20.09% University First Federal Credit Union $912,008 $758,501 $810, % $3, % 0.34% 2.91% 21.81% 25.01% Average of Asset Group C $739,370 $532,084 $658, % $5, % 0.54% 2.72% 17.37% 18.94% Asset Group D - $1 billion and over in total assets Utah Community Federal Credit Union $1,238,335 $852,906 $1,094, % $3, % 0.19% 2.76% 24.15% 28.34% Goldenwest Federal Credit Union $1,372,546 $933,080 $1,170, % $2, % 0.50% 2.92% 39.01% 40.54% Mountain America Federal Credit Union $6,456,586 $5,381,884 $5,393, % $3, % 0.54% 3.20% 26.26% 32.90% America First Federal Credit Union $8,761,088 $6,097,618 $7,739, % $3, % 0.42% 2.93% 26.20% 29.11% Average of Asset Group D $4,457,139 $3,316,372 $3,849, % $3, % 0.41% 2.95% 28.91% 32.72% Source: SNL Financial NA = data was not available.

10 Asset Quality

11 NM = per SNL Financial, the data was not provided as the ratios are too high/low to be meaningful. Asset Quality Data Page 9 of 14 Asset Quality March 31, 2017 Run Date: May 21, 2017 As of Date Region Institution Name Total Assets ($000) Delinquent Loans => 2 months ($000) NPLs / Loans (%) Loan Loss Reserves / Gross Loans (%) Reserves / NPLs (%) NPAs / Equity + LLRs (%) Delinquent Loans/ Asset Group A - $50 to $250 million in total assets Tri-County Credit Union $158 $ % 6.67% 29.41% 34.00% 10.76% Beckstrand & Associates Credit Union $283 $0 0.00% 0.00% NA 0.00% 0.00% Presto Lewiston Employees Credit Union $337 $0 0.00% 1.81% NA 0.00% 0.00% Valley Wide Federal Credit Union $489 $2 0.57% 1.42% % 2.17% 0.41% Granite Furniture Employees Federal Credit Union $862 $0 0.00% 1.29% NA 0.00% 0.00% North Sanpete Federal Credit Union $881 $0 0.00% 1.66% NA 0.00% 0.00% South Sanpete Credit Union $1,042 $0 0.00% 1.10% NA 0.00% 0.00% UCB Credit Union $1,213 $ % 6.17% % 7.06% 1.48% Employees First Credit Union $1,756 $1 0.34% 2.04% % 0.21% 0.06% Sunnyside Credit Union $2,674 $6 0.41% 1.66% % 2.05% 0.22% Provo Police & Fire Department Credit Union $2,817 $ % 3.61% % 6.08% 0.85% Dugway Federal Credit Union $3,163 $ % 1.12% 29.63% 10.19% 2.56% Uintah Credit Union $3,384 $0 0.00% 0.75% NA 0.00% 0.00% Orem City Employees Federal Credit Union $3,687 $5 0.38% 1.15% % 1.24% 0.14% Utah Prison Employees Credit Union $3,719 $ % 2.45% % 4.36% 0.43% S E A Credit Union $4,738 $ % 1.10% 34.12% 7.71% 1.79% Meadow Gold Employees Credit Union $4,907 $1 0.03% 0.77% NM 0.09% 0.02% Gibbons & Reed Employees Federal Credit Union $5,002 $ % 1.52% 36.73% 11.00% 1.96% MidValley Federal Credit Union $5,694 $ % 1.18% 20.00% 7.62% 2.46% Tanner Employees Credit Union $6,003 $ % 1.12% % 3.68% 0.47% C.U.P. Federal Credit Union $6,507 $0 0.00% 0.12% NA 0.00% 0.00% HollyFrontier Employee's Credit Union $6,788 $ % 0.82% % 4.15% 0.77% Devils Slide Federal Credit Union $11,434 $ % 1.07% % 0.74% 0.10% City Center Credit Union $11,606 $ % 0.69% 83.72% 8.97% 0.74% Kings Peak Credit Union $12,455 $ % 1.71% % 13.17% 0.96% P & S Credit Union $15,795 $7 0.08% 1.72% NM 0.49% 0.04% Varex Federal Credit Union $15,914 $6 0.09% 0.20% % 0.23% 0.04% San Juan Credit Union $18,794 $ % 3.13% % 6.83% 0.70% Utah Federal Credit Union $18,824 $ % 0.26% % 0.92% 0.11% Logan Medical Federal Credit Union $21,536 $ % 0.46% 30.93% 5.75% 0.90% LU 354 IBEW Federal Credit Union $24,086 $ % 0.60% % 0.67% 0.09% Logan Cache Rich Federal Credit Union $24,228 $8 0.08% 0.49% % 0.25% 0.03% Grand County Credit Union $28,183 $ % 1.00% 52.17% 21.51% 1.55% Federal Family Federal Credit Union $28,721 $ % 0.92% % 1.11% 0.15% Education First Credit Union $30,946 $ % 0.60% 66.49% 6.40% 0.62% National J.A.C.L. Credit Union $31,689 $ % 1.01% % 0.65% 0.07% Nephi Western Employees Federal Credit Union $32,539 $ % 1.29% % 0.39% 0.12% Freedom Credit Union $33,472 $ % 0.64% % 2.46% 0.14% Desertview Federal Credit Union $33,521 $ % 5.92% % 11.07% 1.71% Millard County Credit Union $33,928 $ % 0.13% 38.81% 2.73% 0.20% Firefighters Credit Union $39,339 $ % 0.45% % 2.29% 0.27% Hi-Land Credit Union $51,732 $6 0.02% 1.11% NM 0.07% 0.01% Pacific Horizon Credit Union $57,945 $ % 0.52% 93.02% 4.48% 0.45% Utah Heritage Credit Union $63,770 $ % 0.58% 48.73% 8.62% 0.87% Hercules Credit Union $67,391 $ % 0.38% % 1.48% 0.14% Nebo Credit Union $83,751 $ % 0.56% % 4.04% 0.31% Weber State Federal Credit Union $110,258 $ % 0.18% 96.57% 1.63% 0.16% Members First Credit Union $117,409 $ % 0.14% % 0.63% 0.06% Eastern Utah Community Federal Credit Union $119,749 $ % 0.56% % 2.65% 0.21% Box Elder County Federal Credit Union $120,132 $ % 0.27% 97.31% 0.83% 0.15% Transwest Credit Union $134,042 $ % 1.14% % 2.86% 0.25% Horizon Utah Federal Credit Union $139,942 $ % 0.67% % 1.71% 0.18% Alpine Credit Union $187,056 $ % 0.28% % 2.10% 0.15% American United Family of Credit Unions, Federal Credit Union $195,815 $1, % 1.30% % 7.13% 1.00% Average of Asset Group A $36,706 $ % 1.29% % 4.19% 0.68% Source: SNL Financial NA = data was not available.

12 NM = per SNL Financial, the data was not provided as the ratios are too high/low to be meaningful. Asset Quality Data Page 10 of 14 Asset Quality March 31, 2017 Run Date: May 21, 2017 As of Date Region Institution Name Total Assets ($000) Delinquent Loans => 2 months ($000) NPLs / Loans (%) Loan Loss Reserves / Gross Loans (%) Reserves / NPLs (%) NPAs / Equity + LLRs (%) Delinquent Loans/ Asset Group B - $251 to $500 million in total assets Jordan Federal Credit Union $264,511 $ % 0.38% 98.63% 2.81% 0.22% Wasatch Peaks Federal Credit Union $299,779 $ % 0.38% % 2.22% 0.18% Utah First Federal Credit Union $326,341 $ % 1.10% % 2.87% 0.30% Granite Federal Credit Union $418,539 $1, % 0.83% % 2.74% 0.28% Average of Asset Group B $327,293 $ % 0.67% % 2.66% 0.25% Asset Group C - $501 million to $1 billion in total assets Deseret First Federal Credit Union $591,534 $2, % 0.78% % 7.08% 0.51% Utah Power Credit Union $625,690 $ % 0.27% % 0.72% 0.07% Cyprus Federal Credit Union $828,248 $1, % 0.59% % 1.41% 0.13% University First Federal Credit Union $912,008 $2, % 0.74% % 3.20% 0.25% Average of Asset Group C $739,370 $1, % 0.60% % 3.10% 0.24% Asset Group D - $1 billion and over in total assets Utah Community Federal Credit Union $1,238,335 $2, % 1.31% % 1.89% 0.20% Goldenwest Federal Credit Union $1,372,546 $3, % 1.50% % 2.46% 0.26% Mountain America Federal Credit Union $6,456,586 $22, % 0.59% % 5.12% 0.34% America First Federal Credit Union $8,761,088 $45, % 1.47% % 7.84% 0.52% Average of Asset Group D $4,457,139 $18, % 1.22% % 4.33% 0.33% Source: SNL Financial NA = data was not available.

13 Net Worth

14 NM = per SNL Financial, the data was not provided as the ratios are too high/low to be meaningful. Net Worth Data Page 12 of 14 Net Worth March 31, 2017 Run Date: May 21, 2017 As of Date Region Institution Name Total Assets ($000) Total Net Worth ($000) Net Worth/ Net Worth Growth (Decline) - YTD (%) Total Delinquent Lns/ Net Worth (%) Classified Assets/ Net Worth (%) Asset Group A - $50 to $250 million in total assets Tri-County Credit Union $158 $ % 0.00% 37.78% 11.11% Beckstrand & Associates Credit Union $283 $ % 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% Presto Lewiston Employees Credit Union $337 $ % 0.00% 0.00% 5.56% Valley Wide Federal Credit Union $489 $ % (4.55%) 2.30% 5.75% Granite Furniture Employees Federal Credit Union $862 $ % 3.73% 0.00% 3.38% North Sanpete Federal Credit Union $881 $ % 1.82% 0.00% 5.88% South Sanpete Credit Union $1,042 $ % 0.00% 0.00% 6.67% UCB Credit Union $1,213 $ % (3.42%) 7.76% 9.91% Employees First Credit Union $1,756 $ % (0.86%) 0.21% 1.29% Sunnyside Credit Union $2,674 $ % (28.97%) 2.23% 8.92% Provo Police & Fire Department Credit Union $2,817 $ % 0.00% 7.25% 19.34% Dugway Federal Credit Union $3,163 $ % 1.56% 10.51% 3.11% Uintah Credit Union $3,384 $ % (0.82%) 0.00% 2.07% Orem City Employees Federal Credit Union $3,687 $ % 0.00% 1.29% 3.87% Utah Prison Employees Credit Union $3,719 $ % (1.29%) 5.19% 19.48% S E A Credit Union $4,738 $1, % 4.90% 7.91% 2.70% Meadow Gold Employees Credit Union $4,907 $1, % 1.44% 0.09% 2.15% Gibbons & Reed Employees Federal Credit Union $5,002 $ % 1.88% 11.46% 4.21% MidValley Federal Credit Union $5,694 $1, % (3.29%) 7.73% 1.55% Tanner Employees Credit Union $6,003 $ % 10.39% 3.94% 6.89% C.U.P. Federal Credit Union $6,507 $ % 2.50% 0.00% 0.62% HollyFrontier Employee's Credit Union $6,788 $1, % 8.50% 4.33% 4.33% Devils Slide Federal Credit Union $11,434 $1, % 4.97% 0.77% 5.36% City Center Credit Union $11,606 $1, % 27.11% 7.48% 6.26% Kings Peak Credit Union $12,455 $ % (3.25%) 12.28% 13.51% P & S Credit Union $15,795 $1, % 4.44% 0.55% 12.40% Varex Federal Credit Union $15,914 $2, % 0.31% 0.23% 0.50% San Juan Credit Union $18,794 $1, % 26.87% 8.39% 22.82% Utah Federal Credit Union $18,824 $2, % 2.32% 0.93% 1.33% Logan Medical Federal Credit Union $21,536 $3, % 6.75% 5.85% 1.81% LU 354 IBEW Federal Credit Union $24,086 $3, % 7.74% 0.70% 3.45% Logan Cache Rich Federal Credit Union $24,228 $3, % 4.24% 0.25% 1.59% Grand County Credit Union $28,183 $2, % 19.95% 17.45% 9.10% Federal Family Federal Credit Union $28,721 $4, % 1.14% 0.96% 2.70% Education First Credit Union $30,946 $2, % 5.39% 6.68% 4.44% National J.A.C.L. Credit Union $31,689 $3, % (3.86%) 0.68% 3.96% Nephi Western Employees Federal Credit Union $32,539 $10, % 4.79% 0.40% 3.20% Freedom Credit Union $33,472 $3, % 13.08% 1.30% 4.50% Desertview Federal Credit Union $33,521 $4, % 3.56% 14.01% 26.57% Millard County Credit Union $33,928 $3, % 6.95% 1.76% 0.68% Firefighters Credit Union $39,339 $4, % 2.74% 2.35% 2.41% Hi-Land Credit Union $51,732 $8, % 6.90% 0.07% 3.33% Pacific Horizon Credit Union $57,945 $5, % 7.92% 4.47% 4.16% Utah Heritage Credit Union $63,770 $6, % 9.61% 9.00% 4.38% Hercules Credit Union $67,391 $7, % 1.08% 1.31% 1.47% Nebo Credit Union $83,751 $14, % 6.46% 1.81% 2.49% Weber State Federal Credit Union $110,258 $10, % 4.35% 1.65% 1.60% Members First Credit Union $117,409 $11, % 4.94% 0.61% 0.82% Eastern Utah Community Federal Credit Union $119,749 $11, % 6.60% 2.23% 3.49% Box Elder County Federal Credit Union $120,132 $25, % 8.58% 0.72% 0.70% Transwest Credit Union $134,042 $10, % 10.64% 3.18% 10.92% Horizon Utah Federal Credit Union $139,942 $14, % 4.92% 1.77% 3.42% Alpine Credit Union $187,056 $21, % 3.79% 1.33% 1.56% American United Family of Credit Unions, Federal Credit Union $195,815 $28, % 12.06% 6.92% 7.28% Average of Asset Group A $36,706 $4, % 4.01% 4.22% 5.57% Source: SNL Financial NA = data was not available.

15 NM = per SNL Financial, the data was not provided as the ratios are too high/low to be meaningful. Net Worth Data Page 13 of 14 Net Worth March 31, 2017 Run Date: May 21, 2017 As of Date Region Institution Name Total Assets ($000) Total Net Worth ($000) Net Worth/ Net Worth Growth (Decline) - YTD (%) Total Delinquent Lns/ Net Worth (%) Classified Assets/ Net Worth (%) Asset Group B - $251 to $500 million in total assets Jordan Federal Credit Union $264,511 $22, % 2.61% 2.61% 2.57% Wasatch Peaks Federal Credit Union $299,779 $30, % 3.42% 1.79% 2.77% Utah First Federal Credit Union $326,341 $35, % 14.87% 2.76% 8.02% Granite Federal Credit Union $418,539 $41, % 9.15% 2.87% 6.32% Average of Asset Group B $327,293 $32, % 7.51% 2.51% 4.92% Asset Group C - $501 million to $1 billion in total assets Deseret First Federal Credit Union $591,534 $39, % 7.36% 7.51% 8.32% Utah Power Credit Union $625,690 $82, % 5.94% 0.49% 0.89% Cyprus Federal Credit Union $828,248 $91, % 8.88% 1.14% 4.36% University First Federal Credit Union $912,008 $93, % 8.27% 2.41% 5.94% Average of Asset Group C $739,370 $76, % 7.61% 2.89% 4.88% Asset Group D - $1 billion and over in total assets Utah Community Federal Credit Union $1,238,335 $125, % 4.98% 2.00% 8.89% Goldenwest Federal Credit Union $1,372,546 $183, % 30.42% 1.97% 7.67% Mountain America Federal Credit Union $6,456,586 $581, % 14.18% 3.79% 5.51% America First Federal Credit Union $8,761,088 $959, % 10.72% 4.72% 9.33% Average of Asset Group D $4,457,139 $462, % 15.08% 3.12% 7.85% Source: SNL Financial NA = data was not available.

16 Definitions

17 Credit Union Index DEFINITIONS Total Assets Net Income Return on Average Return on Average Equity (%) Efficiency Ratio (FTE) (%) Salary Expense / Employees Total Loans & Leases Total Deposits All assets owned by the company as of the date indicated, as carried on the balance sheet and defined under the indicated accounting principles. Net income after taxes, minority interest, and extraordinary and other after-tax items. Non-controlling interest may be included, per relevant accounting standards (e.g., ASC for U.S. GAAP which includes non-controlling interests for fiscal years starting after December 15, 2008). Return on average assets; net income as a percent of average assets. Return on average equity; net income as a percent of average equity. Non-interest expense before foreclosed property expense, amortization of intangibles, and goodwill impairments as a percent of net interest income (fully taxable equivalent, if available) and non-interest revenues, excluding only gains from securities transactions and nonrecurring items. Salary and benefits expense / number of full-time equivalent employees at end of period. The total of loans and lease financing receivables, net of unearned income. Includes loans secured by real estate; loans to depository institutions; loans to finance agricultural production and other loans to farmers; commercial and industrial loans; acceptances of other banks (both U.S. and foreign); loans to individuals for household, family, and other personal expenditures; loans to foreign governments and official institutions; obligations of states and political subdivisions in the U.S.; other loans (e.g., for purchasing or carrying securities, and not including consumer loans); lease financing receivables (net of unearned income); and less any unearned income on loans reflected in items above. Amounts in customers banking deposits; any accounts subject to federal banking deposit insurance, including any portions in jumbo deposits that are not insured but subject to the FDIC deposit regulations. Liquidity Ratio (%) Liquid Assets (Cash & Bal Due to Dep Inst + Securities + Fed Fund&Repos + Trading Accounts - Pledged Secs) / Total Liabilities. Total Assets / Employees Loans / Deposits (%) Yield on Earning Cost of Interest Bearing Liability (%) Total assets / number of full-time equivalent employees at end of period. Loans held for investment, before reserves, as a percent of total insured deposits. Return earned on interest-earning assets, expressed as a percent. Total Interest & Dividend Income / Average Earning Assets. Interest incurred on liabilities as a percent of average interestbearing liabilities. Total Interest Expense / Average Interest Bearing Liabilities. Cost of Funds (%) Net Interest Margin (FTE) (%) Asset Growth Rate (%) Deposit Growth Rate (%) Total Loans & Leases Nonaccrual Non-accrual Loans / Total Loans (%) Reserves / Loans (%) Reserves / NPLs (%) NPAs / Total NPA+ Loans 90PD / Tang Equity + LLRs [Texas Ratio] (%) Total Equity Capital Tier 1 Capital Leverage Ratio (%) Tier 1 Risk-Based Ratio (%) Risk-Based Capital Ratio (%) Interest incurred on liabilities as a percent of average noninterest-bearing deposits and interest-bearing liabilities. Net interest income, on a fully taxable-equivalent basis if available, as a percent of average earning assets. Growth in total assets. Annualized: [(Current Period Total Assets - Previous Period Total Assets) / Previous Period Total Assets]. Growth in deposits. Annualized: [(Current Period Deposits - Previous Period Deposits (Domestic & Foreign Office)) / Previous Period Deposits]. The amount of loans and finance leases, gross of reserves, on which the interest is no longer accruing. Non-accrual loans, net of guaranteed loans, as a percent of total gross loans. Reserves for loan losses as a percent of loans before reserves. Loan loss reserves as a percent of nonperforming loans. Nonperforming assets (nonperforming loans and leases, renegotiated loans and leases, and real estate owned) as a percent of assets. Nonperforming assets plus loans 90 days or more past due divided by tangible common equity and reserves. This is also known as the common version of the Texas Ratio. Equity as defined under the indicated accounting principles. Includes par value, paid in capital, retained earnings, and other adjustments to equity. Minority interest may be included, per relevant accounting standards (e.g., ASC for U.S. GAAP which includes minority interest for fiscal years starting after December 15, 2008). For OTS-regulated institutions it represents the amount of core capital as defined under the latest OTS guidelines at period-end. For FDIC-regulated institutions it represents the amount of Tier 1 capital as defined by the latest regulatory agency guidelines. The Tier 1 leverage ratio according to regulatory capital guidelines. Usually defined as Tier 1 capital as a percent of tangible assets. Tier 1 capital as a percent of total risk-adjusted assets. The regulatory risk-based capital ratio as defined under the latest OTS or FDIC guidelines at period-end. This ratio is usually equal to total risk-based capital divided by total riskadjusted assets.